╌>

The Green Line is not a border --- by Bob Nelson

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  10 years ago  •  1 comments

The Green Line is not a border   ---   by Bob Nelson

We had a pretty good conversation a couple days ago about the Middle East. As with many ME discussions, we spent a lot of energy just trying to get our facts straight.

And then, yesterday, my RSS feed from CAMERA (a pro-Israel media watchdog) brought me this:

 
After Contact from CAMERA,  The Washington Post  Corrects on 'Green Line'

After contact from CAMERA,  The Washington Post  has changed inaccurate language in the online  version  of its Dec. 5, 2016 article “Jared Kushner's family foundation donated to West Bank settlements.”

That  Post  report claimed, among other things, that “The Kushner foundation gifts were mostly made to schools, including religious yeshivas,  located outside the Green Line that is internationally recognized as the border of Israel proper  [emphasis added].”

Yet, as CAMERA highlighted in correspondence to  Post  editors and staff on December 7, the Green Line is an armistice demarcation line; not an “internationally recognized border of Israel proper.”

CAMERA pointed out that the West Bank and Gaza frontiers were demarcated by the 1949 Israeli-Jordanian armistice line and the 1950 Israeli-Egyptian armistice line.U.N. Security Council Resolution 242 (adopted several months after the 1967 war), called for negotiations to reach Arab-Israeli peace—to include “recognized and secure boundaries,” since they did not then exist. U.N. Security Council Resolution 338 (1973) repeated this call. However, no agreement on a border has been reached—although several U.S. and Israeli proposals have been offered, but were met with rejection by Palestinian leaders.

Professor Judge Stephen M. Schwebel, the former President of the International Court of Justice and a current member of the Permanent Court of Arbitration,  wrote  in his “Justice in International Law,” that the 1949 armistice demarcation lines are not permanent borders: “The armistice agreements of 1949 expressly preserved the territorial claims of all parties and did not purport to establish definitive boundaries between them.”

The distinction is, of course, important. Claiming that the Green Line is an “internationally recognized border,” is not only inaccurate, but it presents the status of those borders as already determined. In fact, pending final negotiations, they are not.

After several follow-up communications with  Washington Post  editors and staff, CAMERA  noted on December 30 that the paper had issued a formal correction.  The Post  changed the wording to read, “The Kushner foundation gifts were mostly made to schools, including religious yeshivas, located outside the Green Line that separates Israel and the West Bank.”

Additionally, the paper amended the article with a note at the bottom acknowledging that:

“An earlier version of this article incorrectly described the Green Line that separates Israel and the West Bank. Originally established in a 1949 armistice between Israel and its Arab neighbors, the line changed when Israel captured additional territory in 1967. The line is not a recognized border and remains a subject for negotiation.”

 

The distinction between "border" and "cease-fire line" is obviously essential during a time of ongoing negotiations. (Even if "ongoing" has been going on for a half-century...) A "treaty" would establish "borders", and they might be on either side of the Jewish settlements. In a large measure, the settlements are a poker chip.

 

--------------------------------------

 

I spent some time looking for a good map of the Green Line to illustrate how insanely twisted it is. But I ended up retaining two maps that illustrate something else altogether. Under law , the Palestinians are not in a good situation: the disputed lands never belonged to any Palestinian Muslim state, and has been administered by Israel for fifty years. So they and their allies work very hard to "create history" that is more favorable to them. Here's an example:

It looks pretty bleak, doesn't it? But it is full of "half-truths" that are only about 5% true:
 - In 1946, there was no such thing as "Palestinian land", simply because there was no such thing as a "Palestinian". The "Palestinian people" was born in the refugee camps after the 1948 war. The true definition of the green area in the 1946 map is "everything that was not owned and occupied by Jews"; notably including vast tracts of land that was not owned and occupied by anyone.
 - The "UN Plan" map uses the word "Palestine", which the UN plan most certainly did not, because there was no such thing as a "Palestinian" at the time. The UN Plan said "Muslim"... and was refused by the Arab states.
 - The 1949-1967 map is an outright lie . The areas in green were occupied by Jordan and Egypt, both of which repressed any idea of "Palestinian" aggressively. More Palestinians were killed by Jordanians in the Black September struggles than have been killed by Israel in all the wars since independence. Since that was Arabs killing Arabs, nobody cares... not even other Arabs.
 - The 2011 map shows the lands that Israel has confided to local rule. Let me repeat that: Israel confided to local rule. Israel held all power in these areas, but gave it up voluntarily .

So yes, the maps look bleak, but they simply aren't true.

 

Here's another map that is a "half-truth", but this one is "mostly true":

It shows a historical truth : The Brits gave three quarters (well... 73% if you want to be finicky) of the Palestinian Mandate to Muslims.

If you conclude that the Muslims are greedy bastards who are never satisfied, then that is your problem... because the map does not actually say that. The map does not mention that the Brits made promises to both the Jews and the Muslims... about the same ( maybe -- it ain't clear, at all) territories...

----------------------------------------------

My point, here, is that history is not simple. The facts are not simple. We can either make the effort to know the facts... or form opinions based on... gut feelings: Who do I hate more, Jews or Arabs?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    10 years ago

There are a lot of topics that aren't simple...

 
 

Who is online

Gsquared
devangelical
Trout Giggles
MrFrost
Hallux


93 visitors