Bias Honor Roll: How the Media Twists, Distorts and Omits to Smear Charlotte as a Racist Backwoods
community » Discussions » Category » News & Politics » Discussion » Bias Honor Roll: How the Media Twists, Distorts and Omits to Smear Charlotte as a Racist Backwoods
0
Category: News & Politics
Via: sixpick • 10 years ago • 22 comments
And even as some reporters on the scene flee the city — after a night of deliberate attacks on media–the press can’t stop itself from preening shrilly about “a grim snapshot of America’s continuing crisis in black and blue” (as the New York Times put it). This despite mounting evidence that this particular police shooting hardly fits the mold of racist white cops killing unarmed black men
The New York Times ‘s Richard Fausset and Alan Blinder were clearly feeling verbose as they penned their florid coverage of Charlotte’s police killing– in which Keith Scott was shot by black Charlotte police officer Brentley Vinson. While describing the scene on the ground, they waxed poetic:
“The gunshot victim lay motionless on the ground, his eyes open, as people surrounded him and blood pooled among their feet. He was taken into the nearby Omni Hotel, and a series of confrontations played out afterward as the police kept people from entering,” they wrote.But information about the incident that sparked the shooting was buried several paragraphs down. The Charlotte police’s press conference (led by its black police chief) was given a mere two sentences. Brentley Vinson was never mentioned by name, and his race noted only in passing. Long before they discussed the specifics of the case, Fausset and Blinder were trying to line up Charlotte’s story with stories in Columbus, Ohio and in Oklahoma.
“And then it was Charlotte, where Mr. Scott, 43, black like the other two, was shot by a police officer in a parking space marked “Visitor” outside an unremarkable apartment complex. On Wednesday that parking space was both a shooting site and a shrine, and Charlotte was a city on edge.”
A special hats off to USA Today , which leads with a touching portrait of Scott:
“Keith Lamont Scott was well-known in the neighborhood, a fixture in the after-school hours who sat in his truck, passing time reading while waiting for his son to step off the bus, according to local residents.”
Note USA Today ‘s emphasis on Scott’s alleged reading-in-the-car habit, as his supporters claim he was holding a book, not a gun, when police shot him (police insist he had a gun which was recovered at the scene). The newspaper chain’s Tonya Maxwell (of the Gannett-owned Asheville Citizen-Times ) ends her piece by quoting at length a random guy named Calvin Bennett. His tone is “sure”, his words “direct”. He speaks “quietly”:
“You have a child coming off the bus and goes to meet daddy, but doesn’t know what to do because daddy’s dead,” Bennett said. “Think about that image for a minute. America should be outraged.”
“We get killed in church. We get killed when we comply. We get killed when we hold our hands up. We get killed when we wait for our children. What more can we do?” said Bennett, his tone sure and his words direct.
Asked if he is an activist, Bennett’s tone softened. He is not. He keeps up with the shootings of black people and has gotten an education he wish he did not need.
“The black community has this conversation every day,” he said, quietly. “We have this same conversation over and over and over.”
Slate ‘s Leon Neyfakh didn’t even make it to the body of his story before inserting incendiary language, and like the New York Times , he also relied on flowery language to set the scene. A “convulsing” crowd was simply “expressing anger;” a “tumult” moved into a nearby Wal-Mart (he never mentions that they looted it ).
Reporters Cleve R. Wootson Jr., Derek Hawkins and Katie Mettler at the Washington Post wrote eloquently about “blame, rumor and blood ” as protests surged. They’re creative in describing protesters’ wounds, and the quick work of medics saving the innocent from rubber bullets. But they were short on details of exactly what happened in Charlotte to cause the “tense” protests, preferring only to refer to the Charlotte shooting as part of a larger trend and identical to other stories.
“The violence in Charlotte came less than a week after disputed police shooting of a black man in Tulsa — amplifying debates over policing and race that have been thrust open before in places such as Ferguson, Mo., and Baltimore.”
