╌>

Final Tally Of Carrier Jobs Trump Saved And Lost - 800 Saved, 1253 Lost

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  10 years ago  •  30 comments

Final Tally Of Carrier Jobs Trump Saved And Lost - 800 Saved, 1253 Lost

Turns out Trump saved 38.9 % of the jobs slated to move to Mexico. 


 

 

http://www.wthr.com/article/usw-730-union-jobs-saved-in-carrier-deal-not-1100

INDIANAPOLIS (WTHR) - The Carrier deal, brokered by President-elect Donald Trump, may not have saved as many factory jobs as was presented at the plant last week in Indianapolis.

Carrier workers received a flyer from the United Steelworkers, Local Union 1999. It details which jobs are staying here in Indy and which are going to Mexico. The numbers are a bit different from last week's big announcement.

Last Thursday, amid much fanfare, President-elect Trump spent time on the factory floor and talked with union workers at the westside Indianapolis Carrier plant.

"We're keeping a little over 1,100 jobs it turns out," he told them.

He also made a big announcement about a big deal reached with United Technologies, Carrier's parent company, to save 1,100 American jobs that were going to be moved to Mexico.

Carrier worker T.J. Bray, who's also a communications rep for the union, told reporters across the country he was thrilled. His phone rang again while we talked with him Monday afternoon.

"I've been getting non-stop phone calls. Non-stop media. It's been a wild, wild week," Bray said.

But Bray and other union workers just learned some new numbers about the actual number of production jobs saved by the Trump-Pence deal.

"We didn't know the breakdown before because no one would give us any information," Union President Chuck Jones told Eyewitness News by phone Monday. "Now what we're losing is 550 member jobs."

"We found out today that more jobs are leaving than what we originally thought," Bray said. "It seemed like since Thursday, it was 1,100 then it was maybe 900 and then now we're at 700. So I'm hoping it doesn't go any lower than that."

Union workers got a letter at the plant saying Trump's deal with Carrier will save only 730 factory jobs in Indianapolis, plus 70 salaried positions - 553 jobs in the plant's fan coil lines are still moving to Monterrey, Mexico.

All 700 workers at Carrier's Huntington plant will also  lose their jobs .

"We are happy that Carrier Corp. has decided to retain a portion of the manufacturing jobs that it planned to move from Indianapolis to Mexico beginning in 2017," United Steelworkers, Local Union 1999 said in a letter to members. Union leaders thanked both President-elect Donald Trump and Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., for bringing so much attention to their efforts during and after the 2016 campaign.

So how did the president-elect get to that 1,100 number last week?

"It's the R&D jobs that were already slated to stay," Bray explained.

Trump was including 350 research and development jobs that were never going to move to Mexico in the first place. Those were jobs that Carrier said all along would stay in Indianapolis.

"It appears they may have hyped that number (1,100) a little bit and then once the company and everything settled down we started seeing the real numbers and started getting a little discouraged about how many jobs," Bray said.

As a 14-year employee, Bray knows his job is safe. Seniority will decide who's in and who's out.

Workers in danger of losing their jobs to Mexico were hired after February 2005. The union hopes retirements at the plant may help lessen the hit and reduce the number of layoffs.

"We had the seniority list going around today," Bray said. "Everybody wants to know, you know, where they're at - do they meet that cut or not."

Bray says he's still thrilled that many jobs are staying in Indy. But he says last week, it seemed like a lot more co-workers and friends would be safe.

"That's the hardest part about it is we're happy the jobs are saved, but at the same time, we're discouraged and upset we can't save all of them," Bray said.

Eyewitness News reached out to Vice President-elect Gov. Mike Pence's team asking specifically for clarification about the number of factory jobs saved in this deal.

In response, Pence spokesperson Matthew Lloyd said, "More than 1,000 jobs for hard working Hoosiers were going to leave Indiana for Mexico. Those jobs are now staying right here in Indiana thanks to the efforts of President-elect Trump and Vice President-elect Pence."

USW Local 1999 had a brief meeting with Carrier on Thursday to discuss severance packages for those who will still be affected by Carrier's outsourcing. Those discussions will continue over the next few weeks.

The union was not involved in any discussions with President-elect Trump.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    10 years ago

Trumpworld     38.9% = winning

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    10 years ago

All this for the bargain price of 7 million dollars!  What a negotiator.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    10 years ago

Um, when President Obama went to Indiana to help, how many jobs did he save?  Oh wait, did he go to Indiana?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

Trump apparently did a good thing and convinced Carrier to keep 39% of the jobs in Indiana. I will give him due credit for that. 

That should not include him going all over creation bragging about how he kept Carrier in the U.S. When you save less than 40% of the jobs you had a LIMITED success. He should be low key about such a modest achievement, but Trump exists to blowhard about himself, no matter how limited the success. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    10 years ago

Should have just lost the 2,000 jobs then. 

