╌>

Don’t Be So Quick To Laugh At Trump Supporters Who Think ‘Bowling Green Massacre’ Justifies Travel Ban

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  randy  •  9 years ago  •  28 comments

Don’t Be So Quick To Laugh At Trump Supporters Who Think ‘Bowling Green Massacre’ Justifies Travel Ban

 

The poll question was a setup, and breathlessly promoting its results will only make distrust in the media worse.



Just over half of those who support President Donald Trump said that the fictional “Bowling Green Massacre” shows why Trump’s executive order on immigration is necessary, according to a new poll out from Democratic pollster Public Policy Polling . 


 


That makes a splashy headline, and it’s catnip for liberals who want to laugh at how stupid they think Trump supporters are. But it’s not good polling practice and should not be reported without substantial caveats about how the question was written and likely perceived by respondents.



First, most of us who read polls live in a world focused on media and politics, and we should get out of that mindset. The average American doesn’t spend hours of their day glued to Twitter and cable networks watching all the latest developments in Washington, D.C. Most are busy living their lives, caring for families, working non-political jobs or all of the above.



In that frame of mind, how many Americans have probably heard of the Bowling Green Massacre, or know it’s a fake thing Kellyanne Conway made up last week? We don’t know. The poll didn’t ask that question. The question wasn’t even about whether people believed the fictional massacre happened ― that was simply asserted as a fact.


589df7c92800001f00998214.png
Public Policy Polling

This is the exact question wording from PPP.

PublicPolicyPolling ✔ @ppppolls


By 51/23 margin, Trump voters say the Bowling Green Massacre shows why his Executive Order on immigration is needed: http://www. publicpolicypolling.com/main/2017/02/a mericans-now-evenly-divided-on-impeaching-trump.html  …




 




What the question did ask about was whether respondents agreed that a fake event ― presented as a factual event ―  justifies a policy that many Trump supporters already support. Of course many supporters were going to agree with that statement, even if they weren’t aware that the Bowling Green massacre was fiction.



Not knowing about the issue doesn’t make people stupid, either. The pace of news in the last few weeks has been extremely fast. People with nonpolitical lives can’t be expected to keep up.



There’s considerable research on how average people answer poll questions when they might not really know what the question refers to. Some will admit that they don’t know the answer ― as 20 percent of the whole sample and 23 percent of Trump supporters did in this case. But many will think they should have an answer, and say the first thing that comes to mind . This is part of why polling on specific policies is difficult ― people often haven’t given issues a lot of thought, but when prompted, they will make up an opinion.  



Research also shows that when you ask people to agree or disagree with something, they are more likely to agree if they don’t have a solid opinion. This is called “acquiescence bias,” and it’s why many pollsters shy away from yes/no or agree/disagree types of questions.



So PPP’s results likely don’t tell us anything about whether people think the Bowling Green massacre was a real event, as some are interpreting the poll. The question directly tied the Bowling Green Massacre to Trump’s executive order and asked it in an agree/disagree format that would lean Trump supporters toward agreeing.



The 10 or so media outlets covering this question should know better . PPP has a history of asking questions designed to make certain segments of the population look like they believe in fictional things. In late 2015, they asked about bombing the fictional Disney kingdom of Agrabah as if it were a real place. But many media outlets picked that story up too.



It’s even worse now. Many of Trump’s supporters don’t believe mainstream media, so to report on a poll question and basically say , “Haha, look how dumb these people are!” when the question was a total setup only exacerbates the problem that media has in the Trump era.



To assert a fake event as fact in a poll question only perpetuates falsehoods, and the Trump team doesn’t need any help in that area.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/trump-supporters-bowling-green-massacre_us_589df750e4b0ab2d2b14cb22?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    9 years ago

By a 53 to 21 margin Trump supporters assert that shows why his Executive Order on immigration is needed. Think about that for just a moment. By a 53 to 21 margin Trump supporters assert that the ban on Muslims is needed because of a "massacre", a terrorist attack in Bowling Green, that never happened. By a 53 to 21 margin they assert that the Muslim ban is needed because of 100% fake news. Because of something that did not happen.

