Federal Appeals Court Deals Blow to Obama's Amnesty
A federal appeals court on Tuesday ruled that President Barack Obamas most recent executive actions on immigration should remain on hold as a legal fight plays out over his decision to grant quasi-legal status and work permits to millions more illegal immigrants.
The court rejected the administrations request to lift an order blocking Obama from expanding a program for illegal immigrants who entered the country as children and creating a new program for illegal immigrant parents of U.S. citizens.
The New Orleans-based 5th Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals voted, 2-1, to deny an emergency stay of an injunction U.S. District Court Judge Andrew Hanen imposed on Obamas plan earlier this year at the request of Texas and 25 other states challenging the presidents moves.
Writing for the majority, Judge Jerry Smith said the Justice Department had not met the legal standards required to block the lower court ruling.
In an opinion joined by Judge Jennifer Elrod, Smith sounded sympathetic to claims that Obamas actions exceeded the authority given to the president and the executive branch by Congress.
Although the Secretary [of Homeland Security] is given discretion to make immigration decisions based on humanitarian concerns, that discretion is authorized for particular family members and forms of relief, Smith wrote. Congress has developed an intricate process for unlawfully present aliens to reside lawfully.in the United States on account of their childs citizenship..Against that background, we would expect to find an explicit delegation of authority to implement [Deferred Action for Parents of Americans] a program that makes 4.3 million otherwise removable aliens eligible for lawful presence, work authorization, and associated benefits but no such provision exists.
Smith also said the federal government had failed to show that Hanen erred when he concluded that the new program amounted to a formal rule that should have been put through formal notice-and-comment procedures. The Obama administration claims that the policy involves the exercise of case-by-case discretion, but the appeals court found the evidence on that point to be conflicting and said Hanens conclusion wasnt clearly erroneous.
The Obama administration can now turn to the U.S. Supreme Court for a green light to proceed with the program, or Justice Department officials could wait until the 5th Circuit rules on the merits of Hanens legal rationale for the injunction he entered in February. A different panel of the appeals court is expected to hear arguments on those issues in early July.
Spokespeople for the White House and the Justice Department had no immediate comment.
Judge Stephen Higginson, the sole Democratic appointee on the 5th Circuit panel, dissented from Tuesdays ruling. He portrayed Obamas moves not as favors for certain groups of illegal immigrants, but a logical effort to prioritize deportation efforts.
I would say [the Department of Homeland Security] is adhering to law, not derogating from it, Higginson wrote.
It is undisputed that the Executive presently is deporting a total number of immigrants at a faster rate than any administration before, ever; that the Executive is and should allocate limited resources to deport violent and dangerous immigrants, ahead of citizenchildrens parents who self-report to DHS acknowledging their illegal presence; and finally, that even categories of persons, like immigrants cooperating with the government in criminal cases or who contribute to our Armed Forces, historically receive deferrals, the 5th Circuit judge added.
Higginson said he believes the lawsuit brought by the states is non-justiciable, meaning it is in a category of disputes the courts refrain from ruling on because doing so would impinge on the executive branchs traditional authority.
Some of the first reaction to the 5th Circuit ruling came in a tweet from Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R), who as Texas attorney general launched the charge for the states attacking Obamas moves.
Texas just won the Executive Amnesty case at the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals, wrote Abbott, using a shorthand for Texas v. United States. The constitution wins.
The three 5th Circuit judges deciding the case were randomly selected. Smith was appointed by President Ronald Reagan, Elrod by President George W. Bush and Higginson by Obama.
Hanen ruled in February that Obamas November actions violated federal law because they were not properly announced and opened for public comment before being put into effect. The judge did not rule explicitly on questions many Republicans in Congress have raised about the presidents legal authority to carry out his moves.
Read more: http://www.politico.com/story/2015/05/barack-obama-executive-action-immigration-setback-appeals-court-118290.html#ixzz3bHCHXKhw

Will update with actual opinion when it's available.
This is gonna be sweet.
Here's a link to the Court's ruling:
Well when you make half assed proclamations and decisions the other half of the ass is sure to catch up sooner or later.
That even makes sense . It's too bad his majesty-in-chief can't be bothered with these petty details .
Whole new concept - follow the law - wow.
That will help Democrats in 2016.
Further
We'll see.
Until you become an attorney AMac, I think you need to quit trying to "analyze" what the media sez about the law - OK?
So, you are saying that those rulings did not happen. Right?
Another large detailed cut & paste with no analysis . Typical A Mac tactic .
Not OK, 1st.
