The solution to automation-related job loss starts with admitting it’s happening
Original article by Bryan Clark - The Next Web
-------------------------------------
Automation is coming?
No, it’s already here While the current administration focuses on bringing jobs back to the United States from China and Mexico, the real threat to job loss already resides within our borders.
According to a study by two Ball State University professors, 87-percent of all manufacturing jobs lost from 2000 to 2010 weren’t due to globalization, but robots. All told, some five million fewer manufacturing jobs exist today than in 2000, a problem government leaders are mostly ignoring. TNW alum Martin Bryant likened it to ‘recklessly putting their heads in the sand‘ when describing politician’s views on automation.
Brooklyn-based Voodoo Manufacturing offers a peek into what this future could look like.
The 3D printing company consists of nine printers mounted on server racks, a track where a robotic arm harvests finished plates, and a plate “hopper” that feeds new, clean plates to the robot as needed. This is forward thinking, as 3D printing isn’t laborious, per se, but it does require human intervention.
Unfortunately for most humans, these are exactly the types of menial jobs best handled by robots.
Whether you choose to embrace it is up to you, but there’s no denying it’s coming. Humans simply can’t match robots in output at scale.
“Today we have about a 30- to 40-percent utilization rate of our factory,” explained Voodoo Manufacturing CPO Jonathan Schwartz. “We’re hoping to push that to 90- to 95-percent over the next three-to-five years.”
This sort of efficiency before the automation age was unheard of. Now, it’s not only a possibility, it’s a near-certainty. And it’s hard to blame a company aiming to cut costs while improving output. Business, after all, isn’t charity, and global competition is making it harder to compete than ever. If robots offer an edge, businesses are likely to take it.
But maybe we’re focusing on the wrong things.
Once we let the cat out of the bag, which we assuredly did in the push toward automation, it’s not something we can undo. While we attempt to write off job loss to globalization — a petty tactic used to distract, not inform — maybe it’s time to recognize the true cause. And once understand where our jobs are going, maybe then we can put our collective heads together to find out a solution for a newly unemployed workforce.
It’s time to adapt, to create a future that’s both cognizant of what’s coming while impervious to the fear-based rhetoric that surrounds it. Automation is a good thing, or it will be at some point. There will be hurdles, and we will overcome them. But the conversation can’t get underway, at least not in an impactful way, until we quit trying to shove the cat back into the bag.
As for the solution, I don’t have one. But automation is coming, and it’s time we stop pretending we can stop it. It’s time to leap, while at the same time figuring out what this new landing area looks like.
Bring on the robots.
Tags
Who is online
74 visitors

According to a study by two Ball State University professors, 87-percent of all manufacturing jobs lost from 2000 to 2010 weren’t due to globalization, but robots.
Well...I guess one could always take courses in robot maintenance or programming?
A lot of robot programming is already done by robots. Maintenance will take a while, but.
A lot of robot programming is already done by robots. Maintenance will take a while, but.
Even if humans do maintenance: if one robot replaces, say, 10 or 20 humans-- and creates 1 maintenance job-- the net result is a tremendous loss of jobs. (And probbly one maintenance job could be used to service numerous robots).
In addition as robot design improves, I wonder how much maintenance they would require ? I could imagine many types of machines that could operate for days-- perhaps even weeks-- without needed any maintenance at all...or very little.
Intuitively it seems that eventually we will solve the problem-- but I really can't see how increased use if robots would not result in a tremendous decrease in jobs for humans.
Beginning to sound like the start of "The Terminator"
It's the future. Playing ostrich won't help.
I'm glad I'm retired. With all of the changes happening it's beginning to feel more like an escape then anything else. Just so they leave my Social Security and Medicare alone.
Oh, yeah!
But my grandchildren.....
It's time for the Millennials to step forward and enter the fight. The baby boomer generation that I am a part of have done a lot of the work and fought hard, but too many of them sat out this last election and look what we ended up with. They need to get active! They need to run for office! THEY need to start thinking about their future and steal it back from the old men running Washington today! Most of those old men don't have their best interests at heart, so they have to seize power and mold the world into how it will work best for them, like we did! The future is theirs! TAKE IT! The past is ours.
