╌>

Islamic State killed 400 people in Syria's Palmyra

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jerry-verlinger  •  11 years ago  •  19 comments

Islamic State killed 400 people in Syria's Palmyra

Islamic State fighters have killed at least 400 people in Syria's ancient city of Palmyra, most of them women and children, Syrian state television said on Sunday.
logo-aol-e1304029704603.png?width=80

By Mariam Karouny

It said it was quoting residents inside the city, which is known as Tadmur in Arabic and is home to renowned Roman-era ruins including well-preserved temples, colonnades and a theater.

1408332562836_Image_galleryImage_An_image_uploaded_on_June.JPG?width=450

Opposition activists have said on social media that hundreds of bodies were in the streets of the city after it was seized by the ultra hardline group on Wednesday. They said they were believed to be government loyalists.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

How will history judge the rest of civilization in relation to the death of Syria's children?

And how many of America's weapons of war will fall into ISIS hands, that we have given to the rebels? (Which rebels, you ask? Why, I have no idea... I've lost my scoreboard and don't know who is who over there any more.)

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

I live near Palmyra, Indiana, so every time I read the word, I think of the sleepy little town in southern Indiana...

I can't keep up with what's going on over there-- but I'm surely sorry for the regular people who are caught up in this. ISIS is totally untenable. I hope that we can help those who are trying so desperately to stop them.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

These bastards have got to be stopped. Every time they take over another city or territory, they gain in size, strength and wealth. IMO, it's only a matter of time before we'll have to put American boots on the ground over there to get rid of them. Either that, or we could just wait until they come over here.

I hate to have to say we need more American boots over there, because I have one Grandson in the Air Force stationed in Kurdistan, and another reporting for Marine boot camp on August 24, but it's obvious the Mid-East military is unable to cope with these brutal assholes, so it's beginning to look like we're going to have to go over there and straighten them out.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago
This mess just keeps getting worse while we sit around like it will resolve itself in some way other than ISIL taking over the entire Levant. While I fully support entering Iraq (at the invitation of the Iraqi government) and smashing ISIL, I am absolutely opposed to invading Syria (against the wishes of the Syrian government) to do the same thing because U.S. Forces will also topple Assad, walk out, and create another failed state for us to handle in the future.This is problem is difficult because our current foreign policy is disjointed. Syria is in turmoil because of a Sunni revolt against Assad. ISIL has moved to the forefront of that revolt even though they are not necessarily liked by other Sunni fighters but they like Assad even less. The Syrian Sunni are unlikely to join any Shia fighters against ISIL because that may work against their long term interest of getting rid of Assad. So ISIL fights Assad, various Sunni groups fight Assad and ISIL, and some Sunni groups fight with ISIL agaisnt Assad. Iran helps Assad and the Shias to fight everybody fighting him. And we drop bombs trying to hit the right targets in this confusion. If we topple Asssad, the sectarian struggle will not stop because Obama sat on his hands until the sectarian conflict engulfed the entire region.Next door in Iraq, the problem is a little different. Saddam and his Sunni hacks oppressed the Shia. We toppled the government (Based on lies) and the Shia took over and oppressed the Sunni. The Sunni are now in revolt and ISIL has run in front to spearhead a drive to topple the Shia from power. Iran has intervened to prop up its Shia ally, using Shia militia death squads that have plagued the Sunni. The Sunni don't want to fight with the deaths squads who, until recently, were killing their families and the Shia government is not going to rush to arm Sunni tribes who will turn their weapons on the Shia once ISIL is gone (or perhaps before). Meanwhile we just drop bombs and hope the country magically reassembles itself.Basically, Obama has maneuver himself onto both sides of a sectarian conflict: supporting the Sunni against the Shia in Syria and supporting the Shia against the Sunni in Iraq. Complicating this further is the Iranian nuclear talks which make it impossible to strong arm Iran while Iran is providing the boots on the ground to fight ISIL in Iraq. Without Irans support, the black flags of ISIL may be flying over Baghdad. Stop stalling waiting for miracles. Send troops into Iraq now and smash ISIL; let Assad/Iran deal with ISIl in Syria on their own. Fix what we broke in Iraq as best we can and go home without breaking anything else.
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

".... I can't keep up with what's going on over there.

