Are There Too Few Teachers, Or Too Few Good Ones?
Jasmine Gipson has long considered a career in teaching. Her mom has been a teacher for almost 20 years, and Gipson is familiar with everything the job entails including low pay and long hours and those factors havent scared her off.
Ive seen how shes navigated through those things and taken advantage of the benefits shes received, so the idea of teaching doesnt seem as scary to me as it might to other people, Gipson said. Even so, she wont be teaching this fall after she graduates from Harvard with a degree in African and African-American Studies. She hasnt taken a teaching career off the table entirely, but she did say that the politics surrounding teaching and concerns about her potential colleagues have made her hesitate. For now, shell be working as a fellow for a nonprofit agency that focuses on increasing opportunities for low-income children.
Gipsons story is one among many in a larger complex trend in education: For a number of reasons, it appears that fewer of our best and brightest young people are becoming teachers. Enrollment in teacher prep programs both short-term ones like Teach for America and the more traditional college education majors are on the decline. TFA has experienced a 21 percent decline in applications since 2013; federal Title II data on teacher prep programs shows a 31 percent decline in enrollment since 2008; and enrollment in graduate education programs has decreased by about 3 percent annually since 2008. These application and enrollment drops have been well documented by the likes of the New York Times , NPR and Education Week .
The drop could be a holdover from the recession in two ways. First, now that the economy is rebounding, job seekers are on the hunt for more lucrative options. (According to the National Education Association , the national average for a starting teacher salary in 2012-13 was $36,141.) Second, education budget cuts nationwide , both during and after the recession, left a bad taste in many prospective teachers mouths.
In Texas, around 2011, there was a lot of negative press around teaching, said Michael Marder, the executive director of UTeach, a teacher preparation program that was founded at the University of Texas at Austin and has expanded to 44 universities in 21 states. Students were going off on field visits and saying that their mentor teachers were upset, that pink slips were being handed out in anticipation of budget cuts. It left a strong impression.
Marder added that people who may consider teaching later in their careers have been deterred as well.
The press is portraying it in such a way to make people less and less likely to pursue it, and make career changers think three or four times about it, he said. What Ive heard from career changers is, Im willing to spend a year or so preparing and paying for coursework, take a drop in income, go to a rough school, work with challenging kids really stretch myself. But if Im going to do all that, and then theyre going to fire me? Forget it.
Its likely that the drop in enrollment in teacher certification programs is just a blip on the radar resulting from the recent economic turmoil. Economists seem confident that the number of teaching positions will continue to grow; the National Center for Education Statistics annual projections show that the number of teaching positions is expected to increase by about 1 percent every year through 2022. But whether or not enrollment numbers rebound, the recent trend has reignited a discussion about who is choosing to become a teacher and, just as important, how good those people are at what they do.
Kate Walsh, president of the National Council on Teacher Quality (NCTQ), a nonpartisan research and policy organization, believes that the dip in enrollment in teacher training and education programs might be a good thing. With the rebounding economy, its possible that many students who were interested in teaching for job security in the midst of the recession have siphoned off to other pursuits.
If its less academically able students who are choosing not to go into the profession, that would be solving a problem that we have, she said.
That concept that not all teachers are equal has long been a political sticking point. The federal government has focused on tracking teacher quality in the hopes of improving standards, especially since the implementation of No Child Left Behind (NCLB). Part of the legislation required that all teachers of core academic subjects be highly qualified by the 2005-06 school year, but the government has gotten flak for its amended definition of the term highly qualified teacher, which requires only that teachers are making satisfactory progress toward completing full state certification. Under that definition, 94 percent of classes in the 2006-07 school year had a highly qualified teacher at the helm, according to the Department of Educations final report on teacher quality under NCLB.
Walsh says these types of standards are one of the main problems facing the profession.
Our nation has placed minimal expectations on what a teacher should be able to know and do, she said. The U.S. has historically had an open-door policy into the teaching profession, which has to stop if were going to address basic fundamental problems.
While the federal government sets the minimum bar for teacher qualifications, the real onus is on states to implement their own higher standards. State requirements vary widely: 23 states (including D.C.) dont have a uniform content-specific degree standard for high school teachers, according to the secretary of educations most recent report on teacher quality. That means, for example, that some biology teachers might have biology degrees while others dont.
