Trump's National Security Plan - 1950's ,"Anti-Communist" Style, Investigations And Loyalty Tests
LA TIMES EDITORIAL AUG 15 2016
"....“In the Cold War, we had an ideological screening test,” Trump said. “The time is overdue to develop a new screening test for the threats we face today.” Instead of excluding immigrants with communist views, he suggested, a Trump administration would bar immigrants “who have hostile attitudes toward our country or its principles — or who believe that Sharia law should supplant American law.” (How he would test for such attitudes — and why those who harbored them wouldn’t conceal them — went unexplained.)
And where the House Un-American Activities Committee delved into the alleged disloyalty of Americans during the Cold War, Trump would establish a Commission on Radical Islam that would “expose the networks in our society that support radicalization.” Trump said that “reformist voices in the Muslim community” would be invited to take part — an invitation unlikely to be accepted.
The goal of these initiatives, Trump suggested, would be to promote assimilation of Muslims and spare the United States the sort of alienation that has produced violence in Europe. What he apparently doesn’t recognize is that Muslims are far better assimilated in America than they are in the European countries that have been victimized by Islamist terrorists.
Obviously Americans aren’t immune to the siren call of Islamist extremism; witness the attacks in Boston, San Bernardino and Orlando, all of which Trump mentioned. Screening of potential immigrants and asylum-seekers for possible connections to terrorism is a matter of common sense as well as national security.
But ideological litmus tests for immigrants and a national commission to study “radical Islam” could be catastrophically counterproductive. Requiring assent to a checklist of values would punish thoughts rather than deeds and might encourage newcomers to dissemble about their beliefs. A commission designed to expose radicals could bring back the days of blacklists and guilt by association. These are frightening ideas. It’s no surprise that they have been proposed by Donald Trump."
http://www.latimes.com/opinion/editorials/la-ed-trump-foreignpolicy-20160816-snap-story.html
Tags
Who is online
137 visitors

Malcolm Vance, a 35 year veteran of counter terrorism operations and analysis ( ) said later that Trump's call for loyalty tests and surveillance of American Muslims is the stupidest thing on the subject of terrorism that he has ever seen.
The reason? It will create more home grown terrorists than it uncovers.
WE can start calling Trump, ''Tail Gunner Joe''.....Opps one problem, he never served in the military. Perhaps we can call him, ''Deferment Donald''.....
Public support for Trump's speech seems mild at best. Another fail.
He was low energy while reading it too.