DNA analysis proves Kennewick man is Native American
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/dna-analysis-proves-kennewick-man-is-native-american/
Wonder how many times the scientific world is going to get egg on its face for denying what Native Americans tell them based on historical/oral stories?
A genome sequence of the 8,500-year-old male skeleton discovered in 1996 in the Columbia River in Washington contradicts earlier work including a cranial analysis that found he resembled populations in Japan, Polynesia or Europe.
The findings in Nature announced Thursday also should bolster hopes from several tribes in the Northwest that want to repatriate the bones - several of which said they now will push to take possession of Kennewick Man, whose skeleton is kept in the Burke Museum of Natural History & Culture in Seattle. It, however, is not on display for security reasons.
"Comparing the genome sequence of Kennewick Man to genome-wide data of contemporary human populations across the world clearly shows that Native Americans of today are his closest living relatives," said Eske Willerslev, whose Centre for GeoGenetics at the University of Copenhagen led the study.
As part of the study, the researchers took DNA samples from one of the five claimant tribes, the Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation. They found the tribe was "one of the groups showing close affinities to Kennewick Man or at least to the population to which he belonged," though they couldn't say exactly which tribe he might come from.
But since the other tribes didn't provide DNA, Willerslev acknowledged Kennewick Man could be more closely related to them. "It is certainly possible," he said. "From my understanding of the history between these tribes, they have been intermarrying with one another for many, many years. So, my expectation is that the other four tribes also would be closely related to Kennewick Man."
They also compared the Kennewick Man's DNA to that of Japanese Ainu and Polynesian populations and found that he didn't have any more of their DNA than contemporary Native Americans.
This marks the latest twist in the saga of Kennewick Man, known by the tribes as the Ancient One, whose discovery sparked a long-running legal battle of who has the rights to the skeleton.

An amazing find 1st.
DNA never lies! It would be in the tribe's best benefit (and science's) to provide DNA and end this debate. Then we can put this whole issue to bed.
Perrie - as you and most of NT, based on articles/threads posted by myself and Kavika and others, tribes/nations have cultural/religious/heritage beliefs against "scientific" invasion of the body/soul/spirit.
DNA is invasive, so, again, for many tribes, it's a moot point.
And, as stated above, the scientificcommunity is ignorant of American Indians - just as society is ignorant of ethnicity concerns. "Studying" American Indians is a pathetic reach of further domination. Are you doing the same with blacks, Hispanics, Asians, Europeans, etc?? Hell no.
Owlsey and Chattels, both forensic anthropolgists declared that Kennewick Man was either European, Ainu or Polynesian based on their ''scientific research'' which was that he looked European, and skull measurements. Now that is what I call really scientific research.
Oh, and Owlsey published a couple of books on it. Think that money could be involved in his ''research''...Chattels also declared that Kennewick Man, wasn't from this area.
Seems that all of their ''scientific research'' has been discredited.
He is, as the tribes claimed even before he was age dated, an American Indian. They were right.
In reality the ''Montana Boy'' was and is a much better study. 12,600 years old, 3,000 years older than Kennewick Man,with direct DNA linking the boy and time period to modern Indians. The testing and respectful burial was done by both the tribe and the scientists.
Now that the link to Native Americans has been established from the DNA of Kennewick Man, perhaps the brilliant scientific community and the courts will return his remains to the tribe for proper burial.
And bears, wolves, bison, etc. - but, they weren't related.
1st,
DNA is a swab test. In fact, it can it can be taken from a hair on a comb. The issue is that the tribes don't trust anthropologist.
And I was raised understanding our traditions. Please don't insult my dad, and just lump me in as being another ignorant non-Indian. Save that for some of our other members who deserve it more.
Wow - where did that come from?????
Not all tribes/nations have the same traditions/beliefs - as you well know and have discussed quite deeply with NT on the FP and in our family group. Not all tribes/nations trust anyone not of their tribe/nation, regardless of their profession.
Nothing was said about you nor your father. The comment was made to SHOW that Indian traditions/heritage/culture has been discussed - NUMEROUS times - and this topic has been discussed numerous times over the past three years and WE have all discussed how the various/many tribes/nations do, in fact, have different cultures/traditions/heritage.
You jumped way too quick - not like you.
1st,
It came from here:
You were lecturing me as if I didn't know, which I do. I found it very condescending. On the other hand this comment was somehow missed:
Which was a cheap shot at the fact that Kennewick man was found with a wound implying that it came from his own people... I guess the word savage was missing?
How about lecturing on that?
Shocking indeed!
His Indian name is ''Babbles from the Tower''.
Do you really want to bring this to the FP?????
Sorry Teacher, was replying directly to your comment - just can't get past the "recapping" of discussions that we always have, specifically when writing a reply - tell what you're gonna say, say it, recap what you've said - so, I recapped. No dig at you - just pulling a GOOD discussion procedure learned from many years of school and writing experience with the Feds.
"Remember when we discussed this"???????? Is that calling you an idiot?
