╌>

Why Trump’s Maternity Leave Proposal Is Smart

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  10 years ago  •  109 comments

Why Trump’s Maternity Leave Proposal Is Smart
At a campaign visit to Aston, Pennsylvania Tuesday, Donald Trump announced a new policy proposal on paid maternity leave for all American women. According to the Washington Post, Trump would have the federal government guarantee six weeks of paid leave to every new mother.

Trump’s declaration puts him at odds with conservative orthodoxy and many Republican Party leaders. As with his minimum wage proposal, he has stolen a popular idea from the Democratic playbook. In this case, however, conservatives should think twice before rejecting this challenge to the status quo.


When a societal shift emerges, conservatives have two options: resist it with all our might, or accept it and work to make the resulting change fit with our idea of a just society. Which approach to choose depends on the nature of the shift. Abortion, for most conservatives, falls into the first approach, because we believe no just society can comprehend wholesale violence against its most vulnerable members.

Most other changes suggest the second approach. The income tax, for example, was new and radical a century ago; now, most changes we propose involve making it better, fairer, and simpler, rather than repealing it entirely. Most conservatives can imagine a just society that includes taxes in income.

Paid maternity leave increasingly looks to be another of these latter issues. Since women have entered the workforce in numbers equal to men, doing work equal to men, society must necessarily confront that women are different from men, most obviously regarding human reproduction.

A man and woman may agree to share child-rearing responsibilities equally, but one of them, physically, bears a far greater burden. How to handle that scenario for working women was always going to be a part of the question of women in the workplace. That we have done our best to ignore it until now shows the answer is not simple or obvious.

We Can Be Pragmatic About This
The question of whether and how to pay women for the time they spend away from work following the birth of a child is one on which reasonable people may disagree, and there are many shades of gray in among the potential answers. Who should pay? How much should they pay? Who is eligible? For how long? None of these questions requires the black-or-white answer suitable to the questions that truly divide American society. There is room for compromise, and conservatives can work to make that eventual compromise as close as possible to one that matches our vision of what our society should be.


Paid maternity leave is a change that is coming, whether conservatives want it or not. A YouGov survey last year found that 69 percent of Americans believed employers should be required to offer women paid leave after the birth of a child, against only 19 percent who were opposed. An AP-GfK poll earlier in 2015 found a similar result, with 67 percent in favor and 13 percent opposed.

Small-government conservatives recoil at the idea of progressives’ universal mandates, and rightly so, but facing a 50 percent margin of defeat in popular opinion, it might be time to abandon outright opposition and shift toward managing a just solution to something a large majority of Americans see as a serious problem.

Maternity Leave, Republican-Style
Trump’s paid maternity leave proposal works through the existing system of state unemployment insurance that has been in place since the New Deal. In its embrace of federalism, this is already more conservative than many proposals from the Left (existing unemployment insurance is subject to federal oversight but administered by the states).

Further, adding onto an existing benefit structure would mean maternity leave would be paid out through a state-by-state bureaucracy that has long experience in delivering benefits—and detecting fraud. A new federally administered benefit would mean a whole new system of rules and regulations, and a new bureaucracy to sort them out. We saw how well that worked out with Obamacare’s exchanges. Simply expanding the unemployment system to cover a new form of short-term joblessness avoids those growing pains and missteps.

The unemployment system also has the advantage of cost transparency. As with Social Security, unemployment insurance was sold to the American people as a kind of self-sustaining insurance system. This is only partly true. In both systems, there is no account with your name on it: benefits are paid out of current taxes. In both, although the amount you may receive is related to how long you worked and how much you earned, it is not a one-to-one correlation.


While both systems’ financing mechanisms appear transparent in the line-item flat tax listed on your pay stub, the truth is more complicated. Those taxes pay for Social Security and unemployment, but so do other taxes on employers that are not listed. As the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities explains, it is all ultimately a tax on your labor, but only some of it is easily disclosed.

We’d All Have to Pay For This, For Sure
A more transparent policy would show the entire tax take on people’s pay stubs, letting the potential beneficiaries understand the full cost of their benefit. I suspect most people would not change their minds—the amount is still smaller than any other payroll deduction—but at least they would be working with all the facts.

This is where the Trump plan goes awry. With his typical fuzzy math, Trump calls his plan “self-supporting,” saying eliminating fraud in the system could pay for it. This is what politicians often tell us when they want to promise voters something for nothing. It is, as the vice president might say, “malarkey.”

To be fair to Trump, the source of Hillary Clinton’s plan’s funding is not much clearer. On her campaign website, Clinton promises 12 weeks of paid leave with “no additional costs on businesses” by some vaguely worded “tax reforms that will ensure the wealthiest Americans pay their fair share.” To translate: “tax reforms” means “tax increases” and “wealthiest Americans” means anyone with a job.

