The real solution to the Carrier jobs fiasco was under Trump’s nose the whole time
The real solution to the Carrier jobs fiasco was under Trump’s nose the whole time
Ethan Wolff-Mann,Yahoo Finance Sat, Dec 3 5:22 AM PST
President-elect Trump tours the Carrier facility in Indiana. Source: AP
This week in Indianapolis, President-elect Donald Trump announced that he would save hundreds of Americans’ jobs from going to Mexico.
Speaking at United Technologies’ ( UTX ) Carrier air conditioning company, Trump announced a deal that kept 800 jobs in-state in exchange for $7 million in tax breaks. Meanwhile, 1,300 are still leaving, according to a letter sent to employees.
To workers at Carrier, the triumph is sweet, but it feels something like a stay of execution for their jobs, not an acquittal, given the circumstances.
“As much as we’re happy jobs are staying, a lot of us don’t know how much trust to put in Carrier,” 14-year Carrier employee T.J. Bray and USW union leadership member told Yahoo Finance. “If Trump doesn’t get re-elected, will [the jobs] leave then?”
The fact that Indiana taxpayers had to cough up millions to keep the jobs in-state—as well as the reality that automation will continue to make some human skills obsolete —paints Trump’s solution as a Band-aid. It is not a reasonable long-term strategy to retain manufacturing jobs. And as Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders pointed out , Carrier’s sweet deal shows other companies how to out-negotiate Trump.
But lost in this confusing situation is the solution. It’s been there, provided by Carrier and its parent company United Technologies since the beginning: education and training.
Carrier understands the real solution is to retrain employees for modern jobs
Buried in Carrier’s letter to its employees, there’s a promise to provide “four full years of the Employee Scholar Program post-employment, which pays for education to develop new skills in a field of their choice.”
For employees, this is huge. “Ninety some-odd percent of the folks that work at Carrier are assembly line workers,” says United Steelworkers Local 1999’s President Chuck Jones. “They’re gonna have to be retrained if possible to other skill sets.”
This program from United Technologies isn’t new, and it’s not just for laid-off workers. Employees who currently work there can receive free education, too.
“All [United Technologies] companies have had this for along time, but they’ve been pushing it even more since the announcement,” Bray says. “A lot more employees have been taking advantage of it. It seems like it’s probably gone up to 15% who have taken advantage.”
According to United Technologies, the Employee Scholar Program currently has around 7,000 people enrolled, and pays for tuition, academic fees, and books at approved institutions. Since 1996, 38,000 degrees have been awarded to employees globally through this program.
“I’ve known folks that have gone out and left and got better jobs,” Bray says. “This person did a scholar program and now they’re an engineer here at Pratt and Whitney.”
For American manufacturing workers, losing jobs to automation and to those earning cheaper wages abroad is inevitable: Manufacturing just requires fewer people than it used to, and education and retraining seems like the only way out. In September, Jones told the Wall Street Journal that companies like Boeing ( BA ) are hungry for skilled tradespeople, but only a handful of affected Carrier employees had the required training and skills for those jobs.
In Bray’s view, Carrier’s giving its employees and former employees a path to find jobs that require other skills is going above and beyond what most companies would do. “Many jobs just up and leave, and you don’t hear much from the company about programs like what UTC [Carrier] offers,” he says. “It sucks they’re doing this, but they’re really encouraging and giving opportunities they can to get these programs out the workers.”
https://www.yahoo.com/finance/news/the-real-solution-to-the-carrier-jobs-fiasco-was-under-trumps-nose-the-whole-time-132227508.html

In Bray’s view, Carrier’s giving its employees and former employees a path to find jobs that require other skills is going above and beyond what most companies would do
This would be a great formula to apply to every company that decides to relocate out of America.
The idea that people who lose their jobs to automation can be retrained for jobs that won't then at some point also be lost to automation is a pipedream.
The unfortunate thing is that not everyone is cut out for college, particularly when they've been out of school for a lengthy time. If you're talking about an engineering program, I highly doubt a person working on the line for ten years will be able to get in to that area, much less keep the GPA required for tuition reimbursement.
Well I think this is much better than just handing over $7million of tax payer money that could have gone to infrastructure or education or other tax breaks for hard working Americans. This may not be a fix it for all but it's a start and they can explore other ways of re-training workers to be able to succeed in today's world unlike lying to them and saying they are going to bring back coal jobs.
I agree - free college is an awesome benefit and should be taken advantage of anywhere it is offered. Practically speaking, however, if you're going to engage then you need to have realistic expectations of what you are capable of after being out of school for years and spending your days pushing part A into part B. Engineering is a very hard program, where many kids go from AP high school classes to dropping out of a college engineering program because it is too hard.
Surely, there are 'trade' jobs they could apply for with some training... Things like plumbers, electricians, carpentry, auto mechanics. Where would we be without all those people? Training in those fields would increase their chances of finding another job elsewhere-- and many of those pay very well!
I agree, but whether trade schools are included in a tuition reimbursement program is questionable. Carrier is not interested in training plumbers. They want that money to benefit themselves to some degree. Typically these programs require the participant to continue working for the provider for X number of years, or else the pafticipant will be required to pay back the tuition. In MD, I believe the public school system works this way. They pay for your masters, you agree to not leave the school system for five years.
Carrier could train people to be electricians, auto mechanics, etc., and still reap some benefits themselves. My former company would have paid for me to get my MBA, but I didn't want one, frankly. I would have gladly taken some classes on geology, but they weren't available for reimbursement, so I see your point.
Still, if they were really interested in re-training their work force to find other jobs, they shouldn't be fussy about what their workers want to be trained in...
Well I think this is much better than just handing over $7million of tax payer money that could have gone to infrastructure or education or other tax breaks for hard working Americans.
Boy you really must REALLY be upset about over HALF A BILLION ((over 535 MILLION) that BO pissed away on Solyndra Huh?
Were you upset about his too?
ARGH....GRRRRR.........( that's me growling ) I'm mad. I'm really really mad!
pssst.... I guess when you don't have a legitimate reason or answer the best approach is to implement the "but look what they did" strategy.
OMG- I just had a great idea!!!!! They could be trained to do the agricultural jobs and the housekeepers and janitorial jobs that we will have a shortage on once Donald deports all the immigrants. Problem solved. Of course they won't get paid minimum wage but at least they'll be working and they need to be grateful.