In all, these reporters seem to view Charlotte as a playing ground to win a Pulitzer Prize, the scene of a new civil rights movement, playing out like a maudlin Hollywood film before their eyes. And they are the people who will set the scene for the history books, even if they aren’t quite covering the story.
They also describe Charlotte as a dystopic backdrop for violence and revolution. In all these accounts, life is brutal, and daily confrontation is routine. But just a few short years ago, in the same place riots are now ripping through the downtown, the Democrats held their national convention. The Democratic National Committee picked Charlotte, it said , because it was “vibrant and diverse,” and because it was “reaching for tomorrow.”
Just two years ago in the New York Times , Charlotte was a functioning, innovative city. Thursday morning, it’s a hellhole of racial disunity. And it’s all in how the New York Times spins it.
The Democratic National Committee picked Charlotte, it said , because it was “vibrant and diverse,” and because it was “reaching for tomorrow.”
Just two years ago in the New York Times , Charlotte was a functioning, innovative city. Thursday morning, it’s a hellhole of racial disunity. And it’s all in how the New York Times spins it.
Since YouTube deleted the video above, I had a copy and I'm sure others made a copy as well. YouTube is getting really good about deleting videos that tell the truth about different individuals and other MSM PC.
although I truly believe Keith Lamont Scott died needlessly, has nothing to do with this video, most of the other deaths do has something to do with this video. Why can't these people learn before they get killed just obey the law. That's what I do. Isn't that what you would do? I think that one thing would save a lot of lives and change the attitudes on both sides of the issue for the better as well. I believe this guy was one of the lucky ones. I would never do what he did.
I wish people would stop using the "paragraph" settings for an entire long article. It makes the thing basically unreadable to have every word start with a capital letter.
I wish people would stop using the "paragraph" settings for an entire long article. It makes the thing basically unreadable to have every word start with a capital letter.
Thanks John, I'll consider that. What is the best font to use. I've noticed when I post an article the font is often too small. So are my comments. This one looks good to me, I mean the size. We'll see when I push reply.
What did you think of the guy who wouldn't give up his driver's license? I believe if people would just do this one thing and do what the police tell them to do, it would make a big difference, don't you think?
Its a shame the NYT can't recognize stupid actions as a cause for police reaction . Scott had a gun & wouldn't drop it despite being ordered to do so multiple times . The NYT is implying its OK to stay armed when police are trying to deal with you . That is stupid and destructive ...
Scott was a violent thug who was shot by a black cop when he would not comply. There's no big story here, but the racebaiting media and their liberal adherents will strive to concoct a narrative nonetheless.
Meanwhile in Chicago the black gangs are killing blacks by the hundreds ... but cops can't even show up in the ghetto without being called racist . Sick joke !
Why don't you care ? You think it is OK for black gangs to kill without restriction ? I call that truly racist . BTW I met about 5 black men today in my travels . They were all peaceful .
Chiraq citizens have long since lost the ability to see the black bodies they step across during their daily lives. They have become immune to the horror.
Chiraq citizens have long since lost the ability to see the black bodies they step across during their daily lives. They have become immune to the horror.
How many white people on NT are ever in danger from "black thugs"?
What is with all this phony hand wringing and strenuous "concern" ?
Not that much John, but we do care about the innocent blacks who have to deal with them and we really don't want to have to deal with them either. What about you? How do you feel?
I was shot at a few times , twice during 'gang fights' and once in a drive by. It was a product of a changing neighborhood where the white flight brought in a large number of blacks and until the neighborhood turned completely black there was a lot of conflict between the teenagers.
I don't know if Charlotte is any more a racist backwoods than anywhere else in the nation. Urban or rural. It is, however, a hole of shyte.
It does have a righteously good gun store. I'll give it that.
As far as the protests go, folks are rightfully pissed and apparently have had enough. When resisting an institution that repeatedly uses violence to solve issues and express it power, violence is pretty much is to be expected.
It is a mistake to use the violence that has come down as an excuse to ignore the very real problems that are the genesis of the protests. Tactically, philosophically and morally. As my Grand Maw was won't to say, "No good can come from this."
