WASHINGTON -- American law enforcement and intelligence agencies are examining intercepted communications and financial transactions as part of a broad investigation into possible links between Russian officials and associates of President-elect Donald J. Trump, including his former campaign chairman Paul Manafort, current and former senior American officials said.
The continuing counterintelligence investigation means that Mr. Trump will take the oath of office on Friday with his associates under investigation and after the intelligence agencies concluded that the Russian government had worked to help elect him. As president, Mr. Trump will oversee those agencies and have the authority to redirect or stop at least some of these efforts.
It is not clear whether the intercepted communications had anything to do with Mr. Trump's campaign, or Mr. Trump himself. It is also unclear whether the inquiry has anything to do with an investigation into the hacking of the Democratic National Committee's computers and other attempts to disrupt the elections in November. The American government has concluded that the Russian government was responsible for a broad computer hacking campaign, including the operation against the D.N.C.
The counterintelligence investigation centers at least in part on the business dealings that some of the president-elect's past and present advisers have had with Russia. Mr. Manafort has done business in Ukraine and Russia. Some of his contacts there were under surveillance by the National Security Agency for suspected links to Russia's Federal Security Service, one of the officials said.
Mr. Manafort is among at least three Trump campaign advisers whose possible links to Russia are under scrutiny. Two others are Carter Page, a businessman and former foreign policy adviser to the campaign, and Roger Stone, a longtime Republican operative.
The F.B.I. is leading the investigations, aided by the National Security Agency, the C.I.A. and the Treasury Department's financial crimes unit. The investigators have accelerated their efforts in recent weeks but have found no conclusive evidence of wrongdoing, the officials said. One official said intelligence reports based on some of the wiretapped communications had been provided to the White House.
Counterintelligence investigations examine the connections between American citizens and foreign governments. Those connections can involve efforts to steal state or corporate secrets, curry favor with American government leaders or influence policy. It is unclear which Russian officials are under investigation, or what particular conversations caught the attention of American eavesdroppers. The legal standard for opening these investigations is low, and prosecutions are rare.
"We have absolutely no knowledge of any investigation or even a basis for such an investigation," said Hope Hicks, a spokeswoman for the Trump transition.
In an emailed statement Thursday evening, Mr. Manafort called allegations that he had interactions with the Russian government a "Democrat Party dirty trick and completely false."
"I have never had any relationship with the Russian government or any Russian officials. I was never in contact with anyone, or directed anyone to be in contact with anyone," he said.
"On the 'Russian hacking of the D.N.C.,"' he said, "my only knowledge of it is what I have read in the papers."
The decision to open the investigations was not based on a dossier of salacious, uncorroborated allegations that were compiled by a former British spy working for a Washington research firm. The F.B.I. is also examining the allegations in that dossier, and a summary of its contents was provided to Mr. Trump earlier this month.
Representatives of the agencies involved declined to comment. Of the half-dozen current and former officials who confirmed the existence of the investigations, some said they were providing information because they feared the new administration would obstruct their efforts. All spoke on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the cases.
Numerous news outlets, including The New York Times, have reported on the F.B.I. investigations into Mr. Trump's advisers. BBC and then McClatchy revealed the existence of a multiagency working group to coordinate investigations across the government.
The continuing investigation again puts the F.B.I. director, James B. Comey, in the middle of a politically fraught investigation. Democrats have sharply criticized Mr. Comey's handling of the investigation into Hillary Clinton's use of a private email server. Mrs. Clinton has said his decision to reveal the existence of new emails late in the campaign cost her the election.
The F.B.I. investigation into Mr. Manafort began last spring, and was an outgrowth of a criminal investigation into his work for a pro-Russian political party in Ukraine and for the country's former president, Viktor F. Yanukovych. In August, The Times reported that Mr. Manafort's name had surfaced in a secret ledger that showed he had been paid millions in undisclosed cash payments. The Associated Press has reported that his work for Ukraine included a secret lobbying effort in Washington aimed at influencing American news organizations and government officials.
Mr. Stone, a longtime friend of Mr. Trump's, said in a speech in Florida last summer that he had communicated with Julian Assange, the founder of WikiLeaks, the anti-secrecy group that published the hacked Democratic emails. During the speech, Mr. Stone predicted further leaks of documents, a prediction that came true within weeks.
In a brief interview on Thursday, Mr. Stone said he had never visited Russia and had no Russian clients. He said that he had worked in Ukraine for a pro-Western party, but that any assertion that he had ties to Russian intelligence was "nonsense" and "totally false."
"The whole thing is a canard," he said. "I have no Russian influences."
