# PEOTUS arrives in 15 minutes and this is the crowd (or lack thereof) at 12th Street. W @ bterris # Inauguration # InaugurationDay2017
On Day 2 of his presidency, Trump wages war with the media over the size of his inauguration crowd
https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2017/01/21/on-day-two-of-his-presidency-trump-wages-war-with-the-media-over-the-size-of-his-inauguration-crowd/?utm_term=.8a2dda36baa4
President Trump took advantage of a visit to the American intelligence community to insult the intelligence of the American people.
Speaking at CIA headquarters in Virginia on Saturday, Trump challenged media characterizations of the crowd size at his inauguration a day earlier. In doing so, he presented preposterous arguments about the actual attendance.
“We had a massive field of people, you saw that. Packed,” Trump said to the audience. “I get up this morning, I turn on one of the networks and they show ... an empty field. I said, wait a minute, I made a speech! I looked out, the field was ... it looked like a million, a million-and-a-half people. They showed a field where there were practically nobody standing there. And they said, 'Donald Trump did not draw well!' ”
Trump blamed the “almost raining” weather, saying that God kept it from raining during his speech. “It looked, honestly, it looked like a million-and-a-half people,” he continued. “Whatever it was it was, but it went all the way back to the Washington Monument. And I turned on — by mistake, I get this network, and it showed an empty field and it said we drew 250,000 people. Now that's not bad, but it's a lie. We had 250,000 literally around, you know, in the little bowl that we constructed. That was 250,000. The rest of the, you know, 20-block area all the way back to the Washington Monument was packed.”
“So, we caught them,” he said, apparently referring to the media. “And we caught them in a beauty and I think they're going to pay a big price.”
This is simply nonsense.
It is very hard to judge crowd size from within a crowd, as we pointed out on Friday. Looking out over a sea of people makes it hard to gauge where there are gaps in the audience; Trump's vantage point during the inauguration was one of the worst possible places from which to make such a determination. Aerial photos show very clearly that there huge empty areas in the crowd moving back from the Capitol Building.
Here's a comparison that The Washington Post's graphics team made with the 2009 inauguration.
Those white areas are the “empty fields” Trump likely says the network showed. And they showed those empty areas because they existed. Our Ben Terris was a bit to the east of the Washington Monument about an hour before the speech began. You can see that, from his vantage point, there was a gigantic swath of empty space. An empty field, if you will.
Trump, speaking from the barely visible Capitol, would not have been able to see the empty white space as readily. To him, it may well have looked like the crowd stretched all the way back.
The inaugural committee did print nearly 250,000 tickets to attend the event, covering the areas in color on the map at right. It's not clear if all of those tickets were used or if they corresponded one-to-one to seating, since the numbered regions on that map were filled with chairs, limiting capacity. Notice, too, that the colored regions include areas that stretch back past the reflecting pool.
The 250,000-person estimate to which Trump referred probably comes from Dan Gross, who helped coordinate crowds for former president Barack Obama's 2012 inauguration. He tweeted the figure on Friday.
Kenneth Still, an expert in crowd sizes, told the New York Times that he estimated the turnout at about a third of the count for Obama in 2009. (The Times also has clear comparisons of the crowds that year with those on Friday.) The total audience eight years ago was estimated at 1.8 million — putting Trump's number somewhere closer to 600,000.
A critical lesson in this is that crowd estimates are tricky and that our sense of the scale of big numbers is iffy. If Trump made up the number 1.5 million — and it seems likely that he did, given that he wavered between 1 million and 50 percent more as he was talking — he added a huge number of additional people. A noticeably huge number. Compare the visual difference between 250,000, 600,000 and 1.5 million.
Trump's new press secretary, Sean Spicer, spoke briefly to the press several hours after Trump addressed the CIA.
"Photographs of the inaugural proceeding were intentionally framed in a way, in one particular tweet," he said, "to minimize the enormous support that had gathered on the national Mall." He's presumably referring to this tweet from the Boston Globe's Matt Viser, which was retweeted more than 20,000 times.
The use of white "floor coverings," Spicer said, unfairly highlighted areas where people were not standing, as in the comparison photographs at the top of this article. (He claimed this was a first; it was not .) His implication is that the crowd looked more sparse as a result. (You may be the judge of that.) Further, he noted that security measures extended further down the Mall than in years past, meaning that "hundreds of thousands" of people were unable to get into the Mall as quickly.
