╌>

Obama: Supreme Court Should Not Have Accepted Obamacare Challenge

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  96ws6  •  11 years ago  •  59 comments

Obama: Supreme Court Should Not Have Accepted Obamacare Challenge

On Monday, President Barack Obama said the Supreme Court should not have taken up the challenge to the Affordable Care Act in King v. Burwell.

"This should be an easy case. Frankly, it probably should not even have been taken up," Obama said during a press conference at the G-7 summit in Germany.

When asked whether the administration had a "plan B," in the event that the Supreme Court strikes down subsidies in states that do not run their own health insurance exchanges, Obama said there are no easy solutions.

"You have a model where all the pieces connect," he said. "And there are a whole bunch of scenarios -- not just with relation to health care but all kinds of stuff I do -- where if somebody does something that does not make any sense, it is hard to fix. This would be hard to fix."

The president called the legal challenge bizarre in light of the laws successful implementation.

Whats more the things working, Obama said. Part of what is bizarre about the whole thing is that we have not had a lot of conversation about the horrors of Obamacare because none of them have come to pass.

The Supreme Court will announce a ruling this month on whether the Affordable Care Act's designation of an "exchange established by the state" means that the law can only provide subsidies to individuals in states that run their own exchanges. If the court rules in favor of a narrow interpretation of that provision of the law, 6.4 million people in 34 states will lose their subsidies, leaving many unable to afford insurance.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2015/06/08/obamacare-supreme-court_n_7535472.html


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

The case presents no Constitutional principle in the law (both interpretations of the law are Constitutional). This is simply an adjudication of a conflict between the Executive and those in the Legislative branch on whether the Legislature truly expressed the Legislature's intent in the language of the law (to limit subsidies to those only in State exchanges). Could the Legislature truly haveintendedto expressthat distinction? What was their purpose in expressing the distinction.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Once again BO takes an unprecedented douche-bag move by (as president) commenting on a Supreme court case that is still in process.

"This should be an easy case. Frankly, it probably should not even have been taken up," Obama said during a press conference at the G-7 summit in Germany.

Here he goes trying to pass the blame again. The fact is that if the law was written responsibly, it wouldn't have been taken up. The problem is that the law is a poorly written clusterf*ck so it WILL be scrutinized and mark my words, this won't be the last time either.

When asked whether the administration had a "plan B," in the event that the Supreme Court strikes down subsidies in states that do not run their own health insurance exchanges, Obama said there are no easy solutions.

Translation: I have no plan B to help people that may get screwed because of my poorly written law and since 85%+ people on my "Affordable" health care can't afford it without help, make no mistake, it is going to be a huge mess and lots of people will get screwed.

If it looks like this will adversely affect my party I may finally think about getting off my ass and may actually try and do something to try to fix the bloody mess I have created but certainly not before then.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

He's trying to intimidate the Court, just like he did before the ruling on the law's constitutionality.

He's a menace.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

arrogance

nounarrogance\er--gn(t)s,a-r-\

: an insulting way of thinking or behaving that comes from believing that you are better, smarter, or more important than other people

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Yep, hence the

unprecedented douche-bag move

part of the comment.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Tell it to those who could lose their health care

61% are WHITE!

81% are WORKING!

A significant percentage is comprised of people who live in the SOUTH!

And one Republican Senator is accusing Obama of "NOT HAVING A BACKUP PLAN" if the SCOTUS kills the Affordable Health Care Act!

Is he fuckin' kidding?

I GOT YOUR BACKUP PLAN MR. PRESIDENT.

Tell them it's UNIVERSAL HEALTH CARE -- MEDICARE FOR ALL!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Your percentages are no surprise considering 87% of people who signed up for "affordable" health care are getting help paying for it because they can't afford it. I wonder how long that is sustainable.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

One of the pillars of the current liberal thinking focuses on excessive corporate profits in the financial sector. Here was one bill that could've provided affordable healthcare for all, AND stanch "excessive" profits in the insurance sector. And yet, since the ACA, the insurance companies are reaping record profits.

