The Bigotry of Our Time
The Bigotry of Our Time
By Douglas Murray, The Gatestone Institute, June 16, 2015
The letters page of The Guardian in the UK is regularly filled with letters, jointly signed by "correct-thinking" people who hope that in so doing, they will give themselves both a little puff of publicity and simultaneously signal their loyalty to all modern virtues. The pecking order can be rough. Ordinarily the paper selects the headline names to put under the letter and then adds "and 57 others" or some such. So if you're the Guardian 's idea of a household name, your name will get in print. But if you are one of the space-filler "C-list" celebrities, people will have to guess whether you are among the "others."
The letter that went into the Guardian this week was unusual in having almost nobody sign it who is a household name. The letter was a demand from a group of "artists, producers and concerned citizens," who, it said, "are disappointed and saddened to see that Curzon, Odeon, Bafta and other cinemas are hosting the London Israeli Film and Television Festival." It takes a particular type of ego to think their "sadness" should be the subject of a public declaration; however, these saddened signatories warned that, "This comes at a time when the global boycott, divestment, and sanctions (BDS) movement against Israel is gaining unprecedented momentum, and the Israeli government is finding itself increasingly isolated for its systematic violation of Palestinian human rights, the Geneva conventions, and international law."
The complaint against the London cinemas for hosting the event comes, the signatories claim, because "The Israeli state is promoting this festival and supporting it financially. By hosting it, these cinemas are ignoring the 2004 call by Palestinian civil society for sanctions against Israel until Israel abides by international law and ends its illegal displacement of Palestinians, discrimination against them, and occupation of their land."
As you might guess, the signatories claim the right to decide what should or should not be shown, and where, because they say they are in the movie business.
They go on to claim that, "This festival comes in the aftermath of the wanton destruction and killing in the Gaza Strip by the Israeli military in 2014, and the re-election of an Israeli prime minister who denies Palestinians their equal rights and self-determination."
Of course, every word of all that is untrue. Have any of the signatories any idea of what "wanton destruction" -- as opposed to the most targeted and precise use of military technology in any conflict in history -- actually looks like?
Anyhow, their interminable letter continues to declare that the screening of Israeli films in these circumstances makes the cinemas "silent accomplices" to violence. For a profession so obsessed with glorifying violence, you would think that the signatories would be more careful about throwing around such charges, but almost none of the signatories seems to have anything much to do with film. Of the more than forty signatories, only Ken Loach and Mike Leigh could have any claim to prominence in their field. Some people may remember Miriam Margolyes -- another signatory -- for a bit-part in one of the Harry Potter films, but these days she is best known for signing anti-Israel joint letters "as a Jew." The other signatories include as their occupation "activist," a "Theatre Maker," a schoolteacher and a university lecturer from Bournemouth.
| Director Ken Loach (left) is the most prominent signatory of a letter to the UK'sGuardiannewspaper, calling for a boycott of the London Israeli Film and Television Festival. Actress Miriam Margolyes (right), another signatory, is best known for signing anti-Israel joint letters "as a Jew." |
Their opinions on Israeli counter-terrorism strategy may be those of a group of teachers, the unemployed and two extreme-left filmmakers, but it is Israel they are against, so of course the letter is of note. So much so, that it received an accompanying news story in the print edition of the paper. This gave a further quote from Ken Loach, who said: "The boycott campaign specifically says this is not a campaign against individual film-makers, it is a call for a boycott when the state of Israel invests money or is promoting the event. I'd be the last person to want to censor an individual voice."
One doubts, in fact, that Loach would be the last. He is always among the first. The letter -- and the surrounding furore -- is simply the latest in a series of attempts to make Israeli and indeed Jewish culture "forbidden." In London, we have had Israeli orchestras, theatre companies and even string quartets howled down by mobs during performances, and Israeli-performed shows cancelled because the venues hosting them just do not want the bother. Last year, the Tricycle Theatre in London refused to proceed with a festival of "Jewish" culture because a tiny proportion of the festival's funding was coming from the Israeli embassy in London.
