WikiLeaks Releases What It Calls CIA Trove Of Cyber-Espionage Documents
Updated 5:15 p.m. ET
WikiLeaks has released thousands of files that it identifies as CIA documents related to the agency's cyber-espionage tools and programs.
The documents published on Tuesday include instruction manuals, support documents, notes and conversations about, among other things, efforts to exploit vulnerabilities in smartphones and turn smart TVs into listening devices. The tools appear to be designed for use against individual targets, as part of the CIA's mandate to gather foreign intelligence.
A CIA spokesperson would not confirm whether the documents were genuine, telling NPR, "We do not comment on the authenticity or content of purported intelligence documents."
Former CIA Director Michael Hayden told MSNBC that if WikiLeaks' account was true, the document dump would be "very, very damaging."
And the anti-secrecy site says there's more to come: WikiLeaks has dubbed Tuesday's release "Year Zero," saying it is the first of a series of CIA-related leaks that the site is collectively calling "Vault 7."
Nicholas Weaver, a computer scientist at the University of California at Berkeley, says the documents don't seem to reveal significant news about the CIA's capabilities — "it's describing a hacking organization that's doing a reasonably good job," he says.
What is surprising is that the documents are being published.
In a statement accompanying the document release, WikiLeaks alleges that the CIA has recently "lost control of the majority of its hacking arsenal," and that an archive with "several hundred million lines of code" has been circulating among former government hackers. One former government hacker or contractor gave a portion of that code to WikiLeaks, according to the organization.
Weaver calls that story "implausible," and raises the possibility that someone from outside the U.S. government compromised the CIA's systems to acquire the documents. And that, he says, would be a big deal: "Spies gonna spy, that's dog bites man. Spy dumps data on Wikileaks, proving that they exfiltrated it from a top secret system? That's man bites dog."
Regardless of how they were acquired, the documents in the "Year Zero" release do not include the code for any cyberespionage programs. In its press release, WikiLeaks says it is "avoiding the distribution of 'armed' cyberweapons until a consensus emerges" on how to analyze and disarm such weapons.
Instead, the purported CIA documents reference and describe agency tools designed to extract information from computers, monitor communications and control electronic devices.
WikiLeaks says the files came from the CIA's internal Confluence system — a platform for team collaboration. They include instructions on how to use programs, and guides describing how to reduce the risk of CIA involvement being detected in a program. Some pages have comments from users whose names have been redacted, but appear to be software developers.
The alleged CIA documents show techniques developed specifically for "embedded systems" — which the files describe, in non-technical terms, as "the Things in the Internet of Things." Think devices that don't look like computers, but use the Internet to work. For instance, one program uses a Samsung TV as a listening device, turning the microphone on while the TV appears to be off.
The documents also appear to show techniques the CIA has used to compromise and control individual smartphones. WikiLeaks notes that such tactics would allow the agency to read even encrypted communications — but Weaver says that's misleading.
"The real story on encryption is not, 'Oh my God the CIA breaks encryption,' but that encryption is so good that the CIA has to risk $1.5 million assets to compromise a target's iPhone if they want to read his messages," he says, noting the high price of developing smartphone-infiltrating techniques.
There's another concern about the methods that the CIA used to compromise phones. Ben Wizner, director of the ACLU Speech, Privacy, and Technology Project, says the documents suggest the CIA "deliberately maintained vulnerabilities" in widely used devices.
"Those vulnerabilities will be exploited not just by our security agencies, but by hackers and governments around the world," he said in a statement. (Security consultant Tom Ritter tells NPR that according to the documents, the CIA does seem to have been aware of security vulnerabilities and not informed companies that could have fixed them.)
The CIA has traditionally been responsible for human espionage — officially , the NSA gathers "signals intelligence" and the CIA analyzes it. But the CIA also carries out its own cyber operations.
In February 2016, then-CIA Director John Brennan spoke with NPR's Mary Louise Kelly about, in part, the agency's desire to expand its cybercapabilities.