Everyone was told that they would have to chip in. The "rich" would have to take up and support the poor in the quest to have healthcare available to every American. The insurance industry was given no such mandate; there was no legislation affecting the insurance industry.

Hypocrisy at its most hypocritical.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Your percentages are no surprise considering 87% of people who signed up for "affordable" health care are getting help paying for it because they cant afford it.

81% ARE WORKING!

But feel free to blame the potential victims living in a country where HEALTH CARE IS A COMMODITY!

Shame!

Knowing the COST of things WITHOUT CONSIDERING VALUES isnot my idea of being a human being.

Republicans pander Christian and practice THE MARKETPLACE IS GOD

To discredit Obama, Republicans are willing to literally allow people to die for lack of affordable health care/insurance.

Giving and getting help is no sin

I wonder how long that is sustainable.

How long is Corporate Welfare sustainable?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

nd one Republican Senator is accusing Obama of "NOT HAVING A BACKUP PLAN" if the SCOTUS kills the Affordable Health Care Act!

First, the Supreme Court isn't going to kill the bill. The democrats nightmare is that the Court will order the ACA enforced as written and passed by Congress. Shocking concept that a law should be enacted consistently with how it's language, I know.

It was a Democratic bill passed exclusively by Democrats. What duty is there for Republicans to fix democratic incompetence? The problem, such that is, is exclusively of the democrats own doing, any duty to fix lies squarely on their own shoulders.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

2300.png&w=1484

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Medical Loss Ratio

Many insurance companies spend a substantial portion of consumers premium dollars on administrative costs and profits, including executive salaries, overhead, and marketing.

The Affordable Care Act requires health insurance issuers to submit data on the proportion of premium revenues spent on clinical services and quality improvement, also known as the Medical Loss Ratio (MLR). It also requires them to issue rebates to enrollees if this percentage does not meet minimum standards. MLR requires insurance companies to spend at least 80% or 85% of premium dollars on medical care, with the review provisions imposing tighter limits on health insurance rate increases.If they fail to meet these standards, the insurance companies will be required to provide a rebate to their customers starting in 2012.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Say what you will, this monster is not so much about health care as it is about record profits for insurance companies.

The only way health care is going to be affordable is when drugs, insurance and services don't cost 10x what they do everywhere else. Giving insurance companies record profits to match service and drug prices/profits and on top of it taking out the risk for the insurance they provide and putting it on the backs of the taxpayer certainly aren't the way to do it.

There needs to be some deregulation on drugs more competition in service area (which the current lack of is due to insurance companies) and competition in insurance without the government promising taxpayers will bail them out to fix the mess if one ensues. (this is totally ridiculous and basically negates the whole frigging purpose for insurance)

There also needs to be immigration reform in a way that gives productive immigrants a path to citizenship and that deports all who aren't to help control "free care" which will also bring the cost down. Of course securing the borders is important for this to work as well.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

There needs to be some deregulation on drugs more competition in service area (which the current lack of is due to insurance companies) and competition in insurance without the government promising taxpayers will bail them out to fix the mess if one ensues. (this is totally ridiculous and basically negates the whole frigging purpose for insurance)

Agreed

The fact that Medicare is forbidden in the law that created Medicare Part D to negotiate lower prices is no accident. The drug lobby worked hard to ensure Medicare wouldnt be allowed to cut into the profits which would flow to big Pharma thanks to millions of new customers delivered to them by Part D.

Even some Republican House members (this was a GOP sponsored bill) , including Rep. Walter Jones from North Carolina and Rep. Dan Burton from Indiana, were aghast at the whole process:

And

One popular idea among Democrats is allowing the federal government to negotiate with pharmaceutical companies on the cost of prescription drugs for Medicare, which covers more than 50 million Americans. President Obama put the idea in his 2016 budget, though it was restricted to some high-cost specialty drugs. Liberals have pushed for negotiating the price of all drugs covered under the government insurance plan.

