╌>

Hillary Clinton and her Extreme View of Israel

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  krishna  •  10 years ago  •  8 comments

Hillary Clinton and her Extreme View of Israel


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    10 years ago

Uh-oh!

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    10 years ago

Headline :

Noam Chomsky agrees to have Hamas members set up their headquarters on his personal property !

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    10 years ago

It would be nice to know what Krishna posted as an article, since I am unable to open YouTube (as he well knows).

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    10 years ago

Transcript

English (Automatic Captions) pixel-vfl3z5WfW.gif
0:00
I want to turn back to the democratic debate that was held here in Brooklyn
0:05
Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton sparred over the issue of Israel and
0:09
Palestine this exchange begins with a question from the moderator Wolf Blitzer
0:13
Secretary Clinton you agree with senator Sanders that Israel over reacts to
0:21
Palestinian attacks and that in order for there to be peace between Israel and
0:26
the Palestinians Israel must quote and it's disproportionate responses i can
0:32
tell you right now because I have been there with Israeli officials going back
0:37
more than 25 years that they do not seek this kind of attacks they do not invite
0:45
Rockets raining down on their towns and villages
0:49
so I don't know how you run a country when you are under constant threat
0:56
terrorist attack Rockets coming at you you have a right to defend yourself and
1:01
let me say this if yasser arafat had agreed with my husband at Camp David in
1:07
the late nineteen nineties to the offer that Prime Minister Barack put on the
1:11
table
1:12
we would have had a college students in kindergarten
1:15
all right
1:16
I
1:20
whoo
1:21
anybody would suggest that Israel invites or welcomes missiles are flying
1:30
into their country that is not the issue and you evaded the ANCYL he evaded the
1:35
question the question is not does Israel have a right to respond not does Israel
1:40
have a right to go after terrorists and destroyed terrorism that's not the
1:45
debate was their response disproportionate
1:48
I believe that it was you are not answer that there comes a time when if we
1:56
pursue justice and peace
1:58
we are going to have to say that Netanyahu is not right all of the time
2:04
that's Bernie Sanders and Hillary Clinton on the issue of Israel and
2:08
Palestine noam chomsky response
2:11
well it's interesting than helpful this sander said that by world standards its
2:19
way off to the extreme
2:23
I don't know what dimension to call it the nationalist right
2:27
the talk the question of Israel's disproportionate response is a little
2:33
bit like the question of expansion of the settlements the only one you're
2:37
allowed to discuss here
2:39
these are not the questions the question is why is there a response at all
2:44
why are there any settlements the settlements are totally illegal
2:49
that's been determined by the heart highest authorities security council
2:54
international court of justice
2:57
Red Cross ministers the Geneva Conventions
3:01
there's simply no question about their legality
3:04
at one point the u.s. also agreed that they were illegal
3:08
now they just say it's an obstacle to peace so
3:11
and the same is true of the disproportionate response so let's take
3:15
it these alleged missiles for so there are any missiles but the so called
3:20
rocket attacks that are coming why are they coming
3:23
you look at the record i've gone through it in detail and print if you want to
3:27
look at it in the book that you just mentioned in fact consistently what has
3:32
happened is this ceasefire agreement is reached between Hamas and Israel the
3:39
terms are always about the same and the siege
3:43
no more military action beginning of commercial relations and so on
3:49
Israel complete Hamas lives up to the terms Israel totally disregard them
3:55
maintains the siege a brutal harsh siege continues with military actions
4:03
finally some Israel escalation Israeli attacks leads to a Hamas response at
4:10
that point we get another episode of what Israel politely calls mowing the
4:15
lawn
4:16
each one worse than the last then we get a question here is Israel's response
4:21
disproportionate that's I'm if it weren't so grotesque it would be comical
4:27
the question is why is Israel maintaining a harsh brutal vicious siege
4:34
which is destroying Gaza consistently violating the ceasefire agreements that
4:40
it reaches and then when there's some response to it
4:45
escalating crimes carries out a monstrous attack while its protector
4:51
debates whether the responses disproportionate the the real problems
4:58
right here as long as the United States continues to support all of this it's
5:04
going to continue and incidentally us support for Israeli actions is not only
5:10
is not only supporting violations of enter
5:13
national law it is explicitly violating US law
5:18
take a look at us law so called lay low it flatly bars military as a dispatcher
5:26
of military equipment to any military group that is involved in consistent
5:32
human rights violations
5:34
there's simply no doubt that the Israeli army is involved in extremely serious
5:40
human rights violations consistently that's why organizations like Amnesty
5:45
International and I if I recall correctly Human Rights Watch have called
5:51
for a ban on sending weapons Israel in accord with US law incidentally so yes
5:58
if the United States lived up the US law if it stopped providing the decisive
6:05
support for the settlement activities that claims that supposed to for other
6:11
repression and violence then there wouldn't be any need for any response
6:16
certainly not a disproportionate response as to clinton's famous offer
6:22
less at Camp David
6:25
mrs. Clinton may remember that Clinton himself recognized that it was
6:31
inadequate a couple months later in December he after camp david he issued
6:38
what he called his parameters for a settlement both sides accepted them both
6:45