What kind of a mind does it take to think that? How low of an information person does it take to believe that. Fake news sites like infowars play to the lowest common denominator. They aim their content to the lowest idiot who is willing to consume it (and Trump reads and believes it) and believe it. And they succeed. What does this say about the average American? Are they really so stupid as to believe this garbage? Are the really so stupid as to believe these easily disprovable lies just because of their source? As Chico Marx once said (paraphrasing) are they really willing to believe the incredible lies they are being told or do they believe their own eyes and ears? Whenever I tell my wife something outrageous or unbelievable that a poll shows or that the right wing gets away with she invariably says the same thing "The American People are stupid." Until now I have defended the American people, but the American people are making it very, very hard to defend them any longer. I am beginning to think that, as a group, the American people ARE stupid.

If Americans as a whole really are a stupid as this poll indicates, then we do deserve to go down in flames and die as a society. It would be a blessing on the world.

 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    9 years ago

 How low of an information person does it take to believe that. Fake news sites like infowars play to the lowest common denominator.

It's a perfect example not of the people's stupidity, it's a perfect example of the media deliberately using polling to make news. Fake News BTW.

It is dishonest. If, as the article points out, push polling is used to reveal a flaw in the system in current use or a manner in which the system is being used unfairly, then it is good. And this article in fact does that very thing.

But to insinuate that a certain class of people are of less intelligence simply cause they are not as plugged into the system as others are is a very bad way. Pushing a false narrative is what it is called and the article also makes that very point. It is called creating a false narrative and is why the people in question have serious issues with the media.

Is this what you intended to show Randy?

That PPP is pushing an agenda by creating fake news? Cause if it was you succeeded very well.

But if you are using it to castigate Trump supporters in any way as intellectually on a lower plane than the media cycle plugged in person. Then you are no better than PPP in pushing a false agenda.

It's called propaganda in action. Used to create a false paradigm.

A very technical way to say Black people don't have as big a brain as white people therefore they are a lower form of life than White people are.

Trump supporters, since they are not as plugged into the news cycle, are a lower form of life than those that are. (typically democrats)

Your conclusion....

 If Americans as a whole really are a stupid as this poll indicates, then we do deserve to go down in flames and die as a society. It would be a blessing on the world.

Is very cleverly disguised as talking about all people, but who you really mean is any people that disagree with you, your ideology, or PPP's position/ideology.

It is strange that Huffpo actually posted an article that revealed PPP for the shucksters they are, now that is strange for them.

But using it in the manner you are, the conclusion in opposite of the articles point, only reveals bias, the bias that those that disagree with you are lesser than you.

Despite your great efforts to hide it.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    9 years ago

I disagree. It is perfect example of people on the right taking real news and making it fake news. Surly you can not contest that the idea of 53 to 21percent of Trump supports believing that there actually was a Bowling Green massacre is not an example of a stupid herd like mentality the masss  to be becoming more pronounced on the right wing.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

53/21% of people answering a fake question in which they do not know it's a fake question?

And you are willing to judge people based upon presupposing it's real?

And you have no problem with the fact that they set up people to look like fools?

And then want to run with it to insinuate a whole class of people based solely upon their political affiliation, (opposite yours) answering a fake question are stupid?

It is more revealing of your biases than theirs...

And proof that liberals will throw any integrity they have left out the window to discredit that which they hate.

Just a clue how fucked up that is?

HUFFPO RAN AN ARTICLE CRITICIZING IT!

WOW there is at least one liberal rag that is willing to say that it is too much and going too far....

Please pardon the yelling, but this is such an enormous subterfuge to create a false paradigm to be used against a whole class of people that it boggles the mind at how far some would go with their hate.

And Huffpo demonstrates there is a limit on how far they will go by exposing it, there is hope for the world...

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

53/21% of people answering a fake question in which they do not know it's a fake question?

And you are willing to judge people based upon presupposing it's real?

And you have no problem with the fact that they set up people to look like fools?

And then want to run with it to insinuate a whole class of people based solely upon their political affiliation, (opposite yours) answering a fake question are stupid?

