Krauthammer: Iraq’s Decline into Chaos Traces Back to 2011, Not 2003
Ramadi falls. The Iraqi army flees. The great 60-nation antiIslamic State coalition so grandly proclaimed by the Obama administration is nowhere to be seen. Instead, its the defense minister of Iran who flies into Baghdad, an unsubtle demonstration of whos in charge while the U.S. air campaign proves futile and Americas alleged strategy for combating the Islamic State is in free fall.
It gets worse.
The Gulf States top leaders, betrayed and bitter, ostentatiously boycott President Obamas failed Camp David summit. We were Americas best friend in the Arab world for 50 years, laments Saudi Arabias former intelligence chief.
Note: were, not are.
We are scraping bottom. Following six years of President Obamas steady and determined withdrawal from the Middle East, Americas standing in the region has collapsed. And yet the question incessantly asked of the various presidential candidates is not about that. Its a retrospective hypothetical: Would you have invaded Iraq in 2003 if you had known then what we know now?
First, the question is not just a hypothetical, but an inherently impossible hypothetical. It contradicts itself. Had we known there were no weapons of mass destruction, the very question would not have arisen. The premise of the war the basis for going to the U.N., to the Congress, and, indeed, to the nation was Iraqs possession of WMD in violation of the central condition for the cease-fire that ended the first Gulf War. No WMD, no hypothetical to answer in the first place.
Second, the if you knew then question implicitly locates the origin and cause of the current disasters in 2003. As if the fall of Ramadi was predetermined then, as if the author of the current regional collapse is George W. Bush.
This is nonsense. The fact is that by the end of Bushs tenure, the war had been won. You can argue that the price of that victory was too high. Fine. We can debate that until the end of time. But what is not debatable is that it was a victory. Bush bequeathed to Obama a success. By whose measure? By Obamas. As he told the troops at Fort Bragg on December14, 2011, We are leaving behind a sovereign, stable, and self-reliant Iraq, with a representative government that was elected by its people. This was, said the president, a moment of success .
Which Obama proceeded to fully squander.
With the 2012 election approaching, he chose to liquidate our military presence in Iraq. We didnt just withdraw our forces. We abandoned, destroyed, or turned over our equipment, stores, installations, and bases. We surrendered our most valuable strategic assets, such as control of Iraqi airspace, soon to become the indispensable conduit for Iran to supply and sustain the Assad regime in Syria and cement its influence all the way to the Mediterranean. And, most relevant to the fall of Ramadi, we abandoned the vast intelligence network we had so painstakingly constructed in Anbar province, without which our current patchwork operations there are largely blind and correspondingly feeble.
The current collapse was not predetermined in 2003 but in 2011. Isnt that what should be asked of Hillary Clinton? We know you think the invasion of 2003 was a mistake. But what about the abandonment of 2011? Was that not a mistake?
Madam Secretary: When you arrived at State, al-Qaeda in Iraq had been crushed and expelled from Anbar. The Iraqi government had from Basra to Sadr City fought and defeated the radical, Iranian-proxy Shiite militias. Yet today these militias are back, once again dominating Baghdad. On your watch, we gave up our position as the dominant influence over a sovereign, stable, and self-reliant Iraq forfeiting that position gratuitously to Iran .
Was that not a mistake? And where were you when it was made?
Iraq is now a battlefield between the Sunni jihadists of the Islamic State and the Shiite jihadists of Irans Islamic Republic. There is no viable center. We abandoned it. The Obama administrations unilateral pullout created a vacuum for the entry of the worst of the worst.
And the damage was self-inflicted. The current situation in Iraq, says David Petraeus, is tragic foremost because it didnt have to turn out this way. The hard-earned progress of the surge was sustained for over three years.
Do the math. Thats 2009 through 2011, the first three Obama years. And then came the unraveling. When? The last U.S. troops left Iraq on December18, 2011. Want to do retrospective hypotheticals? Start there. Charles Krauthammer is a nationally syndicated columnist. 2015 The Washington Post Writers Group
Read more at: http://www.nationalreview.com/article/418738/iraqs-decline-chaos-traces-back-2011-not-2003-charles-krauthammer

Except that we DID know
False. Did you read what he said? Of course not, you rely on Daily Kos and Mother Jones and there completely unsupportable, exaggerated headlines. There's a reason this "story" is relegated to propaganda sites like that. If he said, "we knew Iraq had no WMD's" it would be a story covered by legitimate news outlets, not relegated to far left wing sites that provide mindless content for their mindless readers. Chris Matthews yelling is not evidence of anything other than the fact that Matthews is a blowhard.
The gullibility of some people is truly astounding. If evidence existed that Bush knew Iraq didn't have WMDs it would be the story of the century. The major news outlets would kill for proof of that story. It would make more careers than Watergate. Yet, some idiots are so stupid that they actually believe such a major story would be confined to the left wing echo chamber!