Of all the 2016 candidates, only Bernie Sanders admitted he would raise taxes to pay for his maternity leave plan (also 12 weeks.) Although Sanders’s projected costs (“$1.61 a week for a typical worker”) are probably too optimistic, at least the voters can see the costs of the proposal before deciding if they want the benefit.

Let’s Make It Better
If conservatives cede the field to progressives on this issue, we will have no input into its outcome. The next time Democrats hold the presidency and Congress, they will impose their vision of maternity and paternity leave, whether we like it or not. To imagine how that might turn out, look at Obamacare: a bloated collection of recycled Beltway ideas spiced up with a few handouts to the insurance lobby and other interest groups, simultaneously unworkable and unrepealable. It was sold as cheap and easy to manage, and has proven to be anything but.


Republican involvement was never going to save Obamacare—the Democrats’ huge legislative majorities in 2009 made Republicans’ input unnecessary—but a program acceptable to both sides might have been better constructed and more successful at solving the problem. Instead, we have a program that makes life worse for the average American family. The same would likely be true of any new Democratic benefit scheme, including paid maternity leave.

So what would a conservative paid leave policy look like? As I’ve said, transparency in the costs is a must. As much as people hate taxes, there are some things they are willing to pay for. To see if this is one of them, we must present the choice honestly, with all the potential pluses and minuses. If it would really cost the average American less than $2 a week, as Bernie promised, many people would sign right up. But we must have all of the facts before we decide.

Another improvement could be reducing the coercive elements present in most progressive plans. The minimum wage, for example, is easy for congressional Democrats to raise, because they bear none of the costs. Instead, they use the law to interpose themselves between employer and employee and dictate workers’ salaries. Similarly, the Americans with Disabilities Act demands businesses upgrade their properties, but fails to provide any funding. The bill passes costs to business owners, whether they can afford it or not.

The unemployment system has no such unfunded mandate. Any tax-funded system has some coercion at its core—people don’t pay taxes out of the goodness of their hearts—but that is a criticism of all government, not just paid maternity leave. This system, at least, adds no new unfunded mandate to further burden employers. All that would be required of them is to hold the employee’s position while she is out, something already required of employers for up to 12 weeks under the Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993. Many changes in labor law harm businesses’ profitability, but this proposal leaves them in the same position they currently occupy.

Conservatives could also use the maternity leave program to undo some of the damage done to American families by Great Society anti-poverty programs over the last half-century. Trump’s proposal does not cover paternity leave, but Clinton’s website suggests she thinks men should get time off, too. While short on specifics, she would likely mirror European plans that give fathers and mothers equal leave time.

A conservative plan could limit paternity leave to fathers who are actively involved with their child’s daily life; that is, those who are married to and cohabitating with the child’s mother. Unlike most federal programs, this one could serve as an incentive to marriage. Don’t expect such an idea to find its way into a bill passed by Democrats alone.

Do It For the Right Reasons
Paid maternity leave helps two-income households maintain a more consistent income while having children, something that hasn’t been possible since men stopped being the sole breadwinners. In a year when both political parties are looking at the world with their own shade of nostalgia, that would seem to be reason enough to push the policy: regaining one of the advantages of the old days while keeping the advances of the new. Sounds like a winner! http://thefederalist.com/2016/09/15/trumps-maternity-leave-proposal-smart/

Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ    10 years ago

This is all BS.  First of all, republican men don't think women should be allowed to work so this is a ridiculous notion that its a joint partnership.  These inferior small handed men think women should be prisoners in the home and tied to the kids and the kitchen.  Waiting on their all mighty man to come home from work and then flutter around him kissing his butt to make sure he's happy otherwise he'll trade her in for a newer model.  Almost the marriage model of none other than....yep, you got it.....Donald Trump!

I'm so darn tired of hearing MEN tell me what's best for me!  If you're going to try and control me you've got to have at minimum big hands.  I mean really really huuuuge hands. I've got to go because I'm starting to hyperventilate.  

The plan isn't paid for so it will never come to fruition except in the male's mind.

 

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

Pj, a bit of a broad brush, there.  Republican men want their wives to be prisioners?  Come on, you don't really believe that, do you?  As far as "men" telling women what to do with their bodies, no, thats not the point.  Women want to work, and have babies, and expect to be treated exactly like men careerwise.  Just not feasible.   In my school, we have three pregnant teacher now.  They will get paid maternity leave for six weeks. And someone else will also get paid to do their jobs while they are gone.  How many small businesses can absorb those costs for a six months to a year maternity leave? For men and woman to have family leave? Reality is, you cannot have it all. Choices must be made. And in the end, we are responsible for ourselves. 