It's time for the Millennials to step forward and enter the fight. The baby boomer generation that I am a part of have done a lot of the work and fought hard, but too many of them sat out this last election and look what we ended up with. They need to get active! They need to run for office! THEY need to start thinking about their future and steal it back from the old men running Washington today! Most of those old men don't have their best interests at heart, so they have to seize power and mold the world into how it will work best for them, like we did! The future is theirs! TAKE IT! The past is ours.
YES, YET, YES!
Its time for the younger generation to pick up the proverbial torch!
To channel all that pent up energy-- and march off to a Brave New World! Marchon Enfants de la Patrie-- La Jour Du Boire et Arrive!
Yes-- Millennials Must Vigorously March Off into the Sunset into a Brave new World!
Aren't the Pet Shop Boys from the 1980's?
Yes-- they are from the 80's. But its the spirit that counts. The Pet Shop Boys should be an inspiration to all Millennials! (And besides, the garbage Millennials listen to now-a-days is certainly no inspiration to them for the difficult task that lies ahead! The die is cast-- they must now face virtually endless legions of insidious foes in the form of..robots!
And I absolutely adore the Pet Shop Boys . . . they are so wonderfully .. GHEY!!!
(And especially that video-- the hats alone make it worth watching!).
Well if it's about hats
<iframe width="854" height="480" src="https://www.youtube.com/embed/IIEVqFB4WUo" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>
Kitsch is good.... but not five fucking minutes of it!!
THEY need to start thinking about their future and steal it back from the old men running Washington today! Most of those old men don't have their best interests at heart...
The elderly are not particularly fixated on the future. As you say, the young must step up.
We have to change our "work ethic". "Toil" is not "noble". Keeping people "on the job"... flipping hamburgers... is not rendering them more noble. It degrades them, putting them in a pointless squirrel cage.
Well...I guess one could always take courses in robot maintenance or programming?
I believe there's actually a shortage of good programmers now (all sorts of programming, nt just robots.Don't knw if its still true.
Apparently most American kids don't want to go into the field.
I learned a little programming a while back-- it really does take an unusual kind of mind to really understand hw to do it well.
But people from some poor countries study it in hope of coming to the U.S. and really doing well.
Recently I met a group of people, some new friends. Most of them are programmers-- and about 90% of them are either Chinese-American or Indian (India)-American.
There's a joke about meeting Indian-Americans for the first time-- you ask them:
Which type of Indian are you? A motel owner or a computer programmer?
(So many are programmers. And many are sucessful entrepreneurs-- often they own a motel or a 7-11).
I remember when I was installing and teaching staffs who to use computer property management systems in mid-level hotels (Holiday Inn, Staybridge, etc.) one of the first questions we asked before we got the paperwork and our flight information was is it a Patel property. At least one out of every three properties I worked was owned by someone named Patel.
I remember when I was installing and teaching staffs who to use computer property management systems in mid-level hotels (Holiday Inn, Staybridge, etc.) one of the first questions we asked before we got the paperwork and our flight information was is it a Patel property. At least one out of every three properties I worked was owned by someone named Patel.
And this may surprise a lot of people-- but Indians (India) are one of the wealthiest ethnic groups in the U.S. They are very industrious, entrepreneurial-- and many have well paying jobs in high tech. Plus they have values consistent with success. I will google to see if I can find a good article on the subject.
And this may surprise a lot of people-- but Indians (India) are one of the wealthiest ethnic groups in the U.S. They are very industrious, entrepreneurial-- and many have well paying jobs in high tech. Plus they have values consistent with success. I will google to see if I can find a good article on the subject.
Well, as they say in India--Voila!
This US Ethnic Group Makes the Most Money
Guess who?
Indian Americans are the richest ethnic group in the United States, earning a median income of $100,547 in 2013, according to data from the U.S. Census Bureau . Compare that to $51,939, which was the median income for all Americans during the same period.
Many Indian Americans are recent arrivals to the United States. In 2010, more than 87 percent of Indian-American adults were foreign born, which might help explain their current success.
“Immigrants are more likely than the native born to hold a BA [bachelor’s degree] and they’re much more likely than the native born to hold a higher degree like a master’s degree,” said Leah Platt Boustan, an associate professor of economics at the University of California, Los Angeles, who has studied immigration patterns.
