╌>

Trump Says Veterans with PTSD Aren't Strong

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  ambivalent  •  10 years ago  •  15 comments

Trump Says Veterans with PTSD Aren't Strong

Yet another jab at POWs.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    10 years ago

Way to take a comment way the fuck out of context.  Pure Bullshit.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    10 years ago

 

Here’s a transcript of what Trump said:

 

"When people come back from war and combat and they see maybe what the people in this room have seen many times over, and you're strong and you can handle it, but a lot of people can't handle it,"

 

"People are killing themselves what are waiting on line because they have days and days before what could be a simple procedure, a simple prescription, and the wait is so long, they can't take it,"

 

Let me tell you the story of a Combat Veteran.  A Marine.  Two tours in Iraq.  Two tours in Afghanistan.   A combat Marine that was in the thick of the shit during the battle for Fallujah.  He watched in the rear view mirror of his Humvee when an IED blew up under the Humvee 100 yards behind him.  It killed two of his close friends, PFC Brooks and LCPL Hanson.  He watched from 200 yards away as an IED obliterated one of his SGTs, Staff SGT Patterson.  He spent 2 hours collecting body parts so they could find the left hand, and return his wedding band to his wife.

 

He was a tough Marine.  Tough enough to stand his ground at an outpost and empty a clip into an oncoming vehicle that blew past two road blocks.  He was tough when he helped load two of his wounded buddies on the Medevac helicopters when the car finally blew up.

 

Yeah, he’s a tough Marine.  Tough enough to go back to school when he got out.  Where he has to deal with a VA bureaucracy that screws his GI Bill up every month, making him spend hours on the phone trying to get someone to listen to him so he will have money for gas to get to school.  A school where he has to put up with pansy ass Nancies who think it’s a joke to sit or kneel during the national anthem.  Where liberal pussy professors tell him he went over to Iraq for oil.  But he’s tough.  He can handle it.  He can handle it when a shithead who doesn’t know what is in his shorts gets upset when he’s called a dude.

 

Yeah, he’s tough.  Until he goes to bed at night.  And he wakes up at 2 AM in a cold sweat dreaming about his Humvee blowing up.  Or Staff SGT Patterson’s left hand hitting him in the face.  Or Brooks, or Hanson talking to him with their faces burned off.  Yeah, he’s tough.  He can handle it.  He can handle the exhaustion because he can’t sleep, because the demons are always waiting for him.  He’s tough.  And yet…he’s not.

 

Because he’s not strong.  And he knows it.  It’s why he’s rated 90% disabled for PTSD.  It’s why he’s on a waiting list to talk with doctors about his nightmares.  It’s why he wants to move out of my house and get his own apartment so he can get a PTSD dog.  You see, my son can’t have one in my house.  Because we already have 7 dogs.  And although they love my son, and feel his pain, and know he’s not strong, they aren’t trained in how to calm him.  And neither am I.

 

Everything Trump said was true.  They think they’re tough.  Until they’re not.  And every day 22 of them come to that realization, and can’t get the help they need from a bureaucracy that doesn’t care about them, and they take their own lives.  Twenty Two a day.

 

So you take your hit piece, and you shove it in your ear.  Trump is the only one who has shown for me that he cares for the veterans.  I have absolutely no faith that a Hillary presidency will do any good for my son.

 

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee  replied to  Uncle Bruce   10 years ago

I truly hope and pray your son gets the help he needs and deserves.  I cannot, even in my most terrible imagination, concieve of what these veterans go through, what they bring home, what they keep inside.  To say they are not strong enough is not an insult, it should be a cry for help.  These veterans should be at the top of the list of Americans getting anything they need.  Unfortunately,  they are  not. 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

HERNDON, Virginia — Donald Trump is drawing scorn from veterans' groups after he suggested that soldiers who suffer from mental health issues might not be as strong as those who don't.

Trump was speaking at an event organized by the Retired American Warriors political action committee Monday when he was asked about his commitment to faith-based programs aimed at preventing suicides and helping soldiers suffering from posttraumatic stress disorder, traumatic brain injury and other issues.

"When you talk about the mental health problems — when people come back from war and combat, and they see things that maybe a lot of the folks in this room have seen many times over, and you're strong and you can handle it. But a lot of people can't handle it," he said.

"And they see horror stories. They see events that you couldn't see in a movie, nobody would believe it," he added.

Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks during a town hall with the Retired American Warriors, Monday, Oct. 3, 2016, in Herndon, Va. (AP Photo/ Evan Vucci) © The Associated Press Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks during a town hall with the Retired American Warriors, Monday, Oct. 3, 2016, in Herndon, Va. (AP Photo/ Evan Vucci) The comment drew condemnation from critics as well as veterans' groups that have been working for years to reduce the stigma associated with mental health issues in an effort to encourage soldiers to seek treatment.

David Maulsby, the executive director of the Texas-based PTSD Foundation of America, told The Associated Press that, at first, he hoped Trump's remarks had been taken out of context. But after watching a recording of the exchange, he said the Republican nominee's words were detrimental to veterans struggling with PTSD symptoms.

"At the very least, it's a very poor choice of words. PTSD is basically a rewiring of the brain as the result of trauma or prolonged trauma. That is not a reflection of a person's strength, character, stamina — any of that," Maulsby said.

"Our veterans who are struggling with post-traumatic stress as a result of their combat need to be encouraged to seek help, and not be told they are weak or deficient in character in any way, shape or form," he said.

Zach Iscol, a Marine veteran and executive director of the nonprofit Headstrong Project, which helps provide free care for veterans suffering from PTSD, said Trump's comments weren't "just wrong, they're dangerous."

"The biggest barrier we have to people getting help is the stigma of getting help," he said. "It just shows a complete misunderstanding of what post-traumatic stress disorder is."

Retired Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn, a top Trump adviser, responded with a statement that accused the media of taking the GOP nominee's words out of context "to deceive voters and veterans."

Flynn said Trump has been highlighting the challenges veterans face when returning home and "has always respected the service and sacrifice of our military men and women."

Trump has vowed to make improving veterans' mental health services a top priority if he makes it to the White House.

Trump previously angered veterans when he suggested that Sen. John McCain, a former POW, was only considered a war hero because he was captured.

 

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

Trump doesn't think a lot before he speaks. I think this was one of those cases. 

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

John - you've not had any military experience and it's very obvious by your comments that you haven't the foggiest idea of what military members go through.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    10 years ago

Yesterday, social media lost it’s shit again when Marine Staff Sgt. Chad Robichaux, president and founder of Mighty Oaks Warrior Programs, at a town hall style meeting with some veterans asked Donald Trump if he’d support using religion-based programs for helping veterans with PTS and TBI problems. Here is Trump’s complete response;

When you talk about the mental health problems when people come back from war and combat and they see things that maybe a lot of folks in this room have seen many times over, and you’re strong and you can handle it, but a lot of people can’t handle it, and they see horror stories, they see events that you couldn’t see in a movie, nobody would believe it. Now we need a mental health help and medical and it’s one of the things that I think is least addressed and it’s one of the things I hear — like your question — one of the things I hear most about when I go around and talk to the veterans.

So we’re going to have a very, very robust, very very robust level of performance having to do with mental health. We are losing so many great people that can be taken care of if they have proper care.

You know when you hear the 22 suicides a day, it’s a big part of your question, but when you hear the 22 suicides a day, that should never be. That should never be, So we’re going to be addressing that very strongly.

And the whole mental health issue is going to be a very important issue when I take over, and the VA is going to be fixed in so many ways, but that’s gonna be one of the ways we’re gonna help. And that’s in many respects going to be the number one thing we have to do because I think it’s really been left behind. Ok? Thank you very much.

Of course, most media outlets edited that response to appear as if Trump didn’t understand the problem and that he was calling veterans who suffer from PTS as “weak”. CNN even told it’s readers what to think about Trump in their opening paragraph of the report before presenting his response to the question;

Donald Trump suggested Monday that American soldiers and veterans who commit suicide do so because they can’t handle the post-traumatic stress of war.

CNN went on to ask the opinion of highly partisan Democrat operatives like Jon Soltz, of MoveOn.org’s VoteVets;

Jon Soltz, an Iraq War veteran and Chairman of the progressive VoteVets.org, called Trump’s comments “horrible” but “not shocking.”
“We’re talking about a person, in Trump, who believes that POWs aren’t real heroes, and that he’s made sacrifices akin to Gold Star Families who lost their loved ones in war,” Soltz said in a statement. “The constant disrespect Donald Trump shows towards our veterans and servicemembers is sickening, and completely and totally disqualifying.”

