Job Retraining Won’t Work. We’ll Need Government Jobs, Then a Universal Basic Income
Job Retraining Won’t Work. We’ll Need Government Jobs, Then a Universal Basic Income
There is a growing consensus among futurists and visionaries of various backgrounds that the challenges of an automated economy will require implementing a universal basic income. These thinkers range from former SEIU president Andy Stern to Robert Reich to a wide range of entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley. Martin Luther King, Jr., advocated for it, as did conservative Milton Friedman.
For all the hoopla over china, trade and immigration, 85% of the manufacturing losses in the United States were due to automation, not trade . And it’s not just manufacturing. Automation imperils huge swaths of employment, from the medical profession to the finance industry. Drivers of all kinds, from truckers to cabbies to worksite drivers, are all on the chopping block. Big data threatens to slash middle level managers and analysts of all kinds. Something will have to be done.
But most people aren’t ready for a universal basic income. Wherever the public has had a chance to vote on it, it has failed–and usually dramatically. People aren’t comfortable with the idea yet–they worry about creating a class of layabouts, and about removing the dignity that comes with a job, and about losing the leverage workers have had against capital since the dawn of the labor movement. Most of these are cultural fears that will dissipate over time, but they are very real.
Because of that, reducing structural underemployment and unemployment due to automation is going to require a large push for government sector employment first. There is a great deal of work to be done in repairing and creating new infrastructure, in retrofitting existing equipment to implement renewable energy, water saving and carbon-controlling measures, and in forward-thinking work like space travel. A great deal of this work will be manual and skilled trade labor of the sort that can be done by Americans hardest hit by the global economy.
But to get even that far will require an acknowledgment that retraining for the “jobs of the future” is not a satisfactory answer. Former factory workers in places like Muncie , IN, either cannot or will not learn to code and develop apps. Job retraining programs have not been very successful in part because of cultural challenges, and in part because there isn’t actually a skills gap between American workers and unfilled jobs . The “jobs of the future” are rapidly changing as well. Ten to fifteen years ago the “cool” job was web design, and everyone was supposed to learn HTML. Now those skills are nearly useless, as automated tools make it easy to put a website together without any coding knowledge whatsoever. Today’s hot job is making apps, but that labor market is already saturated and globalized, with ever more democratized tools. Tomorrow’s hot job will be in 3-D printers with their own language and requirements, but then that too will be rapidly simplified on the front end. The back ends of all these technologies will require fewer and fewer back end creators, even as machine learning for even back end applications improves.
The free market won’t solve this problem on its own–not even with retraining and intervention. It wouldn’t be able to do it even if human beings were movable automatons themselves, willing to sit behind a desk in a city when they would rather be working in the sun in the towns they grew up in. Culture gets in the way, as do basic human needs. As well they should: people don’t exist to do jobs; jobs exist to serve people.
Politicians will need to acknowledge that the modern late-stage capitalist economy is fundamentally broken. America isn’t great now. It cannot be made great again. It will need an economic revolution.
That revolution must start with government guarantees of employment and well-being. It must begin with a pledge to make it affordable to attain the education to get what few good-paying jobs will remain. It must continue with a commitment by the government to employ those who have been left behind in doing the much-needed work that the free market will not pay for. And it must ultimately include a commitment to use the dividends of increased productivity via automation and globalization that have been going to line the pockets of shareholders in the top .1% of income, to make the citizens who produced that wealth whole again with a guaranteed income productivity dividend.
With those steps taken, cultural resistance to a universal basic income will decline, and people of all classes and identities will be able to step forward into a world freer from inequality, exploitation and wage slavery.

Within the lifetime of people who are alive today this will become the biggest issue in America, by far. There will be no work for 3/4 of the people. Socialism is inevitable.
My suggestion to millennials - go into undertaking and find a way to do it cheaper than the competition.
Or the new market opening up for liberals called green burials where the body is prepared without harmful chemicals.
But yeah my advice too would be to get a job and quit expecting someone else to be stuck paying for you.
Is that really your speech to someone who lost their job to a robot?