The Senate intelligence committee has started its own investigation into Russia's purported attempts to disrupt the election. The committee's inquiry is broad, and will include an examination of Russian hacking and possible ties between people associated with Mr. Trump's campaign and Russia.
Investigators are also scrutinizing people on the periphery of Mr. Trump's campaign, such as Mr. Page, a former Merrill Lynch banker who founded Global Energy Capital, an investment firm in New York that has done business with Russia.
In an interview on Thursday, Mr. Page expressed bewilderment about why he might be under investigation. He blamed a smear campaign -- that he said was orchestrated by Mrs. Clinton -- for media speculation about the nature of his ties to Russia.
"I did nothing wrong, for the 5,000th time," he said. His adversaries, he added, are "pulling a page out of the Watergate playbook."
The lingering investigations will pose a test for Senator Jeff Sessions, Republican of Alabama, who has been nominated for attorney general. If Mr. Sessions is confirmed, he will for a time be the only person in the government authorized to seek foreign intelligence wiretaps on American soil.
Mr. Sessions said at his confirmation hearing that he would recuse himself from any investigations involving Mrs. Clinton. He was not asked whether he would do so in cases involving associates of Mr. Trump.
I posted the entire NYT story just to show that I left nothing out.
Now what does all this indicate?
Gateway Pundit , and Breitbart are using this Jan 20 NYT story to vindicate the Donald Trump tweets, but it does nothing of the kind.
There is nothing, not one word, in the NYT story that indicates that "wiretapping" may have been done at trump Tower, OR of Donald Trump's phones or other devices.
To the contrary, the NYT story specifically mentions the names of three people who came under surveillance in the counter-intelligence investigation. Paul Manafort, Carter Page , and Roger Stone.
None of those three people had an office in Trump Tower during the time of this investigation.
SO, the NYT story of Jan 20 does not really serve to support trump's claims. But Gateway Pundit and Breitbart, two of the most dishonest "news organizations" on the internet, are once again misleading their gullible and ignorant readership.
Just look at the comment section of Gateway Pundit to see the truth of my claim.
TRUMP SAID THE FOLLOWING … which in my mind makes his wiretap allegation POLITICAL … and an allegation without evidence.
The president also said "this whole narrative is a way of saving face for Democrats losing an election that everyone thought they were supposed to win. The Democrats are overplaying their hand. They lost the election and now, they have lost their grip on reality."
I am trying to compile all the Republican HEDGED COMMENTS with regard to Trump's allegations … NOT A SINGLE ONE I'VE FOUND THUS FAR … outright defends Trump's wiretap allegations.
The rats aren't leaving the ship altogether … but it appears they know they're in the neighborhood of SHIT CREEK!
I've known about Jim Hoft (& his weblog, Gateway Pundit) for years.
He is a total nutcase.
Jim Hoft, among his many lies, is the one that was debunked just a few hours after he stated it, namely, that the SHOOTER OF GABBY GIFFORDS WAS A DEMOCRAT!
But wait … there's more.
Republicans rely on Breitbart and other FAKE NEWS outlets to feed their zeal-without-knowledge base.
The Gateway Pundit’s Hoft Says Site Will Have White House Correspondent
Trump Heavily Promotes Gateway Pundit
Trump Is Favoring Propagandists For WH Press Access
Media Have Frequently Criticized Gateway Pundit For Errors
22 TIMES JIM HOFT AND THE GATEWAY PUNDIT WERE ABSURDLY WRONG :
Gateway Pundit Attacked Wrong Asian Woman For “Sneaking Photos” At Hearing
Gateway Pundit Claimed Picture Of Cleveland's NBA Title Parade Was Trump Rally
Gateway Pundit Pushed Fake Story About Bus Of Paid Protesters
Gateway Pundit Fell For Hoax About Paid Protest Group
Gateway Pundit Falsely Claimed John Podesta Said “It’s OK For Illegals To Vote With Driver’s License”
Gateway Pundit Posted -- Then Removed -- Article Claiming Clinton Campaign Manager Deleted Tweets Because Of FBI Announcement
Gateway Pundit Falsely Claimed Obama Made Confederate Flag Pin In 2012
Gateway Pundit Falsely Claimed CNN Lightened Photo Of Fort Lauderdale Shooter
Gateway Pundit Fell For Fake Photo Of Oregon Shooter
Gateway Pundit Claimed “Tests Show" Obama’s Birth Certificate Is “A Forgery”
Gateway Pundit Fell For Parody Article About Obama Birth Certificate
Gateway Pundit Falsely Claimed Michelle Obama Deleted Hillary Tweets
Gateway Pundit Fell For Twitter Joke About Postal Voter Fraud
Gateway Pundit Suggested Hillary Clinton Had “A Seizure On Camera”
Gateway Pundit Fell For Racist Hoax Video About Anti-Trump Vandalism
Gateway Pundit Lie: Trump Would Have Won Popular Vote If Not For “Illegal Vote Tally”
Gateway Pundit Thought Closed Captioning On Jumbotron Was Applause Instructions
Gateway Pundit Falsely Claimed Obama Was Going To "Ban Sport Fishing"
Gateway Pundit Falsely Claimed Obamacare Allows “‘Forced’ Home Inspections”
Gateway Pundit Suggested Obama Was “Photoshopped Into Famous Situation Room Photo” Taken During Bin Laden Raid
Gateway Pundit Fell For Fake Photo Claiming Obama Patted Melania Trump On The Butt
Gateway Pundit Fell For Fake Facebook Page To Claim Mass Shooter Was Obama Fan
___________________________________________________________________________
I am seriously considering challenging the Clinton-haters to post, one-at-a-time, her "lies" so that I can address them; no doubt, some of her alleged lies, are, in fact, lies. But many, if not most, are FAKE from the usual sources.
