╌>

The facts speak for themselves: The Clintons have been quite literally a thousand times more charitable than The Donald.

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jr  •  10 years ago  •  23 comments

The facts speak for themselves: The Clintons have been quite literally a thousand times more charitable than The Donald.

 


SELF-DEALING



Tale of Two Charities: Trump’s Helps Trump While the Clintons’ Is the Real Deal.


The facts speak for themselves: The Clintons have been quite literally a thousand times more charitable than The Donald.



David Cay Johnston

DAVID CAY JOHNSTON



09.22.16 12:00 AM ET





Let’s do a reality check on the charitable giving of the two major presidential candidates in the hope of showing the reason that, to use my favorite Twitter hashtag,  #factsmatter .



First, let’s look at generosity measured as a share of wealth.



Giving money away is easy. Just write a check, sign a credit card voucher or, if you have assets, donate your home or appreciated stock.


 


But effecting change is hard, something I know from co-authoring with my wife, Jennifer Leonard, the Columbia Journalism Review’s 1983 guide for journalists on covering nonprofits, and training the original Chronicle of Philanthropy news staff. And being married for 34 years to the president of a very successful charitable endowment  has given me a very close look at what it takes to improve the lives of poor children and awareness of concentrated poverty where I live in Rochester, New York.



So let’s take the measure of Clinton and Trump’s charitable actions.



Since 2001, Trump has given $3.8 million to charities, the very limited public record on his giving shows. That includes a $1 million gift to a veterans’ charity as part of his campaign to win votes.




 



 





All of the $1.2 million the Donald J. Trump Charitable Foundation had at the end of 2014 came from vendors who do business with Trump. The foundation tax returns show only minor gifts by Trump since 2001 and none since 2008 when he gave $30,000, pocket change for someone who claims to be worth $10 billion.



Trump claims that over his lifetime he has given $102 million to charities, but  his refusal to release any tax returns  (or even proof that he is under audit) makes it impossible to verify that figure.


 


We do know that Trump has said he gave an easement that would bar development forever of land at his Palos Verdes, California, golf resort. Trump has indicated he took a $26 million charitable deduction, equal to almost the $27 million he paid for the entire site with its golf course and buildings. The site cannot be developed because of shifting earth and landslides, so why it would quality for any charitable deduction is unclear. The land in question is used as a driving range for the Trump golf course and resort, rather than as open space.



Since 2001 the Clintons have given $23.2 million to charity, their income tax returns reveal. The Clintons have released 39 consecutive years of tax returns.



Like Trump, the Clintons give primarily to a foundation bearing the family name, the Clinton Family Foundation.



Trump claims he is worth more than $10 billion. That means his verified gifts since 2001 come to less than four one-hundredths of 1 percent of his claimed wealth. Even if we accept his claim of $102 million—and count it as all being donated since 2001—his total giving would be just 1 percent of his claimed net worth.



The Clintons are worth no more than $62 million, their financial disclosure forms show. Their charitable donations since 2001 come to at least 37.6 percent of their maximum net worth.



This means that, relative to wealth, the Clintons have given at a rate a thousand times Trump’s verifiable charitable giving. Even accepting Trump’s claim that his giving is much larger than the public record shows, the Clintons gave at more than 37 times Trump’s rate.




 

 

 

 




The Clintons’ tax returns show that they tithe, giving away a tenth of their income, mostly, like Trump, to foundations bearing the family name.



Now what about the uses of these known charitable gifts? Giving money away is easy, while making a measurable difference is hard.



The Trump Foundation shows mostly small gifts, from $1,000 to $25,000. The three largest grants it made in 2014, its latest tax filing shows, all had an element of self-interest.



The largest grant, $100,000, went to Citizens United Foundation, which promotes anonymous donations to influence elections.



The Leukemia and Lymphoma Society of West Palm Beach was next at $50,000. It pays Trump  to host fundraisers  at the Trump-owned National Doral Miami, a luxury hotel, and  charity golf tournaments  on the Doral’s links.



The Trump foundation also gave $50,000 to Columbia Grammar and Prep School in Manhattan,  a private school whose students include Barron , the candidate’s youngest child.



