╌>

Trump Executive Order Cutting Funding To Sanctuary Cities Is Unconstitutional

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  9 years ago  •  38 comments

Trump Executive Order Cutting Funding To Sanctuary Cities Is Unconstitutional

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2017/01/26/constitutional-problems-with-trumps-executive-order-on-sanctuary-cities/?utm_term=.8700e26fd332

Why Trump’s executive order on sanctuary cities is unconstitutional

Yesterday, President Donald Trump signed an  executive order denying federal funding to sanctuary cities – jurisdictions that choose not to cooperate with federal efforts to deport undocumented immigrants. The order has serious constitutional problems. Unless interpreted very narrowly, it is both unconstitutional and a very dangerous precedent. Trump and future presidents could use it to seriously undermine constitutional federalism by forcing dissenting cities and states to obey presidential dictates, even without authorization from Congress. The circumvention of Congress makes the order a threat to separation of powers, as well.

The order indicates that sanctuary cities “that fail to comply with applicable Federal law do not receive Federal funds, except as mandated by law.” More specifically, it mandates that “the Attorney General and the [Homeland Security] Secretary, in their discretion and to the extent consistent with law, shall ensure that jurisdictions that willfully refuse to comply with 8 U.S.C. 1373 (sanctuary jurisdictions) are not eligible to receive Federal grants, except as deemed necessary for law enforcement purposes by the Attorney General or the Secretary.”

Section 1373  mandates that “a Federal, State, or local government entity or official may not prohibit, or in any way restrict, any government entity or official from sending to, or receiving from, the Immigration and Naturalization Service information regarding the citizenship or immigration status, lawful or unlawful, of any individual.”

There are two serious constitutional problems with conditioning federal grants to sanctuary cities on compliance with Section 1373. First, longstanding Supreme Court precedent mandates that the federal government may not impose conditions on grants to states and localities unless the conditions are “unambiguously” stated in the text of the law “so that the States can knowingly decide whether or not to accept those funds.” Few if any federal grants to sanctuary cities are explicitly conditioned on compliance with Section 1373. Any such condition must be passed by Congress, and may only apply to new grants, not ones that have already been appropriated. The executive cannot simply make up new conditions on its own and impose them on state and local governments. Doing so undermines both separation of powers and federalism.

Even aside from Trump’s dubious effort to tie it to federal grants, Section 1373 is itself unconstitutional. The Supreme Court has repeatedly  ruled that the federal government may not “commandeer” state and local officials by compelling them to enforce federal law . Such policies violate the Tenth Amendment.

Section 1373 attempts to circumvent this prohibition by forbidding higher-level state and local officials from mandating that lower-level ones refuse to help in enforcing federal policy. But the same principle that forbid direct commandeering also counts against Section 1373. As the late conservative Justice Antonin Scalia explained in  Printz v. United States , the purpose of the anti-commandeering doctrine is the “[p]reservation of the States as independent and autonomous political entities.” That independence and autonomy is massively undermined if the federal government can take away the states’ power to decide what state and local officials may do while on the job. As Scalia put it in the same opinion, federal law violates the Tenth Amendment if it “requires [state employees] to provide information that belongs to the State and is available to them only in their official capacity.” The same is true if, as in the case of Section 1373, the federal government tries to prevent states from controlling their employees’ use of information that “is available to them only in their official capacity.”

Some  defenders of Trump’s policy  claim that the anti-commandeering rule does not apply to federal laws that mandate disclosure of information. I addressed that argument  here . Quite simply, there is no information-disclosure exception to the Tenth Amendment, and it would be very dangerous for the courts to create one.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    9 years ago

A segment on Chris Hayes show last night suggested that many if not all of trumps executive orders so far have been unenforceable and or unconstitutional. Trump is not vetting the content of these orders with the appropriate departments or with government attorneys. Chris Hayes alleges that the orders are being written by Steve Bannon and Steven Miller, Trump aides not versed in the constitution or law. 

 
 
 
Uncle Bruce
Professor Silent
link   Uncle Bruce    9 years ago

Wait...NOW you're worried about the Constitutionality of Executive Orders?  After 8 years of Obama thumbing his nose at the Constitution? 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    9 years ago

I just don't want you to be disappointed when none of his shit goes through. 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    9 years ago

I ask you Leftist once again, are you for the American Citizens or are you for Illegal Aliens?

Are you for this country or some other country?

Do you Pledge Alliance to The United States of America or some other country or countries?

Do you want to protect criminals who are illegally in this country or do you want to protect American Citizens?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

we pledge to the constitution

what do you think trump knows of the constitution?

little, next to nothing, or nothing? 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

people in chicago pay federal income taxes, and that money is sent to washington d.c. 

Trump wants to prevent Chicago's share of that money from being returned to the people of chicago in the form of federal programs and grants.

He has no right to do that, according to the constitutional expert that wrote the seeded article. 

Let him find another way to dispute the acceptability of sanctuary cities. 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Are you for or against Sanctuary Cities?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

What's taking you so long for such a short question John?  You answered the one above it in 6 minutes, but it has been 20 minutes and I have heard from you at this time 1258pm.

Hey, I'll ask you another one.  What do you think Trump should do about criminal illegal aliens who are given cover and protection in these Sanctuary cities?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

You know Gunny, I don't believe John is going to answer either one of my questions it seems.  I don't believe I've ever seen a time when John as stood up for this country in all the years I've been here either.  He always takes the position against our country or our Constitution, only quoting something from the Constitution when it can be used against us, very much like Obama.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

I don't believe I've ever seen a time when John as stood up for this country in all the years I've been here either.  He always takes the position against our country or our Constitution, only quoting something from the Constitution when it can be used against us, very much like Obama.

