Trump’s Budget Would Kill a Program That Feeds 2.4 Million Senior Citizens
http://time.com/money/4703456/trump-budget-meals-on-wheels/
President Donald Trump's 2018 budget plan would end a program that provides funding for Meals on Wheels .
A proposal of the Trump budget , released Thursday morning, calls for the complete elimination of the Community Development Block Grant program, which operates under the Department of Housing and Urban Development and covers Meals on Wheels. The budget plan estimates that cutting the program would save the government $3 billion.
"The Federal Government has spent over $150 billion on this block grant since its inception in 1974, but the program is not well-targeted to the poorest populations and has not demonstrated results," the draft of the budget says.
A representative for Meals on Wheels said not enough details were provided to discern how this budget would impact the program, but that "it is difficult to imagine a scenario in which they will not be significantly and negatively impacted."
At a press briefing Thursday, President Trump's Office of Management and Budget Director Mick Mulvaney characterized the proposal as "compassionate," because it would protect taxpayers from putting money toward inefficient or ineffective programs.
"You're only focusing on half the equation, you're focusing on the recipients of the money," he told reporters. "We're trying to focus on the recipients of the money and the folks who give us the money in the first place. I think it's fairly compassionate for us to go and say, 'We're not going to ask for your money anymore unless we can guarantee to you your money is used in a proper function.'"
Meals on Wheels is one of the longest running programs in the Community Development Block Grant program, according to its website , and it served over 219 million meals to 2.4 million homebound senior citizens in 2016. The Community Development Block Grant program was established in 1974 and provides grants to state and local governments that provide assistance like Meals on Wheels, affordable housing services and natural disaster recovery in low income neighborhoods.
In a 2014 bipartisan resolution commemorating the 40th anniversary of the Community Development Block Grant program, Congress noted that between 2005 and 2013, the program provided services to over 100 million Americans and created or maintained 330,500 jobs.
This story has been updated to include comments from President Trump's Office of Management and Budget Director Mick Mulvaney.
Tags
Who is online
108 visitors

Who is Trump helping?
Anyone?
Millionaires?
Here in my area we have an active Senior Outreach which includes Meals on Wheels.
Many of our vulnerable seniors have no one to care for them and are on very limited incomes. These are the people that have worked all their lives raised families and now they are alone or without family that is close. Many that we serve are vets who fought for this country.
Many of us that help out are volunteers, we get no pay (money) what we get out of this is knowing that our seniors have a good hot meal every day. We get to visit with them and learn from them, giving them an outlet and for those that are completely housebound a voice from outside, human company. Those rewards are far more satisfying than money.
How this administration would even think of cutting these programs is beyond me. These are Americans that have more than paid their dues, something that many in this administration haven't done or ever will do.
One of the gentlemen that I visit is a Korean war vet. Purple heart recipient who has out lived his wife and children. He is completely alone and survives on SSN and a small pension. He has his own home that he raised his children in with his wife. He doesn't want to move out of the house. A few times a week I take him to the Senior center where he has others to talk with an enjoy. Others deliver a hot meal to him daily.
He loves it when I stop by to visit him, since I bring my dogs, Wiki and Annie to visit. He loves the dogs and they love him...
This is the American that they want to cut free to try to survive. Oh hell yes, we have to pay for a frickin' wall or more bigger an better ships.
Doesn't he and millions of others deserve some respect, a hot meal, a place to go, and our care...
Where the hell has our humanity gone, it's all about dollars, screw those that helped built and/or protect this country.
And the comment about the program being inefficient is BS...Where are the report/study showing that. On the other hand there a reports that show how efficient they are.
This is a moral test for our society, I hope that we can pass it.
We've already failed. Now I can only hope that this budget passes and those who voted this moron and his band of idiots into power are the main recipients of these changes.
They will be. And they will be REALLY PISSED OFF! If this budget ever manged to pass I wouldn't want to be Trump for Vladimir Putin's money!
But it's "compassionate" to let them starve to give a bigger tax cut to the poor, poor, rich and to build bigger weapons systems! When they are dead, we won't have to pay them the Social Security and Medicare they earned and paid for. And "Meals on Wheels" is so expensive that Trump might have to give up a weekend of golf in Mar-a-lago to pay for it! The goal of the GOP is for the poor and elderly to just die and get out of their way!
The total cost, which includes other programs, is about $2 billion a year, which is less than the government hands out in fossil fuel subsidies every year.
Meals On Wheels alone costs about $3 million a year, which is the cost of just one trip to Trump’s “winter White House.”
I hope that congress stuffs this budget right up Trumps ass.
And puts it on youtube when they do it.
The Democrats will shut down the government before they allow things like meals on wheels to go away and the GOP House will not have the balls to do it and then go home to face their voters when running for re-election. It's DOA and it shows what a real prick he is to those, especially those in the small town, rural and Rust Belt areas, who supported him. Break out the torches and pitchforks if he sticks to this.
“Finally, the Fourth Turning is a ‘Crisis’ period. This is when our institutional life is reconstructed from the ground up, always in response to a perceived threat to the nation’s very survival. If history does not produce such an urgent threat, Fourth Turning leaders will invariably find one — and may even fabricate one — to mobilize collective action. Civic authority revives, and people and groups begin to pitch in as participants in a larger community. As these Promethean bursts of civic effort reach their resolution, Fourth Turnings refresh and redefine our national identity.” (Emphasis added)."