It is more revealing of your biases than theirs...

What is reveling is that 53/21% of Americans were so incredibly STUPID and low information as to not check out the information that they were presented with themselves. They wholeheartedly accepted complete lies, completely fake news as real because they have been conditioned to by the far right wing news mongers such as Steve Bannon and Sean Spicer. They are no better then the Germans who believed everything that Joseph Goebbels told them. They swallow it unquestionably as whole truth without looking at it with an inquiring eye. Without questioning it. And when people begin to take the whole truth from the government without question, then we are on the way to becoming a fasict/authoritarian dictatorship. And before you laugh and say that it can't happen here in America I assure you that American values, while strong, are only as strong as the people willing to believe in them and defend them and there seem to be fewer and fewer people like that here in this country today. I say fuck no to what that current administration tells me not because I am UN-American, but rather because I am defending America.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

Well you defend America in your way And I will defend it in mine.

Mine doesn't presuppose that my opposition are idiots.

How many of the liberal side bought the proven lie that was obamacare hook line and sinker.

Remember that before you start ragging on people on how they take what the government says for rote.

One more thing, Spencer & Bannon have been on the scene for how long? three weeks? four weeks?

Before becoming a part of the Trump administration who were they? Nobody's in fact.

They must be some kind of svengalis to have brainwashed or mind conditioned such a huge chunk of the population that quickly right?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     9 years ago

What this proves is that Kellyanne Conway shouldn't be in the position she is in. The excuse that people answered yes to the question is because they are working, don't use twitter..Give me a break. If this massacre really did take place it would be on every media station, every newspaper, etc etc. in the world.

As the old saying goes, ''there's one born every minute''....

BTW, there really was a Bowling Green massacre, Conway got the century wrong, the place wrong and the race and religion of the people wrong.

It took place in 1643 in Manhattan when white Christian soliders massacred around 80 Lenape natives.

 

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    9 years ago

The poll question was a setup, and breathlessly promoting its results will only make distrust in the media worse.

Yes it was a setup and was corrected the following day, no different than Obama claiming to have visited 57 states during his campaign.

Public Policy Polling is a Democrat polling firm and you can bet they polled Democrats, so I find this to just further the fact the media, for the most part, is mostly fake or twisted news to promote their agenda.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    9 years ago

The part that makes people laugh about it here in KY is that It Never Happened.  So, excuse us, but it supposedly took place here in KY, but didn't.  That's why we're laughing...

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    9 years ago

First and most obvious, this is PPP, the most partisan polling outfit in the country. The mechanics of the poll itself identify  it as nothing more than propaganda designed for the specific purpose of giving it's client something to tweet about.

But go further how many people can name of the top of their head all the Islamic terrorist attacks that have taken place on American soil since Obama was elected. Go ahead, name each location and what happened at  each place without using any references. If you can't name every single one of them, you have no reason to laugh.

Iraqi terrorists were in fact arrested in Bowling Green. Given the amount of successful  and thwarted terrorist attacks its easy to see how even well informed people can confuse at which locations a terrorist attack was successfully carried out, and where they were stopped.

Notice how all the liberals who find this silly poll so noteworthy haven't muttered a peep about Maggie Halberman the New York times Reporter who tweeted that only one terrorist attack had been carried out by terrorist not born in the US, San Bernandino. Any ridicule from liberals even though she missed an obvious one like Boston among others? Of course not, she's one of the "reporters" famously identified by the Clinton camp who they could plant stories with and she would run, no questions asked.  

No surprise liberals hold Trump voters to higher standards then they do liberal reporters for the New York Times.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Sean Treacy   9 years ago

I know nothing about the PPP, etc.  OK?  I grant you that.  What is there to terrorize in Bowling Green, KY?  I mean, there is a college-- a nice one-- they have a geology department, which is pretty good.  About 15,000 students...  Boeling Green and county have a population of about 80,000.  But they are near the Mumfordsville KKK enclave, within 20-30 miles, and, frankly, those good old boys would gladly take care of any "rag heads" down there.  Secondly, the supposed 'terrorists' weren't plotting any terrorist activities on KY soil, they were sending weapons, or trying to, overseas, but were unable to do so, because they were caught by the KY State Police.  We may be uneducated, but we aren't dumb.  A foreign address is a pretty big flag to our post office people, who, despite working for the feds, are mainly retired ex military and just normal people, who look askance at weird addresses and boxes.  They even look askance at letters mailed from the KY Board of Geology, as I can attest to, having been accosted by a post man on my front porch over geologic time.  