I know what you mean Marsha, the playing field and the players in this mess change so often it's difficult to know just what is the best course of action.

ISIS is totally untenable.

Yeah they are.

Lunatic, out of control, maniac murderers that need to be annihilated.

I hope that we can help those who are trying so desperately to stop them.

Are you willing to go so far as to put American troops on the ground to help end this growing nightmare?

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

How will history judge the rest of civilization in relation to the death of Syria's children?

That's a very good question mimi, the children caught up in the middle of these conflicts are the innocent victims of violence they have had no hand in creating.

People often comment that "i t's not our problem ", or " we need to take care of our own first ". Well I say it is our problem, because they are only children, and they know nothing of geographic borders or religious differences. As far as I'm concerned, when it comes to the children,"our own" means " the children, ..... all the children".

Look at this little girl, does it really make any difference where she is from? Does it make any difference what is causing the violence and chaos around her? She's just a little girl and she needs help.
imagesizer?file=jerry6118FD5BDF4-1FAF-8A5A-2CD3-769C820885F6.jpg&width=300

or this little boy ......
imagesizer?file=jerry6110AF04B16-69B5-C2B9-FAC5-4D257B454B18.jpg&width=300

How can anyone look at that picture and say " it's not my problem "?

So how are we going to answer screminmimi 's question, " How will history judge the rest of civilization in relation to the death of Syria's children? "

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

While I fully support entering Iraq (at the invitation of the Iraqi government) and smashing ISIL, I am absolutely opposed to invading Syria (against the wishes of the Syrian government)"

Do you honestlythinkAssad would ever grant the presence of American ground forces in Syria?

"......because U.S. Forces will also topple Assad, walk out, and create another failed state for us to handle in the future."

I don't believe that is a reasonable assumption. What supporting facts or indicators would you present to support your reasoning?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

We are supporting the wrong side in Syria and Iraq. The President has to give up on the silly idea of a one nation Iraq and let it split into three individual nations. The Sunni, the Shia and the Kurds. The people we need to be arming is not the Iraqi army who turn tail and run like the did in Ramadi, even when they had overwhelming force and the best equipment, much of what they left behind forcing many American airstikes to try to destroy as many as possible. As the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs said, the Iraqi army was not driven out of Ramadi, they drove themselves out. We need to be helping out the Kurds a LOT more then we are doing and (this will piss some people off) we need to help Iran with airstrikes to back up their offensive attacks against ISIS.

Of course we could always throw back in 50,000 to 100,000 American troops (which we don't have) and end up just where we were before. With American encampments that have their own KFC's and Pizza Huts and many flag draped caskets (1,000s or more every year) coming back year after year and plan on spending hundreds of billions of dollar a year to keep them there for the foreseeable future (decades at least), because no matter when we leave, even if it's 50 or 100 years, the same thing that is happening now will happen then. This is Vietnam with sand. There is no way for America to win this war. We lost it when we invaded the first time and we'll lose it again eventually.

Taking out Saddam was one of the worst fucking mistakes Bush and Cheney ever did.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

This is problem is difficult because our current foreign policy is disjointed.

You cannot include our entire world-wide foreign policy under one blanket, just because our Middle East policy seems disjointed.

Obama has maneuver himself onto both sides of a sectarian conflict:

I beg to differ, it's the conflict that hasmaneuveredObama, he knows the importance of not throwing the weight of American influence behind one side or the other. ISIS, as you know, is fighting with everybody.

Your own comment outlines how complex a problem we have regarding the mess in the Mid-East, so how do you expect the State Department and the Administration to formulate a solid, cohesive policy in such an unstable and fluid environment?

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago
"Do you honestly think Assad would ever grant the presence of American ground forces in Syria?"Then we have no right to enter."I don't believe that is a reasonable assumption. What supporting facts or indicators would you present to support your reasoning?"1) our stated policy to topple Assad and our understanding with the Saudis that Assad must go; 2) our toppling of Qaddafi and the failed state that followed; 3) our participation in helping to drive the soviets out of Afghanistan and then abandoning It to become a terrorist haven; 4) toppling Saddam, withdrawing, and sitting on our hands while the Shia drive the Sunni to revolt.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago
"We are supporting the wrong side in Syria and Iraq. The President has to give up on the silly idea of a one nation Iraq and let it split into three individual nations. The Sunni, the Shia and the Kurds . . ."The Kurds are overextended. They do a good job of protecting themselves but they cannot stop ISIL from taking everything else and once everything else is gone, ISIL will turn its full attention on the Kurds and exterminate them. It's too late for a three state solution. If ISIL is not stopped, there will only be one state under ISIL control and they will cross the borders into other countries and spread like a disease. We should stop them now.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

