Hillary Clinton Declares War On The Right To Work
Hillary Clinton promises unions that if elected president she will fight against right-to-work laws that have resulted in faster growth and higher incomes. (Campaign video screenshot)
Democrats love to talk about rights. They say people have the "right to affordable health care," the "right to a debt free college education," the "right to choose," and so on.
But there's one right they apparently want to erase: The right to work.
Here's how Hillary Clinton put it in a videoconference this week at the Laborers' International Union of North America: "I will fight back against so-called right to work. Right to work is wrong for workers and wrong for America."
Come again? The right to work is wrong for America?
Clinton is referring to state right-to-work laws that give employees the right to work without being forced to join a union. In states without these laws, unions can force new and existing employees to join a union or pay union dues as a condition of employment at unionized companies.
Get instant access to exclusive stock lists and powerful tools on Investors.com. Try us free for 4 weeks.
Right to work has become increasingly popular. In fact, 26 states now have right-to-work laws on their books. And among the most recent to join this movement were Michigan and Wisconsin — two Midwest industrial states Hillary needs to win election.
As it stands, almost half of the nation's population now lives in right-to-work states, and the majority of manufacturing jobs are located in these states.
There are good reasons for this trend.
When Wisconsin was on the cusp of passing its right-to-work law last year, Gov. Scott Walker said that "This isn't anti-union. It restores worker rights and brings jobs back to Wisconsin."
He's right about that last part. Between 2004 and 2014, overall job growth in the U.S. was 6.1%. In states without right-to-work laws, it was a paltry 3.9%. But in right-to-work states, job growth over those years was 9.1%.
What's more, people are voting with their feet by moving into right-to-work states, which saw their populations climb at twice the rate as forced-union states from 2004 to 2014. And while Clinton would argue that right-to-work laws depress wages, family incomes climbed faster in right-to-work states over these years.
Not only that, but a study published in the Cato Journal found that productivity in non-right-to-work states was just 57% — to 64% of right-to-work states.
These facts raise a question: If Hillary Clinton is so interested in creating good jobs, why in the world would she be attacking an idea that is growing in popularity and has clearly resulted in the creation of more good jobs?
The answer, of course, is that she and her fellow Democrats are beholden to unions for massive amounts of political donations, and so have no other choice but to toe the union line. Plus, the more people Democrats can force to pay union dues, the more money will end up in their campaign coffers. In other words, what Clinton and her union backers want is the right to rip off workers to get more Democrats elected. http://www.investors.com/politics/commentary/hillary-clinton-declares-war-on-the-right-to-work/
Democrats love to talk about rights. They say people have the "right to affordable health care," the "right to a debt free college education," the "right to choose," and so on.
But there's one right they apparently want to erase: The right to work.
Here's how Hillary Clinton put it in a videoconference this week at the Laborers' International Union of North America: "I will fight back against so-called right to work. Right to work is wrong for workers and wrong for America."
Come again? The right to work is wrong for America?
Clinton is referring to state right-to-work laws that give employees the right to work without being forced to join a union. In states without these laws, unions can force new and existing employees to join a union or pay union dues as a condition of employment at unionized companies.
Get instant access to exclusive stock lists and powerful tools on Investors.com. Try us free for 4 weeks.
Right to work has become increasingly popular. In fact, 26 states now have right-to-work laws on their books. And among the most recent to join this movement were Michigan and Wisconsin — two Midwest industrial states Hillary needs to win election.
As it stands, almost half of the nation's population now lives in right-to-work states, and the majority of manufacturing jobs are located in these states.
There are good reasons for this trend.
When Wisconsin was on the cusp of passing its right-to-work law last year, Gov. Scott Walker said that "This isn't anti-union. It restores worker rights and brings jobs back to Wisconsin."
He's right about that last part. Between 2004 and 2014, overall job growth in the U.S. was 6.1%. In states without right-to-work laws, it was a paltry 3.9%. But in right-to-work states, job growth over those years was 9.1%.
What's more, people are voting with their feet by moving into right-to-work states, which saw their populations climb at twice the rate as forced-union states from 2004 to 2014. And while Clinton would argue that right-to-work laws depress wages, family incomes climbed faster in right-to-work states over these years.
Not only that, but a study published in the Cato Journal found that productivity in non-right-to-work states was just 57% — to 64% of right-to-work states.
These facts raise a question: If Hillary Clinton is so interested in creating good jobs, why in the world would she be attacking an idea that is growing in popularity and has clearly resulted in the creation of more good jobs?
The answer, of course, is that she and her fellow Democrats are beholden to unions for massive amounts of political donations, and so have no other choice but to toe the union line. Plus, the more people Democrats can force to pay union dues, the more money will end up in their campaign coffers. In other words, what Clinton and her union backers want is the right to rip off workers to get more Democrats elected. http://www.investors.com/politics/commentary/hillary-clinton-declares-war-on-the-right-to-work/

How many human rights do the Democrats wan't to strip from us?
Trick question: all of them.
Unions have been on the wane for decades ... and for good reasons .