Americans of Indian descent do follow that pattern. They are among the most highly educated ethnic groups in the U.S . In 2010, 70 percent of those aged 25 and older had college degrees. Almost one-third (28 percent) of Indian Americans work in science and engineering fields , according to the 2013 American Community Survey and the Pew Research Center . (LINK)
Hey, wait a second. This is like totally politically incorrect. What about that so-called "White privilege" we keep hearing about? Endlessly...
You know-- that unfair advantage that all White people have. Shouldn't that make"Whites" the richest...? (And everyone knows that Indians aren't "White"-- they are "Brown".. so they should be at a disadvantage. Because of all the racism against Brown people" in this country Indians can't possibly succeed...(could they???)
I'm glad I don't have to try to compete against them.
You know-- that unfair advantage that all White people have. Shouldn't that make"Whites" the richest...? (And everyone knows that Indians aren't "White"-- they are "Brown".. so they should be at a disadvantage. Because of all the racism against Brown people" in this country Indians can't possibly succeed...(could they???)
There's no contradiction. The "average White" includes both the 1% and Joe Sixpack.
As for "anti-Brown"... I think the Indian model shows that mutual help inside a community is more powerful than discrimination from without. There are other examples of communities that are successful despite discrimination.
My wife and I drive across the country when going to/from Yuma/France. I can affirm that the Patels are still there!
If I understand correctly, they are a vast "family" so nebulous that exact blood relationships are often unknown... but "family assistance" operates all the same. A "young Patel" can always find an "uncle" to give him a start... and in exchange, when he has succeeded, he will be expected to give a young "nephew" a start...
There's a joke about meeting Indian-Americans for the first time-- you ask them:
Which type of Indian are you? A motel owner or a computer programmer?
(So many are programmers. And many are successful entrepreneurs-- often they own a motel or a 7-11).
And now our idiot Fuhrer wants to mess with H-1B visas:
Since the early 1990s, H-1B visas have helped companies in the U.S. access qualified — and typically lower-paid — technology workers. The visas require that recipients hold a bachelor's degree and qualify as practitioners of a "specialty occupation" in their field of study.
Currently, around 85,000 visas are granted annually to immigrants by the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) , which is part of the Department of Homeland Security. After that, the individual holding the visa can apply for a green card, making H-1Bs a common path for immigrants who want to continue to work and settle in the United States.
About 70 percent of the 85,000 H-1B visas granted in 2015 were issued to engineers, designers, coders and others from India, according to Goldman Sachs.
That has put the country's tech sector, including IT outsourcing companies like Infosys , Tata Consultancy Services , Wipro and Cognizant — under pressure. Wipro and Cognizant were not immediately available for comment; Tata and Infosys declined to comment for this report.
"Immigration restrictions are the main source of India's vulnerability," Sonal Varma, chief India economist at Nomura, wrote to clients. Varma went on to say that the viability of the offshoring model used by Indian software companies could be at risk.
Citi agrees.
"Immigration reform remains an overhang to watch and likely a key theme for the IT services sector in 2017," Surendra Goyal, Citi's head of India Research, wrote to clients in early January.
The Trump administration may make the case that skilled immigrants are one of the reasons some Americans are out of work, but opponents in Silicon Valley and elsewhere will argue that many of those immigrants are behind the success of U.S. tech start-ups.
Silicon valley is correct-- there just aren't that many American kids going into programming-- so when it comes to attracting the very best programming talent in the world (& hi tech is an extremely competitive sector) .. . American companies need to be able tap into the very best talent-- which means looking at the pool of programmers & related people worldwide.
(Read it all)
When I first got into computers in 1973 there weren't very many programmers. In fact we had none at our base. Our SAC programmers were down in Alabama at Gunter AFB and we called them on a secure line when we had a problem. Then a few years later when I was discharged in 1977 it seemed that every high school counselor must have told everyone to become a programmer or operator and they were everywhere. The problem is that it takes a certain type of person to do these jobs and many of them clearly were not cut out for it and just were not very good. And you could tell they hated it. You had to have a certain amount of insanity and rebelliousness to be good in computers. You have to be sort of like Hawkeye as opposed to Major Burns. If you weren't willing to push things and take chances you never got better at your job and got the most out of your equipment, which was the goal. Take the computer out on the track and see what it'll do and what else you can get it to do that's not in the book. That was the fun part.
Dear Friend Bob Nelson: True.
