I'm Offended
You cant teach at an American college these days without wondering ifand at some schools, lets face it, you wonder whenits going to happen. A student, fellow faculty member, or administrator is going to charge you with offending him.
For 30 years in my introductory American government course I have assigned the Lincoln-Douglas debates. Most students, I think, regard them as a highlight of the class. But its easy to imagine the possible objections. Both speakers discuss Negroes, not a polite term anymore though it was then, and Stephen Douglas enjoys playing to the audiences passions by occasionally unloading the other, vile n-word. He doesnt use it as often as (say) Huckleberry Finn does, but then Douglas isnt a barefoot boy but a distinguished politician. And of course the debates are all about the moral status of slavery, and just how much equality and liberty the Negroes deserve.
Plenty to be offended by. Yet the drama, gravity, and high quality of the arguments on both sides tend to command respect, or at least to invite a reasoned consideration of the debaters claims. The fact that Lincoln lost that election to the U.S. Senate from Illinois brings students up shortan unexpected lesson that political success cannot be the measure of justice, nor history a convenient guide to which is the right and which the wrong side to be on.
Unhappily, todays campus isnt steeped in the spirit of the Lincoln-Douglas debates, or of any debate for that matter. Thats where the new ethos of taking offense comes in. The accusation is, and is meant to be, a conversation stopper. Im offended is not an invitation to a debate but a demand for a confession, retraction, and apology. One could respond, Well, Im offended that youre offended, but that leads nowhere except maybe to a brawl. The charge operates like Ring Lardners great lineShut up, he explainedexcept that absolutely no humor is involved. This new readiness to take offense leads first to trying to halt the offending conduct or speech, and next to trying to outlaw it.
How different is the spirit of I disagree. A disagreement invites an exchange of reasons, hence the possibility, at least, of persuasion. Voltaire never said, I disagree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it, but it sounds like him, and it captures the broadmindedness and generosity of the older liberalism and of the American university in better days, when it was possible to distinguish between rights and the good or bad use of them.
John Stuart Mills On Liberty is far from a perfect book, but liberal-arts students used to read it a lot. I bet it was assigned in three or four of my courses when I was an undergraduate. Figuring out its strengths and weaknesses was part of the fun. When I ask students today, however, almost none has read it. The culture of free discussion and debate is declining, and with it liberty, on and off the campus.
Whats behind the decline? There are many factors, but among the most influential is that dead-end of modern philosophy called postmodernism, which has had two baneful effects. By teaching that reason is impotentthat it cant arrive at any objective knowledge of truth, beauty, and justice because there is nothing out there to be knownpostmodernism turns the university into an arena for will to power. All values are relative, so there is no point in discussing whether the most powerful values are true, just, or good. The crucial thing is that they are the most powerful, and can be played as trumps: do not offend me, or you will be in trouble. If we say its racist, then its racist. Dont waste our time trying to ask, But what is racism?
Second, postmodernism devotes itself to what Richard Rorty called language games. For professors, especially, this is the most exquisite form of will to power, a royal road to social change, as Todd Gitlin (the rare lefty professor at Columbia who defends free speech) observes. So freshman girls became women, slaves turned into enslaved persons, marriage had to be opened to same-sex spouses, and so forth. Naming or renaming bespeaks power, and for decades we have seen this power rippling through American society. Now even sexual assault and rape are whatever the dogmatic leftists on and off campus say they are.
The latest threats to free speech involve campaigns to stop microaggressions and to issue trigger warnings before anything disturbing or potentially offensive is discussed. Perhaps students would find education less fearful if they were encouraged to trust and develop the freedom of their mind, rather than to presume reason is a slave of power.
http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2015/06/03/im_offended_126814.html

You're always offending someone.
I know, it's just your nature, and you can't help it, ......we know that. That's why we tolerate you around here. 8^)}
"Instead of focusing on the rightness or wrongness (or even acceptability) of the materials we reviewed in class, the complaint would center solely on how my teaching affected the students emotional state. As I cannot speak to the emotions of my students, I could not mount a defense about the acceptability of my instruction. And if I responded in any way other than apologizing and changing the materials we reviewed in class, professional consequences would likely follow....
Personally, liberal students scare the shit out of me. I would not get fired for pissing off a Republican, so long as I did so respectfully, and so long as it happened in the course of legitimate classroom instruction. The same cannot be said of liberal students. All it takes is one slipnot even an outright challenging of their beliefs, but even momentarily exposing them to any uncomfortable thought or imageryand thats it, your classroom is triggering, you are insensitive, kids are bringing mattresses to your office hours and theres a twitter petition out demanding you chop off your hand in repentance."
...
Absolutely correct - way, way to "correctness".
Being offended is a choice.
I disagree. I think somethings are offensive on their face. Child rape and/or murder is offensive on it's face. I can not be insulted though, because I allow no person to have that power over me.
I find that I'm offended when adults are raped and/or murdered as well.
No, we aren't - their parents are.
Thank you Dr. Skinner and his fellow psychologists. The "Me" generation, the offspring of the "Boomers", decided discipline was totally unnecessary and harmful, thus their children, the "I'm IT" generation, sadly, is going to be running the U. S.
I'm excited.
I'v noticed the same thing recently. Social norms are changing. In the past most people felt that inflicting actual physical injury was much worse that hurting someone's feelings. Now many people (particularly Millenials) feel that the two are equally wrong-- and in some cases saying something that might cause someone emotional upset is even considered to be actually worse that hurting them physically.
This has also come up in numerous "free speech" cases before the Supreme Court. (Must of what they have ruled asserts the idea that "you do not have the right to not be insulted").
Both true (well, I still disagree with the choice though)....and the Brusselsprouts too!
Is sugar + kids a good idea? Not so much. But offended?
I think the teacher used a poor choice of words. Unhappy would have fit better. Offended is tossed around a lot.
For the way I was raised some things were just offensive no matter what (Union busters, scabs, republicans, etc.
), but you could never be insulted, because if someone insults you, then they are not close enough to you to give a crap what they think anyway. Now if someone close to you says something bad about you, you are not insulted, you are hurt.
The actual measuring stick in SCOTUS is - if it can harm others, it is harmful - regardless of what the case is about.
LOL! The kind I was lucky enough to only have to go one year to! The Sisters still wore their habits back then too and we always kidded that they were really bald under that Vail!