What a misleading bunch of nonsense. The right to work laws, as they are laughingly called, provide one legal proviso which you promoters of the legislation always fail to mention - the law allows any employer to terminate any employee at any time, for any reason. That's the real reason the laws are being pushed. These laws aren't good for the workers, they're good for the employers.
Anyone who tells you any different is a liar.
the law allows any employer to terminate any employee at any time, for any reason.
Not really . There are laws on the books of most [all ?] states for unjust termination .
Why should an employer be forced to employ incompetent employees? What gives the government the right to enslave business owners?
An employer is never forced to retain incompetent employees. All an employer has to do is maintain documentation on training, employee performance and reviews for all employees. When an employee is found to be incompetent, there is no problem terminating employees. But the reality is that the right to work laws are commonly misused by employers to terminate employees for reasons that are not legal, such as discrimination, etc. I've been seeing business owners I've worked with abusing this for years.
I've been a manager too. The burden of creating a paper trail sufficient to deter litigation is almost impossible. It's overly burdensome, and most large companies simply retain the idiots and imperil their bottom line and safety.
Well, I've hired and fired employees for over 20 years. It's not that burdensome to create the paper trail necessary to deter litigation. You simply need competent managers to run your programs, train your supervisors and maintain your documentation. I've been doing this for decades. I've been contracted by companies to set these programs up. It's not costly or overly time consuming, but it does require that you get some training. You should look into hiring a consultant to help you out if this is an issue in your place. It's cheap insurance.
That's not a bad idea. I didn't know there were consultants that specialize in that. Thanks.
Don't tell me. I've been a senior level manager in a "right to work state" for 15 years. Unless you can prove discrimination or a hostile work environment, you can be fired without any legal recourse. THAT'S the real reason these laws are so popular among business owners.
By the way, I want to apologize for the liar crack I made above. That wasn't accurate or very nice of me. Sorry guys.
I agree that that's how the employment at will provisions work. I don't see why a small businessman needs any reason to terminate his relationship with a worker. It's his business.
I agree with you to an extent. But what if the reason he terminates an employee is because he was the wrong religion or something. Doesn't the employee have the right to be able to earn a living without being discriminated against?
Yes, but that is illegal, even in a right to work state. Proving it is harder, I agree. And that is a concern.
Oh for cripe sakes. Who in the hell is going to admit to doing something illegal? Of course it's illegal and of course it's hard as hell to prove - that's the point of putting these laws into place. To set a criteria so that the businesses can't discriminate. They've shown they can't be trusted to do the right thing.
If anyone could complain about bad freaking employees, I sure could. I've encountered the most incompetent under skilled over paid lazy people. In my 22 years I have only been able to get rid of 3 employees. I've witnessed employees lie and cheat the government and have even written statements along with others that witnessed it along with me and guess what happened......NOTHING. Employee relations was afraid to do anything about it because they told me that it would probably lead to a discrimination suit so they recommended putting them on a performance improvement plan. What a frocking joke.
Unenforceable laws accomplish nothing. You have no right to require a business owner to employee an individual.
Really Cerenkov? You don't think there are businesses that haven't discriminated against some employees by terminating them right before the employee is eligible for their retirement package. Why do you think these laws came into fruition? BECAUSE the businesses weren't treating their employees fairly. Their dishonorable practices are the cause of these laws. Are some of the laws ridiculous, yes. Do some need to be abolished and changed, yes but for you to pretend that businesses are the victims is being intentionally blind.
No one becomes eligible for a pension at the end of their career. They earn benefits along the way. Also, firing people for age is illegal. Red herring.
Do you think an employee should not be able to quit a job without a good enough reason? Do you promote forced labor? What's the difference?
But that's just it, it's not a red herring. As you yourself stated, proving such discrimination is harder. In fact it's almost impossible. It is precisely this which enables these laws to be misused against employees. This is the fact. Now, if someone were to propose legislation which addressed this issue and simultaneously protected employees against being forced to join unions, I would support it. But such a concept is most definitely not supported by business owners who actively take advantage of these laws to illegally terminate employees without fear of legal repercussions. I see it all the time.
I see them as separate issues. I've been forced out of a job for raising safety concerns. I could have sued but I was afraid of being blacklisted. IN my case, the government could not protect me. I moved on to a new and better job. Employment is a mutual agreement between a business owner and an employee.
I fail to see how they can be viewed as separate issues when they are part of the same legislation. Secondly, my field is Occupational Health and Safety. I am an expert in OSHA regulations. You are not only protected under the Whistleblower Act against retaliation for raising safety concerns, but people regularly are awarded extremely large settlements and employers are usually fined millions for these kinds of violations. Don't make the mistake of assuming that you'd be blacklisted. I could introduce you to people who won 6 figure settlements and were rehired. Those employers couldn't touch them. If this happened to you, you should have got an attorney. You mad a mistake when you assumed the government couldn't protect you.
Come on! Whistleblower protection is a myth. You can be blacklisted with no chance to prove it. I work in nuclear safety and I've seen it multiple times.
You're just being silly now.
It's my silly dedication to personal liberty. Very old fashioned.
Cerenkov - You're far too "un"silly most of the time so I'll take silly from you where ever I can get it. :0)