Oil pipeline spill near Belfield, ND, estimated at 176,000 gallons
Oil pipeline spill near Belfield, ND, estimated at 176,000 gallons
BELFIELD, N.D. – Belle Fourche Pipeline Co. estimates that 130,200 gallons of oil spilled into a tributary of the Little Missouri River last week and another 46,200 gallons leaked into a hillside, the North Dakota Department of Health said Monday, Dec. 12.
The spill discovered by a landowner on Dec. 5 was not detected by monitoring equipment on the pipeline, which is owned by of True Companies of Wyoming.The spill has contaminated 5.4 miles of Ash Coulee Creek but does not appear to have reached the Little Missouri River, said Bill Suess, spill investigation program manager for the health department.
The spill estimate of 4,200 barrels, or 176,400 gallons, is a “rough estimate” provided by the company, Suess said. Cleanup crews had recovered 983 barrels, or 41,286 gallons, of oil as of Monday, the company said.
At least two cows have been confirmed dead in the area of the oil spill, but the cause of death has not been verified by a veterinarian, Suess said. Crews assisted the landowner in moving cattle away from the creek and have trucked in water, he said.
It’s unknown how long the pipeline, which was built in the 1980s, had been leaking before the landowner discovered it.
The pipeline had pressure gauges and meters to monitor for leaks, said Kevin Connors, pipelines program supervisor for the North Dakota Oil and Gas Division.
The company also does aerial inspections of the pipeline about twice a month, Connors said.
Why the monitoring equipment didn’t detect the leak is part of an ongoing investigation, said True Companies spokeswoman Wendy Owen. The pipeline does not have a constant flow, which may have masked the leak from being detected, she said.
The 6-inch pipeline, which transports an average of 1,000 barrels of oil per day though rugged Badlands terrain, is buried in a hill that is slumping, Suess said. Crews have been unable to investigate further because the hillside is unstable, he said.
“Whether the slumping contributed to the break or the break contributed to the slumping, we don’t know yet,” Suess said.
The pipeline was shut down after the spill was discovered and has been capped at the spill location.
The company is working with SWAT Consulting, a spill response company based in Alberta with experience working in cold weather remediation, Suess said. An additional 60 workers were expected to arrive Monday to assist.
“The weather continues to still be the issue because the safety and security of the responders is our No. 1 priority,” Owen said.
The spill affected privately owned land as well as U.S. Forest Service land, Owen said.
“It’s very, very remote,” Owen said. “The terrain, the topography itself does make access points difficult.”
In addition to the state health department, the North Dakota Industrial Commission, the Environmental Protection Agency and the federal Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration also are investigating.
Last year, the Laborers District Council of Minnesota and North Dakota opposed a pipeline proposed in North Dakota by True Companies, with union representatives citing the company’s track record of spills. The company also owns Bridger Pipeline, which had a pipeline spill in January 2015 that involved 30,000 gallons of oil in the Yellowstone River, contaminating the drinking supply for the city of Glendive, Mont.

The company doesn't know why the monitoring equipment didn't detect the leak...Only around 20% of leaks are detected by monitoring equipment, most are found by the land owner or company employees.
1 quart of this stuff contaminates 50,000 of water to above acceptable contaminant levels... 176,000 gallons is a LOT.
Here is a link to the companies safety record, Dowser.
This is just for ONE company. There are probably hundreds of pipeline companies in the US-- and they all do it! And no one fines them, or makes them increase their safety methods...
The fines that they get are minimal compared to the damage they cause, Dower.
When this was first reported the company said around 10,000 gallons was spilled. Well it's now 176,000 and we haven't reached the final count. We'll probably never get the real number of gallons that spilled.
They also stated it only reached 1.5 miles down stearm. The latest information is 6 miles down stream.
No wildlife was harmed was another of their claims...Some dead cattle was found along the creek bed. Vet's are now checking to see the cause of dead of the cattle. All other cattle have been moved from the area...
I doubt very much if this spill didn't kill fish as well.
A perspective of just how much oil we are talking about.
My outrage over oil spills only grows...
Not only fish, but all the mollusks, the little snails, there is nothing left alive in its wake... It all dies. Any deer that drink the water, the elk, the moose, etc.
I wonder what they're doing to clean it up?
Some of the clean up lasts years, Dowser.
Check out the link below regarding the other real spill problem from fracking. in my response to Perrie.
As I understand... Will do!
This is not getting a lot of press coverage either. I'm surprised they can pop out an estimate after not knowing there was a leak. Hopefully the line is shut down now.
Yes, it's shut down now Spike.
Most of the time the estimates given are spin on the real number that comes out...and the media doesn't give it much coverage because of how safe pipelines are.../s
You are so right about that... For sure, we'll never know how bad it really is...
And they wonder why we don't trust big oil.
They oil spills aren't the only thing that is happening in ND. The brine water used to extract the shale oil is a huge problem. There have been a number of these spills, into the hundreds of thousands of gallons of brine.
It is so bad in Eastern KY, that drinking water wells can't be more than about 50-60' deep, way too shallow to safeguard the aquifer from surface water contamination. So, many of the people in Eastern KY rely on abandoned underground coal mines as small catchment basins for their drinking water. Strangely enough, if you are careful, and stick with the Elkhorn #3 coal seam, the water is good... Surface water contamination is made worse by the strip mining activities that allow all those buried minerals, (like pyrite), to be at the surface where it can weather away... NONE of the creeks and streams in Eastern KY are viable...
It's a right mess. I've screamed about this for years, but to no avail.
At the rate that we are destroying our water supply, there won't be any good water left to drink.
It is already a big issue when looking for drinking water supplies... A HUGE issue. There are so many things to look for. You basically have to do an overview of potential contaminants before you drill... Add the changes in formations, and location of fractures, etc. and it is very difficult to locate a viable site.
That is a really sad situation, Dowser.
At that rate soon water will be a commodity just like gas.
Just so you know, Nestles is already preparing for that day, when they can sell water to utilities to use... They are getting ready for the day when there are no viable water supplies left, but theirs...
That's an interesting turn of events...