"The technological changes are taking place at a warped speed," he said:
Mike Pompeo, the new head of the CIA under President Trump, said in a written questionnaire accompanying his confirmation hearing that he understood that the agency, "upon direction from the President and working in cooperation with other agencies when appropriate, has capabilities to perform a wide [array of] actions related to all forms of cybersecurity policies."
http://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/03/07/519010317/wikileaks-releases-what-it-calls-cia-trove-of-cyberespionage-documents

Remember when Clinton-bashers "justified" the Russian hacking of DNC e-mails and did so by declaring …
"It doesn't matter how we get the truth; so-what if it comes from Wikileaks as long as it's true."
And I do hope the media ask Trump if he still "loves Wikileaks" … if he properly denounces it … Wikileaks may then leak everything he may be hiding from Americans.
Careful what you wish for!
Let the equivocating begin.
Careful what you wish for!
If I were not an atheist, I would say "Amen!"
A potential f'n security disater!
Well, you got that part right. Seems to me that there has to be an insider that allowed this kind of data out. I hope they catch him/her/them, because our procedures are just as important as the information we are able to gather. If an adversary knows the methodology, they will work to close those 'holes' forcing the CIA (and the NSA for that matter) to have to develop new methodologies costing great expense and time.
Making your first comment on this important news story a spin back to the president was silly and beneath you, A Mac.
Making your first comment on this important news story a spin back to the president was silly and beneath you, A Mac.
Yeah … so then, to really make me look silly and beneath myself, you want an independent investigation … correct?
Spikegary,
Rule 608. A Witness
(a) Reputation or Opinion Evidence. A witness’s credibility may be attacked or supported by testimony about the witness’s reputation for having a character for truthfulness or untruthfulness, or by testimony in the form of an opinion about that character. But evidence of truthful character is admissible only after the witness’s character for truthfulness has been attacked.
(b) Specific Instances of Conduct. Except for a criminal conviction under Rule 609, extrinsic evidence is not admissible to prove specific instances of a witness’s conduct in order to attack or support the witness’s character for truthfulness. But the court may, on cross-examination, allow them to be inquired into if they are probative of the character for truthfulness or untruthfulness of:
(1) the witness; or
(2) another witness whose character the witness being cross-examined has testified about.
Prior consistent statements and prior inconsistent statements , in the law of evidence , occur where a witness , testifying at trial , makes a statement that is either consistent or inconsistent, respectively, with a previous statement given at an earlier time
So then, it matters both which truths are obtained, and, the agenda/ultimate motivation of the truth-gathers.
You're late to the party with that ... and I hope this takes some of the wind out of your gloat sails.
Interesting to see who did it. Whoever he or she is, I would expect he has a meeting with a needle at some point in his future if he gets caught.
.
Please clarify that, Sean.
Whoever leaked this should be executed for treason.
And it will be interesting to see who the person is. Is it another rogue contractor? Were they qualified to have access to all this material etc...
Sean,
Are you assuming the leaks came from within the CIA as opposed to a foreign hacker like Russia?
Yes. I would assume a state actor would keep their knowledge secret and exploit it. Publicizing it would be like the brits publicizing that they cracked the Enigma code in WWII,
Could it be a continued Russian interference -- post election collusion?
I am asking in all seriousness ... and with real concern.
In all seriousness, with the number of people in the Trump administration with extensive Russian ties, I think that it is at least possible, if not probable, that the Russian influence operation is ongoing. No one has stopped them, so why should they stop?
Why would the Russians give the best intelligence score in history to Assange rather than exploit it?
If there is collusion, why would they ever shine a light on it by publicizing theft which will inevitably result in a massive investigation and threaten the "collusion."
It makes zero sense, even if you buy into same bizarre conspiracy theory that Trump worked Russians to get elected. If the Russians were colluding with Trump this is the absolute last thing they would ever do.
Why would the Russians give the best intelligence score in history to Assange rather than exploit it?
To compromise the United States as a power and put fear in America's allies as to what could come next.
It's naive to simply dismiss this particularly if Russia has Trump's ass over a barrel with damning information. If Trump is a potential victim of blackmail, as Trump himself would say … "Nothing is off of the table."
If blackmail is in the picture, Trump will have power for himself and a fucking for us.
