╌>

Good Night And Good Luck - Our Murrow Moment In The Trump Era

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  9 years ago  •  3 comments

Good Night And Good Luck - Our Murrow Moment In The Trump Era


GOOD NIGHT AND GOOD LUCK



Our Murrow Moment



The time for hand-wringing and hysteria is over. The Trump presidency promises a civic stress test. In a time of principled fights, citizens and journalists need to respond with fearlessness rooted in fairness.

 

http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2016/12/31/our-murrow-moment.html?via=desktop&source=twitter


 

 



“We must not confuse dissent with disloyalty…We will not be driven by fear into an age of unreason.” – Edward R. Murrow



If you think 2016 has been a wild and rough ride, just wait ‘til you get a load of 2017.



Given everything we know about Donald Trump from his divisive, demagogic presidential campaign, the next four years will be a stress test for the American system.



The Trump Years promise to be full of Oval Office insults, Twitter attacks and disregard for facts. But rather than viewing the prospect of covering a Trump administration with exhaustion, we should feel invigorated. Because when this time is done, we will look back on it as the best and most important time to be a journalist - not because it was easy, but because it was hard and our sense of mission was clear: to respect the office of the President while holding the person in power accountable against a standard of enduring American values.


This iframe is not allowed


For journalists, Edward R. Murrow offers durable inspiration. The man who brought the Battle of Britain home to Americans via radio and pioneered TV News at CBS, is probably best known today from “Good Night and Good Luck,” directed by George Clooney. Murrow famously risked his career to confront a popular and powerful conservative populist demagogue, Senator Joe McCarthy. He secured his legacy through a commitment to independence and integrity.


 


McCarthy used lies and innuendo to intimidate critics, famously parading a fake list of communists in the State Department, accusing a Democratic administration of participating in a vast conspiracy to subvert our sovereignty and falsely declaring that the ACLU a communist front group. In an ironic bit of symmetry, among his aides was a young true believer  named  Roy Cohn, who would later become attorney for both mob bosses and Donald Trump. It was from Cohn that Trump learned to never apologize, always attack. 



Pushing back against the dark tides of his times, Murrow preached fearlessness rooted in fairness. In my office at Beast HQ, I have a Murrow quote on a brass plaque: “To be persuasive we must be believable; to be believable we must be credible; to be credible we must be truthful.”



Trump’s political success was based on declining trust in all civic institutions – especially the media. Not coincidentally, this decades-long decline directly parallels the rise of partisan media, which has allowed people to self-segregate into separate political realities. As conservative radio host Charlie Sykes recently  reflected , “We’ve basically eliminated any of the referees…we have spent 20 years demonizing the liberal mainstream media…But, at a certain point you wake up and you realize you have destroyed the credibility of any credible outlet out there.”



This election’s sinister innovation of “ fake news ” came when this diet of confirmation bias collided with click bait, polluting our political waters with propaganda. 



Journalists determined to hold Trump accountable must understand that offering nothing but reflexive criticism will reduce their credibility. We’ll need to give credit for the policies the administration gets right so that our criticisms carry weight. We’ll need to offer a roster of reporters and columnists with credibility on both sides of the aisle instead of predictable partisanship.  



But it does not mean surrendering our principles or indulging in the idiotic “on-the-one-hand, on the other” drift toward moral relativism that blurs the line between fact and fiction. Separating truth from lies is journalism’s core responsibility.

 

When a McCarthy defender accused Murrow of “bias and hypocrisy,” Murrow coolly replied, “If the weight of public testimony has tended to show that so far, Senator McCarthy’s charges are unproven, that is not my responsibility.”


 


Of course, aiming for the truth doesn’t make you immune from criticism. Some conservatives will call anyone who isn’t conservative a leftist and unleash howling Twitter mobs on them. Liberals have their own identity politics litmus tests that the more militant among them trot out to condemn any one who dares disagree with them. 



Here, too, the example of Ed Murrow offers some perspective. Before taking on McCarthy, he was considered a fairly conventional anti-communist, backing the execution of the Rosenbergs for spying on behalf of Russia. He’d also been called a warmonger by isolationists for his belief that American should stand up to Hitler. Contrary to his critics’ caricatures, Murrow was not a Democrat or a Republican but a registered independent. As his colleague Charles Collingwood said, "His politics were based on old-fashioned notions of morality and honor, not ideology.” His influence stemmed from his independence.



But after taking on McCarthy, Murrow was called a communist “fellow traveler” and worse. The Wisconsin Senator denounced him as “the cleverest of the jackal pack, which is always found at the throat of anyone who dares to expose individual communists and traitors.”



Conservative columnists constantly attacked Murrow and his crew, driving the broadcaster Dan Hollenbeck to commit suicide. J. Edgar Hoover ordered an expansion of his FBI file. Murrow’s eight-year old son was subjected to slurs and their home was inundated with letters and postcards of hate, the doxxing of his day. When asked how they were holding up, his wife Janet calmly explained “we were under worse in London.”  



That is the sound of perspective.

 

Journalists who’ve stood up to Trump, particularly those on the  center-right , were trolled and doxxed throughout the campaign. The Daily Beast’s reporters were  threatened  by Trump’s senior staff, our site was denounced by the candidate and we were among the first news organizations to be placed on his campaign’s blacklist.  Reporters from the  Washington Post  to the  Arizona Republic  received death threats for daring to criticize – or not  endorse —The Donald.  

 

Trump allies have doubled down on the campaign’s blacklist by  floating  the notion of an “enemies list,” echoing Trump’s favorite ex-president, Richard Nixon . Trump and his geo-political paramour Vladimir Putin have a common aim to intimidate critics while creating the false sense of security that comes from rallying around a strong man draped in the flag.



But Murrow would not back down, famously confronting McCarthy on his show “See It Now” in the spring of 1954, subjecting his opponent’s statements to the cool scrutiny of facts combined with unusual eloquence for a television anchorman.




Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    9 years ago

Donald Trump's appeal is "I am the only one telling you the truth", which is quite a claim for a pathological liar to make. The media is now under the gun like never before in our history. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    9 years ago

This was the easiest thing in history to predict. The same media that wikileaks demonstrated served as a semi-official arm of the Democratic Party and Obama administration are going to start pretending to be unbiased warriors for truth while continuing to simply pass on democratic party talking points. 

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   9 years ago

Trump wants to communicate with America through twitter while he avoids press conferences .  He can't handle the truth. 

Trump's twitter page is habitually  filled with mistakes and misinformation. The media needs to watchdog his ass like we have never seen. 

 
 

Who is online


Trout Giggles
devangelical
Hallux


131 visitors