Good lord, if Jim Hoft, the right wing equivalent of Daily Kos, reported that Obama had given Iran the okay to destroy Israel, my suspicions would be immediately raised because of the website promoting it. Then I would look at the "evidence." If the "evidence" consisted of Bill O'Reilly yelling at an Obama official, I would simply ignore the "story." How many times will liberals be suckered into silly overheated claims based on totally misleading evidence that doesn't stand up to the slightest bit of reading comprehension.
Sadly, we will see more foolishness "reported" by the Daily Kos and propagated by fools.
Right's bizzaro world does "victory" mean having to keep large numbers of boots on the ground for years after we've "won."
The war was won. Iraq was stable. Or was Obama lying in 2011?
Everyone, including Obama's Sec Defense knew a small residual force for support wasnecessary. Yet Obama ignored the advice of pretty much every single informed Democrat andRepublicanand refused to leave a small residual US force. The result is on him.
bama was not referring to the time of Bush's welcome departure from the White House, as anyone with half a brain would know.
WTF are you talking about? Don't debate the voices in your head here. Obama is talking about the situation in Iraq in 2011 which wasstable. Then Obama ignored his own experts advice and calamitously withdrew US forces. The whole point of the article is the situation in 2011 when Obama made his obviously disastrous choice to withdraw.
needing to maintain vast numbers of boots on the ground
No one was arguing for "vast numbers." I have no idea what you are going on about.
Ah, Bush did negotiate the withdrawal of troops, it was one of the main bitches that the troops had to go when they (Obama administration) tried to renegotiate for them to stay longer.
They said HELL NO! the American people said HELL NO! guess what Obama was forced to go along with it.
So much for Bush didn't withdraw the troops, his team negotiated the removal, Obamas team tried to change it so they could stay longer.
Hows that for an Oopsie?
Facts are a bitch aren't they?
Very true. The only way the Iraqis were going to let American troops stay was if they were subject to Iraqi law. That wasn't going to happen.
Were you paying attention in 2012 when Obama took personal credit for removing the troops? Or during the debates when he proudly claimed that he refused to negotiate a continued status of force agreement that the Iraqis wanted to keep American troops there?
Facts are a bitch, aren't they? The withdrawal from Iraq was one of the main accomplishments Obama touted in 2012. With the rise of Isis, suddenly it's all Bush's doing the troops were withdrawn.
You rely on Allen West. Pfft.
You have no idea what "rely" means. Please show me any example where I "relied" on him. Here's a helpful hint: saying West is correct about something is not the same thing as relying on him. I trust you, or the person you pay to explain simple things to you, will understand the difference.
So why didn'tBushwithdraw the troops?
We are talking about the condition of Iraq in 2011. It's in the title and everything! Do you believe George Bush was president in 2011?
Okay, so he lied, or at least stretched the truth a bit. He was negotiating to keep up to 10,000 troops in Iraq, but the Iraqis would have nothing to do with it unless the troops were subject to Iraqi law. It's one of the many reasons I didn't vote for Obama.
This is from the Onion, right ?
Yeah. Things are tough for Pulitzer prize winners for commentary. They work for the Onion now.
You can see why. So many Americans are so simple minded that they can't follow or rebut arguments so they just rely on parroting a hackey joke that was original 20 years ago.
Some people even blame the many deaths of Iraqi civilians on the US troops . Absurd . They happened due to the sectarian conflicts between Sunni and Shia .
Well that's good I personally think he is even more clueless than his brother.
And VERY TRUE on the second Iraq excursion. the first one was justified and executed to perfection.
The second was a clusterfuck of mega proportions.
Their lies sound a lot like the democrats lies.
--President Bill Clinton, Feb. 4, 1998
"If Saddam rejects peace and we have to use force, our purpose is clear. We want to seriously diminish the threat posed by Iraq's weapons of mass destruction program."
--President Bill Clinton, Feb. 17, 1998
"Iraq is a long way from [here], but what happens there matters a great deal here. For the risks that the leaders of a rogue state will use nuclear, chemical or biological weapons against us or our allies is the greatest security threat we face."
--Madeline Albright, Feb 18, 1998
"He will use those weapons of mass destruction again, as he has ten times since 1983."
--Sandy Berger, Clinton National Security Adviser, Feb, 18, 1998
"[W]e urge you, after consulting with Congress, and consistent with the U.S. Constitution and laws, to take necessary actions (including, if appropriate, air and missile strikes on suspect Iraqi sites) to respond effectively to the threat posed by Iraq's refusal to end its weapons of mass destruction programs."