Apparently, Since he couldn't save every job it's bad to save some.

what a stupid argument.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    10 years ago

Indiana and the Federal Government will receive at least $7 million dollars in taxes during the next year from those 730 employees.

At $22.00 an hour minimum for union workers everyone of them are in the 25% tax bracket before deductions.  If you cut that in half and make it 12.5% the Fed will received nearly $5 million dollars and the state will receive over $1.5 million dollars the first year.

Sure 730 jobs saved is just a drop in the bucket, but not so much for those who are not losing their job.  We all know Trump is a braggart and nothing is going to change about that, so we may as well get use to it.

If you ask any good businessman does he ever have to buy business and he'll tell you sure.  He doesn't normally buy business when the balance sheet is against him unless he sees a very good possibility of future returns.

Carrier is investing over $16 million in this and that will be jobs for others who are not employed by Carrier as well.

The benefits out way the cost and that is the objective of a good businessman.

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary  replied to  sixpick   10 years ago

Vision is not really their strongpoint, Six.  And politicians bragging and over inflating what they've accomplished?  Yeah no one has ever done that before.  But different standards for different people.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Spikegary   10 years ago

And that's just the beginning Gary.  Over the next 9 years if nothing changes the combined taxes the Federal Government and the State will receive from these 730 people will be approximately $63 million dollars and that is if nothing changes.

I think they said Carrier was getting $7 million over 10 years.  Well that's a $63 million net profit.  

I agree with Kavika that the biggest threat to losing jobs in this country isn't having them leave the country, but being replaced by automation and technology.  If the companies can produce more profit by leaving, then there's nothing or no one who is going to keep them here and if they can see it is cheaper for them to use newly developed technology then they'll stay, but the people will still lose jobs.

This country needs to do all we can to develop technology and automation we can sell to other countries.  There's nothing wrong with trying to keep jobs in this country either.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    10 years ago

Final Tally

Really?

Last time I looked, the business was expanding. There's no final tally. There will be more hiring as the result of the plant being held open.

Nothing "final" here.

Move on.

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    10 years ago

#MAGA!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    10 years ago

Well, I guess he can lie with the best of them.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    10 years ago

I think what we're hearing in the news is not the whole story. 

In terms of the big picture in the U.S., the number of jobs saved is meaningless. And likewise, $7 million is an insignificant amount of money. IMO, carrier didn't do it for the money...(in fact it probably Carrier who made the decision-- it came down from UTX, their parent co.

For starters, Carrier is merely one division a division of a much, much larger company-- UTX ("United Technologies"0-- a really yuge company:

United Technologies Corporation provides technology products and services to building systems and aerospace industries worldwide. Its Otis segment designs, manufactures, sells, and installs passenger and freight elevators, escalators, and moving walkways; modernization products to upgrade elevators and escalators; and maintenance and repair services. The companys UTC Climate, Controls & Security segment provides heating, ventilating, air conditioning, and refrigeration solutions, such as controls for residential, commercial, industrial, and transportation applications. This segment offers electronic security products, including intruder alarms, access control systems, and video surveillance systems; and fire safety products; systems integration, video surveillance, installation, maintenance, and inspection services; and monitoring and response services. Its Pratt & Whitney segment supplies aircraft engines for commercial, military, business jet, and general aviation markets; and provides aftermarket maintenance, repair, and overhaul, as well as fleet management services. The companys UTC Aerospace Systems segment provides electric power generation, power management, and distribution systems; air data, and flight sensing and management systems; engine control, electric, intelligence, surveillance, and reconnaissance systems; engine components; environmental control systems; fire and ice detection, and protection systems; propeller systems; cargo, actuation, and landing systems; aircraft aero structures, and lighting and seating products; space products and subsystems; and aftermarket services. United Technologies Corporation offers its services through manufacturers representatives, distributors, wholesalers, dealers, retail outlets, and sales representatives, as well as directly to customers. The company was founded in 1934 and is headquartered in Farmington, Connecticut.

A lot of very diverse products. Much of it military & aerospace. So UTX gets a lot of their business from the U.S. government. It was obvious that Trump did this as a P.R. move-- propaganda intended to show he jumped right in when it came to "saving American jobs". It was important for him-- and UTX knew it. The size of this recent deal (both in terms of the tiny # of employees involved as well as the tiny sum of a mere $& million)with Carrier is so tiny for UTX that its meaningless for them. However, IMO the reason they did it was to stay on Trump's good side-- because if they pissed off Trump they would loose really big  bucks in government contracts in the future...potential future contracts for UTX worth a small fortune!!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

P.S: We've been losing jobs for years-- its nothing new. 

But the real problem is not jobs being lost to other countries. The real problem can't be solved by either Democratic policies nor Republican policies. the real problem is "technological unemployment".

It not a question of a robot replacing a worker. Its more like one robot replacing many workers!

 
 

Who is online




bccrane
JohnRussell


131 visitors