Wikileaks - Iran Nuclear Deal
From:seizenstat@cov.com To: Jake.Sullivan@gmail.com Date: 2015-06-22 04:23 Subject: Iran Nuclear Deal
Much easier to read this from the site: https://wikileaks.org/podesta-emails/emailid/32
Dear Jake,
I have sent several detailed notes on the Iran nuclear deal, and will avoid repetition. But with the June 30 deadline fast approaching (although it may be extended), and with Hillary certain to be pressed on whether she supports the deal and will urge Congress not to disapprove it, I wanted to share a few thoughts.
1. This could well be a voting issue for many moderates in the Jewish community. The mainstream organized leadership will almost certainly oppose the deal, along with Israel and all the Republican candidates, Saudi Arabia and the Gulf States, and perhaps Egypt.
2. While we cannot be sure until there is a final agreement, it appears that many of the open issues since the preliminary accord, may be resolved in Iran's favor:
(1) Enriched uranium will stay in Iran for dilution, rather than be sent to Russia or France for reprocessing.
(2) Sanctions will not be phased-out commensurate with compliance, as the US Fact Sheet indicated after the last "agreement", but may come off more quickly. This will transfer billions to Iran and enhance its funding for terrorism and its efforts to gain hegemony in the region.
(3) It is not clear what Iran will be required to do on PMD, if anything. This was required of Iraq by the UNSC in September 2002. Iran should be held to the same standard. They have yet to answer 11 of the 12 IAEA questions, yet UN sanctions will be lifted.
(4) Russia, China and Iran itself may be able to block "snapback" sanctions if there is a violation of the agreement. US companies will be disadvantaged compared to European companies, since many US non-nuclear sanctions will remain, while all EU sanctions are nuclear-related.
(5) Military sites (Parchin) are likely to be off the table for inspections.
(6) Iran will likely be able to do research on advanced centrifuges, which enrich more uranium more rapidly than the current generation. This would markedly reduce the breakout time in the last years of the accord. Presidenr Obama has conceded this point (e.g. David Sanger article in NYT, April 8, 2015)
(7) Iran will have an industrial size nuclear program, and will be left as a "nuclear capable state".
(8) Iran will be able to keep 1000 centrifuges at Fordo.
(9) Nothing in the agreement will limit its support for terrorism.
3. That said, there are likely to be positive aspects to the agreement.
(1) The Arak plutonium plant will be effectively dismantled.
(2) There will be more intrusive IAEA inspections, since Iran will sign the Additional Protocol of thr NPT.
(3) The number of centrifuges will be cut by 2/3.
(4) Iran will be a year away from breakout. It would still need to develop a nuclear weapon that can fit on a missile.
(5) Iran's stockpile of enriched uranium from 10 tons to 700 pounds.
(6) Ten years is a long time and Iran's conduct may moderate.
4, Hillary cannot oppose the agreement given her position as the President's Secretary of State and should urge its approval by Congress under Corker-Cardin. But she can and should point out concerns with it (as she did, unfortunately from my perspective, on TPP/TPA). More broadly, she should appear more muscular I her approach than the President's. The statement I suggested a few months ago still would be appropriate. But she should also say the following:
(1) As President, she would never consider Iran a strategic partner in the region. Quite the contrary, she would do all she can to oppose Iranian misconduct.
(2) Our allies in the region must know that we will stand behind them and supply them with the means to defend themselves and avoid the region tilting to Iran, including bunker-busting bombs Bush and Obama refused to provide to Israel.. Defense treaties should be considered so any attack by Iran would be considered an attack against the US.
(3) Bibi should be invited for early talks on how the partnership with Israel can be strengthened to combat Iran and Israel's other avowed enemies.
(4) A common agenda should be forged with Israel and our Arab allies.
(5) If the US itself believes Iran has cheated, as President, she would reimpose US sanctions, even if Russia-China-Iran say there was no violation. She would work to get the EU to also reimpose their sanctions.
(6) It is just as unacceptable for Iran to develop a nuclear weapon after the expiration of the agreement, as it is during the agreement, given the nature of the regime. Therefore, while she would not be president, all means should be used to prevent Iran from acquiring a nuclear weapon.
Best wishes,
Stu Eizenstat
Tags
Who is online
114 visitors

O My friggin' gawd.
speak with (a) forked tongue
I don't think Iran has even signed the deal yet - and "Death to Israel", "Death to America", is still on the tip of their tongues.
