Donald Trump will violate the US constitution on inauguration day
W hen Donald Trump swears at the inauguration that he will “faithfully execute the office of president of the United States, and will to the best of my ability, preserve, protect and defend the constitution of the United States”, he will be committing a violation of constitutional magnitude.
The US constitution flatly prohibits any “Person holding any Office of Profit or Trust under [the United States]” from accepting “any present, Emolument, Office, or Title, of any kind whatever, from any King, Prince, or foreign State”.
Known as the emoluments clause, this provision was designed on the theory that a federal officeholder who receives something of value from a foreign power can be tempted to compromise what the constitution insists be his exclusive loyalty: the best interest of the United States. The clause applies to the president and covers even ordinary, fair market value transactions with foreign states and their agents that result in any profit or benefit. That a hostile government has gotten its money’s worth from our president is obviously no defense to a charge that he has abused his office.
Trump’s continued interest in the Trump Organization and his steady stream of monetary and other benefits from foreign powers put him on a collision course with the emoluments clause. Disentangling every improper influence resulting from special treatment of Trump’s business holdings by foreign states would be impossible. The American people would be condemned to uncertainty, leaving our political discourse rife with accusations of corruption. These problems are exacerbated by the fact that Trump has regularly declined to make his business dealings or tax returns transparent.
Thus a specter of skewed incentives will haunt a Donald Trump presidency.
While much has changed since the constitution was written, certain premises of politics and human nature have held steady. Among them is that private financial interests can subtly sway even the most virtuous leaders. As Alexander Hamilton wrote in Federalist 22: “One of the weak sides of republics, among their numerous advantages, is that they afford too easy an inlet to foreign corruption.” The framers sought to avoid these ends by avoiding these beginnings, writing a broad ban on potentially corrupting foreign influence into article I of our nation’s charter.
By imposing clear limitations, the clause avoids situations in which the American people must search for hints of improperly motivated presidential favoritism toward selected foreign powers, or of foreign attempts to seduce the American president into compromising our national interest for his private profit.
With Trump, this search has already begun. His global business empire creates ideal conditions for ongoing violations of the emoluments clause. Mere weeks before Trump spoke by phone with the president of Taiwan – a dramatic departure from America’s “one China” policy – a businesswoman associated with his conglomerate reportedly arrived in Taiwan to inquire about major new investments in luxury hotels. Trump’s businesses owe hundreds of millions to Deutsche Bank , which is currently negotiating a multibillion-dollar settlement with the US Department of Justice – a settlement that will now be overseen by an attorney general selected by and serving at the pleasure of Trump.
In his last public press conference, Trump called on Russia to hack Hillary Clinton and release her personal emails. Recently, both the FBI and CIA determined that the highest levels of Russia’s government in fact ran a covert operation aimed at helping Trump’s campaign, making his victory in the electoral college more likely.
The bottom line is simple: Trump stands to benefit personally, in innumerable and largely hidden ways, from decisions made daily by foreign governments and their agents. History teaches that leaders with divided interests cannot be counted on to faithfully serve those who elected them.
The framers understood this lesson. The emoluments clause was forged of their hard-won wisdom. No relic of a bygone era, it is a profound expression of insight into the nature of the human condition and the preconditions of sovereign self-government.
Trump’s shifting proposals for addressing his multifarious conflicts of interests are simply inadequate. If he retains an ownership interest in his empire, his personal bottom line is necessarily affected by everything his business does, whether or not he is at the helm.
Nor is a supposedly “blind trust” involving control of Trump’s assets by his adult children remotely sufficient. It is inconceivable that he could avoid discussing with them at least some matters relating to his policies and their business ventures, or that he could avoid noticing and caring about their interactions with foreign nations.
So even full divestment of his personal ownership and control of the Trump Organization is no remedy for his emoluments clause violation: it is often to the prince and not the king that special favors are done.

I said I didn't want to do this - but - the embodiments clause is to prevent "gifts" for governmental favors or the granting of nobility without Congress's approval - what the Billary/Killary clan's foundation does. Trump's business activities, prior to becoming President on 1/20/17, are financial transactions designed to increase/decrease his corporation's holdings.
This is talking about the limitations the united states have on granting nobility. Before they are able to grant power they have to go through congress first.
To prevent the impression of being "bought", like the Billary/Killary foundation does openly, Trump will have to divest himself from his corporations.
No impeachment proceedings can proceed "IF" he divests as he says he is going to do.
Wait and see is my motto on this one.
To my knowledge he has never said he will divest. His "charity" means nothing compared to his assets. Hell, he doesn't even contribute his own money to his charity, and he uses the money others contribute to it for his own purposes, sometimes purely for vanity.
