╌>

Northern Ireland’s new prostitution laws will not make the sex trade safer (Opinion from "Left Foot Forward")

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  the-irascible-harry-krishner  •  11 years ago  •  4 comments

Northern Ireland’s new prostitution laws will not make the sex trade safer (Opinion from "Left Foot Forward")

At midnight on 13 Jan,a Bill criminalising the purchase of sex became law in Northern Ireland. It follows the Swedish system, which prosecutes the buyer and not the seller of sex.

Since Sweden introduced the law in 1999, a number of countries have considered following suit.

In October, the Northern Ireland Assembly voted by 81 to 10 to make it a crime to pay for sex.This was despite research commissioned by the Department of Justice in October which showed that only two per centof sex workers surveyed supported the change in law.

The study showed that61 per cent of sex workers in Northern Ireland thought the law would make them less safe and 85 per cent did not believe that it would reduce sex trafficking.

And crucially, only 16 per cent ofpeople who responded to the client survey said that the law would make them stop paying for sex altogether.

---> LINK


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    11 years ago

As well as the fact that many of thepeople who know the industry best feel threatened by the new law, there are a number of conceptual problems with it.

It pushes the ideathat men are criminally culpable for their actions but women are not, implying that women have lesser moral agency.

TheIrish charity Ruhama who have welcomed the change pointsout that prostitution is very rarely a free choice, and that most sex workers are forced into their lifestyle by a combination of factors. I acknowledge thatthis could, in theory, be said to limit the amount of agency sex workershave over their bodies.

But to concede this has a dehumanising effect, stripping women of responsibility for what they do in undesirablecircumstances where they are, nevertheless,giving consent. We do not automatically define sex that is paid for as rape. That is the key distinction here.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    11 years ago

The issue of female autonomy is not solely an abstract one. In 2013, a Swedish sex worker known as Petite Jasmine was murdered by an ex partner after a long standing dispute over child custody.

Jasmine had been denied custody on the grounds that, as a sex worker, she was a victim unable to make her own decisions, who needed to be saved from herself. She was viewed as being so weak and, implicitly, stupid, that her partner was deemed to be a better parent, despite his history of being abusive.

Activists insist that the Swedish framework contributed to her murder.

 
 
 
Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom
Professor Participates
link   Sister Mary Agnes Ample Bottom    11 years ago

Heads-up on the double article post.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Krishna    11 years ago

Thanks.

I've had this problem before (double post). I'm not sure why it happens.

 
 

Who is online

MrFrost
Igknorantzruls


94 visitors