Stay tuned.
And Mark Levin needs to be hit with a libel suit (even though it's near impossible to make one stick for "political speak"; but Levin's setting off of Trump, indirectly, has made America's security more vulnerable as the world sees Trump as an anger-management candidate.
" There are transcripts that provide very helpful, very critical insights into whether or not Russian intelligence and senior Russian political leaders, including Vladimir Putin, were cooperating, were colluding with the Trump campaign at the highest levels to influence the outcome of our election."
Senator Coons March 3
What transcripts is he talking about and how do transcripts of the "highest levels" exist without surveillance?
Manafort, Page and Stone were not at Trump Tower nor working for the campaign during the time period mentioned in the NYT story , or for that matter, in Breitbart or Gateway Pundit.
Trump pulled this crap out of his ass based on his reading right wing news stories , in particular the story about Mark Levin that was in Breitbart.
Then Trump went even farther than Breitbart did and claimed that Obama had Trump Tower, and Trump's phones, bugged. He accused the last president of a felony. With NO evidence.
Trump is the most irresponsible president we have ever seen.
Sean , that does not bother you. How is your conscience these days?
That didn't answer my question.
What is the basis for Senator Coons claim of transcripts revealing a link between Putin and the Trump campaign?
You would have to ask him.
Not really the topic of this seed.
Yeah. a Democratic Senator claiming the existence of secret transcripts proving a connection between the Trump campaign and the Russians is totally not related to a story about whether the Trump campaign was under surveillance fro illegal contact with Russians.
The transcripts are classified; they were presented to Congress in closed session and they are not permitted to divulge specifics.
The transcripts are classified; they were presented to Congress in closed session and they are not permitted to divulge specifics.
So wiretapping transcripts exist then? Which means Trump is right.
Also, what's inaccurate about the Britbart article? Specifically.
The New York Times has inadvertently attacked the credibility of its own reporting on the Obama Administration’s investigation of Russia and now-President Donald Trump.
Off the top of my head, that would be one. As I said, the NYT article does not even mention Trump Tower, or the president as being targets of the surveillance. So when they come out now and say Trump is making false charges against Obama, that is their basis.
Sean, show us any news story from any source, other than Mark Levin or Breitbart, that supports Trump's claims.
I meant the Breitbart article that Trump supposedly relied on. The one that matters. What specifically, was inaccurate about that one?
Also, what's inaccurate about the Britbart article? Specifically.
We may not only get the answer to that, but, if it turns out to be typical Breitbart bullshit, we might get a President Pence.
We may not only get the answer to that, but, if it turns out to be typical Breitbart bullshit,
The breitbart article that matters is a compilation of reports from the MSM. what's inaccurate about it?
The breitbart article that matters is a compilation of reports from the MSM. what's inaccurate about it?
Wrong question? The question is and has been, what if anything is accurate regarding Trump's (Levin's) allegation?
That's the only question.
So there's nothing wrong with Breitbart. It's the reporting of the New York Times, BBC etc that you have a problem with. Yet there's all this name calling directed at Breitbart, but no one can point out a single thing wrong in it's summary of MSM reporting.
Strange.
Trump is doing more gaslighting.
IF a FISA warrant was obtained by the FBI to investigate Russian meddling in the election, and if it as a by product included Manafort, Page and Carter, and possibly Flynn, that is their problem.
What was the FBI supposed to do? Not investigate because Trump might whine about it someday?
Gateway Pundit and Breibart, and Infowars and others on the right, are not reliable news sources. They are the opposite of reliable.