Spicer claimed that 420,000 people used public transit in Washington on the day of the inauguration, surpassing the 317,000 that used it for the 2013 event. It's not clear where that number comes from. The Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority compared ridership by 11 a.m. from the past four inaugurations on Friday; Trump's was the lowest.
(Ridership for those attending Saturday's anti-Trump rallies, incidentally, was 42 percent higher than by 11 a.m. on Friday.) Over the course of the day, our Luz Lazo reports , there were nearly 571,000 trips taken on Jan. 20 — versus 1.1 million in 2009 and 782,000 in 2013.
Noting that there are no official estimates of crowd size, Spicer also walked through the capacities of various parts of the Mall, totaling 720,000 people. That included space from Fourth Street NW to the "media tent" — the area where Terris was filmed — and from the media tent to the Washington Monument, both of which he said were "full when the president took the oath of office." (You may be the judge of that, too.) Even if those areas were full, this is still less than half of the figure that Trump presented to the CIA. Spicer noted that more people watched the inauguration online and on television, which is true — but also isn't the claim that his boss was making.
Complaints about the media misrepresenting his audience size are not new for Trump. During the campaign he routinely inflated attendance at his rallies. In one notorious incident that parallels Saturday's complaints neatly, he got angry at CNN for saying that he spoke to a half-empty room, insisting that the crowd had rushed forward to hear him speak. That also wasn't true ; the room was demonstrably only half-full.
At that point, though, Trump was just a regular old candidate for office. On Saturday, he was the newly inaugurated president of the United States.
Tags
Who is online
69 visitors




Donald Trump is a hopeless habitual liar. If he gets his press secretary to lie for him too, which he likely will, the people will depend entirely on the media for the truth.
The Useful Idiots already depend on the media for the truth.
Well, we sure as hell are not going to get any truth from Donald Trump. Why is he starting fights with the media. He stood up in front of the CIA personnel today and said the media are the worst people in the world. Has this man lost his mind?
The media could bring down his presidency. And it would probably easier to do with him than anyone else because he is a pathological liar.
He was embarrassed today because millions of people came out to protest him. He cannot stand that.
So he sends his press secretary out to yell at the media. This is not going well so far.
The media could bring down his presidency. And it would probably easier to do with him than anyone else because he is a pathological liar.
For a long time, the Republican base has been wanting somebody to stand up and fight back. Now they have it in a belligerent buffoon. He's already discredited among the protesters and his supporters like what he's doing. The media may be just howling in the wind.
"...people will depend entirely on the media for the truth..."
BWAH HA HA HA!
Of course I believe the media over Donald Trump. I have a brain.
Lol!
Hillary has a 90% chance of winning!
Damn, you're funny!
Most likely a bit off topic , if so I apologize , but about a week ago I read an article that the WH press corps were worried that they may lose their room in the west wing and be either relegated somewhere else on the grounds or off the grounds entirely.
Not saying that's going to happen , and it would set WH protocol back a number of years , but with the way the MSM , or any media is nowdays from all sides , I can see it happening, most people are sick and tired of the self important media types that are not even worthy enough to clean up the spittle of those news media greats that actually had integrity and trust of years gone by and are now a distant memory of history past , never to return, Todays MSM is in it for the market share and the money, not the integrity a free press and the trust of the population .
They no longer deserve any special access. They have been demonstrated to be partisan hacks. I welcome their demotion to regular citizens.
Maybe Putin has altered the photos to mess with his new puppet.
Putin is sooooo scary... You and PJ need to seek counseling and take off the tinfoil....
You need to open your eyes and admit that photos don't lie, and neither is the media on this day.
These guys are in more denial than Trump is. Posting evidence on NT is like talking to a wall.
Actually photographs CAN lie, its all in the framing , and timing . sportsmen do it quite often do it with game to make things look like something its not .
I even did it when one of my kids caught their first fish, was actually a borderline keeper , but being their first , I framed the shot to make it look twice as big.
and if I as an amature can do it , imagine what a professional could do, don't believe me , ask the resident photog experts.
Not in this case. We're not just talking about DC, we're talking about 500 cities in every state, and countries on continents all over the world - with virtually no violence reported at all. That is how unpopular your winner is.
My winner? sorry , but you forgot I said I wasn't voting for him , I voted with my Johnson remember"?
and I have seen a couple different pictures of the Inauguration that contradict each other , the first taken 5 hrs before the even , and one while it was being held , both looked totally different , and I grant they were both taken from different angles.
and this ties back into the integrity of the media , they failed to tell when those photos were taken so people could describe it to their own ends , just has happened , and in case your amiss, integrity = honesty in presentation which leads to trust of the public , which the media after this last election campaign, is sorely lacking for proving how partisan they have become.