Paul Rieckhoff, of course, chimed in;

The Iraq and Afghanistan Veterans of America sent BuzzFeed New s a statement about the importance of language when talking about PTSD.

“Every national leader has a responsibility to use accurate and appropriate language when talking about mental health and suicide especially,” IAVA CEO Paul Rieckhoff wrote wrote. “Terms like ‘killing yourself’ or ‘mental problems’ or any suggestion that suicide only impacts the weak, can promote contagion and may discourage people from getting help.”

He added that “getting help for a mental health injury is not a sign of weakness, it’s a demonstration of strength.”

Marine Staff Sgt. Chad Robichaux, the man who asked Trump the question, though, called the criticism of Trump “sickening” according to the Washington Times .

I think it’s sickening that anyone would twist Mr. Trump’s comments to me in order to pursue a political agenda. I took his comments to be thoughtful and understanding of the struggles many veterans have, and I believe he is committed to helping them. The nature of my question focused on a broken system that’s failing so many of our veterans and, as president, would Mr. Trump take a more holistic approach to health care for veterans.

I interpreted his answer to affirm that the system is broken and he would take the necessary steps to address it. After eight combat tours in Afghanistan I came home and was diagnosed with PTSD, and I struggled with it. Since my own recovery I’ve been privileged to help 1100 veterans who have graduated from our program; none of whom have committed suicide since graduating. It’s a very important issue to me, which is why I was thankful for the opportunity to ask Mr. Trump about it directly.

If the media is trying to make me vote for Trump out of spite, they’re doing a marvelous job.

 

You're all a bunch of fucking dumbasses.  Tell me what that lying criminal bitch Hillary has planned for fixing the VA.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   1stwarrior  replied to  Uncle Bruce   10 years ago

Bruce - as an added - I've known/know many former military who never went to the battlefield - who sat behind their desks and ordered supplies, filled out paperwork, answered phones, delivered needed equipment to the loading docks.  But of those many, at least half of them have "all of a sudden" come down with PTSD for having been in the military and claiming it had to do with war efforts.

Those folks are taking away from the countless many who deserve treatment and aren't getting it due to the backlog caused by the imposters.  My nephew was in the Army - a tanker - and served seven tours in Iraq and Afghanistan.  He had six IED's explode during those tours on his tank and wound up with a total disability for massive concussions, damaged spinal cord, busted ribs, shoulders, arms and legs, plus losing 30% of his sight and 50% of his hearing.

Lee is 34 y.o. - the VA doesn't have the ability/facilities to treat him so they've laced him with an unimaginable amount of drugs and put him on a marijuana "treatment" plan - to ease the pain - to ease the memories and fears and dreams.  He has been waiting SIX YEARS for a VA evaluation - but they don't have time because of the backlog.

His wife has left him - his kids have no idea who he is - and he stays in a drunken stupor while, all the while, screaming for help - and it's not there.

I totally concur with what Trump said - the VA and U. S. government continues to stab our military members in the back and no one in Congress nor the Presidency has the cajones to take the bull by the horns and "fix it" by enforcing the laws, regulations, rules and policies.

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

1st - I blame Congress for not appropriating the necessary funding to help take care of our Vets.  I also blame those who find ways to wiggle out of their responsibility to pay taxes to their Country and to help take care of the Vets that we rely on to keep us safe.  We need to re-direct some of the DOD appropriations that are going towards contractors who are the friends of politicians and give it to the VA.  I doubt seriously whether the VA's budget has been increased proportionately enough that it accounted for so many of our Vets coming home with so many issues and injuries but it sure is funny how a certain party has no problem upping the military budget so they can keep get their friends contracts.  I wish some weren't so blind to that fact.

I'm sorry to hear about your nephew.  Six years is insane to have to wait for an evaluation. 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

Tell me what Trumps plan is...''I'm going to fix it'''...Wow, that's quite the plan...Most of his dumbass followers will believe all of the bs that runs out of his mouth.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    10 years ago

Veterans of Foreign Wars spokesman Joe Davis also put out a brief statement that seemed to agree with Trump’s premise: "It is true that not everyone can handle traumatic events, be it from war, bad car accidents, violent crime or even surviving a hurricane. Regarding veterans, we need to treat those who need help and research how two people experiencing the same time and place can be impacted so differently."

 
 

Who is online






149 visitors