The fool Trump wants to turn the country on it's head for his own aggrandizement and amusement. It is insane.
According to the New York Times, FBI director James Comey has now asked the Justice Department to publicly reject Trump’s claim .
WASHINGTON — The F.B.I. director, James B. Comey, asked the Justice Department this weekend to publicly reject President Trump’s assertion that President Barack Obama ordered the tapping of Mr. Trump’s phones, senior American officials said on Sunday. Mr. Comey has argued that the highly charged claim is false and must be corrected, they said, but the department has not released any such statement.
Mr. Comey, who made the request on Saturday after Mr. Trump leveled his allegation on Twitter, has been working to get the Justice Department to knock down the claim because it falsely insinuates that the F.B.I. broke the law, the officials said.
According to the New York Times, FBI director James Comey has now asked the Justice Department to publicly reject Trump’s claim .
WASHINGTON — The F.B.I. director, James B. Comey, asked the Justice Department this weekend to publicly reject President Trump’s assertion that President Barack Obama ordered the tapping of Mr. Trump’s phones, senior American officials said on Sunday. Mr. Comey has argued that the highly charged claim is false and must be corrected, they said, but the department has not released any such statement.
Mr. Comey, who made the request on Saturday after Mr. Trump leveled his allegation on Twitter, has been working to get the Justice Department to knock down the claim because it falsely insinuates that the F.B.I. broke the law, the officials said.
( hat tip: LGF )
According to the New York Times, FBI director James Comey has now asked the Justice Department to publicly reject Trump’s claim .
WASHINGTON — The F.B.I. director, James B. Comey, asked the Justice Department this weekend to publicly reject President Trump’s assertion that President Barack Obama ordered the tapping of Mr. Trump’s phones, senior American officials said on Sunday. Mr. Comey has argued that the highly charged claim is false and must be corrected, they said, but the department has not released any such statement.
Mr. Comey, who made the request on Saturday after Mr. Trump leveled his allegation on Twitter, has been working to get the Justice Department to knock down the claim because it falsely insinuates that the F.B.I. broke the law, the officials said.
( hat tip: LGF )
And it's not likely that Sessions who is running the DOJ will make such a statement. It's more likely that Comey will will end up being forced out of his office.
Comey will will end up being forced out of his office.
Well, he should have been gone a long time ago when he failed to request charges against Hillary, if for nothing else than destroying evidence that had been subpoenaed and I'm being very generous here.
According to the New York Times, FBI director James Comey has now asked the Justice Department to publicly reject Trump’s claim .
WASHINGTON — The F.B.I. director, James B. Comey, asked the Justice Department this weekend to publicly reject President Trump’s assertion that President Barack Obama ordered the tapping of Mr. Trump’s phones, senior American officials said on Sunday. Mr. Comey has argued that the highly charged claim is false and must be corrected, they said, but the department has not released any such statement.
Mr. Comey, who made the request on Saturday after Mr. Trump leveled his allegation on Twitter, has been working to get the Justice Department to knock down the claim because it falsely insinuates that the F.B.I. broke the law, the officials said.
( hat tip: LGF )
Fact check: Trump's 'evidence' for Obama wiretap claims relies on sketchy, anonymously sourced reports
Our Washington Post colleague Robert Costa has reported that White House aides have internally circulated an article on Breitbart titled: "Mark Levin to Congress: Investigate Obama's 'Silent Coup' vs. Trump." Breitbart is a right-leaning news organization that is a rather unreliable source of information. Often the material that is published is derivative and twisted in misleading ways.
However, a White House spokesman told The Fact Checker that the White House instead is relying on reports "from BBC, Heat St., New York Times, Fox News, among others." He provided a list of five articles.
Let's explore the sources of the president's claim.
The Facts
We are going to start with the Breitbart article, which lists two key data points that appear to relate to the president's claim:
" June 2016: FISA request. The Obama administration files a request with the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISA) to monitor communications involving Donald Trump and several advisers. The request, uncharacteristically, is denied.
" October : FISA request. The Obama administration submits a new, narrow request to the FISA court, now focused on a computer server in Trump Tower suspected of links to Russian banks. No evidence is found - but the wiretaps continue, ostensibly for national security reasons, Andrew McCarthy at National Review later notes. The Obama administration is now monitoring an opposing presidential campaign using the high-tech surveillance powers of the federal intelligence services."
But these data points are not based on reporting by Breitbart. Instead Breitbart links to a report which appeared in Heat Street, another right-leaning news organization: "EXCLUSIVE: FBI 'Granted FISA Warrant' Covering Trump Camp's Ties To Russia." It was written by Louise Mensch, a former Tory member of the British Parliament and an independent journalist. This is one of the news reports identified by the White House, and it's the most important one.