Plus, I honestly know of NO ONE that doesn't have a gun in their home.  We remember the latest greatest War Between the States and are ready to defend our property, if necessary.  Plus, we don't have a lot of time for unpeaceable "rag heads".  We have records of gun purchases, too, and we keep an eye on 'em.  When seemingly a lot of AR whatevers are purchased by someone named Mohammed Adubaba, they land on the watch list, and are carefully watched.  By everyone.

We are laughing because someone put us on the national radar for terrorist activities, when nothing occurred.  It isn't because of Trump-- we're a red state, after all-- it's because some idiot woman doubled down on the lie.  We know better.

Granted, likely 25% of us have no idea where Bowling Green, KY is located, but we can count on our police, our National Guard, our militias, and our good old boys to step in, if need be.  If someone here does something bad, I mean, actually terrorizes someone, you can be sure they won't live long.

Try not to be too snarky.  I wasn't trying to be.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Dowser   9 years ago

I can't edit this, and I find that really annoying.  Also, I forgot to include that Bowling Green is about 1/2-way between two Federal army posts, Fort Knox, and Fort Campbell.  If worst comes to worst, they'd go down there and wreak havoc.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Dowser   9 years ago

Here, just for jollies, I fixed a map for you.  Sure, an isolated incident can occur, but most of our terrorist types are home grown.  Sorry, the labels aren't that great...  Blue stars are National Guard armories who all have troops available, Red/orange stars are military installations, unfortunately Mumfordsville is also blue...  Having computer difficulties today.

ft knox ft campbell labelled.jpg

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Dowser   9 years ago

My point is that there have so many terrorist attacks and thwarted terrorist attacks that's almost impossible to keep them straight. Don't believe me? Try and geographically identify every attack and thwarted attack and that has happened just since Obama was sworn in without looking anything up. Unless you can do that, you have no business laughing at people in other states who probably have only heard about Bowling Green, if at all, in relation to Iraqi terrorists being arrested there. 

Hillary's go to reporter from the New York Times made basic errors about recent terror attacks and the left doesn't care. Yet they somehow find it noteworthy that Trump voters doesn't correctly identify that Bowling Green was only the site of a thwarted terrorist plot when it pops up in the middle of a series of travel ban related questions from a pollster who misleads respondents into believing they are asking legitimate questions.  

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Sean Treacy   9 years ago

I get your point, completely.  What is really a terrorist attack and what is a nutjob attack?  There are foreign terrorists and there are domestic terrorists.  They called the Lone Oak high school attack a terrorist attack, when it was just some kid who fruited out.  (Lone Oak is near Paducah, KY., by the way.)  The State police responded in under 10 minutes and the scene was secured in under an hour.  Thank you, state guys, for all of your efforts and I salute you.  Thank you, too, brave postal workers, who contacted the FBI, who flew down there in a helicopter and x-rayed the packages for weapons.

No, I couldn't possibly identify off the top of my head, all of the attacks that have been dubbed terrorist attacks.  The term has become somewhat muddied by overuse.  At least to me.

My point was that these were caught, before they could do any harm, and if you got every immigrant in the state to band together, (good luck with that), there are ample people here to take them down.  We can't even go to the Patton Museum at Ft. Knox any more, because they don't accept KY driver's license as proof of residency or citizenship.  I don't suppose the fact that the driver's test is now in pictures, not English, has anything to do with that. /s  Which is a crock, but it is what it is...  BTW, I'm watching World War Z, and that's a scary scenario...  

NOTE:  I care about erroneous reporting and terrorist attacks.

Hope you have a great day!