No, but he has stated that he will be placing his business interests in a trust prior to 1/20 - hence no impediment or an impression of impropriety.
It's not a blind trust. Not even close. You may go on and on about Obama, but he dissolved all of his holdings and placed them in a legit blind trust. Trump is not nearly as interested in being a US president as Obama was. Trump's priorities begin with his net worth and end with making America great.
This is as much of a reach as their "Hamilton Electors" scheme.
They are still desperate, and they actually hate him, actually more what he represents than their own personal honesty/integrity...
Who is "they"? The Americans he is supposed to serve? He has made every effort to hide his assets, from not releasing his tax returns to hiding everything he owns is multiple layers of LLCs. It's a given that he does what every other 0.1 percenter does - which is offshoring money to the Caymans or wherever will hold it away from the IRS. And he is refusing to separate himself from the money that he claims is so unimportant to him. If you can't add that up then you're dumber than I thought.
THEY, are those smart people like you. cause according to you, all the rest of us dumb people can't figure out up from down...
Have a nice day.....
Oh when talking about divestiture, remember when Bill was forced to divest himself from a half a million dollar donation cause it came from a Chinese businessman with ties to the Red Chinese government? in fact it was established that it came from the Red Chinese government and the businessman was simply a front?
(that was the reason the clintons started setting up foundations, so it would appear that the money wasn't going to them, how many did they eventually have? six or is it seven, I lost track of all the faux charities they set up to collect illegal payments and get around the emoluments clause you guys are so boringly whining about now)
And now you want Trump to divest himself from his legal and rightfully gained wealth?
Seems like all you smart people want to have Trump held to a much higher standard than your beloved political icons/cronies.
I mean, in your opinion, it is ok for a democrat to take advantage of his/her office, right? Just nobody else can? you only seem to get bent out of shape over improprieties or the appearance of conflict of interests when it is someone you dislike.
Par for the course from such an intelligent person as yourself.
. . . And he is refusing to separate himself from the money that he claims is so unimportant to him.
What requires him to separate himself from his money?
To prevent the impression of being "bought", like the Billary/Killary foundation does openly, Trump will have to divest himself from his corporations.
No impeachment proceedings can proceed "IF" he divests as he says he is going to do.
1st Warrior, please quote where Trump said he is going to divest from his corporations.
He has never said he was going to divest his interest in his company.
“I will be leaving my great business in total in order to fully focus on running the country in order to MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!” he tweeted . “ Legal documents are being crafted which take me completely out of business operations. The Presidency is a far more important task!” -
It's not a blind trust, no matter how vigorously he and Kellyanne spin it.
Spin it any way you want Hal - spin it any way you want.
sum part , subtotal , individual amount
complete
Unless Trump SELLS his holdings he will be in violation of the Constitution. Whether anyone will do anything about it is another question.
Your statement is incorrect. He does NOT HAVE TO sell his businesses.
Don't know who told you that he did, but they lied to you.
1st,
Stop wasting your time with these people. If you try to argue the merits of a case with them, they will simply dismiss all arguments that don't "get" Trump. They are focused on that and that alone and any argument that they are wrong will be ignored. Just use this one. It's much quicker and more to the point.
Get this guys and get it good. The President elect's party holds a majority in the Senate and a large majority in the House. In order to be impeached, far less convicted, about half of the Republican House and Senate members would have to vote against him, which would amount to political suicide. If something like that were possible, Obama would have been gone a long time ago. In order to be impeached, Trump would have to walk out on Pennsylvania Avenue and shoot someone. Stop the whining and get over it. To quote Barack Obama, "Elections have consequences". You lost this one, now suffer the consequences because you can't do a damn thing about it.
Or, as our friend and colleague Bruce, would say - STFU.
Something like that, eh?
Lol - was that supposed to be informative? Inspirational? Defensive? What the fuck was that little diatribe? This place is getting more idiotic by the minute.
What the fuck was that little diatribe?
The best they can do.
First, I'll point out the obvious partisan nature of the controversy. The emoluments clause applies to any federal public office holder and would have seemingly applied with equal force to Hillary, as Secretary of State, as it does to Trump. Democrats had no problem with Hillary's foundation accepting foreign gifts. I think both situations are complicated and venture no opinion at this time as to whether either or both of them have (or will) violate the constitution.