Automation will create mass unemployment in America. Some projections are that 70 or 80 percent of Americans will be unemployed withing the working lifetime of those who are children today. Then you will get your socialism.
Time to start working on population reduction. The first step is to make people responsible for themselves and their families. Time for the Democrats to realize when you create welfare queens you end up with Detroits and Chicagos. But we all know that is their goal.
Your comment has little to do with the article, or the reality of it.
There will be more profit for business owners and managers to use automation, so they will, eventually putting tens of millions of people permanently out of work, as all other jobs will be automated also. This is going to happen.
Your advice to tens of millions of people is "take care of yourselves", which can be seen as a call to anarchy, crime, and mass disorder.
No the crime and anarchy is what happens in your urban liberal welfare hubs. In your crime riddled city how many of those five hundred killed are welfare recipients?
You are off topic.
You were to one asking about the crime and anarchy. I'm explaining where it exists and that it is the result of welfare. When you strip the individual of the responsibility for his wellbeing it changes the culture of the citizens. Welfare creates slums and strips people of the desire to create a better environment for themselves and their families.
How will people take care of themselves when there will be tens of millions less jobs than there are today?
The same way they have for millions of years without welfare. They get off their butts and reap what they sow.
So you expect 100 million and more Americans to be entirely self employed. What will be the success rate and what happens to the failures?
On the other hand, robots will be there to make stuff nobody has the money to buy. It will be sadly comedic if that's how the human race goes into extinction.
"Time to start working on population reduction."
That will be fun, considering that the republicans have won ultimate political control through the workings of Dominionists. Making birth control harder to get and abortion illegal will not reduce the population.
However, my instincts tell me that you are less interested in preventing birth than you are extinguishing life that you don't have any respect for.
When you tell a woman her child will be her financial responsibility and she will not be able to pawn the cost of the kid off on others peoples back she will think twice about getting pregnant. Her pregnancy is her problem not mine. Just because some kniucklehead decides to get knocked up by a loser that doesn't support his family doesn't mean it should be my responsibility.
Let the innocent kids die, in other words. You don't care about anyone at all. Dude, what happened to you to give you the empathy of a serial killer?
He appears to be a hard core Randian. A philosophy also admired by the current speaker of the U.S. house or representatives.
Ironic, since Rand died a welfare queen.
No she didn't.
"In 2011, it was revealed that Rand had spent the last eight years of her life receiving Social Security and Medicare benefits. At the time of her death, her estate was valued at $500,000 (around $1.2 million in today’s money), suggesting her decision was motivated less by rationality than by the sort of parasitic greed she’d always claimed to despise."
Wrong she was fighting to get back what was stolen from her against her will.
Just as I payed in when I was younger I will not need it but will be fighting to recover what was taken from me.
Yeah? How much did she claw back from roads that got paved with her money even though she didn't drive on them? What a genius.
Social security isn't supposed to go towards paving roads.
I didn't say it was. SS is a system, just like the system that paves public roads, or at least used to. To enjoy the benefit of the system, you have to pay into it. You may get more out of it than you put into, or you may get less. If you spend years in and out of hospitals because you smoked yourself to death, then you are definitely going to get more money out of SS and Medicare than you put in, as compared to a person who took care of themselves. In today's world, Rand would be a 'welfare queen' of the highest order.
It's even worse than that as the employer gets stuck paying 6.2% tax to fund it. That drives up the cost of doing business in America and makes us less competitive on the global market. People wonder why iPhones are not manufactured here this is part of the reason.
These liberal socialist programs come with a cost and the cost is it destroys our ability to compete on a global level.
It's just another liberal taker meme about Rand, easily debunked.
"Rand also believed that the scientific consensus on the dangers of tobacco was a hoax. By 1974, the two-pack-a-day smoker, then 69, required surgery for lung cancer. And it was at that moment of vulnerability that she succumbed to the lure of collectivism."
She wasn't just a welfare queen, she was an idiot who incurred huge Medicare expenses by her own naked and stubborn insidiousness.