2. While we cannot be sure until there is a final agreement, it appears that many of the open issues since the preliminary accord, may be resolved in Iran's favor:
(2) Sanctions will not be phased-out commensurate with compliance, as the US Fact Sheet indicated after the last "agreement", but may come off more quickly. This will transfer billions to Iran and enhance its funding for terrorism and its efforts to gain hegemony in the region.
(9) Nothing in the agreement will limit its support for terrorism.
Don't look.... this is not for our eyes. Understand we small minded individuals are unable to understand any of this and obviously we have given up our sovereignty in order to allow this to come to pass or we wouldn't agree to something that was suppose to be a treaty, voted on by Congress, instead of an agreement dictated to us by our Sovereign Leader.
What a disaster.
Indeed. Obama has made Iran a nuclear state. All it needs is time now.
Have you ever noticed how some people tell you what they are going to do or be like "My administration will be the most transparent Administration in history" and turn out to be the exact opposite? I've found the best way to understand these people is when they say something like "You can keep your insurance, period" just turn everything they say around to what would be the opposite of what they said and that will tell you what they are really saying.
There have been arguments put on this site that it was not just Obama who made the deal, but it was the PS+1, meaning the Europeans, etc. The Europeans were drooling for this deal so they could do billion-dollar business with Iran, with no consideration put to security (especially as they never gave a damn about Israel's security) and of course it justified China and Russia's continued dealing with Iran. Obama was the kingpin - he was the only one who could (or would) have assured security for the rest of the world, but he bowed to Iran deeper than he bowed to the Saudi king.
Buzz, you are exactly right in that comment. The main reason there was a deal was because of Europe. They really needed the deal to go through and not learning or caring about past experiences, they keep making the same mistakes over and over in my opinion.
Maybe check out "The Rise of Nuclear Iran - How Tehran Defies The West" by Dore Gold
They have never complied with one single deal they've ever made.
If I'm not too awfully mistaken, this treaty was never ratified as required - Obama signed it making it a done deal.
As I understand it 1st, he didn't have the authority to do the treaty without Congress approving it, so he called it an agreement instead which didn't require Congress to approve it.
The fact is Iran has never followed through with any agreement or treaty. The even boast how they've fooled everyone when it is discovered they didn't do anything but continue pursuing nuclear weapons. The only thing Obama did was pay for it for them by giving them billions of dollars. Even if they had put more restrictions on Iran, they would be exactly the same thing they are doing right now.
The problem they had then and the problem they have now is the accuracy of their missiles, but with China and North Korea's help it is anybody's guess when they will have accomplished their goal, but you can rest assured they haven't slowed down one bit in pursuing it.
If you haven't read the book in the comment I made to Buzz, check it out.
Of course giving Iran a Nuke isn't as important as locker room talk 10 years ago.
Or telling an overweight Miss Universe she needs to lose some weight 18 years ago.
Check out this email address. This is communication to White House.
From:seizenstat@cov.com To: Jake.Sullivan@gmail.com Date: 2015-06-22 04:23 Subject: Iran Nuclear Deal
Gmail......
Jake Sullivan
Jacob Jeremiah "Jake" Sullivan (born November 28, 1976) is an American policymaker and the top foreign policy advisor to Hillary Clinton's 2016 election campaign . [1] He is widely rumored to be a front-runner for the position of U.S. National Security Advisor under a potential Hillary Clinton administration, should she be elected president in 2016. [2]
Sullivan is also a senior advisor to the U.S. government for the Iran nuclear negotiations and a visiting professor at Yale Law School . [3]
Prior to teaching at Yale, Sullivan was Deputy Assistant to the U.S. President Barack Obama and National Security Advisor to U.S. Vice President Joe Biden . [4] He also served as the Director of Policy Planning at the U.S. Department of State , and as Deputy Chief of Staff to U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton . He was deputy policy director on Hillary Clinton's 2008 presidential primary campaign , and a member of the debate preparation team for Barack Obama's general election campaign .
Front-runner for the position of U.S. National Security Advisor....... Don't you think this should have been communicated by some other means than Gmail for a front-runner for US National Security Advisor?
Stuart E. Eizenstat Basically a European PR firm (Are we surprised?)
I guess we should know about those backroom deals that don't change a thing except cost us billions and I bet some of the money went to ......... for that special favor.