 

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

Jennilee - I admit that I do like to paint.  hahahaha

One of the things I noticed that you mentioned in your post was that the teachers were getting paid for six weeks of maternity.  I guess I would ask whether they were getting paid or whether they earned that leave.  It's not up to the employee to figure out how to reduce the cost of running a school.  In fact, I would say you have a great argument for the State to increase funding to schools but we know that's not going to happen.  States would prefer to gut schools and keep people ignorant.  

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

Sorry, not a public school.  Private funded child care center. Ages 0 through vpk, then a before and after school program.  Should we raise our tuition rates on families,  who may already be struggling to pay? Even if it was public school, you say the state should increase funding. That means higher taxes in the school districts.  Women fought for equality in the workplace, but then want employers to pay for our personal family decisions.  I don't think it is their responsibility.   

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

Curious perspective........ So women are the only ones who should suffer the consequences of the decision to have a family.  Interesting.  Thanks for that insight.  It's very revealing.

 

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

Suffer the consequences?  If you are thinking of child rearing as something that must be suffered, you have the wrong attitude about it.  Children and child bearing and rearing should be looked at as a blessing and be made important, not just something you do while waiting for something better to come along.  Businesses do not have responsibility for your family, the fathers and mothers do.  

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  jennilee   10 years ago

Of course.  You're absolutely right.  The woman should stay home.   

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  PJ   10 years ago

"First of all, republican men don't think women should be allowed to work so this is a ridiculous notion..."

Another blatant falsehood, another reason to stop reading.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

I'm starting to sense that it really was something I said.  You seem a little hostile tonight Cerenkov.  I hate to see you blue.....wait a minute......you're always blue!  chuckle

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    10 years ago

It gives us some good ideas and seems to be a workable idea. 

 

This proposal is merely window dressing hastily offered up in the hopes that a few women might forget what massive "Misogynist" he is.

His views on this issue are known.

Trump in 2004: Pregnancy Is an 'Inconvenience' to Employers

Donald Trump has said that pregnancy is "wonderful" - unless you're an employer.

In an October 2004 interview with NBC's Dateline, Trump said pregnancy is "a wonderful thing for the woman, it's a wonderful thing for the husband, it's certainly an inconvenience for a business. And whether people want to say that or not, the fact is it is an inconvenience for a person that is running a business."

 

Like most of the "ISSUES"  he says he's running on the info on this one is shallow and poorly thought out.

 

Trump’s maternity leave plan is a joke on parents of all genders

With the unveiling of his new child care plan, Donald Trump showed America how seriously he takes intelligence of women—the voters he is desperately trying to woo. Not very seriously at all.

Trump says he wants to close the gender pay gap and encourage more women to work. He plans to do that via a series of tax and corporate incentives that make child care more affordable. But the centerpiece of his plan for paid maternity leave calls for paying new mother to care for their newborns. But not new dads.

Denying fathers paid leave would likely perpetuate the discrimination that currently hobbles millions of mothers’ careers—and do little to boost wages and female labor participation.

 

Forbs;
Trump's 6 Week Maternity Plan: Too Little, Too Late, Say Parental Leave Advocates

 

Now, if one believes this IS an important discussion we need to be having, a much needed improvement to our society then I'd point you to a real, well thought out, program being offered by someone that has been working on this problem for more than 40 years.

 

Paid family and medical leave

It’s time to guarantee paid family and medical leave in America.

   "Too many moms have to go back to work just days after their babies are born. … And too many dads and parents of adopted children don’t get any paid leave at all. Neither do sons and daughters struggling to take care of their aging parents. None of this is fair to families.
    Hillary, May 23, 2016

The United States is the only developed nation in the world with no guaranteed paid leave of any kind. Supporting families isn’t a luxury—it’s an economic necessity. It’s past time for our policies to catch up to the way families live and work today.


As president, Hillary will:

    Guarantee up to 12 weeks of paid family and medical leave to care for a new child or a seriously ill family member, and up to 12 weeks of medical leave to recover from a serious illness or injury of their own.

    Ensure hardworking Americans get at least two-thirds of their current wages, up to a ceiling, while on leave.

    Impose no additional costs on businesses, including small businesses.

    Fund paid leave by making the wealthy pay their fair share—not by increasing taxes on working families.

Hillary will pay for her paid leave plan with tax reforms that will ensure the wealthiest Americans pay their fair share.

Hillary has a lifelong record of fighting for families:

    After graduating from Yale Law School, she went to work at the Children’s Defense Fund, where she helped expand access to education for children with disabilities.

    As first lady of Arkansas, she helped start Arkansas Advocates for Children and Families.

    As first lady of the United States, she helped win the fight for Family Medical Leave Act. When Bill Clinton became president, Hillary was on the front lines working to ensure the Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) was the first bill he signed into law.