Second, the emoluments clause does not operate to automatically disqualify anybody from office. In fact, it doesn't actually provide a consequence at all. If the congress believes that Trump has violated the constitution and that it is a high crime or misdemeanor subject to impeachment, then the only course of action would be to impeach Trump and remove him from office. That would be fine by me except, as Ttga points out, it is highly unlikely that a republican congress will impeach a republican president. Just as democrats did absolutely nothing about Hillary's foundation.
Third, the president has the power to pardon anyone from being prosecuted for a federal crime. If someone thought Trump had committed a federal crime by violating the emoluments clause, he could pardon himself. That takes us back to impeachment as the only remedy. I suppose someone could ask the Supreme Court for an advisory opinion on an interpretation of the clause but the court doesn't have to give it and, even if they did, it wouldn't be binding on Trump or congress (as co-equal branches of government).
Fourth, the emoluments clause expressly permits congress to allow the president to accept an emolument. So, if a republican congress wants to put this issue to bed, they can simply consent to all or some of Trump's business dealings.
It's just another partisan attack. The clause in question was never meant to prohibit trade with foreigners.
The Clinton Foundation is a charity, with a wealth of good works to back it up. Trump does not do good works for any humanitarian cause, especially with his own money. On the contrary, his ten year old son has a gold plated penthouse in Manhatten, while Trump uses other people's contributions to his "charity" to pay off lawsuits against he and his businesses. Comparing the Clinton Foundation to Trump's extravagant holdings is ridiculous.
The Clinton Foundation is a charity, with a wealth of good works to back it up. Trump does not do good works for any humanitarian cause, especially with his own money . . .
What bearing does this have on whether a contribution to the Clinton foundation is an emolument within the meaning of the constitution?
For charity, for profit - not the same thing.
For charity, for profit - not the same thing.
The issue is whether the contribution is an emolument not whether the entity turns a profit. The constitution says that no person holding public office shall accept "any present" or emolument "of any kind". If the Clintons have a charity and the Saudis donate $10 million dollars to it, is that a violation of the emoluments clause? Does it make a difference whether 100% of it goes to feed hungry children? What if 90% of it goes to pay the salaries of her husband, daughter, or campaign hacks? What if Hillary suddenly flips positions and decides (as Secretary of State or president) to back the Saudis on getting rid of one of their enemies?
As much as I am not a fan of a Secretary of State maintaining a charity where substantial contributions flow in from foreign dignitaries, it is still a charity with an actual history of good works. There is no comparison between that and a multinational business empire who sole purpose is profit. If there is any gray area in this at all, then put yourself in the shoes of the framers of the Constitution to envision whether their intention was to deny charity to the needy, or to deny the uber-wealthy an opportunity to further enrich themselves at the expense of the citizenry, homeland security, and international relations. Unless you can prove that the Clinton Foundation violated any of the latter, then your comparison is nothing but a distraction.
As much as I am not a fan of a Secretary of State maintaining a charity where substantial contributions flow in from foreign dignitaries, it is still a charity with an actual history of good works. There is no comparison between that and a multinational business empire who sole purpose is profit.
There is a comparison to the extent that it involves gifts of "whatever kind." The good works of the charity are irrelevant if a contribution is a gift and Hillary received it.
If there is any gray area in this at all, then put yourself in the shoes of the framers of the Constitution to envision whether their intention was to deny charity to the needy, or to deny the uber-wealthy an opportunity to further enrich themselves at the expense of the citizenry, homeland security, and international relations.
The area is entirely gray because the provision has never been interpreted by the Supreme Court and we have no real guidance. I'll point out that Hillary is uber-wealthy herself and some say she got that way at the expense of the citizenry, in part, through a charity where only a small percentage of contributions went to the needy. And while you can say "put yourself in the shoes of the framers", you have to interpret the text as written, not rewrite it under the guise of interpretation. Plus, if I were to simply put myself in the shoes of the framers, they may not have had any intent of applying this provision to ordinary business transactions (as Cherenkov said). Again, I'm not venturing an opinion at this time as to whether either Hillary or Trump has or will violate the provision because the issue is not clear cut.
Unless you can prove that the Clinton Foundation violated any of the latter, then your comparison is nothing but a distraction.
The whole point of the discussion and this site is to express different points of view. I don't need to prove an opinion any more than you do and you can't "prove" that Trump will violate the emoluments clause. The comparison stands for the purpose of intelligent discussion.
Dear President-elect Trump:
We urge you to announce on December 15 that you’ll divest yourself of all interests in the Trump Organization in order to avoid a) daily violations of the Constitution barring foreign “emoluments” and b) the risk of later impeachment. A For-Profit-Presidency would be blatantly unethical, unprecedented and unconstitutional.