Republicans have warned that Medicare's size means such a measure would lead to outright price controls, though the party's presidential contenders have been quiet on the issue in the early going.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

One more thing

The reason Obama will not and should not offer a plan "B" is quite simple

THE POTTERY BARN RULE

The Pottery Barn rule is an American expression alluding to a "you break it, you buy it" policy, by which a retail store holds a customer responsible for damage done to merchandise on display.

It is an analogy often used in the political or military arena to suggest that if an actor inadvertently creates a problem, the actor is obliged to provide funding sufficient to correct it.

If the law goes down, the anger will not be directed at the President and the Democrats that gave America the Affordable Care Act -- it will be directed at the Republicans who will be deemed the ones who took it away WITH NO ALTERNATIVE REPLACEMENT EVEN AFTER TRYING FOR FIVE YEARS AND FIFTY-EIGHT VOTES TO DO SO.

"You break it, You buy it"

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

How do you imagine Republicans "broke"a bill they didn't vote for and didn't alter? They left it alone to operate as passed by Democrats and somehow they are to blame. Talk about insanity. The language at issue was intentionally put in by the Democrats, ask Johnathon Gruber.

It's like arguing that Democrats have a "duty" to fix the Defense of Marriage Act that they don't support because the court invalidated it.. Just silly.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

So by enforcing the law as written you are breaking the system? And that's WHO'S fault?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

IT'S A METAPHOR!

When you take something from someone and you're not the one who gave it to him, IF YOU DON'T GIVE HIM SOMETHING BETTER OR OF EQUAL VALUE HE'LL BE ANGRY AND LIKLY TRY TO PUNISH YOU!

Try it and see. Take something from someone.

Get back to me with his reaction.

It's like what it is, Sean.

Your analogy is just silly.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

So by enforcing the law as written you are breaking the system? And that's WHO'S fault?

There have been cases won on the basis "intent" rather than on "the letter," and, there have been cases lost because the language and the intent did not jibe.

The concept of the common good -- plays an essential role in an adequate theory of legal and, more specifically, constitutional interpretation. The concept of the common good fills a gap in the current understanding of legal and constitutional interpretation.

And

General Welfare

Theconcernofthegovernmentforthehealth,peace,morality,andsafetyofitscitizens.

Providingforthewelfareofthegeneralpublicisabasicgoalofgovernment.

ThepreambletotheU.S.ConstitutioncitespromotionofthegeneralwelfareasaprimaryreasonforthecreationoftheConstitution.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

A Mac

Interesting metaphor and appropriate to many things that the government has gotten into the past, is getting into presently and will get into in the future.

Some might opine that aspects of the PPACA were broken in shipment and therefore the responsibility to replace it (or parts of it) rests with the manufacturer

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

BO and his admin wrote the law poorly. This falls on their shoulders and SCOTUS for their ruling on it. I would remind you once again if the law was properly written we wouldn't be having this conversation and SCOTUS would not be involved.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

No.

More like coming in 16 hours after a conversation starts, elbowing through every thread.

Actually, that's not arrogant. More like a side effect of boredom.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Obama who was hacking for corporations traded away the main benefit of a national health plan, but he traded it to Republicans.

...and that's the Republican's fault? Always partisanship when it comes to screwing the American people. Can't wait to finally see how much damage he will do to this country with TTP that he is working so well with Republicans on.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

"In fact, the ACA was the result of more than a year of congressional committee hearings in which progressive ideas like single payer or a public option were jettisoned, and hundreds of GOP amendments to the law were accepted, in exchange for zero Republican votes.