What Trump supporters dismiss out-of-hand, is the justification for a bi-partisan, or, special investigator investigation into the wiretapping tweet and the Russian/Trump connection. ONLY THE FEAR OR GUILT CAUSES RESISTANCE TO A SERIOUS INVESTIGATION INTO THE FACTS! Confidence of a finding to PROVE INNOCENCE generates the exact opposite.
The dopes on the Trump staff calling for an investigation into the alleged "wire tapping by Obama" -- may have begun to bring down the (White) house.
Once it's published, the value is dramactially decreased. it's simply insane for a hostile power to give up the keys to its enemies intelligence service for a temporary public relations win. It would be the stupidest possible move and putin, with his bad ground in intelligence, would never burn a such a source after a single month,
it's simply insane for a hostile power to give up the keys to its enemies intelligence service for a temporary public relations win.
I doubt that Putin would do this for P.R. objectives; this is a huge embarrassment to the U.S. and allows Putin to put fear in other governments as well.
We disagree, Sean.
it's simply insane for a hostile power to give up the keys to its enemies intelligence service for a temporary public relations win.
Haven't you noticed Trump's war with the Intelligence community and Bannon's objective to "DECONSTRUCT WASHINGTON"?
What's insane is what the Trump Administration is really about, the Republican Congressional pimps and whores who won't fix what's broken as long as it benefits them politically, and the Trump voters whose zeal-without-knowledge will eventually bite them in the ass along with the rest of us.
The rich guys will do just fine, however.
I did note that the procedures describe allow the CIA and whoever else that might have this information to disguise themselves as Russian Hackers. So, was it the Russians that did the pre-election hacking or someone pretending to be them to cover their tracks?
As to Russia giving out valuable intelligence data that they have been able to compromise our intelligence gathering? That would be stupid to do and I don't believe Putin is stupid. They would use those assets ot continue to look in the back door of the CIA.
I did note that the procedures describe allow the CIA and whoever else that might have this information to disguise themselves as Russian Hackers. So, was it the Russians that did the pre-election hacking or someone pretending to be them to cover their tracks?
Ask the 17 agencies that stated it was Russia.
Think about what you're thinking; if it was the CIA disguised as Russians … that would mean Americans were helping to elect TRUMP! Either way, he's implicated in a collusive act of treason.
As to Russia giving out valuable intelligence data that they have been able to compromise our intelligence gathering? That would be stupid to do and I don't believe Putin is stupid. They would use those assets ot continue to look in the back door of the CIA.
I've responded to this already …
Again …
Why would the Russians give the best intelligence score in history to Assange rather than exploit it?
To compromise the United States as a power and put fear in America's allies as to what could come next.
It's naive to simply dismiss this particularly if Russia has Trump's ass over a barrel with damning information. If Trump is a potential victim of blackmail, as Trump himself would say … "Nothing is off of the table."
If blackmail is in the picture, Trump will have power for himself and a fucking for us.
What Trump supporters dismiss out-of-hand, is the justification for a bi-partisan, or, special investigator investigation into the wiretapping tweet and the Russian/Trump connection. ONLY THE FEAR OR GUILT CAUSES RESISTANCE TO A SERIOUS INVESTIGATION INTO THE FACTS! Confidence of a finding to PROVE INNOCENCE generates the exact opposite.
The dopes on the Trump staff calling for an investigation into the alleged "wire tapping by Obama" -- may have begun to bring down the (White) house.
The dopes on the Trump staff calling for an investigation into the alleged "wire tapping by Obama" -- may have begun to bring down the (White) house.
I agree. Senator Graham and Senator Whitehouse have decided to take them up on their request to look into this and sent a letter to the FBI asking for any evidence of any wiretapping of Trump Tower. Because they would be concerned if Trump made a charge against Obama that simply not true, but equally concerned that if Trump himself was under investigation for something that rises to the level of a Judge or the FISA court thinking it was serious enough to justify a warrant to conduct the surveillance. Calling for Congress to investigate may well turn out to be one of most incredibly stupid things for Trump and the White House to do. If they insist that Trump was wire tapped then they are saying that either Barack Obama committed a crime (that would require a considerably large conspiracy) by illegally having Trump Tower wire tapped or that a judge believes that Trump may have.