Neither the president nor public should tolerate the built-in-bribery of foreign governments quietly lining the pockets of a person they are seeking to influence on policy. That’s why we have an Emoluments Clause in Article One, Section 9 of the U. S. Constitution. It says that “no person holding any office...shall, without the consent of the Congress, accept any present, emolument [profit, gain], office, or title, of any kind whatever, from any king, prince or foreign state.”
This prohibition became a part of the Articles of Confederation for its entire eight year existence, then was included intact by the Constitutional Convention in 1787. Alexander Hamilton in Federalist 22 worried that Republics “have too easy an inlet to foreign corruption.”
“In 1902, an attorney general’s opinion said it is ‘directed against every kind of influence by foreign governments upon officers of the United States.’ In 1970, a comptroller general opinion declared that the clause’s ‘drafters intended the prohibition to have the broadest possible scope and applicability.’ A 1994 Justice Department opinion said ‘the language of Emoluments Clause is both sweeping and unqualified.’”
You appear to have ambivalent views of this provision and problem. On the one hand, you repeatedly attacked Democratic Nominee Hillary Clinton for what you regarded as clashing interests between her public role as Secretary of State and her husband’s Clinton Foundation. Last month you said that “I will be leaving my great business in total in order to fully focus on running the country...[because] it is visually important, as President, to in no way have a conflict of interest with my various businesses”; you later tweeted that “legal documents are being crafted which take me completely out of business operations” [emphases added].
On the other hand, there have been numerous reports how you have put yourself in just such conflicting situations. Presumably, old habits die hard and you’ve spent your entire adult life in the pursuit of profit and the “art of the deal.” But what’s customary in business can be corrupt once in public office.
For example:
-Of the first 29 foreign leaders you spoke with, you had properties in eight of their countries.
-In a post-election call with Nigel Farage, then the leader of the British UK Independent Party, you two apparently discussed your opposition to windmills near a golf course that you own in Scotland...Your company reportedly researched a string of hotels in Taoyan, Taiwan before you had a controversial phone call with Taiwan president Tsai Ing-wen...In your first meeting with a foreign leader, Prime Minister Shinzo Abe of Japan, your daughter attended even though she has no formal portfolio or experience in international diplomacy and was then negotiating a licensing deal with a giant Japanese retailer backed by the government-owned development bank....
-You praised Turkey President Erdogan’s crackdown this year following a failed coup attempt at the same time that you were managing the massive Trump Towers in Istanbul...Your partner in a 57 story building in Manila recently visited you, as an official Philippine envoy, before you spoke with and lauded President Duterte, who has killed several thousand people who he suspected of selling drugs (see generally, Paddock, et. al., “Potential Conflicts Around the World for Trump, the Businessman President”, New York Times, Nov. 26, 2016).
“Oligarchs” are rich dictators and the super-wealthy in countries such as Russia who exploit public office for private gain at the expense of their citizenry. This is neither an American nor a Constitutional value in our democracy, as our founding document makes clear. Yet you and some supporters appear disdainful or dismissive of the principles behind conflicts laws and the Emoluments Clause:
-You have tweeted that “only the corrupt media makes this a big deal.” (Actually, a recent CNN/ORC poll found that 59 percent thought that turning over management to your children was insufficient to protect against conflicts.)
-Kellyanne Conway said on Meet the Press that divestment would be unfair to your adult children who are entitled to work. Obviously, however, when you chose to seek the Presidency, you understood that you might put your family firm in precisely this predicament. You created this situation and now only you can cure it.
-Homer Jenkins Jr., writing in the Wall Street Journal and repeating your view, argued that this issue “was simply part of the bargain when voters elected Mr. Trump, in full view of his business interests.” Really in “full view”? As everyone knows, you refused to disclose either your tax returns or portfolio of loans and partnerships that could have shed light on possible entanglements with your world-wide holdings.
Nor can it be persuasively contended that the minority of voters who chose you as President-Elect should now simply trust your voluntary adherence to your own rules. It’s a basic premise of the Rule of Law that “no man can judge his own case.” In any event, even voters cannot overrule the Constitution except through a process of amendment specified in that document.
-Putting your assets in your suggested “blind trust” to be run by your adult children ignores the reality that a) you talk to your children and b) you’d know about the possible impact on your family holdings whenever you made presidential decisions, especially since your name of course is emblazoned on so many of your physical assets. (When you groused that some critics prefer that you “never ever see my daughter Ivanka again,” we assume that you didn’t intend this reductio ad absurdum to be taken literally.)