Six, please don't use my name in your gibberish. 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Can you answer either of the questions I asked?  I mean whenever they have a meta article about having discussions you are right in there and when you leave you go right back to your same old tactics.  I mean both of them are very simple and in order to continue any kind of discussion it would be nice to know if you are for or against Sanctuary cities.

I can tell you now, I'm not for Sanctuary Cities.  Can you say the same?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

Listen, we won't worry about John.  He's not going to try and have a discussion.

Are there any others here who are for or against Sanctuary Cities and why do you feel the way you do?  Don't be shy.  I mean we are on a discussion forum where people are suppose to discuss things.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    9 years ago

He's not saying that they cannot be sanctuary cities, quite the contrary John.

They can be anything they want to be.

What he is saying is the federal government is not going to financially support cities/states that willingly violate federal law.

What Seattle Mayor Fred Murray has said in response?

Fine, we will just increase taxes and do it ourselves.

Excellent!

One of the things you argued vehemently for while Obama was in office is that the president has exactly the kind of power Trump is now exercising.

Now that the shoe is on the other foot it is interesting that you making the constitutionality argument your opposition was making when Obama was doing the exact same things.

Hypocrite much?

So what we now have proven, is John believes anything a liberal does in office is constitutional, but when anyone else is in said office it is illegal for them to do exactly the same things. Especially when it comes to money for his specially protected classes.

It's is positions you take like this which explains why you have absolutely no credibility John.

Obama did have a record setting presidency, he increased the CFR by 97,000 pages. And did it through executive order without one iota of guidance or approval by congress.

More than the last three presidents combined.

More whine and cheezz please...

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

One of the things you argued vehemently for while Obama was in office is that the president has exactly the kind of power Trump is now exercising.

Now that the shoe is on the other foot it is interesting that you making the constitutionality argument your opposition was making when Obama was doing the exact same things.

Hypocrite much?

Not surprisingly, you suck at explaining my positions. 

Obama was stonewalled by the Republican congress. Especially after the 2010 midterms put the GOP in control of the House. 

I said that if the Republicans would not co-operate with Obama then he would have no choice, from his perspective, but to try and implement his agenda through whatever legal means he had available. President Obama always knew there was a chance some of his executive orders would be overturned by conservative courts. He just didnt see any alternative other than accepting that his would be a do nothing presidency in the second term. 

Trump just got elected and his party controls both chambers. Why isnt he running all this stuff through Congress? 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

I'm not even going to bother to explain how government actually functions, (government 101 level stuff)

He doesn't run it through congress cause he doesn't have to dummy, go back to school.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

Then Obama didnt have to either, did he?

You are too easy NM. 

Trump went into a flurry of EO's because Obama used them. It is "payback".  Now, when the unconstitutionality of many if not most , or all , of Trump's orders is established, will he have learned his lesson?   lol. 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

John just likes to fuss back and forth like a five year old.  He's not interested in adult discussions.  He puts article up that are controversial and whenever anyone tries to carry on a sensible conversation, he disappears or doesn't participate until he sees something he can make a stupid response to thinking he's being smart.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Obama lost more Supreme Court cases than any other present in history.  There's one for you John.  Find that one President who challenges that statement.  That will give you something non productive to do, since you refuse to grow up and have an adult discussion, we can play the game with you as well.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

Sixpick, the article is about the unconstitutionality of Trump's executive order. I am not sure you have devoted a single sentence to that topic in any of your many comments on this thread. 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Well, if you feel it is unconstitutional and can prove it, tell me, did you think it was unconstitutional when Obama made his threats to different people and states to withhold funds unless they followed his Executive Orders?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

It's is positions you take like this which explains why you have absolutely no credibility John.

Absolutely NO CREDIBILITY AT ALL!!!!

When a person will not tell you whether they support something or not but wants to put an article up about it and a process he obviously doesn't agree with to deal with it.  Are you for or against Sanctuary Cities?  Pretty damn simple question.  And from there we can discuss possible other ways to deal with the situation.

Are you for or against Sanctuary Cities NWM?  If you expand on your answer it would be great.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

I don't want the police or military running around looking for illegals, but I don't want criminal illegals to have a refuge right here in our country where they are protected.

I don't really like the idea of a border fence, but in this day, there are so many dangers it seems it is the only way to protect our country from the people who are coming here to harm us. 

Any other ways anyone can think of they think would be a better solution.

Certainly we shouldn't have little areas all over the country where illegal criminals can feel safe, should we.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  sixpick   9 years ago

I'm neither for them or against them.

I just do not want to pay for them.

If a city decides to trash itself more power to it, it is their right to make such a decision. If the citizens of said city don't like it they can avail themselves of the processes to change that.

None of my business.

But where it does effect me, is my tax dollars, which I do not want going to such activities, so I guess in general I am against such policies as "Sanctuary Cities" for either illegals or the homeless.

And that is because the progressive leaders of Seattle are making it such a visible issue. (blue tarp capital of the country)

But then I also recognize said cities rights to do it whatever way they choose and can afford/willing to pay for themselves.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

I can understand your position on this NWM.  But doesn't a city who protects illegal criminals also become a city who protects criminals?

Would it not be feasible to commit crimes in other cities and run back to the fort for protection.  Is it not a State crime to kill someone instead of Federal crime?   What better place to run for shelter than a Sanctuary City?

 
 

Who is online



SteevieGee


74 visitors