The campaign is obviously organized. The same names crop up again and again. Little, if any, rigour is paid to whether the signatories of such letters even do what they say do, or have opinions worthy of any note. Beneath the barely-built veneer of "professionals objecting to something in their own profession," is just the same tiny number of anti-Israel and anti-Jewish obsessives. A sprinkling of "as a Jew" Jews, like Margolyes, help, of course. But the aim is clear. These people, step by step, want to make every expression of Israeli and Jewish cultural life subject to their idea of how a nation under constant threat of terrorist bombardment should behave. They denounce Israel as a militaristic society and then attempt to outlaw every non-militaristic cultural and artistic expression from that society.
It is the bigotry of our time. And if unchecked, it will lead in the same direction as it historically has done. Thankfully, although few people have seen the films of those self-important Guardian letter signatories, we have all seen this larger, historical film -- and it is not one that decent people would like to see repeated.
Their opinions on Israeli counter-terrorism strategy may be those of a group of teachers, the unemployed and two extreme-left filmmakers, but it is Israel they are against, so of course the letter is of note. So much so, that it received an accompanying news story in the print edition of the paper. This gave a further quote from Ken Loach, who said: "The boycott campaign specifically says this is not a campaign against individual film-makers, it is a call for a boycott when the state of Israel invests money or is promoting the event. I'd be the last person to want to censor an individual voice."
One doubts, in fact, that Loach would be the last. He is always among the first. The letter -- and the surrounding furore -- is simply the latest in a series of attempts to make Israeli and indeed Jewish culture "forbidden." In London, we have had Israeli orchestras, theatre companies and even string quartets howled down by mobs during performances, and Israeli-performed shows cancelled because the venues hosting them just do not want the bother. Last year, the Tricycle Theatre in London refused to proceed with a festival of "Jewish" culture because a tiny proportion of the festival's funding was coming from the Israeli embassy in London.
The campaign is obviously organized. The same names crop up again and again. Little, if any, rigour is paid to whether the signatories of such letters even do what they say do, or have opinions worthy of any note. Beneath the barely-built veneer of "professionals objecting to something in their own profession," is just the same tiny number of anti-Israel and anti-Jewish obsessives. A sprinkling of "as a Jew" Jews, like Margolyes, help, of course. But the aim is clear. These people, step by step, want to make every expression of Israeli and Jewish cultural life subject to their idea of how a nation under constant threat of terrorist bombardment should behave. They denounce Israel as a militaristic society and then attempt to outlaw every non-militaristic cultural and artistic expression from that society.
It is the bigotry of our time. And if unchecked, it will lead in the same direction as it historically has done. Thankfully, although few people have seen the films of those self-important Guardian letter signatories, we have all seen this larger, historical film -- and it is not one that decent people would like to see repeated.

The actions that are being taken are reminiscent of Germany in the 1930s. I will not be surprised to see a new Kristallnacht soon. Look at their faces, if you can.
Why is it that Jewish citizens of France, or England, or Germany, or Denmark, or Sweden who have no ties to Israel, are probably not Zionists, but just want to live out their lives as peaceful and peace-loving citizens of the countries in which they are resident are being attacked. Why are they to blame for what is happening in Israel? Could it just possibly be because they are....Jewish?
Okay, flame, you consider yourself the champion of the underdog, the downtrodden. So what we are seeing is a big rise in world-wide anti-Semitism, a desire on the part not just of Hamas to wipe out the Jews of the world, Muslim countries that make the life of any Jews still remaining there miserable (if they are even allowed to live there), almost a million Jews who were not Israelis forced out of their homes and made into refugees who do not (as the Palestinians do) get UN pogey, a focus by the UN and its branches almost entirely on criticizing Israel while being blind to the horrors perpetrated by other countries and other religions, many of whom sit on the committees or branches that demonize Israel, Jewish temples and synagogues and offices of Jewish organizations throughout the world require guards to be posted, especially during High Holiday time.....need I go on?