I didn't analyze anything, I merely posted an article the offers counter points to the article that began this thread.
But I will offer the following analysis I remember when Republicans were opposed to activist judges.
Anyway, if it will make you happy, I'll stop commenting on any NT articles going forward.
For the hopelessly dim -- cut and paste is a way to provide information for those who require it.
Get off my ass with the cut & past rants -- if you cant rebut the content, move on.
Thanks for demonstrating you are incapable of thinking for yourself ... arriving at conclusions from all that information . Take a position already !
What conclusion?
Did I not include in my comment the words "we'll see"?
Instead of making personal comments, since you're big on "thinking for one's self," give it try.
For the hopelessly dim -- cut and paste is a way to provide information for those who require it.
He is far too dim to even understand what you are posting. Far, far too dim. Always has been. Not worth talking to or engaging in conversation with.
OK , so summarizing your position it's : ""we'll see" . What a waste of my valuable time . How about doing some work instead of stating the obvious ? Here's another suggestion . You could add words like "that suggests" to your commentary to show you've got the germ of an idea & not a fully formed conclusion ...
Oh, 1st, is it all right if I say something else?
Let me know; meanwhile, I was thinking that sometimes, even rulings of appellate courts get appealed! Who knew?
And then sometimes, what one court determined was correct, turns out that a higher court overturns.
I figured that out and I'm not a lawyer.
Sean must be a lawyer 'cause this is his article. Ditto the others in the thread that concur with the decision.
I know when I'm out of my league.
Bye guys -- I'm leavin' this to the hey, wait a minute! Hey Petey, I think Sean copied and pasted this whole f'n seed!
Typical double standard on your part.
Now I'm leaving.
Oh, yeah, WTF was I thinking trying to have a discussion in a discussion forum?
I need to introspect.
And yet here you are violating the CoC to do just that . Why is that ? Hypocritical much...
I can't moderate here but as a member, I ask that you guys stop.
Understood and I will.
Nope - but cutting'n'pasting with no "input" is just the same as just - - - - - cut'n'pasting the article, giving it no value other than an echo.
All of us, even you Randy, can read and think about what they are reading. The vast majority of folks can/will comment on what they just read, offering their opinion of what was said. Cutting'n'pasting does none of that other than offering an echo which does nothing more than regurgitate someone else's view/thoughts - not the responders.
No problem .
Oh, and AMac - you weren't "commenting" - you were copying.
"Further" and "we'll see" aren't comments further than saying "see next page".
When an article is seeded verbatim, it is quite legitimate to copy and paste another article giving both the background issue in the seeded article, and, a contrary possible outcome which is exactly what I did.
I began my comment with
A short, succinct analysis original input at that as to how such an "activist" decision could impact elections in 2016.
To merely express an opinion without providing background and projection/prognosis, while possibly insightful and interesting, to offer both is the result of doing one's homework before positing.
It's only an "echo" if it repeats the original content. My cut and paste is a counter point based on the evolving scenario.
"We'll see" means, both literally and figuratively, that the "jury" is still out . It's more honest than taking the seeded article's report as definitively conclusive, particularly since the decision is predicated on a "delay" of implementation and not "case closed."
And here is Sean's comment on the article he seeded the first on the board
...
Any your comment is a "victory lap" of sorts but the game ain't over.
And while you accuse me of not being a lawyer, you said nothing about Sean's
I repeat WE'LL SEE.
Thanks to the both of you.
WTH 1st, why should anyone quit trying to ''analyze'' what the media says? It's done every day on NT, by a multitude of people, on many different subjects, the law being just one.
Maybe we should have a item added to the CoC. No analyzing unless your an attorney. Better yet, a practicing attorney, or even better yet a practicing attorney, that specializes in that particular segment of the law.
What do YOU mean by "reform" ?
What I don't like is that this feels like bullying to Mac and please note I am saying this as a member. This is a discussion site and we all give our opinions and even try to back them up with some copy and paste from reliable sources to make our arguments.
Come on guys.. play nice.
I am so glad to have my time wasted by someone who provides information . Like there isn't already enough of that ...
Then you proceeded to post a volume of material which may or may not be related . Do you mind pointing out the relevant passages ?
The important thing is the crap going on in your head . Everything else isn't even worth reading . Have I got the gist of your "argument" or did I leave anything out ?
I'm not looking for more info . I'm looking for interpretation . I'm looking to save time . But if you like I will post the entire contents of the US constitution as a copy/paste job ...
Yeah! Information that's for people who want to be educated who needs it?
Waste of time enough learning already.