This article claimed : "Two separate sources with links to the counter-intelligence community have confirmed to Heat Street that the FBI sought, and was granted, a FISA court warrant in October, giving counter-intelligence permission to examine the activities of 'U.S. persons' in Donald Trump's campaign with ties to Russia."
Mensch claimed that the warrant was related to an FBI investigation of a possible secret channel of email communication from the Trump Organization to a Russian bank - an investigation that, as far as anyone knows, went nowhere.
"The FISA warrant was granted in connection with the investigation of suspected activity between the server (in Trump Tower) and two banks, SVB Bank and Alfa Bank. However, it is thought in the intelligence community that the warrant covers any 'US person' connected to this investigation, and thus covers Donald Trump and at least three further men who have either formed part of his campaign or acted as his media surrogates," Mensch wrote.
The Washington Post for months has sought to confirm this report of a FISA warrant related to the Trump campaign but has been unable to do so. Presumably other U.S. news organizations have tried to do so as well. So one has to take this claim with a huge dose of skepticism. Indeed, the New York Times reported before the election that the FBI "ultimately concluded that there could be an innocuous explanation, like a marketing email or spam, for the computer contacts" with the Russian banks.
Interestingly, as far as we can tell, only two other reports have touched on this FISA claim, and they also have British connections. One is a report in the BBC from January, which the White House also cited as a source. The BBC reported:
"Lawyers from the National Security Division in the Department of Justice then drew up an application. They took it to the secret US court that deals with intelligence, the FISA court, named after the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act. They wanted permission to intercept the electronic records from two Russian banks.
"Their first application, in June, was rejected outright by the judge. They returned with a more narrowly drawn order in July and were rejected again. Finally, before a new judge, the order was granted, on 15 October, three weeks before election day.
"Neither Mr Trump nor his associates are named in the FISA order, which would only cover foreign citizens or foreign entities - in this case the Russian banks. But ultimately, the investigation is looking for transfers of money from Russia to the United States, each one, if proved, a felony offense.
"A lawyer - outside the Department of Justice but familiar with the case - told me that three of Mr Trump's associates were the subject of the inquiry. 'But it's clear this is about Trump,' he said."
Finally, there was a report in The Guardian, which reported on the supposed June FISA request, but could not confirm the October one. (The White House did not cite the Guardian.)
"The Guardian has learned that the FBI applied for a warrant from the foreign intelligence surveillance (FISA) court over the summer in order to monitor four members of the Trump team suspected of irregular contacts with Russian officials. The FISA court turned down the application asking FBI counter-intelligence investigators to narrow its focus. According to one report, the FBI was finally granted a warrant in October, but that has not been confirmed, and it is not clear whether any warrant led to a full investigation."
You know, we're not getting anywhere here when you use the Washington Post to discredit another source, AMac.
Yeah, Six,
Go with Breitbart.
From now on, when one of you Trump ass-kissers questions me on something I've posted, come with a specific rebuttal rather than a challenge to my information without any rebuttal.
After all, that's how you play it.
Don't agree or believe the accuracy of anything I post … DO YOUR HOMEWORK AND PROVE ME WRONG.
Otherwise, amuse yourselves with weak ass commentary on my font selections.
So your argument is that brietbart accurately reflects MSM news reports that were thinly sourced. Why did the MSM publish shuch shoddily supported allegations?
so you believe trump and breitbart should know the MSM lies or makes up stories without doing their dilligence.
Don't agree or believe the accuracy of anything I post … DO YOUR HOMEWORK AND PROVE ME WRONG.
Mac, you're the one making the statements, IT'S NOT UP TO ANYONE TO PROVE YOU'RE WRONG, IT'S UP TO YOU TO PROVE THAT YOU'RE RIGHT, and I don't mean with biased sources like WAPO (or even Breitbart).
That said, I see little or no actual evidence that the Obama administration wiretapped the Trump campaign. Of course, that's exactly the same amount of actual evidence (little or none) that the Trump campaign colluded with the Russians, and yet stories seem to abound, here and elsewhere, that they did exactly that.
MORAL TO BE LEARNED: Don't throw around bullshit accusations unless you want some of the bullshit thrown right back in your face. Trump seems to be learning how to play the game.
Don't agree or believe the accuracy of anything I post … DO YOUR HOMEWORK AND PROVE ME WRONG.
Mac, you're the one making the statements, IT'S NOT UP TO ANYONE TO PROVE YOU'RE WRONG, IT'S UP TO YOU TO PROVE THAT YOU'RE RIGHT, and I don't mean with biased sources like WAPO (or even Breitbart).