Trump himself has plenty of connections to the Russians, but one that is not shown on that display is Rex Tillerson, who he didn't know before the election and who is now the Secretary of State. Tillerson himself has spent considerable time "in bed" with Vladimir Putin.
Sorry to interrupt a perfectly amazing round of conspiracy theorizing devoid of any connection to reality, but did you ever think what sort of policies Putin would actually want the US to pursue? As Scott Johnson said,
“In a sane world, the proposition that the Trump campaign colluded with the Russians and the underlying theme that the Russian government preferred Donald Trump would have to contend with events that belie it.”
Putin wants the US:
to slow down American Domestic energy production.
see US slash militarily expenditures and readiness
slash nuclear stockpile/modernization
stop missile defense and refuse to extend shield to countries like Poland
Enter into one sided nuclear arms control agreement.
In other words, as Tom Cotton points out, the ideal American President for Russian purposes would continue the policies of Barack "i'll have more flexibility after the election" Obama and do the opposite of everything Trump has pledged to do. The architecht of the disastrous Russian reset would be the perfect candidate to continue following the path that let Putin achieve such power on the world stage.
Trump's policies are the last thing Putin wants, especially regarding energy production. If you want to know what a Russian stooge would do in the White House, just look at the last 8 years of servile behavior from the man who attacked Mitt Romney for suggesting Russia was a threat.
Trump's policies are the last thing Putin wants, especially regarding energy production. If you want to know what a Russian stooge would do in the White House, just look at the last 8 years of servile behavior from the man who attacked Mitt Romney for suggesting Russia was a threat.
Yeah … what would a Rex Tillerson have to do with energy policy?
It's not about Obama, Sean … it's about a POTUS who has kissed Putin's ass and and administration with many parties having Russian connections.
But tell me you want an investigation into this … think of how bad I'll look if an investigation turns up nothing.
My personal opinion is that if an investigation turns up that nothing happened concerning Barack Obama wiretapping Trump Tower, that Trump, having such a fondness for conspiracy theories, would say that Obama holdovers managed to destroy all of the evidence, Alex Jones, Mark Levin and Breitbart would all back him up and the hardcore Trump supporters would still believe his delusion. The rest of the world would continue to lower their overall opinion of both Trump and America.
There's already an investigation into it, by both congress and the FBI.
Please Explain how having the former head of a competitor to Russian energy companies in an administration dedicated to expanding domestic energy production is somehow good for Russia,
you realize putin funded opposition to the pipelines that trump just greenlighted , right?
There's already an investigation into it, by both congress and the FBI.
Neither entity is independent, Sean.
There's already an investigation into it, by both congress and the FBI.
Neither entity is independent, Sean.
Got that right, FBI found Clinton guilty of many things including perjury but advised not to prosecute. It appears the FBI obeys whomever the current master is at the time quite well.
It appears the FBI obeys whomever the current master is at the time quite well.
And because TRUMP and Sessions are the current Master and appointee, an independent investigation is called for.
Good call!
EXXON/Mobil hold the leases on almost 64 million acres in Russia, potentially worth billions of dollars in Natural Gas and Oil that it wants to develop, but can not because of the current sanctions against Russia over their takeover of Crimea and their action in Eastern Ukraine. If Trump lifts those sanctions then EXXON/Mobil can develop that land and nothing happens in Russia without Putin getting his cut. Presumably so would Tillerson, if not others.
Also EXXON/Mobil is not in competition with the Russian owned oil company (Rosneft), it is in partnership with it.
TTT
TTT
???
TTT
???
Let me save a lot of unnecessary banter … any further comments characterizing my position as "delusional," "conspiracy theorizing," just post those two characterizations …
THEN HAVE THE CONFIDENCE IN THOSE ASSERTIONS TO DEFINITIVELY STATE THAT YOU WANT AN INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION INTO THE WIRE TAPPING ALLEGATION AND THE RUSSIAN INTERFERENCE!
The truth shall set us free … one way or the other.