There john , I attempted to keep it in line with the subject of the article , which is the media from what I can tell.
Wow. That's so irrelevant. ..
in contrast , there is Hillarys inauguration..../s/
And the timing of that Trump shot they used for the compare was at 6:00 AM, at 12:12pm right after he took the oath, it was twice as full. Mediatite has a shot from the earthcam on the Washington monument aimed at the capital exactly at that time.
The Obama shot, was at 12:10pm.
If you really want a full and complete understanding of what they are trying to say. Snopes has a more accurate description and comparison to previous inaugurations.
Was Obama's Inauguration Crowd Larger Than Trump's?
Of course it was, Obama's first was the largest ever seen estimated at 1.8 million. But one must understand one thing. it was the first Black Man elected president taking office in a 65% black inhabited city that is 95% hard core liberal.
Trump had larger numbers that Bush, and larger numbers than Clinton. (topping attendance at all four of their inaugurations)
And from this image....
Upper image is Trump's, lower is Obama's first.
It is plain that the images used by the media to make their comparison have issues
No official estimate has come out about attendance since the US park Service doesn't do such estimates anymore.
But it is clear, the media is distorting the truth again....
Courtesy of Heavy.com...
Inauguration Crowd Photos: Trump vs. Obama, Bush & Clinton Comparisons
A much more accurate portrayal of the numbers.
And another reason to ignore anything mainstream media says about President Trump.
The MSM has been proven to be dishonest and partisan. Only a fool believes their swill.
Nowhere Man , try to come back into contact with reality. Make an effort anyway.
This is from YOUR SOURCE,
Obama’s first inauguration was at least double the number of people who attended Trump’s today.
You're trying to "gaslight" us, aren't you? No can do, lol.
Sean Spicer, the Trump boot licker who is now in charge of lying for Mr. President said today that more people saw the Trump inauguration than any other inauguration in the history of the universe.
These people have no shame.
Your funny!
You know why?
It is clear you didn't read my entire posting. cause you plainly missed this part...
Of course it was, Obama's first was the largest ever seen estimated at 1.8 million. But one must understand one thing. it was the first Black Man elected president taking office in a 65% black inhabited city that is 95% hard core liberal.
So no, unfortunately, no gaslighting. But thank you.
Thank you for revealing that you have a one track mind that doesn't track very well. That you cannot follow a posting from start to finish. And you assume things are true when they aren't.
In your zeal to prove me wrong, you reveal the lack of intellectual integrity that is unique to you. Most would acknowledge that I covered the size of Obama's inaugurations and what they represented.
And the plain fact that they were the largest ever seen.
In your zeal, you just made a fool of yourself again.
By completely missing the point of the posting.
Thank you.
I understood your post completely. Sean Spicer said today that more people saw Trump's inauguration than any other one.
Was Spicer telling the truth?
Who put him up to the falsehood?
Worry about that instead of imagining what you think I mean.
The article isn't about Sean Spicer, it's about the media representation.
Now I admit there can be two points to this, I chose to deal with the medias photo representation, which is obviously false.
You seen to want to deny or are forced to defend their representation. Which becomes hilarious when viewing the truth.
I would suggest if you want to make it about Sean Spicers claim being inaccurate, find another way. The media manipulating the photos destroys the argument.
And comes across and minor whining, way below what decent people want to hear.
Makes them look cheap and childish.
Makes you look even worse for going with it without a shred of investigation.
But that is what your famous for, taking what the media puts out there and running with it right wrong or indifferent.
I wouldn't expect nothing less from you John.
“This was the largest audience to ever witness an inauguration, period — both in person and around the globe,” a seething Sean Spicer said in a Saturday address riddled with falsehoods.
Do you think Sean Spicer would say a word from a prepared statement that had not been approved by his boss?
Spicer's job is to speak for the president.
Keep spinning NM.
-
The media manipulating what photos? Bizarrely , you argue that photos were manipulated to falsely prove something that you CONCEDE (Obama had a bigger crowd).
Trump is nuts. Let's concentrate our thoughts on that fact for a while.
I think the photos clearly show that Obama's crowd is significantly larger than Trump's. The photos that NWM posted are taken from the capital steps facing the Washington monument. From that perspective, the crowd size of both events looks roughly the same but you can't really see the end of the crowd because the camera isn't mounted high enough. Hal's pictures are taken from the opposite direction, at a much higher elevation, looking from the Washington monument side of the mall toward the capital. Both of Hal's shots show the inaugural event in progress. The Washington monument is a little more than 14 blocks away, on the other side of 14th street. Trump's crowd thinned out long before 14th street while Obama's crowd was still thick.
