AT&T opts out of FCC’s Lifeline broadband subsidies; other providers likely to follow
The Federal Communications Commission’s plan to add broadband subsidies to its Lifeline program may need a life preserver.
The sinking plan recently saw AT&T opt out, and other providers such as Verizon, Frontier and CenturyLink are expected to do the same, Fortune reported . Friday is the last day for telecoms to notify the FCC if they’re in or out.
The FCC announced the Lifeline expansion in April. Previously focused on telephone service for low-income Americans, that program created in 1985 will now include broadband services. Those who qualify get a $9.25-per-month subsidy to apply toward high-speed home internet or a data plan for their cell phones.
The FCC is budgeting $2.25 billion annually for the broadband expansion of Lifeline. Ratepayers pay for the program through the Universal Service Fund, a tax on phone bills. Lifeline takes about $1.75 of the $3-or-so USF tax on the average consumer’s bill.
About a third of the 40 million households eligible for Lifeline don’t currently subscribe to broadband. The expansion is expected to add about 5.5 million people to a program that now serves 18 million.
Joan Marsh, vice president of the federal regulatory division of AT&T, recently wrote on the company’s blog that AT&T believes it can better serve low-income residents by offering its own Access from AT&T program, which costs $10 a month for 10 megabits-per-second download speeds and $5 for 3 mbps.
She notes that consumers who get a Lifeline subsidy could actually pay much more for internet, pointing to the FCC’s own national benchmark of $69.14 for download speeds of 10 megabits per second. With the subsidy, customers would still average paying nearly $60 per month.
Both Lifeline and Access from AT&T primarily use the recipient list of the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program to determine eligibility.
Another concern is the FCC’s plan to use a new third-party to determine Lifeline provider eligibility and administer program rules rather than putting the onus on states. The program has seen its share of fraud, with resellers signing up ineligible people as they took a share of the subsidies.
But the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners and a coalition of nine states filed a petition with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit asking the court to scrap the FCC plan. That group worries that the FCC’s plan to fast-track the subsidies could result in more fraud and abuse in the program.

What a mess. Lifeline is a lifesaver.