This may mean more than people think. Bannon has said Americans will have to suffer a lot before the new order is achieved. He wants the sort of chaos that defunding all the social programs and the science programs and the health programs might bring about.
Snopes says this headline isn't true because the bulk of funding for wheels on wheels comes from sources other than the block grant program.
So it is OK with you for the federal government to partially fuck hungry old people? Next Ryan and Trump are going after Medicare and Social Security. How much of the dick do they have to shove in before YOU say it's wrong?
And I'd like to hear what you have to say about Trump's lies to the people in coal country? He closed their help programs down completely. Or at least he will if the really compassionate party who really care about the poor and working class, the Democratic Party, can stop him. And we will. We'll shut down the government to stop this worse then Ebenezer Scrooge budget.
From Snopes.
''Though the [budget] blueprint doesn’t contain enough detail to know for certain how local Meals on Wheels programs will be affected, spokeswoman Jenny Bertolette said, “It is difficult to imagine a scenario in which they will not be significantly and negatively impacted if the President’s budget were enacted.”
My step-daughter is mentally disabled. She has the mental capacity of about an 8 or 9 year old, even though she is in her late 40's (and she is a first class sweetheart!). She lives in an independent living facility in Hartford, CT with a roommate and they both get Meals on Wheels. To them Meals on Wheels is so much more then a warm lunch. It's therapeutic contact with the outside world from a friendly, caring person who has become their friend. Especially for the shut ins and elderly. The program is about SO MUCH MORE THEN FOOD! People need to understand that!
It is about a lot more than food. The human contact for the elderly or anyone that requires the service, is just as important as the meal.
Absolutely. I used to work as an EMT in Sun City and we used to see these elderly people in the stores and the post office and such. They made a big deal out of mailing a letter they could have just put a stamp on and dropped in a box or buying a few small items that they could have picked up doing weekly shopping, but instead spread it out so they "have" to go to the sore 4 or 5 times a week. They're mostly widowed, lonely and going to the post office is probably the only real human contact some of them have for days at a time, except for Meals on Wheels. Meals on Wheels not only makes sure they get a good nutritious lunch (the same with the school lunch programs that heartless bastards on the right want to cut out) it gives them something to look forward to everyday. They know that they are going to get a visit and a short conversation with someone who cares. It's the highlight of their day (What? You thought Matlock was?) That is priceless and cheap for what it costs the government. Only a sick prick could be against it.
Which sort of tells you what Trump is.
Also from snopes:
The elimination of the federal CDBG program would reduce local funding for a number of programs, including Meals on Wheels, but the overall impact on the program is uncertain. According to the Meals on Wheels 2015 annual report , the majority of the national office’s funding (about 84%) comes from individual contributions, while only 3% comes from federal grants such as the CDBG program provides.
Rather than letting some old people starve, I assume that meals on wheels could offset the loss of 3% in block grants by looking to increase individual contributions by the same amount.
1ofmany this is not the only program that would be affected...
A proposal of the Trump budget , released Thursday morning, calls for the complete elimination of the Community Development Block Grant program, which operates under the Department of Housing and Urban Development and covers Meals on Wheels. The budget plan estimates that cutting the program would save the government $3 billion.
That $3 billion could be made up if Trump's wife moved to the White House and he didn't spend so much time at this ''Florida White House''....
Of course, Trump has to live his life style while screwing people that are struggling...
It's the old MAGA scam.
I'm aware of what block grants cover but the article chose to say that Trump intends to starve the elderly to death so I limited my comment to that.
I hope it's just the tip of the iceberg of the massive cuts to come. Obama left us buried under a mountain of debt and we want big tax cuts. It's time to shrink this sucker down to the size that we can drown it in a bathtub. Long live the tea party. It's about time we put the responsibility for these people back on the shoulders of the families. If you're looking for free crap beg on the street corner like the rest of the bums.
Not an unexpected comment from someone who's God is money....
Wetback welfare queens are spitting out anchor babies here for the free crap and I don't want to be stuck paying the bill for their responsibilities.
The article is about Meals on Wheels, Dean....I don't think any of the seniors are spitting out babies or are '' wetback welfare queens''...
BTW, nice racial slur. Again not unexpected from the white is right crowd. MAWA.
This all about Trump trying to find money to build a wall. Maybe illegal aliens can "volunteer" to work on the wall as community service (or part of a criminal sentence) for having entered the country illegally and as a partial offset for the cost of rounding them up and deporting them. Old people are saved and the cost is actually on the cost causer.
The fact is that if Trump builds the wall some of the companies that will greatly benefit from it are Mexican corporations...
Gotta love that. Make Mexico Great Again.
Acutally it isn't all about Trump trying to cover the costs of building a wall. It's also trying to cover the $54b increase to the DOD. Pay for 15,000 new border patrol agents. Of course that number changes on the day of the week with Trump. Then there is the tax cuts promised.
BTW, wasn't Mexico going to pay for the wall...
BTW, wasn't Mexico going to pay for the wall...
Just make the illegals build it and they can get a free t-shirt on their way out the door which reads "I built that fucking wall."