The GOP’s fuzzy Mideast plan
Critics of the way President Obama is dealing with the Islamic State should be required to specify what alternative steps they would take and how their strategies would make a difference.
Republican presidential candidates are unanimous in charging that Obamas handling of Iraq and Syria has been all wrong. But when pressed to lay out a specific plan of action and explain why they believe it would work better than what Obama is doing now, they tend to mumble and look for ways to change the subject.
Oh, theres no shortage of tough-guy rhetoric that sounds as if it were stolen from a big-budget Hollywood action movie. Actually, some of it was stolen from a big-budget Hollywood action movie: Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) appropriates Liam Neesons signature line from the movie Taken, shifts it from the first-person singular to the plural, and declares to terrorists, We will look for you, we will find you and we will kill you.
Thats actually a pretty good way to describe Obamas campaign of assassination by drone strikes. Rubio describes the presidents policies as a failure, yet he seems to promise more of the same.
Rick Santorum , who made his candidacy official this week, says the way to deal with the Islamic State is to load our bombers up and bomb them back to the 7th century. If you take him literally, he seems to be saying that we ought to destroy Iraqs Anbar province in order to save it.
But do we also blow up Mosul, one of Iraqs biggest cities? And the half of Syria that is under Islamic State control? Someone should inform Santorum that Syrian dictator Bashar al-Assad has been trying this approach since the civil war began and that it hasnt worked.
Sen. Lindsey Graham (S.C.) is the one GOP hopeful with an actual plan of action. He wants to increase the number of U.S. troops in Iraq currently fewer than 3,000 to about 10,000. Graham says that this would allow us
fewer than 3,000 to about 10,000. Graham says that this would allow us to train the Iraqi army at a faster pace, give them capability that they dont have.
But the problem isnt that the training process is going too slowly. As Defense Secretary Ashton Carter pointed out after the fall of Ramadi , what the Iraqi troops evidently lacked was the will to fight . Thats not something you get from a field officers manual.

So far the GOP candidates foreign policy as it applies to the war in Iraq is simply to say that the President is doing it all wrong, without saying what they would do different. They bitch, bu do not have a plan. I will give some of them credit for saying that would send in our troops to destroy ISIS. Which of course will not work because we don't have all of troops we had during the Iraq war, there wold be little, if any "Coalition of the willing" (hell I doubt even the Brits would join in) to help and the American people can not and will not stomach another invasion of Iraq, considering the first one was one of the worlds biggest fuck ups in history if the first place. So that's not going to happen. It sounds like good tought red meat on the campaign trail, but it is not going to happen.
Obama has had a precise plan about the middle east from the beginning . It basically involves bending over backwards to muslims at every opportunity :
Very, very off topic. This thread is about what the republican candidates plans are for dealing with Iraq. If you post another of topic post, I will delete it. Talking about what you think the president is ding wrong is not the topic. The topic is what plans do the GOP candidates have to do deal with theIraq war better? If they were president.Don't do it again. Thank you. One warning.
Go ahead. Post her plan and compare it to any republican candidate's plan you want. The republicans as a group have no plan.
Your post was deleted for being off topic. You were warned this is about not what the President is doing. The topic is what plans do the GOP candidates have to deal with Iraq, not how the President is handling it.
Not to put too fine a point on it, but wouldn't a fuzzy plan (by any candidate of any political persuasion) be a continuation of the strategy that has been employed for the past decade plus?
Can a moderator moderate an article he is participating in now?
Actually, Mickey is the articles author. He can have what ever he needs done on his article. So the issue isn't moderating his article.
The real issue is should an articles author, having moderator powers be moderating his own article bypassing the group policy?
The rest of us that post articles (non-moderators) have to ask...
He can ask another moderator to take a look at a comment and if it warrants removal, then the seeder can have it removed. No big deal here. I didn't see the comment. I assume it is saved in the archive. I've seen the comment now and it should have been removed.
Logic and evidence to back it up, what a novel idea.
I think each candidate running for office should answer the question as to what they would do and that goes for all candidates.
A person can get a mod to delete a comment that is off topic. It would have been better form, if MM got a mod, just so no one could claim that he was inappropriate in the removal of a comment, but there is nothing in the CoC saying otherwise. My suggestion to MM is to get a mod in the future, so that no one will think his actions are an overstep of the rules.
Thank you...
Six
I agree
And I would pose a question for you as well - "Isn't Hillary (as the SoS for most of the Obama administrationto date) a major contributing architect to the fuzzy strategy in the Mid East as it exists today?
MM
You have violated the rules of the CoC by deleting my comment . You are required to get a moderator to do it . Therefore I will repost it .
Comment removed "off topic" [ph]He deleted not just my comment but also my name . That is illegal aside from the fact that it should have been done in purple .
Suggestion my ASS Perrie. This is exactly the thing that I got my dick slapped about when I was a mod. Publicly.
Moderation here is becomingrathertotalitarianof late. Deleted articles, mis-application of the CoC, now moderators deleting comments in their own articles?
Do I need to write another META?
Yea but don't tell her supporters that. (not like they would listen anyhow)
So do I. I think Rand is the only one that has so far.
Understood Perrie and I will do so in the future. It was late and no other mod was available and in my own defense he had posted one off topic post and I waned him not to do it again and that it would be deleted.
The subject of this article is what are the plans of the GOP candidates to handle Iraq if they become President. The current President is not the subject. I will be asking another moderator to delete your comment as off topic. You're video is also off topic and that's where I warned you. I made the mistake of letting you put one in my article. That won't happen again.
My bad. I apologize for not getting another moderator to delete Petey's off topic posts (which off are topic and he was warned). I will next time.
Bruce, you are absolutely right. I should have got another moderator to delete Petey's off topic posts. My apologizes to the group.
Randy, you can not remove someone comment box because it can't be restored, if it is decided to be on topic. Please do not do it agian.
Understood and it will not happen again. I am sincerely sorry.
The comment has been re-posted on the following page.
Bruce,
First, I was unaware that Petey's comment box was removed. That is a Violation and he just got his slapping, publicly. I did my due diligence in my previous comment to MM.
As for the comment, MM warned Petey as per the CoC that his comment was off topic and what the topic was.
Petey proceeded to posted another off topic comment.
MM should have waited for another mod to delete the comment and I have warned him to do so in the future. But since Petey was warned what the topic was, off topic (as per the CoC), You are correct that MM should have waited for a mod, but the net results are the same, as the comment is off topic.
I will strive to make sure that the mods are following the letter of the CoC.
Yes, but she hasn't been SOS in well over two years and a whole lot has happened in Iraq in those two years. I would like her to answer the question also, however the GOP candidates all seem to be more then happy to say what is wrong in Iraq, but none of them (if you have Paul's position I would be very interested in reading it) ever say what they would do to help solve the situation and that's what I'm asking in this thread. It's easy to sit on the sidelines and throw rocks, but what would you do if you were the one in the Oval Office? Whenever one of them is asked they just go right back to saying how screwed up the President is making it, without saying what they would do (realistically) different?
What little you do get out of them sounds pretty much divided between what is being done now or a lot of tough talk that is empty of real ideas.
Thank you Perrie, for addressing this issue, and making sure the moderators are informed and in compliance with the CoC.
The issue is not merely not following the CoC . It is about biased moderation . There is no clearer example of biased moderation than comment deletion in your own article .
No harm, no foul. Still friends.