sides had reservations Israel had extremely severe reservations they were
6:52
to negotiate these in Taba in january two thousand one negotiations took place
7:00
they were called off by Israel at a point where the negotiators at least
7:05
said they were coming pretty close to an agreement an agreement which was much
7:09
less next extreme on the pro-israel side than the Clinton proposals
7:15
well Prime Minister Barack himself has said informally that may be operating
7:24
correctly that the Israeli negotiators a top i had no authority to negotiate
7:28
anything at so it was kind of a show
7:31
no I wanted to go back to the candidates on this issue particularly what Hillary
7:38
Clinton had to say to a pack earlier this year when she criticized the BDS
7:44
movement the boycott divestment sanctions movement as i wrote last year
7:49
in a letter to the heads of major american jewish organizations we have to
7:54
be united in fighting back against BDS many of its proponents have demonized
8:01
Israeli scientists and intellectuals even students to all the college
8:08
students who may have encountered this on campus
8:11
I hope you stay strong keep speaking out don't let anyone silence you bully you
8:18
or try to shut down debate especially in places of learning like colleges
8:24
and university
8:25
yeah
8:27
yeah
8:42
anti-semitism has no place in any civilized society not in America not in
8:49
Europe not anywhere
8:52
professor Noam Chomsky can you respond to presidential candidate Hillary
8:57
Clinton
8:58
well some of what he said is quite accurate on strongly
9:03
I'm very happy that she has agreed that when should not shut down debate on this
9:08
issue in campus
9:10
she's about 40 years too late over the past decades I've had plenty of
9:16
experience the few other people who talk about this issue have similar experience
9:22
of trying to give talks on the topic on university campuses with police
9:29
protection with meetings broken up violently with the airport style
9:35
security at entrances
9:37
even my own University until not long ago
9:42
not only did they have to be a police presence but the police insisted on
9:46
walking me back to my car just because of the threat of violence
9:51
so that's been going on for decades and it's very nice that mrs. Clinton finally
9:56
decided yes
9:57
maybe it would be nice to have free and open debate on campus as there is now
10:02
for the first time and it's a good thing that there is that there is now a
10:10
possibility of free and open debate on campuses
10:14
you can find if you search the Cape Martin marginal cases of it accesses
10:21
reminds me of background 1970 when people like see more Martin lips were
10:28
desperately searching through the local black newspapers to see if they could
10:35
find an anti-semitic comments somewhere so they could then condemn the black
10:41
movement is anti-semitic
10:43
you know you can understand the game
10:45
but the fact of the matter is now there is for the first time
10:49
free open extensive discussion and debate on campus not perfect by any
10:55
means on you can find things on all sides but radically different from
11:00
before
11:01
as to the tactics of boycott and divestment they make perfect sense when
11:07
the Presbyterian Church imposes a boycott and divestment on anything
11:16
connected to the aki israeli-occupied territories including US multinationals
11:22
that's critical
11:24
which are involved in the territories that's a very positive step forward
11:30
certain economic and supportive of international law supportive of genuine
11:37
moral principles of a very significant act non violent act to oppose the
11:45
brutality violence and repression we could I think go much farther
11:51
as I said we should be calling for implementation of US law along joining
11:57
Amnesty International and others to call for an end the US military aid to israel
12:04
for a boycott and sections make a perfectly good sense when these tactics
12:10
are properly applied as they often are you can understand what Hillary Clinton
12:15
is frightened of them they might undermine the policy of her husband then
12:21
his predecessors and Obama as well to support is really violence and
12:27
aggression to protect Israeli nuclear weapons from scrutiny
12:33
so we can't have a nuclear weapons for his own in the region the veto Security
12:38
Council resolutions which literally support official US policy as Obama did
12:46
in February 20 2011
12:49
yeah
12:50
and the non violent actions to undermine this legitimate actions of course
12:56
frightened Hillary Clinton enormously and then your tirades like this but one
13:02
part was correct
13:04
namely a good idea to protect the right of free discussion and debate on campus
13:11
shame that that never occurred to her for the past 40 years when it was
13:15
impossible to have debate and discussion without violence of police protection
13:20
so on no my want to break and then ask you who you are supporting in this
13:25
presidential race noam chomsky world-renowned political dissident
13:28
linguist author institute professor of America emeritus at Massachusetts
13:32
Institute of Technology his latest book who rules the world stay with us
 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Larry Hampton   10 years ago

If you scroll the script will too.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna  replied to  Larry Hampton   10 years ago

Buzz will thank you for that!

I was too lazy to do it....I was just going to post a one or two sentence summary.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

Supposedly there is a Chinese youtube that has some stuff too, though I'm not sure.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Larry Hampton   10 years ago

Interesting debate, including a dedicated self-loathing Jew anti-Semitic Israel demonizer, a politician who condemns Israel for disproportionate response to thousands of rockets raining down on Israel because he ignorantly thinks the IDF killed TEN THOUSAND Gazans (which is ludicrous), and unfortunately Hillary who had difficulty defending Israel on the basis that Arafat walked away from an offer that would have given him somewhere between 95% and 97% of his demands.

 
 

Who is online





152 visitors