America will not stomach another mass invasion of Iraq. That idea is off the table. That is why we must give support to the countries and groups who are really out to stop ISIS and clearly tat does not include the Iraqi army. All they are are delivery boys of the weapons we give over to ISIS and then they run. They won't fight. The Kurds and Iran and the Syrian resistance fighters are the three powers in the area who will die to destroy ISIS, We must help them do it! But not with a major invasion of American troops! NO! All we'll get is more dead Americans for nothing like we did the last time.

Oh and as for these people who say we should have left 30,000 to 50,000, thousand troops there and blame Obama for not doing it are wrong. The new Iraqi government refused to give them immunity while they were there. That means if a American Soldier shot and killed someone, he could be arrested and the police would decide if they were going to charge him or her and put him or her on trial for murder. Would you really want thousands of troops serving there when they have to obey every new law the new government came up with? To, in effect, be armed citizens of Iraq and no longer under the control of their own commanders? The President decided that, without immunity our troops were in more danger from the new Iraqi government, that we helped to put into power, then any terrorists that they might be arrested for killing. He did the right thing and it as the same thing any President would do. You can't have troops in a place who are expected to fight to be subject to arrest! To have to worry about the law against murder every time he pulls the trigger. Troops will hesitate and then they will die, wondering if they had the right under the law to shoot.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago
"You cannot include our entire world-wide foreign policy under one blanket, just because our Middle East policy seems disjointed."I was referring to our Middle East policy, not the entire world."I beg to differ, it's the conflict that has maneuvered Obama, he knows the importance of not throwing the weight of American influence behind one side or the other. ISIS, as you know, is fighting with everybody . . ."To be maneuvered by events is, itself, a failure of policy. If you will recall, ISIL grew into the present monstrosity as part of the Sunni rebel force that we funded to topple Assad. Weapons from Libya, our other foreign policy disaster, somehow walked themselves to to Syria and fell into the hands of the rebels. The Syrian problem was ignored by Obama and sectarian rivalry ignited into a regional conflict as some, including the Saudis, predicted would happen. ISIL then crossed the border into Iraq to spearhead a Sunni revolt there. ISIL could have been stopped at the Iraqi border a long time ago but Obama has been waiting for a magical healing of Shia/Sunni animosity, which grows worse not better, and limits our involvement to dropping bombs when he knows full well that bombing alone cannot stop ISIL. If an army of sociopaths is able to take Damascus and Baghdad, creating a terrorist state, then he will be a bigger fool than George Bush.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago
"America will not stomach another mass invasion of Iraq. That idea is off the table. That is why we must give support to the countries and groups who are really out to stop ISIS and clearly tat does not include the Iraqi army. All they are are delivery boys of the weapons we give over to ISIS and then they run. They won't fight. The Kurds and Iran and the Syrian resistance fighters are the three powers in the area who will die to destroy ISIS, We must help them do it! But not with a major invasion of American troops! NO! All we'll get is more dead Americans for nothing like we did the last time."The consequences of inaction will be worse.
 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

1) our stated policy to topple Assad and our understanding with the Saudis that Assad must go

We do have a stated policy to remove Assad, but where is the support for your claim that we will, "walk out, and create another failed state for us to handle in the future."?

2) our toppling of Qaddafi and the failed state that followed;

I believe it's a little premature to call post QaddafiLibya a "failed State", yes they are having difficulties staying on the transitional track proposed by the UN, but establishing a strong central government after years of oppression and dictatorship is never an easy transition. Or, are you suggesting that Libya was better off under Qaddafi?

3) our participation in helping to drive the soviets out of Afghanistan and then abandoning It to become a terrorist haven;

(?!) We helped drive the soviets out of Afghanistan? I was always under the impression the Russians (there were no "Soviets" at that time) had given up on the place and left for the same reason we gave up and left 12 years later; it always was and always will be a "terrorist haven"

4) toppling Saddam, withdrawing, and sitting on our hands while the Shia drive the Sunni to revolt.