Some times it isn't necessary to give people enough rope to hang themselves
Copied and pasted, every damned one.
Uhm should I tell him or will someone else?
Yes, I mind.
If you read it and understand it, you'll be able to determine if there are any relevant passages.
Did you ask Sean to point out the relevant passages in his seeded article, or do you take any/everything that Sean seeds/posts as relevant?
Night everyone I'm tired of getting beat up by myopians (I think Myopia is a town in Mississippi).
If you want me to read volumes of your seeded material try seeding an article . But if I have the time to waste going through volumes of unrelated crap I will consider looking at your comments . The question is : do you have that time ? I'm thinking the answer is no but you want to waste everyone else's time .
Let me emulate a "Petey Coober" by urging him to
1) Point out the "unrelated crap" in my comment regarding the court decision that is the subject of this seeded discussion
2) Specifically explain why it is unrelated
3) Rebut by correcting any inaccuracies/unrelated crap
We will watch for the tap dance.
Petey,
What you do regularly in these discussions is akin to the Wizard of Oz character; you send those with who you disagree after the debate equivalent of the "witch's broom." Then when they bring it, your response is "not so fast -- not so fast."
You can't send us "back to Kansas" so you send us on a fool's errand -- an attempt to have us do something that has no chance of success because, in the wings, is the next fool's errand.
You talk about "tactics" --
Yours is the subject of one of the most famous stories in the history of film.
You're a bright guy; instead of using your intelligence to dodge an inconvenient truth, go right at it -- knock down if you can. Otherwise, you discredit yourself.
Let them all in... the Rohingya boat people, everyone. We don't have over crowded prisons and jails, failing infrastructure, severe drought, food shortages, over crowded schools, cutbacks on teachers and law enforcement, Congress and state governments cutting back on social services and Congress wanting to do away with "entitlements" ......
you just can't fix STUPID, but someone better hurry up and invent a pill for it. We have enough useless people who are real, true citizens of this country, we sure as hell don't need to import any more.
Mimi,
That's not what the President's reform is about
Further
Yeah! It's copied and pasted for those who will comment on that but not the content.
I was gonna' make up stuff but I thought it better to just post facts.
If those who are here illegally are allowed to stay here, the law means nothing.
Deporting all who are here illegally is an impossibility.
Just yesterday, in another thread, Sean was preaching "Christian Forgiveness."
Good thing it is.
BUT THESE FOLKS WHO TALK-THE-CHRISTIAN-TALK WHEN IT'S CONVENIENT -- THEN FAIL TO FORGIVE THE CHILDREN WHO HAD NO CHOICE BUT TO COME TO THE U.S. WHEN THEIR PARENTS BROUGHT THEM HERE ILLEGALLY are hypocrites!
WALK-THE-WALK or be a Christian in name only!
Where do you get your perception of Christianity from , the bible ? The bible has been roundly ignored since the advent of Calvinism .
Irrelevant to my comment as in this instance, I was responding to Sean's idea of one of the tenets of Christianity.
But, you are entitled to a response.
Much of my perception of Christianity comes from my studies in conjunction with a graduate degree (and then some) in Fine Arts/Art History.
Among the areas of concentration are Italian Renaissance art, much of which is comprised of Christian themes. I not only know the art and the artists, but, in conjunction, have read thousands of critiques, analyses and studies in the iconography.
Beyond that, while I detest organized religion of all forms, I find much in the way of wisdom in the Old and New Testaments, the Talmud and other writings. Sadly, organized religion seems to have few adherents who actually live by the wisdom with which the claim to identify.
OK , so material prior to the espousal of Calvinism . Very old fashioned . No wonder you get few actual discussions on your views .
I gave you the respect of bringing you the witch's broom you requested but as usual, you were ready with the "not-so-fast" man-behind the curtain.
I explained why I referenced the Christian tenet of forgiveness and won't do it again.
The "few actual discussions" are the result of no viable challenges or debate counter points coming from those who provoke but can't "get-it-up" when they get handed a serious argument.
Calvinism or vegetarianism, I still know as much (and often more) about the iconography and meaning of Christian tenets and symbolism and dogma than a lot of folks who call themselves Christians but who aren't Christ-like in their views.
But do tell me how Calvinism would help me better address Sean's, et al praise of "forgiveness" but failure to offer it to the children of illegal immigrants who came here without a choice and who have lived as de facto Americans ever since.
Please any of you "good right-wing xenophobic Christians," do explain what would Jesus do.
You didn't read the proposed law it's not about million more.
Your hatred of Obama blinds you and you didn't see all that well to begin with.