So, who's the downtrodden, flame? Open your mind.
Protests and peaceful demonstrations are not the problem, flame. You really don't get it, do you. Obviously you dont disagree with the fact that innocent Jews are being attacked and murdered around the world even in Western countries.I wish you would try to pretend you're Jewish for a few days - just to see what it's like. You can get the idea if you watch the movie "Gentlemen's Agreement". Try being a Jewish kid on campus, even a Jewish kid who doesn't agree with Israel's defence tactics. You have no idea what it's like to be Jewish, and as I've said before you have no idea what life is like in Israel because you've never been there, but typical of most armchair critics you regurgitate what you read.
At least a day ago I posted a comment on your article
(Israeli leader criticizes upcoming UN report on Gaza war), and although you responded to comments that were posted after it was posted, you never bothered to respond to this one. I would have liked to have seen what your dissent to this would have been.
There is a folk song written and sung by Ian and Sylvia (Canadian folk music duo from the 1960s-70s) called "You Were on My Mind".
"When I woke up this morning
You were on my mind
And you were on my mind..."
So I just woke up this morning and this article was on my mind. The first thing I noticed is how half-truths and outright lies can lead a reasonable discussion astray. For example, when I read this:
Every few years the IDF moves in and cuts back the population and economic gains of Palestinians.
That might be taken from a pro-Palestinian source, but the fact is that it suggests that Israel just once in a while decides to go kill a lot of people. The fact is that the only time Israel has "moved in" is when they are attacked, such as rockets being fired into civilian areas, and even then they allow thousands to rain in on them before they take action to stop them. The provocation is from Gaza and what nation in the world would not try to stop them if they were the target?
However, you can believe whatever you want, Hamas propaganda, Israeli propaganda, pro-Palestinian Jews like Noam Chomsky and Norman Finklestein, NGO's that take sides even opposite to their brethren, pro-Israeli Palestinians (and I have seen some), but when I see a report from an experienced and qualified military and political group that are neither Muslim nor Jewish, neither Israeli or Arab, I tend to believe it.
My reasons for my personal bias goes back to when I was child, to the time of The Holocaust, to the time of Partition - I remember the emotion of that time. My personal bias is because, contrary to so many armchair critics who are taking a stand on this issue, more than once I travelled in Israel, and in Jordan, Egypt and The West Bank and have personal experiences as does my immediate family. I witnessed a bus bomb explosion that took many innocent lives. I had to hide in a bomb shelter from Hezbollah bombs. But for the grace of God my daughter is still alive because she wasn't standing right beside her classmate Marni Kimelman who stepped on a buried pipe bomb on the Tel Aviv beach.Only by the grace of God my son is still alive because he slept in one morning instead of having coffee at the Jerusalem street cafe in front of where he was sleeping when a bomb went off there.
The UN is perpetuating the conflict, by continually financially supporting the multiple generations of Palestinian refugees (but of course never considering doing the same for the nearly one million Jewish refugees forced out of Arab/Muslim countries) so the Palestinian refugees need not go hungry, need not make a life for themselves, but how many people who chastise Israel for its treatment of the Palestinians give a shit about the Palestinian refugees in Syria who were wiped out? You know what I think about that "selectivity" but I'm not allowed to say it.
This issue is never in my lifetime going to be solved, and I'm beginning to think it's just a waste of time to even think about it. It is obvious to any sensible person that after the Palestinians had been offered, but walked away from, more than once, almost 100% of their demands, they will never recognize Israel as being a Jewish State, and they will never give up their resistance. There will never be a solution to this problem until Israel is, as has been threatened by Iran, by Hamas, by many Palestinians and by many of their supporters, wiped off the face of the Earth, but at my age I don't think I'll live to see that day.