We toppled Saddam ... then we withdrew. There was nothing in between those two events. That seems to me to be an over simplification of events, and does nothing to support your contention that the administrations' goal is to walk out and create a failed state.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    11 years ago

ISIL will turn its full attention on the Kurds and exterminate them

With our help and even help from the Iran, I don't think ISIS can come close to exterminating the Kurds. You are underestimating theKurdawholelot! I also believe you are giving ISIS far too much credit. Far too much.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

We do have a stated policy to remove Assad, but where is the support for your claim that we will, "walk out, and create another failed state for us to handle in the future."?

Obviously I can't provide evidence of events that haven't yet happened. Instead, I suggest that past is prologue and cite our actions inAfghanistan and Libya where we overturned theapple cartand walked away.

I believe it's a little premature to call post QaddafiLibya a "failed State", yes they are having difficulties staying on the transitional track proposed by the UN, but establishing a strong central government after years of oppression and dictatorship is never an easy transition. Or, are you suggesting that Libya was better off under Qaddafi?

You must be joking. Rebels have seized Tripoli and the elected government has fled to Tobruk. There is no central control at all and the place is in chaos. To make matters worse, ISIL is establishing a presence. And, no, I don't think replacing a dictator with a madhouse/civil war is an improvement.

(?!) We helped drive the soviets out of Afghanistan? I was always under the impression the Russians (there were no "Soviets" at that time) had given up on the place and left for the same reason we gave up and left 12 years later; it always was and always will be a "terrorist haven"

It has not always been a terrorist haven. TheSovietUnion did not fall until 1991 so it was the Soviet Union that invaded Afghanistan in 1979. To undermine the Soviets, we helped fund theMujahideenresistance, that included Osama Bin Ladin, andtaughtthem how to cripple a super power. Once the Soviets were driven out, we simply walked away. TheMujahedeensplit into warring factions and, ultimately, the Taliban emerged. The Taliban let Osama's al Qaeda terrorists useAfghanistanas a base of operations which led to the attack on 911.

We toppled Saddam ... then we withdrew. There was nothing in between those two events. That seems to me to be an over simplification of events, and does nothing to support your contention that the administrations' goal is to walk out and create a failed state.

With regard to Iraq, you can fill in the gap if you like and the fact will remain that we walked out leaving an unstable situation that's requiring us to consider going back in again to fix it. The goal of our foreign policy is not to create a failed state. Instead, a failedstate is theconsequenceof a poorly thought out foreign policy. Shifting to Syria, if Assad is toppled, I have not heard Obama articulate what comes next and why that is better. To me, Obama's policy is naive to the point of being similar to aDisneymovie: just kill thewickedwitch and,magically, the clouds will disperse, the sun will shine, flowers will bloom, andthe birds will sing. However, if you're not careful, another witch will replace the old one and she could be worse.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

With our help and even help from the Iran, I don't think ISIS can come close to exterminating the Kurds. You are underestimating theKurdawholelot! I also believe you are giving ISIS far too much credit. Far too much.

The Kurds are fighting for autonomy, not simply against ISIL. Every country in the area opposes Kurdish autonomy (Turkey, Iran, Iraq, and Syria) and would be slow to come to the Kurd's defense (if they came at all). I'm not giving ISIL credit but rather observing the speed with which this cancer spreads. Despite USair-power (and Iran and Shia militias), ISIL is advancing on Baghdad and controls 50% of Syria. My guess is that the Shia militias are overextended because they're crossing back and forth between Iraq and Syria (fighting in two different conflicts). Anyway, if ISIL captured Iraq and all the military equipment we dumped in there, they will be able to crush the Kurds and the surrounding countries may not lift a finger to stop them.

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Jerry Verlinger    11 years ago

I don't think ISIS can come close to exterminating the Kurds. You are underestimating theKurdawholelot!

I agree with that 100%!

I also believe you are giving ISIS far too much credit. Far too much.

I don't know about that, because they have not been held in check, they re getting stronger every day.

 
 

Who is online

Nerm_L
CB
bccrane
Snuffy
JohnRussell


83 visitors