It's no secret BO is the worst negotiator in the country's history.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

I blame Republicans too ACA Is a clusterf*ck IMO, but that doesn't change the facts of who was in the drivers seat and what the drivers ultimately passed.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

If it weren't poorly written and executed the Republicans wouldn't be able to tear it down. Will people be pissed because they lost money because of a poorly written law or because the poorly written law is being executed the way it was written?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

It's poorly written because Republicans forced a bunch of amendments into the bill. Including the one you are currently bitching about.

Republicans helped write it, and completely muddied the waters of a pretty simple concept.

If you want to try and blame a bill that was written by the BO admin and passed without a single Republican vote on Republicans that is your own Boobery.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

It's poorly written because Republicans forced a bunch of amendments into the bill.


That's insane. Stalin would blush at such blatant falsehoods. If you've been paying any attention to the Senate, you know Reid stripped the minority party of any power to "force" amendments on this bill.

What's makes your delusional arguments even more preposterous is that not a single Republican Senator voted for passage. The only way Republicans could "force" language into the bill is if their votes had been necessary for passage, which they indisputably weren't.

As no Republicans votes were necessary for passage, it defies every principle of logic and reality to claim Republicans "forced" Pelosi to Reid to do something they didn't want to do.

You should be ashamed of peddling such transparent lies.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

iObamacare is the law of the land, and it is Republicans who are trying to break it

Upholding the text of Obamacare means you are trying to break it.

Priceless.

The problem is that Republican don't have ideas.


You should pay attention. Even President Bush's proposed health care reform would have covered more additional people than Obamacare at less cost.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

I am not trying to argue that Republicans may have had influence on the bill that you or anyone else may disagree with. My point is that no matter how bad the Republicans screwed it up, a bill that couldn't be fully read and digested was passed and it was passed byDems ONLY. Not a single Republican voted for it.

The Dems never should have passed it if the Repubs F*cked it all up and regardless of how bad Republicans screwed it up, NO REPUBLICANS VOTED FOR IT! The Dems have full responsibility for passing it, and therefore own the entire f*cked up mess!

 
 
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

It's the conservative Justices' "out" that the remedy is simple and belongs in the legislature, not the Court.

The Legislaturewrote the law. The Executive interpreted it as "the subsidies are available to all who purchase their insurance on the State exchanges (not limited to the State- run exchanges)". Does the Supreme Court want to get involved in semantics?

King V Burwell Simplified

 
 
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

It's the conservative Justices' "out" that the remedy is simple and belongs in the legislature, not the Court.

The Legislaturewrote the law. The Executive interpreted it as "the subsidies are available to all who purchase their insurance on the State exchanges (not limited to the State- run exchanges)". Does the Supreme Court want to get involved in semantics?

King V Burwell Simplified

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Some might opine that aspects of the PPACA were broken in shipment and therefore the responsibility to replace it (or parts of it) rests with the manufacturer

On the other hand, it's working for millions of Americans who never could afford or be eligible for health care for themselves or their children so, perfect or less than perfect it is helping recipients live healthier lives, and SAVING LIVES.

To those who want to evade the realities and say "this is about poorly written language," those who filed suit DID NOT DO SO BECAUSE THE LAW IS POORLY WRITTEN, they did it to embarrass Obama for political and hateful reasons. Whether the law is written in an air-tight manner or with some sloppy language, the fact that it's working and saving lives seems of no interest to the "I hope he fails" gang.

I have threatened the following before, RIO, and you in particular took strong exception but here it is one more time:

Should the SCOTUS do the bidding of Republicans who have tried 58 times to repeal Obamacare/ACA, I will use the network of professionals I established throughout my career, to bring about this wherever possible.

1298_discussions.jpg

To those who think I won't pursue this

You don't know me.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

A Mac

I agree that the PPACA was a step in the right direction (with good intentions) but it is only a small step and there are inherent problems that must be overcome if we are ever to truly reform and improve health care in the U.S.