Those three grants come to more than a third of the Trump Foundation’s 2014 grants, which totaled $591,450, a piddling sum for the self-described 10 billion-dollar man.



The self-interested nature of those grants fits with another pattern. The Trump foundation has made eight improper gifts,  some of which are flatly illegal , reporting by David Fahrenthold of  The Washington Post  and others shows.



These include a $25,000 political donation—a no-no for any charity—to help Pam Bondi win a second term as Florida attorney general. The Trump foundation improperly reported the gift on its annual tax filing, then offered a convoluted story about confusing the names of a Kansas and California charity with Bondi’s campaign group, whose treasurer said in 2013 it had no problem with accepting a campaign donation from the Trump charitable foundation. Trump says he paid a $2,500 penalty for the illegal campaign donation and donated $25,000 as a replacement of the money to his foundation.



The Trump foundation also paid off personal and business obligations of Trump,  The Washington Post  reported this week. That is known as self-dealing, which is also an illegal use of charitable funds. These include buying two paintings of himself for $30,000 and shelling out $258,000 to settle lawsuits.



And the Clinton Family Foundation and the related Clinton Global Initiative? The foundation is a grantmaker, while the  initiative facilitates action by others .



At least 11 million people are breathing as this is written because of the Clintons’ charitable endeavors, which increased the number of poor people overseas getting life-sustaining drugs to suppress HIV from about 250,000 to nearly 12 million.



Critics have questioned donations by others. Trump says Clinton engaged in pay-for-play when she was secretary of state, but has offered no proof, just assertions, of anything improper. The issue has received extensive news coverage, but no smoking gun has been found.



For example,  a front-page  Wall Street Journal  story this week  examined how the fragrance industry paid Bill Clinton to give a speech and also gave money to the global initiative’s Haiti office to help develop lime orchards in impoverished Haiti to ensure an abundant supply of citrus juice used for making nice scents. So some poor Haitians were better off because they had a buyer for their fruit.



Charity watchdogs groups have also examined the candidates’ foundations.



Charity Navigator lists Trump’s foundation as  unrated .



Charity Navigator gives the Clinton Foundation  a rating of 94.74  on a scale of 100.



Now let’s look at compliance and transparency.



There is no audited financial statement at the Trump websites for the Trump Foundation or any of the charity watchdogs.



The Clinton Foundation’s audited financial statements and amendments are all  online at its website .



In addition, responding to criticism, the Clintons ordered a forensic audit. That means instead of sampling accounts, as in a normal audit, an intense and aggressive hunt was made to find anything wrong. Nothing but minor matter were amiss.



Because some cynics are going to ask, I’ll disclose that my wife and I, who depend on her salary and my writing business for more than 99 percent of our income, gave 25 percent of what we earned last year to charities.



I expect to now hear from Trump fans who believe he is what he says he is, an ardent philanthropist running against “crooked Hillary.”



That’s not what the facts show. What they show is a lot of unverified claims and countervailing facts on Trump’s side and transparency and effective action on Clinton’s.



But the facts are what they are. You can download and examine the 990s of the Clinton and Trump charities for free by registering at  guidestar.org .




Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

In addition, responding to criticism, the Clintons ordered a forensic audit. That means instead of sampling accounts, as in a normal audit, an intense and aggressive hunt was made to find anything wrong. Nothing but minor matter were amiss.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

None of this will matter to the Trumpettes....Fact's are a foreign substance to them.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

The debates won't even matter to Trump supporters.  He could walk out on stage, pull out his tiny penis and wave it to the world, and Trump supporters would be unmoved.  His debate contributions will be a massive embarrassment to thinking folk, but not to the knuckle draggers who put him there.  He is a national disgrace an clearly the worst humanity has to offer as a leader.  

Sadly, he could be setting an example for future campaigns.  Unscrupulous politicians have seen that there is a block of voters who are unwavering in their dedication to not using their brain, and they are salivating over the prospect of controlling them.

