Hillary Clinton's Emails: The Real Reason the FBI Is Reviewing More of Them
Hillary Clinton's Emails: The Real Reason the FBI Is Reviewing More of Them
Updated | The disclosure by the Federal Bureau of Investigation late on Friday, October 28 that it had discovered potential new evidence in its inquiry into Hillary Clinton’s handling of her personal email when she was Secretary of State has virtually nothing to do with any actions taken by the Democratic nominee, according to government records and an official with knowledge of the investigation, who spoke to Newsweek on condition of anonymity.
The revelation that the FBI has discovered additional emails convulsed the political world, and led to widespread (and erroneous) claims and speculation. Many Republicans proclaimed that the discovery suggests Clinton may have broken the law, while Democrats condemned FBI Director James Comey for disclosing this information less than two weeks before the election, claiming he did it for political purposes.
Donald Trump, the Republican nominee, said the development showed his opponent had engaged in corruption “on a scale we have never seen before,’’ while Clinton called for the FBI to release all of the information it has, saying the American people have a right to know everything.
The truth is much less explosive. There is no indication the emails in question were withheld by Clinton during the investigation, the law enforcement official told Newsweek , nor does the discovery suggest she did anything illegal. Also, none of the emails were to or from Clinton, the official said. Moreover, despite the widespread claims in the media that this development had prompted the FBI to “reopen” the case, it did not; such investigations are never actually closed, and it is common for law enforcement to discover new information that needs to be examined.
U.S. Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton speaks at the Black Women's Agenda Annual Symposium, Washington, D.C., September 16. Carlos Barria/Reuters
As of Friday night Comey had only said the bureau is seeking to determine whether these newly discovered emails involved classified material.
The FBI found the new evidence during an unrelated inquiry into former Democratic Congressman Anthony Weiner regarding an allegation that he sent illicit, sexual text messages to an underage girl in North Carolina. In the course of that investigation, agents seized a laptop computer Weiner shared with his wife, Huma Abedin, a longtime Clinton aide who has already been questioned by the FBI during its investigation. The bureau found the emails now being examined on this shared device, which agents obtained some time ago.
This new evidence relates to how Abedin managed her emails. She maintained four email accounts—an unclassified State Department account, another on the clintonemail.com domain and a third on Yahoo. The fourth was linked to her husband’s account; she used it to support his activities when he was running for Congress, investigative records show. Abedin, who did not know Clinton used a private server for her emails, told the bureau in an April interview that she used the account on the clintonemail.com domain only for issues related to the Secretary’s personal affairs, such as communicating with her friends. For work-related records, Abedin primarily used the email account provided to her by the State Department.
Because Clinton preferred to read documents on paper rather than on a screen, emails and other files were often printed out and provided to her either at her office or home, where they were delivered in a diplomatic pouch by a security agent. Abedin, like many State Department officials, found the government network technology to be cumbersome, and she had great trouble printing documents there, investigative records show. As a result, she sometimes transferred emails from her unclassified State Department account to either her Yahoo account or her account on Clinton’s server, and printed the emails from there. It is not clear whether she ever transferred official emails to the account she used for her husband’s campaign.
Abedin would use this procedure for printing documents when she received emails she believed Clinton needed to see and when the Secretary forwarded emails to her for printing. Abedin told the FBI she would often print these emails without reading them. Abedin printed a large number of emails this way, in part because, investigative records show, other staff members considered her Clinton’s “gatekeeper” and often sent Abedin electronic communications they wanted the Secretary to see.
This procedure for printing documents, the government official says, appears to be how the newly discovered emails ended up on the laptop shared by Abedin and her husband. It is unclear whether any of those documents were downloaded onto the laptop off of her personal email accounts or were saved on an external storage device, such as a flash drive, and then transferred to the shared computer. There is also evidence that the laptop was used to send emails from Abedin to Clinton; however, none of those emails are the ones being examined by the FBI. Moreover, unless she was told by Abedin in every instance, Clinton could not have known what device her aide was using to transmit electronic information to her.