Data from the report also shows that while each state has its own assessment for teacher preparation programs, and its own minimum passing score for those assessments, the national average score cutoff is 56.5, while the national average score of test takers is 71.3. The difference in these two numbers suggests that the bar may be set relatively low across the board, according to the report. Cut scores range from 42.6 in Puerto Rico to 70 in Arizona, Illinois and Oklahoma.
A 2014 report from the NCTQ shows that theres also a low bar for education majors throughout their time in school. It found that education majors made disproportionately higher grades than students in other majors, largely because grading standards for teaching candidates are much lower than for other majors.
Its a very easy major. Its attracting students who are not serious about teaching, Walsh said.
Walsh may have cause to be optimistic about the future of the profession, however: An Educational Researcher study published in November found that the average SAT scores of students in New York entering the teaching profession have been on a sharp rise since 2007, which mirrors the findings of a 2013 national study .
Once these teachers have entered the field, however, they might be less likely to stay in the classroom, according to the most recent data from the National Center for Education Statistics.
One such teacher, Jasmine Mack, who teaches family and consumer sciences at Pflugerville High School near Austin, Texas, moved to teaching two years ago after two and a half years at a nonprofit agency. Shed always wanted to be a teacher but was initially deterred by the stigma. When I was a freshman in college, my dad said, Absolutely not. Im not paying for your college when I know youre going to be a slave and not make any money or get any appreciation. So I gave it up and decided to go into a different field.
She did find her way to teaching, but she was quickly disillusioned, and now shes leaving the profession at the end of this school year.
It was a very hard decision. I do enjoy what I do, she said. But it feels like theres always more being added to your plate. Youre working a ton of hours, having to go to trainings, always having to be implementing new things in the classroom with no extra time, help or money to do so. Why would I stay?
Walsh and Mack agree that to attract the best possible teachers to the profession and to keep them there better incentives are key.
Districts and states need to make it possible to earn a nice salary if youre good at your job, Walsh said. If you want to attract really good people, youre going to have to reward them for being good.
But improving teacher pay especially based on quality and experience is easier said than done.
The problem is that there is no market mechanism I can see to stem the tide of teachers fleeing or choosing not to go in the first place, Marder said. Just because the state requires something to be taught doesnt mean salaries will rise to protect the teachers who teach it.
http://fivethirtyeight.com/features/are-there-too-few-teachers-or-too-few-good-ones/

Good teachers are a precious natural resource -- very few people will argue with that assertion.
Almost as many will also agree that bad teachers are a major drag on the education process and on the reform and improvement of the education systems in the U.S.
So insuring that we have more of the former (good teachers) and fewer of the latter (bad teachers) seems an obvious part of the solution to the decline of the education processes in the U.S., along with more effective and equitable funding processes for schools at all levels and without regard to socio-economic factors.
We have all had great teachers and terrible teachers, we never forget either for very different reasons as both types leave indelible marks on the students they interact with.
Arguments and rhetoric about the good and evil of charter schools, teachers' unions, church-affiliated-schools, urban schools versus rural schools or schools in the suburbs have valid aspects but tend to take the eyes of the prize of actually improving the education system.
There would be less bad teachers if the Teacher's Unions were not so strong.
Buzz
I am not ready to accept that as a direct relationship of one to the other.
I would also offer that if salaries were higher, better teachers would remain and not leave the field ad that if funding for education was not such a mess in many states that schools would be better equipped to retain good teachers and better able to tech our children.
I do not discount that bad effects have been generated by teachers unions, but there have always been bad side effects associated with the positives of unions in the U.S. and I would opine that teachers' unions are no different.
I appreciate the feedback and perspective.
Robert,
There has never been a shortage of teachers. The concept of a teacher shortage shows its head periodically whenever the Colleges of Education find that they have empty seats to fill in their classrooms. Then, the publicity about the great teacher shortage starts operating again, just as it has for many years. There is no shortage. What you really have are a great many good, well trained teachers doing other jobs (everything from car salesmen to truck drivers) because THERE ARE VERY FEW TEACHING JOBS AVAILABLE. Those that are there require not only ability and training, but also some sort of political pull within the school district in order to get hired. If you don't have the latter, it doesn't matter how good you are; you can't compete with the nephew or niece of a school board member.
And there are few teaching positions available because of piss-poor administration and school board autocats.