    As U.S. senator from New York, she fought for paid leave. Hillary helped expand FMLA to wounded soldiers and their families. And in her campaign for president in 2007, she proposed a national paid leave program and called for guaranteeing paid parental leave for all federal employees.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    10 years ago

All this discussion about paid or unpaid leave sounds good, but that's not the biggest problem facing families or children.  A glance at my classroom of 2 year olds, two, 24 to 36 months old, shows some scary and unsettling statistics.  Breakdown:

In foster care...2.   Being raised by grandparents..4.   Dad not in their life....5. Parents separated..2. Parents married...5. Parents living together...4.   

So over 50 percent of kids in my class are being raised without a mother and father in the home.  All this fight about how much parental leave is necessary is just another way the government is trying to control lives with money.  It makes parents think that they need government intervention to be able to raise their families. And that is not what they need. They don't need less responsibility to their own lives and the lives of their children, they need more!

 

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    10 years ago

Unless one understands the difference between a tax exemption and a tax credit, one will not understand that Trump's plan benefits only those wealthy enough to hire nannies to watch and essentially raise their children.

Don't take my word for it … ask an accountant.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    10 years ago

If you insist on living in a fact-free world …

Otherwise …

Trump’s Childcare Plan Helps the Wealthy, Not the Poor

By now, you’re probably aware that Donald Trump gave a speech on economics yesterday. You may be less familiar with a particular piece of his speech—the bit where he addressed making childcare more affordable. As you may remember, affordable childcare played an important part in his daughter Ivanka’s speech at the Republican National Convention. How does Trump propose to fix the high costs of childcare, which often price women out of the job market entirely? Like  this :

My plan will also help reduce the cost of childcare by allowing parents to fully deduct the average cost of childcare spending from their taxes.

If you’re familiar with how taxes work, you’ll recognize that this is a  terrible  solution.  Here  is how twitter user and self-described econ wonk Michael Linden explained it:

13941121_10103641200986038_906620059_n

13933100_10103641201065878_2146079772_n

13956855_10103641201120768_1771516407_n

13933577_10103641201155698_448814766_n

13933254_10103641201270468_408594647_n

Here is the text of Linden’s tweets, which he helpfully numbered:

1. Making child care fully tax deductible is just about the worst possible way to help subsidize the cost of child care.

2. Roughly a third of households with kids in the bottom 80% have no fed. income tax liability so this policy wouldn’t help them at all.

3. By making child care deductible you’d be directing larger benefits to richer families than to poorer ones. That’s the nature of deductions.

4. For example, a family in the top tax bracket would get a $400 subsidy for every $1,000 paid in child care costs.

5. Whereas a middle class family in the 15% bracket would get only $150 in savings for the same $1,000 in child care costs.

6. And of course, it’s mostly middle and low-income families who really need help paying of child care, not those in the top tax bracket.

7. For families paying for childcare, making under $55,000, they spend an average of about 20% of their monthly income on child care.

8. For very low income families, that ratio can be as high as 45 percent. A tax deduction for child care doesn’t help them one penny.

9. Child care deductibility also doesn’t help families who have liquidity constraints. Child care costs are typically weekly or monthly.

10. But the benefits of a child care tax deduction, for most people, come once a year. Not much good when you’re struggling every week.

11. If you want to use the tax code to help families pay for child care there are better ways to do that. Expand and fix the CDCTC.

12. This is the policy you get when you ask 6 guys named Steve, but no women or people of color, how to help people pay for child care.

A tax deduction exempts a certain amount of your income from income tax. The mortgage tax deduction is an example of this—any money you spend on mortgage interest is deducted from your income for the purposes of federal income tax. Unfortunately, tax deductions tend to benefit the wealthy more than they do the middle class (who have lower tax brackets) or the poor (who may not have any federal income tax liability to begin with). This is a rich man’s solution to the problem of childcare costs. Given that it was a very rich man giving this speech, this is perhaps not surprising. It should, though, be soundly troubling. We need childcare solutions that center the needs of the poor and middle class.

- See more at:

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    10 years ago

Among the working poor are those who do not earn enough to owe taxes … they need child care in order to hold a job that doesn't pay them enough to afford child care.

The REAL world has some big time dilemmas.

And some of the companies that pay poorly, force their employees to require food stamps, WHICH MEANS THE TAXPAYERS SUBSIDIZES WELFARE FOR THOSE COMPANIES!

The game is rigged, my friend.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    10 years ago

I have gone through the article and since there was so much back and forward with the insults, that started with colorful use of language, I have cut those who now see "Delete" a small break and not marked them as violations even though they were. The only reason I have made this exception was that I was not available to moderate earlier. It better not happen again. 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    10 years ago

Anyone remember Greece?

United States GDP Growth Rate

 
 

Who is online





81 visitors