If the FBI determines that any of the documents that ended up on the shared device were classified, Abedin could be deemed to have mishandled them. In order to prove that was a criminal offense, however, investigators would have to establish that Abedin had intended to disclose the contents of those classified documents, or that she knew she was mishandling that information.
If the documents were not classified, no crime was committed. But either way, this discovery has embarrassed Clinton, even though there is no evidence at this point suggesting she has been implicated in any potential wrongdoing.
According to a letter Comey sent to the chairs of several Congressional committee on Friday, he learned of these new emails on Thursday, October 27.
His decision to immediately reveal this discovery was not a partisan act, although it was a horribly mishandled one. Arguably, he had to issue his letter because of previous statements he had made to Congress. In September, he testified that the bureau had completed its review of the evidence in the case and found no crimes had been committed. With the discovery of the information on the laptop shared by Weiner and Abedin, that sworn statement was no longer true, and there was new evidence that needed to be examined. As a result, Comey felt he was obligated to inform the committees as quickly as possible that his previous statement was now incorrect.
However, the letter he sent could well damage the reputation of the FBI as an apolitical organization for years to come. Given that Comey also testified that his agents would examine any new evidence that emerged, Democrats will undoubtedly argue that issuing a letter repeating that point was unnecessary.
In a communication to bureau employees, Comey described his letter to Congress as an attempt to thread a needle – amend his testimony while not disclosing details of an ongoing investigation. The combination, however, created a circumstance where politicians are filling in the blanks, creating a storyline of corruption that was not justified by the evidence developed by the bureau. Making it worse, the communication to the bureau employees is far more detailed than what Comey issued to Congress.
“There is a significant risk of being misunderstood,” Comey told the bureau employees in the communication, explaining why he was so vague in his letter to Congress. “It would be misleading to the American people were we not to supplement the record. At the same time, however, given that we don’t know the significance of this newly discovered collection of emails, I don’t want to create a misleading impression.”
Unfortunately, by trying to have things both ways – revealing the change in circumstances while remaining vague about what the agents know – Comey has created that misleading impression that could change the outcome of a presidential election, an act that, if uncorrected, will undoubtedly go down as one of the darkest moments in the bureau’s history.

Comey should have waited until after the election to bring this up, absent any indication that there is something in the emails that is incriminating about Hillary Clinton. This really amounts to tampering with the election.
Hey, James Comey is the new wikileaks.
So they should keep a lid on the truth about more potential illegal activities until after the election on someone who should not even be allowed to run in the first place. Spoken like true partizan hack.
On what basis should Hillary Clinton not be allowed to run?
Cornell Law Library Former United States Attorney General Michael Mukasey tells MSNBC that not only is Hillary Clinton’s private email server illegal, it “disqualifies” her from holding any federal office. Very specifically points to one federal law, Title 18. Section 2071.
So here’s the one law you need to know that should terminate her presidential campaign:
For those of us who do not have United States Code committed to memory, here’s what it says:”(a) Whoever willfully and unlawfully conceals, removes, mutilates, obliterates, or destroys, or attempts to do so, or, with intent to do so takes and carries away any record, proceeding, map, book, paper, document, or other thing, filed or deposited with any clerk or officer of any court of the United States, or in any public office, or with any judicial or public officer of the United States, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both. (b) Whoever, having the custody of any such record, proceeding, map, book, document, paper, or other thing, willfully and unlawfully conceals, removes, mutilates, obliterates, falsifies, or destroys the same, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than three years, or both; and shall forfeit his office and be disqualified from holding any office under the United States. As used in this subsection, the term “office” does not include the office held by any person as a retired officer of the Armed Forces of the United States.”
Yes, it explicitly states “shall forfeit his office and be disqualified from holding any office under the United States.”
Last July the FBI concluded that the statute you list was not applicable to Hillary Clinton in this case. What is it about that that you fail to comprehend?
Many legal experts looked at Title 18 Section 2071 , over the course of many months, and reached the same conclusion Comey did.
I would post some of them for you to read but I am sure it would be a waste of time.