And a reasonable person cannot think that the PPACA was or is without flaws which is the point I made.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The term common good does not appear in the constitution. What does appear is "general welfare" as part of the Spending power. Article I Section 8- Congress has the power to spend money in order to pay the debts and provide for the common defense and general welfare of the US.

The ability to spend for the general welfare was upheld in US v. Butler.

Taxing and spending for the general welfare

Although it struck down the Act, the Court dealt positively with taxation and the expenditure of funds to advance the general welfare as specified in Article 1 8 of the Constitution.

The Court stated that the issue presents the great and the controlling question in the case. After comparing expansive vs. restrictive interpretations of the Spending Clause, the Court adopted the philosophy that:

The clause confers a power separate and distinct from those later enumerated[,] is not restricted in meaning by the grant of them, and Congress consequently has a substantive power to tax and to appropriate, limited only by the requirement that it shall be exercised to provide for the general welfare of the United States. It results that the power of Congress to authorize expenditure of public moneys for public purposes is not limited by the direct grants of legislative power found in the Constitution.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago
I think the billboard should have a list of republicans that are in favor of protecting our constitution rights. I'm glad we don't have any of those ghetto billboards where I live.
 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    11 years ago
I'm not the one looking to put up one of those ugly eyesore ghetto billboards. If they ever build them where I live I'll most likely move.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I think the billboard should have a list of republicans that are in favor of protecting our constitution rights. I'm glad we don't have any of those ghetto billboards where I live.

Ghetto billboards?

Ghetto?

I already explained the constitutionality of funding the "general welfare."

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I'm not the one looking to put up one of those ugly eyesore ghetto billboards. If they ever build them where I live I'll most likely move.

Ghetto?

Just a guess your kind of billboard?

1299_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

You are always whining

Thanks for the observation.

Mind backing it up?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

I'm glad we don't have any of those ghetto billboards where I live.

Beyond the aesthetics and the "ghetto" thing, what specific objections do you have to providing information regarding individuals who would die almost directly commensurate with the taking of their health care through politically-pressured court action?

The billboard is not the issue, and now that you've used it to beg the question, answer the question.

Should we bury such information along with the victims?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

What's a ghetto billboard?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    11 years ago

Huh?

There's a debate going on with pro and con, and we are not sure yet?

That's embarrassing.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

It's Obama's fault he's hacking for corporations... and corporations fault... lest we forget them.

I am glad to see we have come to an agreement.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

What's a ghetto billboard?

IMO, it's one with a utilitarian message that attempts to appeal humanistic thought and which puts human welfare ahead of partisan insidiousness.

It's one that appeals to But I'll let Dean explain it since it's his label.


                            
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

Republicans didn't vote for it because they weren't operating in good faith. They were trying to undermine the bill because they didn't want Obama to have a legislative win.

It does not take a genius here to know they could have passed it without trying to appease the Republicans. It is simple math. The reason it passed is BECAUSE they didn't NEED a single Republican vote to pass it.

So the Dems "put a bunch of crap in to appease the republicans" (keep telling yourself that) then passed it without Republican help...just like they knew they could and intended to do in the first place...and the Republicans are the dumbasses/villains/crooks here? Really?

Face it Flame, any way you slice it, the Dems screwed the pooch on this one. If they really didn't want the Republican crap in the law it wouldn't be there. They knew damn well they could and would push though whatever they wanted without a single Republican vote and that's exactly the way it happened.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The letter of the law versus the spirit of the law is an idiomatic antithesis . When one obeys the letter of the law but not the spirit, one is obeying the literal interpretation of the words (the "letter") of the law , but not necessarily the intent of those who wrote the law. Conversely, when one obeys the spirit of the law but not the letter, one is doing what the authors of the law intended, though not necessarily adhering to the literal wording.

"Law" originally referred to legislative statute , but in the idiom may refer to any kind of rule. Intentionally following the letter of the law but not the spirit may be accomplished through exploiting technicalities , loopholes , and ambiguous language.

