╌>

Media Hype “Optics” In AP Report On Clinton Foundation, While Admitting There Is No Evidence Of Ethics Breaches

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  looser-too  •  10 years ago  •  2 comments

Media Hype “Optics” In AP Report On Clinton Foundation, While Admitting There Is No Evidence Of Ethics Breaches

http://mediamatters.org/research/2016/08/24/media-hype-optics-ap-report-clinton-foundation-while-admitting-there-no-evidence-ethics-breaches/212634

Media are attempting to scandalize a report from The Associated Press that revealed that “[m]ore than half the people outside the government who met with now-Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton while she was secretary of state gave money ... to the Clinton Foundation,” calling the report “breathtaking” and “disturbing,” because it “looks bad,” and the “optics” and “perceptions” are problematic, despite the fact that their programs also note that “it wasn’t illegal,” and there was no quid pro quo. The focus on the “optics” of the situation rather than the facts has led some in media to criticize the reporting, and explain that “consumers of the media [should] think twice about whether or not the narrative” media are pushing “fits ALL of the facts.”

Suggesting “The Optics Are Disturbing” While Admitting “There’s No Evidence That There Were Ethics Breaches” Is Terrible Reporting


Journalist And Yale Political Science Lecturer John Stoehr Criticized The Media For Reporting Accusations Of “Pay To Play” When There Is “No Evidence To Suggest” Wrongdoing.  In a series of tweets, Yale lecturer and journalist John Stoehr criticized the media coverage of Judicial Watch’s allegations, saying it proves the thesis of a 1996  Atlantic  piece called “Why Americans Hate the Media.” He said of Clinton’s actions, “This is not pay to play. There’s no evidence to suggest it, no matter how much the right-wing group Judicial Watch urges to the contrary.” [ Media Matters ,  8/23/16 ]

MSNBC.com: “There Are No Real Allegations Of Wrongdoing, Only Assorted Details That Seem Kinda Sorta Wrong. … The Result Is Something That  Resembles  A ‘Controversy,’ Even If The Evidence Is Vague And Unpersuasive.”  In an August 24 article on MSNBC.com, Steve Benen wrote that “there are no real allegations of wrongdoing here, only assorted details that seem kinda sorta wrong to Clinton’s detractors” creates “something that resembles a ‘controversy,’ even if the evidence is vague and unpersuasive.” From MSNBC.com’s August 24 article (emphasis original):


The report from the Associated Press yesterday came with a headline designed to raise eyebrows: “More than half those who met Clinton as Cabinet secretary gave money to Clinton Foundation.” The story’s lede leaves no doubt that the AP believes it’s uncovered something resembling wrongdoing.

[...]

But right off the bat, the first sentence undercuts the provocative headline: “more than half” of those Clinton met with  “outside of government”  supported her husband’s charitable foundation. In other words, to arrive at the controversial figure, the Associated Press had to exclude all kinds of people: State Department officials, diplomats, ambassadors, foreign leaders and officials, White House personnel, military servicemen and women, etc.
 
In other words, after excluding the people any Secretary of State might ordinarily see on a typical day, and looking exclusively at this smaller subset of people Hillary Clinton met with, more than half of  them  contributed to Bill Clinton’s charity.

[...]

There are no real allegations of wrongdoing here, only assorted details that seem kinda sorta wrong to Clinton’s detractors. The result is something that  resembles  a “controversy,” even if the evidence is vague and unpersuasive. There’s a perception of some unidentified wrongdoing, and evidently, that’s enough.

[...]

But without proof of improprieties, this new “scandal,” at least for now, rings hollow. [MSNBC.com,  8/24/16 ]


Washington Monthly ’s Nancy LeTourneau: “From The Perspective Of The Other People Judging” Clinton, “It  Looks  Bad. Welcome To The World Of Optics As Scandal.”  In an article titled “How the AP Spun the Story About the Clinton Foundation,”  Washington Monthly  magazine’s Nancy LeTourneau explained how the AP report “has just shown us why it is important to be vigilant in how we consume the news as it is reported.” LeTourneau lambasted media for reporting on the AP report by suggesting that “it just plain  looks bad,” saying, “That is basically what most every drummed up ‘scandal’ against Hillary Clinton comes down to.” From  Washington Monthly ’s August 24 article (emphasis original):


The Associated Press has just shown us why it is important to be vigilant in how we consume the news as it is reported. They took some interesting information they gathered and spun it into something it wasn’t…scandalous.

[...]

In other words, what it comes down to is “it just plain  looks  bad.” That is basically what most every drummed up “scandal” against Hillary Clinton comes down to: from the perspective of the people judging her – it  looks  bad. Welcome to the world of optics as scandal.

One way to look at this is that the AP spun the story they wanted to tell about this information. That happens almost all the time and we often don’t notice. To clarify how that happened here, note first of all the AP headline: “Many Donors to Clinton Foundation Met With Her at State.” As Adam Khan points out – that’s actually not true.

[...]

One has to wonder why the AP chose this story of Clinton’s 30+ year relationship with a Nobel Peace Prize recipient committed to combating global poverty as the one to highlight in their efforts to suggest that the Secretary of State met with people because of their donations to the Clinton Foundation. I can’t imagine a more flawed example.

I am not suggesting any nefarious motives on the part of the AP reporters. But as we see so often in the media, the facts must be paired with a narrative that gives them meaning. It behooves us as consumers of the media to think twice about whether or not the narrative fits ALL of the facts. [ Washington Monthly ,  8/24/16 ]


Vox’s Matthew Yglesias: “Journalists Need To Admit When We’ve Struck Out.”  Vox’s Matthew Yglesias wrote that publications will sometimes use “spurious findings” because “everyone is trying to be interesting,” and the Associated Press report is no exception. Yglesias wrote that the AP report “did not come up with anything” and “that’s the story” and “despite very intensive media scrutiny of the Clinton Foundation, we don’t have hard evidence of any kind of corrupt activity”:


Publication bias is the name of a well-known but hard to solve problem in academic research. A paper with a striking new finding is much more likely to be accepted at a top journal than a paper that says, “I investigated an interesting hypothesis, but it turned out to be wrong.” This means that spurious findings — statistical coincidences and such — make it into the published literature, while boring null results don’t. This gives a distorted picture of reality simply because everyone is trying to be interesting.

Similarly, the AP’s basic reporting project here seems like it was worth a shot and probably also fairly time-consuming. But it did not come up with anything. Clinton tried to help a Nobel Prize winner. She went to the Kennedy Center Honors. She had a meeting with the head of the charitable arm of MAC Cosmetics about a State Department charitable initiative.

There’s just nothing here. That’s the story. Braun and Sullivan looked into it, and as best they can tell, she’s clean.

[...]

The real news here ought to be just the opposite: Donors to the Clinton Foundation may believe they are buying Hillary Clinton’s political allegiance, but the reality is that they are not. I wouldn’t be surprised if there is someone, somewhere whom Clinton met with whom she wouldn’t have met with had that person not been a Clinton donor of some kind. But what we know is that despite very intensive media scrutiny of the Clinton Foundation, we don’t have hard evidence of any kind of corrupt activity. That’s the story. [Vox.com,  8/24/16 ]


 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

RED BOX RULES

OFF TOPIC COMENTS WILL BE REMOVED AT THE DISCRETION OF THE SEEDER

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    10 years ago

Just because something looks bad, doesn't mean it is.  

I'm very disappointed in AP.  This is something I expect from Fox, not the AP.  I hope some heads roll over this. 

 
 

Who is online





140 visitors