Nothing is surprising about an overwhelmingly democratic city and surburban area turning out in large numbers to see the inauguration of a democrat, especially if he's making history as the first black president. Trump might be making history too . . . but it's as a widely despised buffoon so he really shouldn't expect an obama sized crowd to show up in a democratic stronghold unless he's being hanged.
Agreed, what John doesn't get cause he is wearing VERY thick blinders, is I'm not challenging that Obama's crowd wasn't larger.
All the photos show it.
but they took and use disparate photos taken at different times to make it look even thinner than it actually was.
Mediatite had a photo showing the view from the WM at the exact time he took the oath showing a crowd twice the size as the one they are using to compare.
He wants to make it out that I'm defending Spicers claim, I'm not, I'm exposing the exaggerated emphasis the media is using to discredit it by manipulating the pics. (using shots that are from different periods)
But John can't have or allow even that little bit of honesty, if you agree with the fact that Spicer is wrong then in his world that MUST mean you also accept the medias misrepresentation of reality.
I will not accept such.
The posted comparison pic.....
Here is the mediatite pic timestamped...
There you go 12:12 just after the oath was given, there are twice as many people on the mall as the pic used to compare in Johns original posting.
The media used a different image , one NOT of the actual time of inauguration but much earlier.
Captured live.
The media exaggerated the difference.
Case closed.
When Trump was filling stadiums and Hillary couldn't fill a high school gymnasium, the media didn't think crowd size meant anything at all. Now that Trump's inaugural crowd size is smaller than Obamas and the size of the protest is large, crowd size is suddenly worth mentioning. So I agree that the media manipulates coverage to subtly put its finger on the scale. However, in this case, I don't know.
The photo JR uses is from a different angle than mediatite, the latter putting the tree line of the mall in the center of the photo. The people standing on the mall stand in blocks or "patches". In JR's photos, I count six patches from the capital steps and the seventh patch is empty. In the mediatite photo, the picture looks to be cropped at the 6th patch which leaves out the area captured in JR's photo. I assume that these kinds of photo discrepancies are why the park service and others don't want to get drsggged into disputes over crowd size and say judge it for yourselves.
I'll leave it to Trump to fight about his crowd and hand size. . . .
The park service doesn't do guesstimations of crowd size anymore cause they were sued by the organizers of the "Million Man March" when they guesstimated the crowd size was a bit short of a million. ( about six tenths of a million short, 400K ) Of course one has to remember it was Louis Farrakhan claiming it was almost 1.5 to 2 million men. Most academics agreed with the park service.
Due to the potential for political issues with the nation of Islam, they decided to end the process and haven't done any since.
I used a color scan to determine the dark to light latency of the images in the areas of people. using the blocks that appear in both images.
The image I have shows a lot less light area than the images they used for comparison. The light area, (mats laid on the ground to protect the grass) were first used during Obama's second inauguration, and are a great method using satellite imagery and lightness darkness sampling to determine (guesstimate) the number of people that attended. Since there is no way to do an accurate head count.
The military does the same thing to guestimate the size of military formations from space. Fairly accurate within 10K as long as the images are clear.
Not hard to do at all.
The military does the same thing to guestimate the size of military formations from space. Fairly accurate within 10K as long as the images are clear.
So what is your guesstimate of the crowd size?
If I had to guesstimate from the work I've done having Obama's first (1.8 mil) as the largest and using Clinton's second (250,000) as the low end, I would say somewhere around 550-575,000. Not bad, you will have to go back to Reagan's second or Bush I's to get comparable.
Wasn't a bad turnout compared to average. (average being 400K)
That had to sting. Block after block of EMPTY stands. Lol.
And the timing of that Trump shot they used for the compare was at 6:00 AM
Quite a trick, since sunrise didn't happen until 7:22am. Talk about extreme gaslighting.
as for todays protests and the numbers, way I see it Trump , got more out of shape women out walking and doing breathing exerszies in 24 hrs , than Mrs Obama got to do the same in 8 years of telling them how to eat and exersize.
Of course that's how you would see it. Anything to avoid the truth.
Penis envy...nothing more...from the man with the tiny, tiny, bizarrely tiny hands...and non-disclosure contracts from all of his immigrant ex's...or they'll lose their payoff money. Is anyone surprise that everything associated with him "has" to be the biggest? He is the very picture of over compensating for his..."short comings".