Letter to President Clinton, signed by:
-- Democratic Senators Carl Levin, Tom Daschle, John Kerry, and others, Oct. 9, 1998
"Saddam Hussein has been engaged in the development of weapons of mass destruction technology which is a threat to countries in the region and he has made a mockery of the weapons inspection process."
-Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D, CA), Dec. 16, 1998
"Hussein has ... chosen to spend his money on building weapons of mass destruction and palaces for his cronies."
-- Madeline Albright, Clinton Secretary of State, Nov. 10, 1999
"There is no doubt that ... Saddam Hussein has reinvigorated his weapons programs. Reports indicate that biological, chemical and nuclear programs continue apace and may be back to pre-Gulf War status. In addition, Saddam continues to redefine delivery systems and is doubtless using the cover of a licit missile program to develop longer-range missiles that will threaten the United States and our allies."
Letter to President Bush, Signed by:
-- Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL), and others, Dec 5, 2001
"We begin with the common belief that Saddam Hussein is a tyrant and a threat to the peace and stability of the region. He has ignored the mandate of the United Nations and is building weapons of mass destruction and th! e means of delivering them."
-- Sen. Carl Levin (D, MI), Sept. 19, 2002
"We know that he has stored secret supplies of biological and chemical weapons throughout his country."
-- Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002
"Iraq's search for weapons of mass destruction has proven impossible to deter and we should assume that it will continue for as long as Saddam is in power."
-- Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002
"We have known for many years that Saddam Hussein is seeking and developing weapons of mass destruction."
-- Sen. Ted Kennedy (D, MA), Sept. 27, 2002
"The last UN weapons inspectors left Iraq in October of 1998. We are confident that Saddam Hussein retains some stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, and that he has since embarked on a crash course to build up his chemical and biological warfare capabilities. Intelligence reports indicate that he is seeking nuclear weapons..."
-- Sen. Robert Byrd (D, WV), Oct. 3, 2002
"I will be voting to give the President of the United States the authority to use force -- if necessary -- to disarm Saddam Hussein because I believe that a deadly arsenal of weapons of mass destruction in his hands is a real and grave threat to our security."
-- Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Oct. 9, 2002
"There is unmistakable evidence that Saddam Hussein is working aggressively to develop nuclear weapons and will likely have nuclear weapons within the next five years ... We also should remember we have always underestimated the progress Saddam has made in development of weapons of mass destruction."
-- Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D, WV), Oct 10, 2002
"He has systematically violated, over the course of the past 11 years, every significant UN resolution that has demanded that he disarm and destroy his chemical and biological weapons, and any nuclear capacity. This he has refused to do"
-- Rep. Henry Waxman (D, CA), Oct. 10, 2002
"In the four years since the inspectors left, intelligence reports show that Saddam Hussein has worked to rebuild his chemical and biological weapons stock, his missile delivery capability, and his nuclear program. He has also given aid, comfort, and sanctuary to terrorists, including al Qaeda members ... It is clear, however, that if left unchecked, Saddam Hussein will continue to increase his capacity to wage biological and chemical warfare, and will keep trying to develop nuclear weapons."
-- Sen. Hillary Clinton (D, NY), Oct 10, 2002
"We are in possession of what I think to be compelling evidence that Saddam Hussein has, and has had for a number of years, a developing capacity for the production and storage of weapons of mass destruction."
-- Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL), Dec. 8, 2002
"Without question, we need to disarm Saddam Hussein. He is a brutal, murderous dictator, leading an oppressive regime ... He presents a particularly grievous threat because he is so consistently prone to miscalculation ... And now he is miscalculating America's response to his continued deceit and his consistent grasp for weapons of mass destruction ... So the threat of Saddam Hussein with weapons of mass destruction is real..."
-- Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Jan. 23. 2003
Were those Democrats lying?
Yes they did there was a vote.
Here are the Democratic Senators who voted YEA on October 2002.
Baucus (D-MT), Yea
Bayh (D-IN), Yea
Biden (D-DE), Yea
Breaux (D-LA), Yea
Cantwell (D-WA), Yea
Carnahan (D-MO), Yea
Carper (D-DE), Yea
Cleland (D-GA), Yea
Clinton (D-NY), Yea
Daschle (D-SD), Yea
Dodd (D-CT), Yea
Dorgan (D-ND), Yea
Edwards (D-NC), Yea
Feinstein (D-CA), Yea
Harkin (D-IA), Yea
Hollings (D-SC), Yea
Johnson (D-SD), Yea
Kerry (D-MA), Yea
Kohl (D-WI), Yea
Landrieu (D-LA), Yea
Lieberman (D-CT), Yea
Lincoln (D-AR), Yea
Miller (D-GA), Yea
Nelson (D-FL), Yea
Nelson (D-NE), Yea
Reid (D-NV), Yea
Rockefeller (D-WV), Yea
Schumer (D-NY), Yea
Torricelli (D-NJ), Yea
Our Iraqi allies said. essentially, "Thank you for getting rid of Saddam, a horror which you visited upon us , now please get the hell out of our country and leave us alone to get friendly with Iran".
