Government Goes After Speech That It Doesn't Agree With
First Amendment: At America's founding, it was thought that guaranteeing free speech was a fine idea. Today's Justice Department has a different view, and it's using the force of government to shut down open expression.On the last day of May, Nick Gillespie wrote a post on the Reason Foundation's Hit & Run blog about the sentencing of Ross Ulbricht, founder of Silk Road, "a revolutionary website that made it easier and safer to buy and sell illegal drugs (along with just about everything else)."Prosectors wanted Ulbricht, who was found guilty of multiple felony charges, to serve "substantially more than the mandatory minimum" of 20 years. But the judge, Katherine Forrest, an Obama appointee, went beyond the recommendation and sentenced him to life in prison without the possibility of parole.This riled up a few Reason readers who expressed their scorn toward the judge. And they did so anonymously. So the Justice Department got riled up too and did what any reasonable inquisitor would: send Reason a subpoena, demanding that the organization help identify and find those who made the comments that the Justice Department wants to believe are mailed threats.Granted, the six comments that offended Justice went beyond civil discourse. One suggested that "judges like these ... should be taken out back and shot," while another said "it's judges like these that will be taken out back and shot."Another liked the idea of shooting "judges like these," but thought the better place would be "out front, on the steps of the courthouse." Yet another wanted to employ a wood chipper, since it wouldn't "waste ammunition."To call such thoughts intemperate would be an understatement. But to consider them real threats goes beyond sensible thinking.Is the Justice Department so cyberbackward that it can't grasp the nature of comments made on a blog? Web comments tend to be threads brimming with nothing more than big talk and fleeting fury.If the Justice Department insists on continuing its assault on free speech and hounding a legitimate journalism outlet, we suggest a look at how Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, a Ronald Reagan nominee, has been treated on the Web.Three years ago, after some hotly debated rulings were handed down, one fellow asked President Obama via Twitter to "please put Scalia on your kill list ." Another figured "we need a constitutional amendment to legally kill Scalia."It was at that same time that the tolerant left went after Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, a Bush appointee, calling him "one ni**er that should (have) been a slave."Then there's the infamous line from USA Today columnist and Pacifica Radio talk show host Julianne Malveaux, who in 1994 said she hoped Thomas' wife "feeds him lots of eggs and butter and he dies early like many black men do, of heart disease" because "he is an absolutely reprehensible person."Or that golden radio moment in 2011 when talk show host Mike Malloy wondered when "SEAL unit six" was going to "drop in on George Bush." A couple of years later, Malloy said he'd "provide the butcher knife" for Senate leader Mitch McConnell to stab fellow Republicans Ted Cruz and Mike Lee in the back.The authors of these thoughts were in all cases exercising their free speech, excessive and disagreeable though it might be.But in no instance do we recall the Justice Department forcing a private organization to help identify the anonymous sources so it could torment them.We cannot remember, nor do we find any evidence, that the Secret Service investigated Malloy for hoping the U.S. military would kill a former president.Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials/061015-756727-justice-department-subpoenas-reason-foundation.htm#ixzz3chn6orRr Follow us: @IBDinvestors on Twitter | InvestorsBusinessDaily on Facebook
Tags
[]
Professor Quiet
sixpick
11 years ago
Professor Silent
Cerenkov
11 years ago
I am pretty strong on freedom of expression but anonymous posters death wishing may cross the boundary.
