╌>

The Left Doth Protest Too Much

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  10 years ago  •  15 comments

The Left Doth Protest Too Much
When Andrew Cuomo proclaimed at the Democratic National Convention in Philadelphia, “Our progressive government is working in New York,” he was rebuked by some on the left who questioned his progressive bona fides. But Cuomo, ever sensitive to the way political winds are blowing, was merely adopting the language of the moment among Democrats. As more and more of the party faithful lean further left, Democrats like Cuomo are embracing the term “progressive.” But they also feel the need to reassure voters—as Cuomo and even Hillary Clinton did at the convention—that progressivism actually works. No wonder. In its current incarnation, progressivism largely expresses lofty ideals and exalted goals, while saying little about governing. That might not matter much to loyalists, but to voters who care about government picking up the garbage, filling in potholes, and maintaining public order, governing well is pretty important. The question is whether the 80 percent of voters who don’t identify as progressives buy into the Democrats’ avowals or whether those voters hear these reassurances as a case of politicians protesting too much.
In its earliest American manifestation, in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the Progressive movement sought to create better government. Books like Woodrow Wilson’s The Study of Administration touted a government run by an elite bureaucracy, independent of potentially corrupt elected officials. Theodore Roosevelt set out to demonstrate what progressive reform could accomplish when, as president of the board of New York City Police Commissioners, he instituted widespread changes in how cops operated, such as instituting hiring practices based on merit rather than political connections. The influential master builder Robert Moses entered public life writing studies on how to reduce political patronage in government—though Moses also embodied what opponents feared in progressivism, emerging as a powerful autocrat who steamrolled opposition as he constructed vast public projects in New York.
Progressivism lost some of its momentum during World War I, though many progressives subsequently saw Franklin Roosevelt’s New Deal as a 1930s offspring of their movement. In the Cold War era that followed the Second World War, however, many on the left become uneasy with progressivism’s vision of intellectuals “using the state to mold society in the interests of the collective,” as Charles Murray has described it, because the ideology seemed an echo of Communism. John F. Kennedy, a staunch anti-Communist, avoided the progressive label but once said that he was “proud to be a liberal.”
But now the term “liberal” itself, with its emphasis on economic freedom, democracy, and individual rights, has fallen out of favor with many Democrats. They’ve helped give birth to a new progressivism, which emulates its predecessor’s disdain for individual freedoms and its admiration for collective action. But the new version differs from the old in at least one crucial respect, as one left-leaning writer explains: “The almost complete lack of attention being paid by modern progressives to public administration and government structure.” Even progressives themselves, when they’re not pontificating with overstuffed clichés about social justice, environmental harmony, and sustainable economics, worry about the movement’s flimsy track record of achievement. When Bill de Blasio became New York’s mayor, taking over after 20 years of successful governance by two non-progressive mayors, you could sense the anxiety within the movement: “Many progressives believe the best thing de Blasio can do to make a difference for progressive politics is to be a great mayor of New York City,” wrote Salon. That imperative was especially urgent given that New York’s last acknowledged progressive mayor was David Dinkins, whose reign was so disastrous that he became a one-termer. De Blasio is currently making such a mess of governing that he risks being the latest progressive to be one-and-done in Gotham.
Others on the left fret about what actual results this new progressivism, seemingly unmoored from governing realities, could produce. Some left-of-center economists have already worried publicly, for instance, that the rush to raise the minimum wage all the way up to $15 an hour might shrink employment in the country—and how that might spark a backlash against other progressive-minded economic prescriptions.
Hence the drumbeat about progressivism that’s practical and effective. Hillary Clinton spent years as a U.S. senator and then as a cabinet member, but she nonetheless felt that she had to tell voters in her Philadelphia speech that “I’m a progressive who likes to get things done.” What’s the alternative, one wonders—a progressive who doesn’t like getting things done? Hammering home the point, Clinton and her political supporters similarly described running mate Tim Kaine—long acknowledged as a moderate Democrat—as “a progressive who gets results.”
State delegations are pushing the same line. On the convention’s third day, the speaker of the California Assembly boasted at a breakfast that “California is proof that you can be progressive and prosperous at the same time.” The day before, Cuomo had called New York a “progressive bellwether for the nation.” The two big coastal states make poor advertisements for progressive success, however. New York and California rank, respectively, as the nation’s most unequal and seventh-most unequal states. Whole swaths of both states have been left behind by the current economic recovery. Nine of the 10 metropolitan areas with the highest unemployment rates today are in California. In New York, where two Cuomos have led the government for 17 of the last 33 years, large regions north and west of New York City and its suburbs are depressed; former governor Eliot Spitzer, on a visit upstate, compared some areas to Appalachia. http://www.city-journal.org/html/left-doth-protest-too-much-14683.html

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    10 years ago

States like NY and California will always have the most inequality-- because they have the most very wealthy people.

And NY will always have wealthy people, because its the center of the Stock Market. California has Silicon valley.  Both of those things bring in tremendous amounts of money. 

So income equality will be great-- regardless of the number of poor people.

But the two states also have the largest stream of immigrant-- and most immigrants when they arrive won't have jobs or high economic status. (California because they are one of the main states for two different immigrant types-- both Mexicans and Chinese. And New York , on the other coast, because its the main immigration entry point for European, African. & Middle-Eastern immigrants).

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

Although I believe you are right when it comes to Hispanic/Mexican immigrants who are generally poor, for some reason I don't think that Chinese immigrants come to the US with empty pockets. They don't exactly cross the Pacific in rafts. The example of the Vancouver area is that the Chinese are responsible for the skyrocketing price of real estate there due to outbidding local residents. It became so bad that the Province imposed a substantial tax on non-resident purchases to slow it down.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

Although I believe you are right when it comes to Hispanic/Mexican immigrants who are generally poor, for some reason I don't think that Chinese immigrants come to the US with empty pockets. They don't exactly cross the Pacific in rafts. The example of the Vancouver area is that the Chinese are responsible for the skyrocketing price of real estate there due to outbidding local residents. It became so bad that the Province imposed a substantial tax on non-resident purchases to slow it down.

I don't know.  Maybe something you might want to listen to Buzz.  Open it in another window and come back to this one.  If all the immigrants here were Chinese we'd be in great shape.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  sixpick   10 years ago

Okay, I got through about 15 minutes of it until boredom (perhaps a dementia-approaching condition) took over.  I did get the point that the Chinese are at about 32% welfare usage as compared to very high numbers from others.  My personal experience with this is when I was one of a group who sponsored in Canada a Vietnamese boat person and his young daughter. He worked two jobs, eventually bought a home, sent his daughter to university, and remained a good friend of everyone in our sponsorship group - we all admired his industry, humility, and fine character.

 
 

Who is online






139 visitors