That said, I see little or no actual evidence that the Obama administration wiretapped the Trump campaign. Of course, that's exactly the same amount of actual evidence (little or none) that the Trump campaign colluded with the Russians, and yet stories seem to abound, here and elsewhere, that they did exactly that.
MORAL TO BE LEARNED: Don't throw around bullshit accusations unless you want some of the bullshit thrown right back in your face. Trump seems to be learning how to play the game.
Let me unpack this Trump-like-in-your-face bad argument.
There is such a phenomenon as "Going on the Record," meaning …
"to publicly and officially tell people your opinion about something"
This is a matter of stating with integrity and good faith; the difference between Breitbart and other right-wing bullshit sources, generally resides in the tendency of one URGING FOR AN INVESTIGATION TO VALIDATE OR PUT TO REST, IT'S POSITION vs. RESISTING FURTHER SCRUTINY …
Like this …
Of course, that's exactly the same amount of actual evidence (little or none) that the Trump campaign colluded with the Russians, and yet stories seem to abound, here and elsewhere, that they did exactly that.
No fewer than 17 security entities have verified the interference of Russian hacking and connections between Trump operatives, Russian officials, oligarchs, Russian money laundering and other questionable dots to connect.
And while Democrats and people like myself urge bi-partisan/special prosecutor investigations TO DETERMINE THE TRUTH, Republicans and Trump folks look the other way, or, ironically, simultaneously declare "there's no evidence" while making it clear they don't want to see a legitimate process TO LEARN WHAT EVIDENCE DOES OR DOES NOT EXIST!
MORAL TO BE LEARNED: Don't throw around bullshit accusations unless you want some of the bullshit thrown right back in your face. Trump seems to be learning how to play the game.
If I take a position … if I go the record and OWN MY POSITION … unlike the "alternative facts" crowd, I urge any/all who disagree, to post counter-information rather than one-line quips, insults, dismissive comments, rhetorical questions (to which they have no answers).
Those who want the truth keep looking for it until they find it … knowing it may not match their expectations or preferences. Contrarily, those who fear the truth … denigrate the ones demanding it.
"The truth is incontrovertible. Malice may attack it, ignorance may deride it, but in the end, there it is." _ Winston Churchill
No fewer than 17 security entities have verified the interference of Russian hacking and connections between Trump operatives, Russian officials, oligarchs, Russian money laundering and other questionable dots to connect.
Name the entities and quote their reports, including the names of the agents who made the reports. Otherwise there is no evidence, just speculation.
Name the entities and quote their reports, including the names of the agents who made the reports. Otherwise there is no evidence, just speculation.
Are we doing the Man Behind the Curtain's "Not so fast -- Bring me the Witch's Broom"?
Here's my response.
_______________________________________________
The United States Intelligence Community has concluded that the Russian government interfered in the 2016 United States elections . [3] The report stated that Russian President Vladimir Putin ordered a campaign to influence the U.S. presidential election, weaken U.S. democracy, "denigrate Secretary Hillary Clinton ," and weaken her electoral chances against Trump. [4]
The Office of the Director of National Intelligence (DNI), representing 17 intelligence agencies, and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) jointly stated that Russia hacked the Democratic National Committee (DNC) and leaked its documents to WikiLeaks . [5] In early January 2017, Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper testified before a Senate committee that Russia’s alleged meddling in the 2016 presidential campaign went beyond hacking, and included disinformation and the dissemination of fake news often promoted on social media. [6]
U.S. intelligence agencies assessed that Putin "personally directed" the operation. [7] CIA Director John Brennan , FBI Director James Comey and DNI James R. Clapper agreed on the "scope, nature and intent" of Russia's alleged interference to assist Trump. [8] Several cybersecurity firms stated that the cyberattacks were committed by Russian intelligence groups Fancy Bear and Cozy Bear . [9] In October 2016, Obama used the red phone line to directly contact Putin and issue a warning to him regarding the cyber attacks . [10] Russian government figures have repeatedly denied and condemned the allegations of interference in the United States electoral process. [11] [12] [13]
Make a definitive comment, Sean. Feel free to take anything I post with which you take issue and explain your specific objection ... and correct it.
Make a definitive comment, Sean
You have yet to demonstrate any lies or mistakes by Breitbart. Attacking the reporting of the sources, like the BBC and NYT, that Breitbart relied on only speaks to Breitbart's judgment in relying on the MSM to report facts.
Is that your point? That Breitbart and everyone else should never rely on the reporting of the MSM?
Sean, what evidence does Donald Trump have that Obama ordered his phones tapped?