Interpretations of the U.S. Constitution have historically divided on the "Letter versus Spirit" debate. For example, at the founding, the Federalist Party argued for a looser interpretation of the Constitution, granting Congress broad powers in keeping with the spirit of the broader purpose of some founders (notably including the Federalist founders' purposes). The Federalists would have represented the "spirit" aspect. In contrast, the Democratic-Republicans , who favored a limited federal government, argued for the strict interpretation of the Constitution, arguing that the federal government was granted only those powers enumerated in the Constitution, and nothing not explicitly stated; they represented the "letter" interpretation.

Modern Constitutional interpretation also divides on these lines. Currently, Living Constitution scholars advocate a "spirit"-esque interpretative strategy, although one grounded in a spirit that reflects broad powers. Originalist or Textualist scholars advocate a more "letter"-based approach, arguing that the Amendment process of the Constitution necessarily forecloses broader interpretations that can be accomplished simply by passing an amendment.

Copied, pasted DOCUMENTAION

Spirit of the law refers to ideas that the creators of a particular law wanted to have effect. It is the intent and purpose of the lawmaker, or framer of the Constitution, as determined by a consideration of the whole context thereof. Spirit of law is determined form the letters and the circumstances surrounding its enactment.

Regarding the question:

Do you understand the pitfalls in "interpretations" by presidents in contradiction to the wording of the law?

Do you understand that it is one of the primary function of the SCOTUS to "interpret" laws?

  • TheSupreme Courthas two fundamentalfunctions. On the one hand, it must interpret and expound all congressional enactments brought before it in proper cases;
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   seeder  96WS6    11 years ago

It does not take a genius here to know they could have passed it without trying to appease the Republicans. It is simple math. The reason it passed is BECAUSE they didn't NEED a single Republican vote to pass it.

So the Dems "put a bunch of crap in to appease the republicans" (keep telling yourself that) then passed it without Republican help...just like they knew they could and intended to do in the first place...and the Republicans are the dumbasses/villains/crooks here? Really?

Face it Flame, any way you slice it, the Dems screwed the pooch on this one. If they really didn't want the Republican crap in the law it wouldn't be there. They knew damn well they could and would push though whatever they wanted without a single Republican vote and that's exactly the way it happened.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Who is saying this besides you?


Umm, pretty much every person whose paid a little attention to the lawsuit knows the plaintiffs are suing the government to implement the ACA as written. That's not even controversial.

Republicans are not upholding the text of Obamacare, they are objecting to it.


I'll say this for you, you certainly don't let the English language, logic or reality get in the way of your pontificating. Again, this isn't controversial or debatable, the plaintiffs want the law enforced as passed by Congress. The text is plain and the plaintiff's want the plain text followed. The administration wants to ignore the plain text and substitute its own preferred outcome. Simple as that.

Arguing like a four year old who puts his hands over his ears to ignore reality doesn't make you effective in propagating your imaginary points. Anyone who reads anything about this from anything approaching an unbiased source knows how full of shit you are on this subject.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

Wrong case. Different issue. Not relevant. Again.

Do you know stare decisis?

stare decisis
ster dsss/
noun
LAW
  1. the legal principle of determining points in litigation according to precedent.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

If you want to try and blame a bill that was written by the BO admin and passed without a single Republican vote on Republicans that is your own Boobery

Lest you forget the dynamics

There didnt seem to be an urgent need for Democrats to reconcile both bills immediately, because the Massachusetts special election (scheduled for January 19, 2010) was almost certain to fall to the Democrat, Attorney General Martha Coakley. After all, no Republican had been elected to the U.S. Senate from the Bay State since Edward Brooke in 1972 38 years before!

But in yet another twist of fate, Republican Scott Brown ran his campaign as the 41stsenator against ObamaCare and shocked nearly everyone by winning the special election by 110,000 votes.