J W
For those who have been instructors or teachers of children or adults, the "term" scary makes a lot sense.
A room full adolescents or teenagers and one teacher (doubling as animal trainer, nanny, security guard, mentor, etc) can be a scary place, but the good teachers face and overcome that scariness and see the challenge of molding the lives of young people as more important than anything else.
TTGA
There is a shortage of good teachers - that is the problem.
There are good teachers working in other career fields for sure, but just as alarming (actually more so) there are a lot of people in teaching that should be in other career fields for their own good and most importantly for the good of their students.
1st
Actually the diminishing number of positions is more due to inept funding models for public schools than the ineptness of administration or school boards.
While a teacher, 35 years ago, I had knives pulled on me, was threatened with rape and assault, had my car raided--(my battery and my spare stolen), my coat stolen, my purse stolen, my rocks stolen, etc. Yeah, no way would I teach in today's climate. It was bad enough, back then.
Good experience, though, for working in some of the places I had to work as a geologist.
A long as powerful teachers' unions keep incompetant teachers from being fired, the nations' public schools will continue to go downhill.
Krish
Unions are only a part of the problem and not even the biggest problem in the poor quality of the U.S. education system
States are making changesto tenure processes for teachers and in my view unions will give on some of these and gain some in other areas.
It is too easy to say it is all the unions' fault and incorrect as well.
Dowser
The teaching experience can be challenging and dangerous but all of the best teachers I have had and my children I have had always told me that all the challenges were worth it in comparison to the satisfaction they felt when the kids succeeded and excelled.
Well, I left teaching. It was satisfying and fulfilling, and wonderful, and I loved it. But I couldn't make my house payment, and ate canned vegetable soup every night for 18 months. That, I could afford-- $.26/can.
Besides, there is something also satisfying about beating a rock with a hammer when you're frustrated with it. You can't do that with kids...
RIO...I agree....
Nona
Appreciate the perspective
Now that is true!
I totally agree that part of the solution is to pay the good teachers a sufficiently high salary that they can have a good life and help create good lives for their students.
Max
Excellent point on the massiveness of the administrative and support staff in relation to the actual teaching staff
This is an added complication to the funding miasma most schools are facing, which administration exacerbates by looking to cut teachers first when money is tight rather than consolidating the administrative and support functions.
All part of the needed reform
Thanks for the feedback
When I had opportunities to teach technical subjects, I found teaching to be one of the most rewarding things I have ever done. I have to stress that I was teaching to adults that wanted to, and were motivated to learn about electronics, plant heat transfer, mathematics and plastics processing, Etc.
Would I be as thrilled about teaching high school biology (which I love) to a bunch of semi-intelligent Labradoodles that were motivated just to pass the class...... I don't know. I know how to generate interest and get people fired up to learn, but the ones that didn't care about the subject matter would be a problem for me because I believe EVERYONE should care about what I'm teaching. In short, if they don't see a need to learn, I wouldn't see a need to teach them.
FLY
I was a service school instructor for about four years and I agree it was very rewarding.
I enjoyed the motivated audience eager to learn things that I had become expert at through schooling and practical application of the skill.s
I also agree that teaching a room full of teenagers that for the most part want to be anywhere else but in the classroom is an entirely different kettle of fish.
In my view, a major trait and ability of the good teacher is the ability to grab the interest of even the unwilling or unmotivated student and kindle the desire to learn and grow. Those are the teachers I most remember
Thanks for the feedback
I think most teachers become teachers because they want to help children and young adults, but get caught up in the business end of it and government control of the creativity and knowledge they could pass on to their students.
I think teachers should be paid more, but have a better way to gauge their success as a teacher. I do not think they should have tenure. And this doesn't mean they can be fired at will. I think they should have a way to save their career if they aren't incompetent in doing it.
Six
Good points, thanks for the feedback
At will employment does not mean that discriminatory firing is possible but I agree that a reasonable review of performance process (including termination provisions) needs to be standardized as part of education reform.
I can certainly understand that attitude Fly. Unfortunately you would be the second teacher. The first teacher would be the parents and too many of them are bad teachers which has a strong tendency to make it nearly impossible for you to do a good job.
Six
The importance of active and positive parental participation in the education of children and in the reform of the education process cannot be overemphasized
Thanks for that perspective