Did anyone watch the tv series over the summer called Brain Dead?  It was an entertaining parody of this new America.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

He could walk out on stage, pull out his tiny penis and wave it to the world, and Trump supporters would be unmoved. 

Hillary could do the same thing and get the same reaction from her supporters . . . in fact, they would probably applaud her courage in being man enough to become a woman.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

As they are to John.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

This is a Clinton deflection. The issue is not which charity is more charitable. Instead, the question is whether the Clintons used their charity and the State Department as part of a pay to play scheme. An example would be the Russian uranium deal where the foundation got a $500 million contribution from the Russians at the same time Hillary was sitting on a panel that decides whether to raise objections to the deal. 

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

And, one of the latest news comments is that they only gave 15%  of their donations to charities.

Between 2009 and 2012, the Clinton Foundation raised over $500 million dollars according to a review of IRS documents by  The Federalist  ( 2012 ,  2011 ,  2010 , 2009 ,  2008 ). A measly  15 percent of that, or $75 million, went towards programmatic grants . More than $25 million went to fund travel expenses. Nearly $110 million went toward employee salaries and benefits. And a whopping $290 million during that period — nearly 60 percent of all money raised — was classified merely as “other expenses.” ...The Clinton Foundation may well be saving lives, but it seems odd that the costs of so many life-saving activities would be classified by the organization itself as just random, miscellaneous expenses. - 

PunditFact: A Case Study In Fact-Free Hackery

The problem here is not one of facts or accuracy, but ideology. Jacobson simply doesn’t like the implications of the fact that the Clinton Foundation spent less than 10 percent of its budgets on charitable grants in 2013. He doesn’t like the fact that the two single largest “charitable” initiatives of the Clinton Foundation — by its own admission — are the Clinton Presidential Library, which exists solely to put a positive spin on the 42nd president’s term in office, and the Clinton Global Initiative, which the New York Times characterized as a “glitzy annual gathering of chief executives, heads of state, and celebrities.” If hanging out with celebrities at glitzy dinners is the height of charity, then it’s time to beatify the Kardashian sisters.

Oh yeah - the Clinton Foundation has 49,000 employees, the Trump Foundation has 0.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

The Clinton Foundation is a charity itself, not an entity which gives money to other charities in the form of grants. That is where your misunderstanding lies. 

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

True - it is registered as a 501(3)(c) and it uses the 15% to maintain that status.  But, they are a slush fund designed to enhance Bill and Billary/Killary's life style way beyond proportion.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

The Clinton Foundation is a working charity. They have travel expenses because they have people traveling around the world doing the charity's work. You are falling for a bunch of crap 1st. 

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

"Working charity" Lol. They are certainly working the system... Fortunately it's not hard to dupe their audience. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

The clinton charity is a slush fund.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

I think I'll take David Cay Johnston's opinion over yours. He investigates this stuff for a living and has won a pulitizer prize for it. 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

''Oh yeah - the Clinton Foundation has 49,000 employees, the Trump Foundation has 0.''

You don't need employees if the foundations doesn't do anything other than give away other people money.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Which Trump does and the Clinton's don't.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

You may want to check out the number of times his ''charitable contributions'' have run a foul of the law 1st...Pam Bondi anyone.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

And the same holds true for the Clinton's.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

Wow, this is poor journalism. This "piece" fails to come close to proving it's premise. For a junior high debate class, I would give it a C for effort. Anyone buying into it gets a D-...

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

People who have reading comprehension understand the article. 

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

The Clinton foundation is hardly an open book and Hillary has a penchant for destroying or hiding what she doesnt want found so the absence of proof may mean that she's just up to old tricks. Did Johnston opine on whether he saw any problem with the Russian uranium deal or was that just fine to him?

And I'll note that the purpose of reporting charitable contributions on a tax return is to obtain a deduction from adjusted gross income to lower the amount taxed. It's a tax mechanism, not simply a matter of good heartedness. For all I know, Trump gives cash and doesn't report it as a deduction . . . but I don't really give a shit what either of them do with their money because I'm only concerned with what they do with mine.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Only useful idiots are swayed by this dishonest propaganda. 

 
 

Who is online






107 visitors