I am aware Comey added the new provision/interpretation of "intent to do harm" to the law, WHICH DOES NOT EXIST IN THE LAW THE WAY IT IS WRITTEN. There is good reason this is not the way the law is written. Regardless of INTENT, this kind of handling of classified information can cause untold damage to the country.
Perhaps he has finally interpreted the law correctly, or perhaps he thinks there may be proof of intent.
Either way, he repeatedly told congress the investigation was over and if it is not, especially if there is possible new evidence that could change his recommendations, it would be an injustice to the American people not to point it out before the election.
Sitting on the news and lying to congress until the election was over would be be the worst thing the FBI has ever done. Full disclosure is better than lying. John, as a loyal Clintonite, Wants comey to lie and conceal the truth from the public rather thin explain the sitaution truthfully like he did.
of course, if you don't want the FBI involved in the election, don't nominate someone under FBI investigation. You have no one to blame for this other than Hillary and the people who voted for someone under criminal investigation.
You have turned yourself into a ridiculous shill Sean. Without even knowing what is in these emails Comey inserted them into the election. Donald Trump says this is now "worse than Watergate", even though he has no idea what is in them or if they are even relevant. THIS is what Comey has done.
There are too many conspiracy nuts, and frankly, right wing idiots, in this country for it to be wise to put unsubstantiated or misleading information before the public.
He obviously has some idea of the contents of some of them at least. Agents read them and realized they were relevant, triggering the notification. What's amazing is that Lynch's DOJ is holding up the subpoena that will allow the FBI to study all of them and report on them to congress and the public,
Why do you think Obamas DOJ is keeping the FBI from doing its job?
I would like to see a financial tally of how much the investigation into Hillary's email has cost the American taxpayers.
Probably two or three times as much as if they'd farmed it out to a private contractor. Probably would have gotten it done in half the time too.
Since "getting it done" amounts to finding nothing, it's an egregious misuse of hard earned money by American taxpayers. Meanwhile, the bridges they travel on to earn that money are falling apart.
About two seconds worth of annual spending, and most of that was caused by her stonewalling, lying etc...
We should bill her.
Maybe the FBI should devote half their resources to verifying you are innocent of something and send you the bill.
The FBI didn't say she was innocent of anything. Read what comey said again.
We now have two full days of people on this site non stop rehashing something that was disposed of 4 months ago.
"Benghazi, Benghazi, Benghazi"
Well then is a layup for you. Please point to any statement by Comey where she said Clinton is innocent of wrongdoing.
Go ahead, prove it.
Comey indicated that the two statutes everyone was pointing to did not apply to Clinton , for the reasons he stated. I personally posted about 5 different articles from various legal experts last spring , prior to Comey, which all predicted she would not be indicted. The reasons given were exactly the reasons Comey eventually gave.
How any rational person could then conclude that Comey was "given instructions" to let Clinton off the hook is inexplicable. But that is the way the political right rolls, irrationally and inexplicably.
Yes, I am aware of where he declined to prosecute because of what he described as an inability to prove intent.
Where did he say she was innocent of wrongdoing?
Nice spin. They demonstrated that she wasn't innocent. She was grossly negligent. They just declined to prosecute.
Those sort of facts only confuse their simple narrative.
John and the democrats are mad Comey won't perjure himself to protect Clinton. Clinton supporters must be confounded that someone actually takes perjury seriously, they sure don't.
Party over nation.
Look at these and tell me which one she didn't violate.
Executive Order 13526
18 U.S. Code Chapter 37 - ESPIONAGE AND CENSORSHIP and choose
18 U.S. Code § 793 - Gathering, transmitting or losing defense information US Code Notes Section (f).
PART 1230—UNLAWFUL OR ACCIDENTAL REMOVAL, DEFACING, ALTERATION, OR DESTRUCTION OF RECORDS
§1230.10 Who is responsible for preventing the unlawful or accidental removal, defacing, alteration, or destruction of records?
Violation of the 2009 Federal Records Act page 48 of 58 Section 1236.22
I know Executive Order 13526 is pretty long. The main pertinent information is at:
Part 4 - Safeguarding and Part 5 - Implementation and Review
The other links above are as clear as it gets.
I would like to see anyone challenge them.