Sean, what evidence does Donald Trump have that Obama ordered his phones tapped?
And the question is" "What is "None", Alex."
Been through this with you before; my expertise is Labor Law; I did not require a law degree to qualify for my career in collective bargaining and labor relations; that said, I know a hell of a lot more about what I post than you do.
You never make an argument of merit; you're Trumpesque in the way you use insults and deflection.
You do occasionally imply that you'd pummel a detractor ... It's good that you change it up once in a while.
Rather than act as if you know more than those who actually take definitive positions on issues, show what you actually do know about a given issue.
I've tried to be civil with you while you prefer confrontation, not confrontation with counter point argumentation, rather with mockery, insults and intermittent truly funny stuff.
Stick with the funny stuff rather than denigrate people's backgrounds based on what you think you know.
Should you be tempted to evaluate other parts of my education and career, bone up on biology/aquatic ecology, art history, photography, computer graphics, newspaper editor, editorial writing and publishing ... so your talking down will come with a bit of knowledge.
Seriously, Dude, debate the issues with me and avoid the personal stuff.
Almost since he announced he candidacy for the Presidency Donald Trump had declared war on both the media and, more importantly, the intelligence agencies. Of course neither of these things really mattered as long as he was a candidate. Other countries could look at his comments as the semi-mad ravings of a semi-lunatic. Of someone who was not looking to become the POTUS. Still a fluke happened and he, thanks to Russia, obtained enough electoral college votes to sort of claim the White House. The upshot of all of this has been that Donald Trump has been thrust into a world that he never expected to be in, that he does not understand, that he is lost in, that scares the hell out of him and that he is in way over his head in and, quite frankly, honestly wishes he could get out of. He is a scared young teenager trapped on a very scary carnival ride that is many times more worse then he ever thought it could possibly be.
He knows no evidence to back up this wire tapping claim. The simple reason is that he believed a clam that Mark Levin just pulled out of his ass and he fell for it. He is in the position to where he could order the FBI to reveal any and all evidence from the FBI that would show one way or another if Barack Obama wire tapped Trump. It is in his power and does not require a Congressional investigation. All he has to do is to ask or order it. That's it. No drama. No question. Simple. However he will not do it because he knows that it did not happen and that he is either a very clever person who is lying his ass off to distract the press and hoping it will be forgotten or he actually believes this theory and with absolutely no evidence, thinks it is really true in which case he is insane. Take your pick. Is the man pretending to be the President a compulsive, pathological liar or is he insane. Those are the only two choices and neither is a real winner for America,
Then there is the very real fact that he has attacked the press, which the better ones, such as The Wall Street Journal, The Washington Post, The New York Times, The Los Angels Times and the BBC who have very, very, very good investigative reporters with sources that they have developed over decades. If you attack them there will be a small number of your followers that will look at these sources as fake news. However, in the end the bulk of Americans will turn toward long time trusted news sources for the truth. If you make the investigative reporter divisions of these sources angry, you will be sorry. They will make you pay and pay big time.
It is the same and much, much more with his attacks on the intelligence agencies. Thee agencies stick together. If he attacks the FBI (which s what he is doing) he might just as well be attacking the CIA, the National Intelligence Agency, Naval Intelligence, Army intelligence, Air Force OSI, and on and on and on. If you attack one, they will all draw together and hurt you and hurt you badly. And I am amazed that Donald Trump actually thought he could get away with comparing the FBI to Nazis and not expect a possibly career ending backlash from the rest of the intelligence agencies. I would be more surprised if they didn't take him down. He is getting what he should have expected and deserves.
Now how are going to get anywhere here Randy with you talking such nonsense?
The mainstream media has been pushing this Trump and the Russians forever it seems. Probably quite a few people think there is something to it by now, wouldn't you think? But as far as the people who are the only ones who should know are saying, there is no evidence of a collusion between Trump and the Russians after all these months of the MSM pushing this narrative.
It has been reported there were two FISA court request for surveillance of Trump and his associates, the first one being turned down and the second one being approved. I don't think they put Trump in the second one as reported, but who knows if this reporting is true?
Clapper says there has not be a FISA request granted as to his knowledge and indicates if there had been he would know. Of course Clapper has been known to lie a little. Sometime you may want to study up on Clapper, he has a very interesting connection himself to many people, companies and countries in and out of politics.
Now we all know Obama himself didn't order any surveillance, at least not officially. He's smarter than that and as far as I understand it, he wouldn't be the one officially ordering it anyway, but like the CEO of the company, he doesn't have to run around to each employee and tell them when to put the next cartridge in the copy machine, they are a team or employees and are suppose to be working together for the same goal.