Didn't think so.
Your second "quote" was directed specifically at Robert - not you - and, for EVERYONE's information, not everyone back in those days was related to each other - FYI, there were different tribes/bands and they did war/fight against each other.
Any other digs on my comments?
Can't be - has two eyes.
Actually no 1st... I didn't want to take this to the front page. But I also don't want to be lectured to. Taught yes, as we all can learn from one another..but I have always treated you with respect. I expect it in kind.
I don't understand. And I asking so that we don't have another misunderstanding.
Love it!
Now make them give his bones back!
DNA never lies! It would be in the tribe's best benefit (and science's) to provide DNA and end this debate. Then we can put this whole issue to bed.
And finally and rightfully, lay this man to rest.
Yes and yes. - Oh, and the word "know/remember" SHOULD have been at the end of that first sentence but - ol' age excuse here - didn't catch the omission.
If memory is correct (and I can go into my 6,800 threads/comments if need be), we've held discussions regarding tribe's/nation's not sharing anything with anyone not of their nation/tribe - even cheek swabs. That is against their traditions/culture/heritage.
Simple example - ask the Navajo about their religious ceremonies or the meaning of their symbolism. You know what the answer will be. Or the Hopi or Apache or Chickasaw or Oneida or Seneca. or Micmac.
In layman's terms - what happens in 'Vegas, stays in 'Vegas.
Or "found bones" - that works on some of the digs I've been on too.
Your 1st grouping of words was correct 'cept that he "might not" have been related to the people in the area - such as the fella found in the Alps couple of many years ago - a hunter out of his "area/hunting grounds".
Your 2nd grouping of words is Robert
Anything that you want to do RG. Feel free to run your mouth.
Being laughed at...or about has never stopped him before.
And that can be taken in many ways - and I'll choose the good one.
@Robert:
Why should Indians trust anyone outside their own Nation/tribe? In spite of their oral histories which reach back centuries, the white man has often called them liars and "tellers of tale tales," accused them of inaccuracies and fallacies.
Who teaches the history of Indian heritage in American schools? Indians?
Who has always told the tale of how Columbus "discovered" America? Indians?
Who got to relate the real reason of the "massacre" of the 7th Calvary at Greasy Grass while studyingAmerican history of the old West? Indians??
Who was it who outlawed the "witchcraft" of Indian Shamen and Medicine Men and Medicine Women because the herbs and natural plants they used, and the methods of healing, had no real medicinal value, yet today doctors take sabbaticals to reservations to learn from the savages and apply that ancient knowledge to modern medicine?
Everything of value gained through interaction with Indians is "appropriated." It becomes the property of whatever white man or entity was fortunate enough to be the first on hand to seize it from the Indian's grasp. The entire history and culture of Indians can be changed at the whim of a white man's drunken dream or at the indigestion of a group of congressmen who all ate the same disgusting meal.
There was an explorer whose name I can't remember just now who set off for Alaskan waters almost two hundred years ago and disappeared. Remains of his ship and what happened to the man and his crew has been a great mystery and he and the ship have been sought at various times for almost two centuries. The indigenous Indians on the shores of an Alaskan inlet had been handing down a story all that time about men with gold hair and fair skin who came with a great wooden boat that sank in the inlet. Many searchers had listened to the tale and dismissed it, until two years ago when someone decided to take a chance and look.
What do you know!!!!! At the bottom of the inlet was the ship, exactly where the Indians said it was, in their oral history!
"Science" is the most untrustworthy field of study there is... it changes with each new day's discovery. Kennewick man deserves his burial.
You should light a candle RG. You're stuck in the dark.
I would prefer that there be no personal issues on this thread from anyone against anyone - please.
Thank you.
mimi - I remember Kavika giving us the great account of that discovery - awesome how science can be so ignorant so much of the time when it comes to American Indians.
''The Myth of Scientific Discovery'', Vine Deloria.
"because the obvious necessities of avoiding anything that might upset Indians."
Something you obviously have no qualms with. Read mimi's response and think about what she said. Then think about some of the many, many articles/threads posted on NT regarding American Indians and determine who is doing the upsetting - very intentionally - because they have to dominate.
"they didn't bow to "Indian concerns" which were nonsense"
"Nonsense"??????? Religion is nonsense? Custom is nonsense? tradition is nonsense? Heritage is nonsense? History is nonsense? You are and always have based your responses from a non-Indian perspective - which, based on what you are saying now - is pure nonsense. Doesn't stand up to the argument.
"as closely related as Ellie Reynolds"
Apples and Oranges - wanna add 'bout 8,300 years to that? Stick to the thread/facts and quit your suppositions - they don't work.
"he has never been treated so gently."
I guess having your body pulled apart and skeleton separated, bone by bone, bones drilled, teeth yanked, sinew shredded off, eye orbs drilled for DNA substance could be called "gentle" in your NE part of the world - but not in mine. That's called invasive gathering and it is far from gentle.