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Dowser   9 years ago

Yeah, we can't get into the Ft Lewis military Museum either without special permission and the McChord Air Museum is specifically off limits to civilians.

I mean there is careful and then there is downright utopian....

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

It's not such a great museum anymore, anyway...  They moved all the WWII era tanks from Ft. Knox down to that giant military installation in GA or AL..  Can't think of the name, but I've been there.  Old age is hell.  I can't remember anything any more.  I think my hard drive is full.  Ft. Bragg doesn't sound right.  So, it's likely the other one.

It was really funny to compare the old tanks with modern cars, back in the day...  The Italian tanks were rickety, but at bit more rakish.  The German tanks were leather and polished everywhere with lots of intricate gadgets.  The Russian tanks looked as if they had been cut by a chainsaw, and had few creature comforts.  The English tanks had a mug holder for tea...  (or at least, that's how I remember it.)  And the Japanese tanks were made of thousands of tiny parts that rattled.  Funny.  We spent nearly a whole day there, reading and climbing on them.  The American tanks were just like our cars-- mass-produced, but comfortable, and sturdy. Or our OLD cars...  Someone designed them for business, and they were heavily armored, for the most part.  There were some early tanks that couldn't stand up to the Panzers, and you could see why-- not armored enough.  But later, we got in the groove.  I expected to see parts of old Buick fenders protruding, but we were better at that than I imagined...

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    9 years ago

It is well known that Fox News viewers and people who absorb right wing media are less knowledgeable about the real world than others. 

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Links to articles confirming this claim:

As two respected examples...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Dowser   9 years ago

Yeah I'm sorry to disappoint, you didn't need links just mention Time and Psychology Today and you already know what side they will come down on.

But they represent the most elite amongst us.

So I would have to ask sweets, you support the notion that everyone that supports other than the liberal plantation view is of less intelligence?

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

I don't.  I just keep reading about it.  I personally, don't think any such thing.  I believe there are rational and sane and intelligent people of both sides of the ideologies.

I certainly feel that you are rational and sane, and I certainly feel that I'm rational and sane.  I think we need to drop the extremes of both parties and take a leaf out of the common sense book.  On both sides.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Dowser   9 years ago

I agree, common sense is being drowned out in the rush to judgments regularly made today.

And I do not and never will agree with the ideal that "Niggers, (using the colloquial definition of a "Nigger") have smaller brains and so are less than the rest of us.

But we do hear it every day don't we.

and you know what? I'm proud to be one of those "Niggers" John keeps railing about.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

I've been called a "pale face", an "injun lover", a "nigger", too, among other things.  I marched, too, just a bit later than you-- in 1971.  I was even thrown in a paddy wagon, with my black friends.  So maybe I'm not normal.  We don't have a lot of black people out and about in the state, so it is pretty prejudiced out there--not that I partake or want any part of it.  Louisville has the highest percentage of the population of black people in the state.  So what?  It's a normal state of affairs.  It is, in fact, a REAL shock to go out and about in the state and never see anyone who is black.  I never think about it, except when confronted with so much whiteness.  We see a lot of Mexican people, as well as people from Bosnia, Samoa, China, Japan, Ethiopia, Egypt, Saudi Arabia, Holland, France, England, Spain, Nigeria, India, Pakistan, etc., mainly students or professors-- or doctors...  I live in a college town, so you expect a little more diversity.

I was taught to never use the N-word, and even writing it in quotes makes me feel bad.  I have a lot of faults, and I'm sure that somewhere deep down, I am prejudiced.  But I fight against it each and every day and try to best to be accepting of peoples.  

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Dowser   9 years ago

That is exactly what I'm talking about my friend.....

It's why I luv ya and am proud to call you friend!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Nowhere Man   9 years ago

Ditto to you, too!  Big hugs

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Dowser   9 years ago

Links to articles confirming this claim:

This is funny. No, your chosen articles don't. Not at all.  Just classic. 

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Sean Treacy   9 years ago

That's fine.  I have stated that I don't believe it, anyway.  So where is your beef with me?

 
 

Who is online

evilone
Nerm_L


88 visitors