-Political commentators understandably discount any mention of impeachment pre-Inauguration because, among other reasons, there will be a GOP majority on the House Judiciary Committee and Chamber for at least two years. While we may anticipate that Congress will now be your “shut-eyed sentry”, in Kipling’s phrase, we are here discussing morality and constitutionality, not political probabilities. Indeed, within two years of an actual presidential landslide, Richard Nixon was impeached in 1974 after Republican senator Barry Goldwater supported his removal from office.
-Supporters such as Rudy Giuliani contend that your holdings are so large that divestment is just unrealistic. But size does not erase principle. Self-enrichment is wrong whether an office holder is of modest or great wealth — indeed, if anything, the greater the amount, the worse the problem. We should not apply the much criticized banking ethic of “too big to fail” in this circumstance.
-Other supporters like House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy dismiss the problem as merely hypothetical, adding that should problems arise, they can be dealt with later. But of course “later” such political enthusiasts may argue that it’s really too late once you’re president...which is precisely why all your modern predecessors resolved this problem early before bad practices were set in concrete.
But the reality of #DivestOrImpeach cannot be discounted or dismissed. There’s nothing strange about warning someone about to hit the gas that if they drive 80 mph into a crowded intersection, there is likely to be deadly results. Actions have consequences.
Indeed, calls for divestment are bipartisan. Former Reagan speechwriter Peggy Noonan wrote a Wall Street Journal column titled “No More Business as Usual, Mr. Trump” (Nov. 26). It concluded that “...he can’t, however offhandedly, both do business and be president. Future and credible reports that he had engaged in such a conflict of interest would doom his presidency.” President George W. Bush’s ethics counsel, Richard W. Painter, recently argued that “no president should allow his name to be put on commercial properties in return for payment. The presidency is not a branding opportunity.”
In effect, this letter takes the form of a citizen demand to avoid a situation that would be untenable for you and the country. It cannot be in either your legal or political interest to be regularly probed by investigative journalists and prosecutors or accused of self-enrichment whenever a White House decision, intentionally or not, affects your family’s fortune. And it certainly is not in the national interest for Americans to regularly wonder if their president is engaged in public service or self-service.
Nor can mere disclosure rule suffice, not when a foreign power knows it can favor your family’s bottom line somewhat effortlessly — such as sending their delegations abroad to Trump Hotels — hoping that you’ll get the message. You would become, in Harvard law professor Lawrence Tribe’s phrase, “an emoluments magnet.” This bias toward bribery was explained in a petition from 13 public interest groups and experts sent to you on November 17th: “Every time any foreign government or company controlled by a foreign government does business with a Trump entity, you could be accused of accepting a payment in violation of the emoluments clause of the Constitution.”
All of us are accountable to others, including presidents. In such situations, it is not enough to say or imply, as you have done and Richard Nixon explicitly did, that “if the President does it, that means it’s not illegal.”
True, your conflict cannot be solved by the easy sale of stock on a public open market. But compliance with the Constitution and our country’s laws do not depend on degree-of-difficulty. The only convincing cure to a situation that you knowingly entered is to have an independent trustee sell off all your holdings — your corporations, partnerships, any remaining stocks and bonds (but of course not homestead properties such as residences, yachts, planes...) — and place the proceeds in a true blind trust or treasury note that presents no ongoing conflicts since you will be unaware of the investment.
Already, White House ethics counsel insist that no company put the name “Barack Obama” on products for fear that gullible people would think that he was in fact associated with the enterprise. That should be doubly true when your name indeed has been associated with the properties involved
You ran for president with the Constitution we have, not the Constitution you may want. Given the importance of this public matter, may we respectfully request that you respond not with a diversionary or denunciatory tweet or a hair-splitting memorandum that distinguishes between operations and ownership. Each alone only continues the problem of self-dealing. The cliche that ‘you can’t be half pregnant’ comes to mind.
The only appropriate response is to completely divest on December 15 and therefore avoid potentially becoming a walking Article of Impeachment beginning on January 20. So: will it be America First or Trump First? The choice is yours, at least for now.
Sincerely yours,
Ralph Nader
Mark Green
Then I guess Hillary should be prosecuted for her proven pay to play schemes as SOS and the various Clinton foundations need to be investigated to where these "Donations" have actually gone....
Maybe the Clinton's need to divest themselves of the hundreds of millions they profited from their time in office.
Correct?
I mean if what Nader is saying is correct.....
While I appreciate the opinions of Ralph Nader and Mark Green, neither of them are part of a voting majority on the US Supreme Court. As such, their views are just opinions and one legal opinion on the subject is as good as another. But what in that long cut and paste illuminates an objective standard for interpreting the emoluments clause so that we can tell whether and to what extent it applied to Hillary?