That left House Speaker Nancy Pelosi and President Obama in a dilemma. Everyone assumed that the Christmas Eve 2009 Senate bill would be tweaked considerably to conform more with the House bill passed two months previously. But now that strategy wouldnt work, because the Democrats no longer had the 60thvote in the Senate to end debate.

What to do? They decided to have the House take up the identical bill that the Senate passed on Christmas Eve. It passed on March 21, 2010, by a 219 212 vote. This time, no Republicans came on board, and 34 Democrats voted against. President Obama signed the ACA legislation two days later on March 23.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

bama was actually trying to cut a bipartisan deal. And that in the process Obama made a bunch of concessions that were extremely unpopular with his base.

Wow. This is pure b.s., not to mention it makes Obama look like the world's biggest idiot. To make your fantasy come true, Obama granted concessions to Republicans and then left them in the bill without getting a single Republican vote. Then every single democrat voted for the bill with "bad" republican amendments that were they free to remove at any time, since it was clear no Republican would support the ACA.

What a preposterous joke and how insulting to Obama. He's the dumbest President,ever, if that actually happened. Seriously, what sort of an idiot would add amendments he opposed without promises of actual votes from the opposition in exchange? Good lord, if a Republican ever accused him of acting so stupid they'd be tarred and feathered as a racist.

Here's the truth. Republicans and Democrats negotiated and it went no where. The Democrats decided to do a bill on their own. This was the "best" bill the democrats could negotiate among themselves to get sufficient support to pass. Any "bad" amendments in the bill are their because the Democrats needed those amendments to attract Democratic votes. That's it.

None of this has anything to do with the text at issue in the lawsuit, of course. All of this whining about imaginary Republican amendments is an attempt by the Obamaphiles to defend the administration and his party from the incompetence they displayed in passing a bill they didn't understand.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

It doesn't have to be the same issue, it's rarely if ever "the same issue," it's the principle

This began with the discussion of the concept of "The Common Good" and the "General Welfare."

You took issue with the concepts although they come directly from the Constitution. I tried to enlighten you but you lost track of the road you went down.

Not my fault.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

The SC wouldn't hear a case if they thought it was obviously dealt with by a recent ruling.

The ruling I cited isn't recent but it was/is precedent setting regarding the common good/general welfare and how those principles obtain when the letter and spirit of the law are at issue.

And the SCOTUS did "recently" rule on the ACA you yourself commented earlier in the thread that "Roberts would cave again" (or to that effect).

And why do you suppose Roberts "caved"? Maybe he didn't want his name on a "billboard," etc. along with the names of deceased individuals who became deceased once they lost their health care.

"The Spirit of the Law" that literally has an effect on life and death matters of American citizens is a way the SCOTUS can use "intent," the "common good" and "general welfare" to rule in the case of the ACA and avoid the blowback from enraged widows, widowers, the parents of dying and deceased children all those who would lose loved ones because of "poorly negotiated/written language."

 
 
 
rimbauda
Freshman Silent
link   rimbauda    11 years ago

The truth is, the Supreme Court is not a Sophomore "bull session" and the Court does not pontificate on issues unless an adversary proceeding is brought before it, in which one party sues the other for damages it has suffered. No laws of Congress can be overturned unless they are first challenged, usually in lower courts, and a constitutional issue raised.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    11 years ago

BILLBOARD AVERTED!

1300_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

It was an easy case and I don't really think that there was any serious doubt that the SCOTUS would rule in favor of Obamacare. The question was going to be by how much. How close of a vote would it be and rightly so, it wasn't even close with both Kennedy and Roberts casting correct votes. It was something the GOP never should have pushed for, but are now breathing a huge sigh of relief at the court ruling.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

Obama: Supreme Court Should Not Have Accepted Obamacare Challenge

Seems like they agreed.

 
 

Who is online





JohnRussell
Dismayed Patriot


70 visitors