Obama has a long history of lying and deceptive practices. I'll put one in here for you. Trump is a liar as well and seems to have pulled off a few unscrupulous acts of his own. Now we're even on that, but Obama doesn't plan on Trump erasing his legacy and his part in the destruction of this country by overloading it with undocumented Democrats, loading us down with debt, starting wars all over the world, giving Iran the pathway to nuclear weapons, removing Crimea's weapons so Russia could easily take over while Obama put a few sanctions on them for doing it, changing the way raw information could be passed out to all the agencies 17 days before leaving office and quite a few more things, but we'll leave that for a little later.
Obama has had surveillance on many others during his time as President and attacked companies that didn't support him and even attacked people such as Ben Carson with the IRS, which brings to mind one of his employees didn't need to have him stop by and tell her to discriminate against conservative 501C's, you know Lois Lerner, who is happy with her government retirement plan now. Hey, don't you think a government employee who is called before Congress should have to answer questions if they involve their work or just give up their retirement and health benefits? I know that sounds kind of draconian, but you know all these Executive Privileges to protect ones ass is like a get out of jail free card. I mean, in the real world if an employee was to be found to discriminate against someone, they would be fired and relinquish all benefits, kind of like the Military.
Now I'm not worried about Trump's tweets in the least. Obama can say he didn't order anything and be honest about it, since he wouldn't be the one officially ordering the surveillance and Clapper can say there were no FISA court request granted to his knowledge and pretty much be honest, at least for awhile.
Now here is one of the sites you should frequent, since you say you are a Socialist:
Only days before Trump’s inauguration
Obama expands NSA spying
With the inauguration of President-elect Donald Trump only days away, the Obama administration announced on Thursday a vast expansion of the spying power of American intelligence agencies. Under the new rules, the National Security Agency (NSA) can now share raw bulk data consisting of private communications with 16 other intelligence agencies, including the FBI and the Department of Homeland Security.
In response to the recent rules set forward by the Obama administration, NSA Whistleblower Edward Snowden Tweeted on Thursday, “As he hands the White House to Trump, Obama just unchained NSA from basic limits on passing raw intercepts to others.”
Previously, NSA analysts were required to sift out information they judged irrelevant and withhold the names of individuals deemed innocent before passing along information to other agencies. Attorney General Loretta E. Lynch signed the new rules, which grants multiple agencies access to “raw signals intelligence information,” on January 3. The director of national intelligence, James R. Clapper Jr., approved the measure on December 15, 2016.
n short, raw data previously investigated by the NSA will be thrown open to 16 other agencies, with entire personal information of millions of people exposed to and combed through by the CIA, FBI, and other agencies.
Perhaps most significant, under the new rules, any incriminating information of American citizens will be sent to the Justice Department, setting forth a wave of possible new accusations and investigations for thousands of people, if not more.
The Obama administration has sought to downplay the significant dangers of the new rules. Robert S. Litt, the general counsel to Clapper, stated, “This is not expanding the substantive ability of law enforcement to get access to signals intelligence. It is simply widening the aperture for a larger number of analysts, who will be bound by the existing rules.”
In reality, this is another step in the attack against democratic rights and a turn towards more authoritarian forms of rule, which has characterized the legacy of outgoing president Barack Obama.
During the last eight years, Obama has not only continued the illegal spying on billions of people around the world, but has dramatically increased it.
In May 2011, Obama signed three provisions of the widely-hated USA Patriot Act. Under the new provisions, spy agencies were granted access to using “roving wiretaps,” the authorization to intercept all communications of suspects; unlimited access to business, purchases, and travel records of suspects; and the surveillance of individuals with no suspected connections to foreign organizations.
The Obama Administration has prosecuted more whistle-blowers than any presidency in American history, and has viciously victimized those who sought to expose this program, imprisoning Chelsea Manning and forcing Julian Assange to seek refuge in the Ecuadorian embassy in London and Edward Snowden to go into hiding in Russia.
Throughout his term, Obama worked to defend and facilitate the crimes of the intelligence agencies, working with the CIA to suppress the revelations of the Senate’s report on torture under the Bush Administration and shielding the architects of the torture program from prosecution.
The complete cynicism and hypocrisy of Obama was on full display during his farewell speech in Chicago on Tuesday. Touting himself as a champion of American democracy, he neglected to mention the mass state spying apparatus which he has expanded and prepared for Donald Trump.
READ ENTIRE ARTICLE
And this doesn't include the IRS audits, millions of Americans and foreigners, companies that have been attacked during Obama's terms.
So, do I think Obama was involved in any surveillance of Trump during his campaign? Yes.