Might as well buckle yer seatbelts. I get the feeling that our collective future might look quite like this.
The Democratic National Committee picked Charlotte, it said , because it was “vibrant and diverse,” and because it was “reaching for tomorrow.”
Just two years ago in the New York Times , Charlotte was a functioning, innovative city. Thursday morning, it’s a hellhole of racial disunity. And it’s all in how the New York Times spins it.
They also forgot to put this in their articles:
Since YouTube deleted the video above, I had a copy and I'm sure others made a copy as well. YouTube is getting really good about deleting videos that tell the truth about different individuals and other MSM PC.
although I truly believe Keith Lamont Scott died needlessly, has nothing to do with this video, most of the other deaths do has something to do with this video. Why can't these people learn before they get killed just obey the law. That's what I do. Isn't that what you would do? I think that one thing would save a lot of lives and change the attitudes on both sides of the issue for the better as well. I believe this guy was one of the lucky ones. I would never do what he did.
I wish people would stop using the "paragraph" settings for an entire long article. It makes the thing basically unreadable to have every word start with a capital letter.
Incisive commentary.
I wish people would stop using the "paragraph" settings for an entire long article. It makes the thing basically unreadable to have every word start with a capital letter.
Thanks John, I'll consider that. What is the best font to use. I've noticed when I post an article the font is often too small. So are my comments. This one looks good to me, I mean the size. We'll see when I push reply.
What did you think of the guy who wouldn't give up his driver's license? I believe if people would just do this one thing and do what the police tell them to do, it would make a big difference, don't you think?
Its a shame the NYT can't recognize stupid actions as a cause for police reaction . Scott had a gun & wouldn't drop it despite being ordered to do so multiple times . The NYT is implying its OK to stay armed when police are trying to deal with you . That is stupid and destructive ...
Scott was a violent thug who was shot by a black cop when he would not comply. There's no big story here, but the racebaiting media and their liberal adherents will strive to concoct a narrative nonetheless.
How many white people on NT are ever in danger from "black thugs"?
What is with all this phony hand wringing and strenuous "concern" ?
Meanwhile in Chicago the black gangs are killing blacks by the hundreds ... but cops can't even show up in the ghetto without being called racist . Sick joke !
Why do you care? You are terrified to get within a million miles of any ghetto.
Why don't you care ? You think it is OK for black gangs to kill without restriction ? I call that truly racist . BTW I met about 5 black men today in my travels . They were all peaceful .
Chiraq citizens have long since lost the ability to see the black bodies they step across during their daily lives. They have become immune to the horror.
Chiraq citizens have long since lost the ability to see the black bodies they step across during their daily lives. They have become immune to the horror.
What idiocy.
You are like a parody of yourself.
See what I mean? No empathy at all.
How many white people on NT are ever in danger from "black thugs"?
What is with all this phony hand wringing and strenuous "concern" ?
Not that much John, but we do care about the innocent blacks who have to deal with them and we really don't want to have to deal with them either. What about you? How do you feel?
You yourself said you were shot at by black thugs for simply walking on their turf.
I was shot at a few times , twice during 'gang fights' and once in a drive by. It was a product of a changing neighborhood where the white flight brought in a large number of blacks and until the neighborhood turned completely black there was a lot of conflict between the teenagers.
where the white flight brought in a large number of blacks
There goes the neighborhood !
I don't know if Charlotte is any more a racist backwoods than anywhere else in the nation. Urban or rural. It is, however, a hole of shyte.
It does have a righteously good gun store. I'll give it that.
As far as the protests go, folks are rightfully pissed and apparently have had enough. When resisting an institution that repeatedly uses violence to solve issues and express it power, violence is pretty much is to be expected.
It is a mistake to use the violence that has come down as an excuse to ignore the very real problems that are the genesis of the protests. Tactically, philosophically and morally. As my Grand Maw was won't to say, "No good can come from this."
Might as well buckle yer seatbelts. I get the feeling that our collective future might look quite like this.
Looting and violence effectively invalidates their message.