One Simple Question To Reveal Racism
“Given the same historical conditions, do you think white people would have been just as damaged by slavery and its aftermath, and complained about them as much?”
1) About 90% of Liberals quickly answer “yes, it would have been about the same.” About 70% of Conservatives will also give that reply. (A conservative Republican I know estimates that it might be only 40-50%. I certainly hope they’re wrong) But I estimate an overall average of 20% of people cannot. IF THEY CANNOT COMMIT, it is safest to assume that they are on the opposing team. They can be friends, and neighbors. They cannot be brothers and sisters. It would be a pointless waste of time to discuss social solutions with them–they are starting from a different station, and heading to a different destination.
2) In the context of this essay there is no social phenomenon, no problem, no horror we are experiencing that is not explained by looking at human beings as equal in capacity, but moving through different social and experiential landscapes. Blacks need not be intellectually inferior to explain their performance, whites need not be morally inferior to explain their actions. People are just people. And there is no problem, seen in that light, that has no solution. The answer is communication, love, and intolerance for hate. It will take time: this pus sore has been festering for centuries. If you expect it to resolve in a single human lifetime, you are sorely mistaken. A rough estimate: I’d guess that by the time everyone born before 1950 is dead, we’ll be on the other side of this. Maybe 1960…but I’d really like to include myself in the group that gets to see the Promised Land. Hope I’m not kidding myself.
3) Conversely, if you believe in inequality, there are really no answers. America and the world will burn. I think that much of the core, deep, existential despair fear and rage you are seeing is from people trapped by their own prejudice, who cannot see a way out of a maze of their own creation. They are dangerous, yes, but also deserve pity.
4) Those who believe in nature over nurture usually think that no, whites would have done better, complained less, and have less current trauma and dysfunction . But…few of them will say this directly. If they do, these are what I would call Honorable Enemy. They can actually be trusted more than those who either ‘don’t know” or pretend not to. Other than “yes” or “no” here are the typical responses to my little question, and my thoughts on them.
5) “That’s a hypothetical question. Its meaningless.” Hypothetical questions are hugely meaningful and can be quite powerful if phrased properly. The entire insurance industry is based on the hypothetical concern that your health may fail, your house may burn, or you may die before your children finish college. What If? Is a question human beings have asked since the beginning of civilization, and much of our invention and discover has flowed from it.
6) “That’s a trick question.” No, it is a question designed to help me understand your beliefs. You’re not ashamed of them, are you? “No one can know what would happen. ” True. But the people who say that, oddly enough, use the same arguments and seem to have the same attitudes as those who believe whites would have done better. Just a coincidence, perhaps. I choose not to take the risk.
7) I suggest that you NOT discuss race with someone who cannot or will not answer the question in the affirmative. They are going down a different track. In fact, they believe that efforts to promote equality will fail, waste resources and disrupt the natural order, as well as stealing money from “the productive citizens.” Ahem.
8) Even if they say “yes” they may be lying. But once said, you can at least look at the subsequent arguments and see if they are congruent with the initial position. Here are some red flags, and my thoughts on them…
9) “Immigrants from other countries do better than blacks. Racism is just an excuse.” Immigration isn’t the same as slavery, any more than sex is rape. American slaves specifically had their name, culture, language, religion, history and personal identity stripped away, like wiping a computer’s hard drive. Then, Slave 1.0 was installed. Imagine the program conflicts and crashes to follow.
10) “That all ended over a century ago.” Followed by Jim Crow and Segregation, which arguably didn’t break down until 1970. Since the first slaves landed in 1619, you’re talking about 350 years of rape, torture, murder, theft, and brainwashing…followed by less than 50 years of potential healing time. How many wounds heal in less time than they took to inflict?
11) “The black family was fine until Johnson’s Great Society and welfare. Then it began to break down, with increases in crime caused by THAT.” This one is a corker, and comes up so often it’s obviously circulated by chain-mail and talk radio echo-chamber. IMO it is an attempt to avoid the reality that yes, slavery and its aftermath did just that much damage . Remember, these are people who equate voluntary immigration with being dragged in chains onto a slave ship. (Here’s a little question I just thought of. When someone does this, at a later time see if they seem to have odd amounts of empathy with rapists, engage in victim blaming, or suggest raped women carry their babies to term. Just wondering) My favorite answer is “So if I locked you in my basement, raped and tortured you for a year, then you escaped and the guy next door bought you a sandwich, it would be rational to blame your problems on the free food?”
16) “The Irish were slaves.” Well, almost everyone was at one time or place or another. But to make that a useful aspect of the current discussion, we have to be sure we’re talking about the same thing in the same place, with the same circumstances. “Slavery” is like the terms “housing” or “food” or “job”, covering a vast range of circumstances and results. You have to compare apples to apples, and in this instance it just doesn’t mesh. In the United States, the vast majority of what some call “Irish Slavery” was actually “Indentured Servitude”, usually in exchange for passage. It lasted about seven years. Chattel Slavery lasted an average of three GENERATIONS. Anyone trying to compare the two has an ugly agenda, or is breathtakingly ignorant.
12) “What about black on black crime?” a favorite distraction. And of course the crime rates are horrible. But if it is higher than white-on-white, and one believes in equality, then the only conclusion is that the initial conditions are different. That to look at it on a personal level, abused children engage in cutting, destructive behavior, drug abuse, and compulsive self-hating behaviors. In other words, a person who believes in equality would see whites suffering identical dysfunctions in a reversed world. Therefore, the answers are two-fold: BOTH the removal of poisonous pressures like racism and police violence AND work within the community to heal and knit together. Both.
MORE http://americannewsx.com/human-interest/one-simple-question-reveal-racism/

The question insists that race be discussed from a position of the belief that all men and races are created equal. He says
7) I suggest that you NOT discuss race with someone who cannot or will not answer the question in the affirmative. They are going down a different track. In fact, they believe that efforts to promote equality will fail, waste resources and disrupt the natural order, as well as stealing money from “the productive citizens.” Ahem.
that conclusion goes hand in hand with this one
12) “What about black on black crime?” a favorite distraction. And of course the crime rates are horrible. But if it is higher than white-on-white, and one believes in equality, then the only conclusion is that the initial conditions are different. That to look at it on a personal level, abused children engage in cutting, destructive behavior, drug abuse, and compulsive self-hating behaviors. In other words, a person who believes in equality would see whites suffering identical dysfunctions in a reversed world. Therefore, the answers are two-fold: BOTH the removal of poisonous pressures like racism and police violence AND work within the community to heal and knit together. Both.
Solve this equation.
5 = 7
9
That's right. If you treat them fairly, you're a racist. If you don't then you are a racist. There's no solution. The tactic originates and is from Cultural Marxism.
That's right. If you treat them fairly, you're a racist. If you don't then you are a racist. There's no solution. The tactic originates and is from Cultural Marxism.
You don't seem to have read the attached article.
So no one wants to address the content of the article?
Not really a surprise.
1