Iraq Resolution
Many voted to empower the President and at the same time disagreed with the way he abused that privilege.
See the amendments to the Resolution , such as:
The Durbin Amendment[ edit ]
To amend the authorization for the use of the Armed Forces to cover an imminent threat posed by Iraq's weapons of mass destruction rather than the continuing threat posed by Iraq. Sponsored by Sen. Dick Durbin (D-IL). [24] Amendment SA 4865 not agreed to by Yea-Nay Vote: 30 - 70 [25]Leading opponents of the resolution included SenatorsRuss Feingoldand Edward Kennedy.
SenatorsChris Dodd,Hillary ClintonandMike Gravelwere some of the most outspoken critics of the Iraq War. Ron Paul has said that "The war in Iraq was sold to us with false information. The area is more dangerous now than when we entered it. We destroyed a regime hated by our direct enemies, the jihadists, and created thousands of new recruits for them. This war has cost more than 3,000 American lives, thousands of seriously wounded, and hundreds of billions of dollars."
If we continue with American imperialism, we're done as a nation. Truly are. And two things coming at us. We're going to be irrelevant in the world. You see this in foreign affairs when you see all these other countries making arrangements by themselves; don't even invite us to the meeting. Why? We come to a meeting; we think we know it all. We're the superpower you've got to listen to us.
The truth is the chicken-hawks werethrilledwith the "victory" of "Desert Storm" and wantedmoreof that same thrill.They were convinced war with Iraq would be a "cake-walk", would be paid for by Iraqi oil, and require no sacrifice on their parts (or on the parts of their families): a volunteer army, no victory gardens or buy US Bonds campaigns and no dropping of the "temporary" tax cuts.Fool speed ahead, cut and spend!
It only took only one success, the victory of "Desert Storm", to give the "chicken-hawks" their excuse tounlearn the lesson of Vietnam. The lesson is "have a clear military objective, use overwhelming force, and,then,get out!". Instead, what the neocons came away with was "war is easy and war with Iraq will be a cake-walk". Instead of an option oflast-resort, endless, pre-emptive war became a "handy tool" of our foreign policy (enforcing our will).
The "neocons" did not trust the American people, on whose behalf they believed they were acting, to trust theirreasons for actingproactively, and preemptively, against possible,futurethreats, not only to the USA but to Israel (what if Saddam had given chemical weapons to the Palestinians?). They wanted to serve the American peoples' best interests, but the American people obviously did not know what was good for them. The attacks of 9/11 was theirlicense to put a bunch of things "right". (You must remember, there were a frustrating 8 years of the Clinton administration between "Desert Storm" and GW Bush).
Really? A frustrating 8 years?
What about Bosnia?
Let's see, that's why we have no troops in Germany, Japan and Italy anymore. Oh, wait.
It's always fun to see stories about how the war with Iraq started in 2003. It started when Saddam and his henchmen invaded Kuwait, a sovereign nation of it's own. Hostilities supposedly ceased, but anyone that was over there knows that never really happened-The Iraqis kept violating the rules established for the cease fire, all the way up to attempting to assassinate President Bush (1st). Frequent no fly zone violations, locking on coalition aircraft with targeting radar, and o so on, the list goes on and on. Nothing truly ended in between Desert Storm I and II, just the 'level' of warfare.
Not completely true... We stopped taking the advice of the surrounding Arab nations that recommended that Saddam be left in power after Desert Storm. You know.... nations that knew what would happen in the power vacuum. Oh and yes, there was the disbanding of the Republican Guard, that would have been useful to hold the country together even with Saddam gone.
Bush/Cheney broke it, Bush/Cheney bought it, and America is having to live with their decisions that date back to 2003
Nope, Jeb has his own problems to deal with. On this level his being a son and brother of presidents is a hindrance rather than a help. Much like being a Kennedy wasn't any help to Teddy, and actually hurt his chances at the presidency.
I will tell ya this, if Jeb does manage to get the nomination, the republican party has no connection to the people anymore. Neither will it represent reality.
Your comparison to the Kennedy name is pretty appropriate in this case.
BTW..... when you find political reality in this country, please leave a trail of breadcrumbs, or at least your empties for me to follow. If I find it first, I'll be sure to do the same for you.
Stop talking about yourself in such a disparaging manner blue . Have some self esteem !
Yeah , it was never broken to begin with :
The Butcher of Bagdad was OK with you Fly ?
LOL about mustard gas ? How sick does one have to be to do that ?
Iraq did have mustard gas . Nothing to laugh about . What "problem" do you have have that you didn't realize that ?