The real test of leadership is to find a way to use technology to create domestic jobs which increase our middle class, increase what we export, and reduce government expenses from former middle class, unemployed and unemployed Americans.
It is possible.
I wish I saw someone taking steps necessary to make it happen.
Good article.
Well done.
Enoch.
IMNAAHO, all robots should tithe "to promote the General Welfare".
IMHO so should the U.S. government.
IMNAAHO, all robots should tithe "to promote the General Welfare".
Wow! "Great minds think alike!"
A very smart guy (who definitely has some great insights as to how the advance of technologies effects society) just recently (2/20!) expressed similar thoughts. (LINK)
This "new" idea is in fact only a new expression of an old one: society needs cash to assist its least favored members. Whatever the mechanism, from non-governmental charity to Islamic alms (zakat) to...
The definition of "least favored" must evolve as society (technology) evolves.
Economists are already talking about "guaranteed minimum income", and a few countries are headed that way.
Put all three together and you get, "Tax the robots!"
There was a study that zeroed in on manufacturing jobs lost due to NAFTA. I forget the exact figures but the majority of manufacturing jobs lost in the U.S. were due to automation, not foreign labor.
Coal mining is the same situation, more automation less human labor.
It's here and our ''leaders'' have their heads in the sand.
Our "leaders" don't want to admit to their base that they will never mine coal again. They really, really, REALLY don't want to address the question what future there is for a "working class" (and I don't mean just blue-collar) in a world of robots.
Automation will keep taking away jobs from humans. I doubt that our leaders will even knowledge that it's happening.
Get into political office, ignore and point fingers, retire with a nice pension and bennies. That's the American way, well for the political class.
What I found very interesting is an article that stated most of the robots used in the U.S. are made in Germany and Japan
Our "leaders" don't want to admit to their base that they will never mine coal again.
Exactly. Coal mining is finished-- its just a matter of time before it ceases totally. I've heard Trump speak about it continuing-- quite simply he's lying. (Unfortunately many miners in coal producing areas believe him, because the truth is too difficult to face).
BTW, many people realize that ingestion of Mercury is toxic. But what many people don't realize is what the main source of Mercury in our lives happens to be (No its not broken thermometers! Seriously, how many broken thermometers have you come in contact with in your entire life?):
Mercury and Coal
Coal-fired power plants are the largest source of mercury in the United States, accounting for about 41 percent (48 tons in 1999) of industrial releases.
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, eight percent of American women of childbearing age had unsafe levels of mercury in their blood, putting approximately 322,000 newborns at risk of neurological deficits. Mercury exposure also can lead to increase cardiovascular risk in adults.
When mercury is deposited on land or in water, microorganisms convert part of it to a highly toxic form called methylmercury. When fish and animals eat these microorganisms, the toxins accumulate and can interfere with reproduction, growth, and behavior, and can even cause death.
(LINK)
This bears repeating: Coal-fired power plants are the largest source of Mercury in the United States . . .
Didn't know this. Thanks.
Businesses continually try to find ways to increase profitability by cutting costs. So even if Trump is successful in getting many factories to move back to the U.S. (which IMO is doubtful anyway)-- the odds are that many of the jobs in those factories won't be done by human workers-- they'll be done by robots!
And when he promised to reopen all of those coal mines in Appalachia he was just plain lying. Tere was a report on on of the networks the other night where they were talking to the CEO of the 2nd largest electric company in Michigan and his plants were getting older. As they were coming offline and being replaced he was replacing them with a combination of natural gas and wind power. He said he can't imagine any new plant being built that would be coal fired.
"Clean coal" is a chimera. The jobs talk is pure grandstanding.
I saw that interview-- yes, he couldn't imagine any new coal plants being built.
I remember when Solar power was first introduced-- it was so expensive that most people couldn't afford it. But now due to advances in the technology its becoming more widespread.
And wind power..
There are also some promising technologies being explored that would harness the natural movement of the ocean tides to generate electricity. Some really creative ideas. And after the initial investment in equipment, except for occasional maintenance-- the movement of the tides, while providing YUGE amounts of energy-- is a gift from nature-- its free! (Of course we already use the natural movement of water in another way-- hydroelectric power from dams. But those possibilities are limited. However locations where the tides can be harnessed are pretty widespread).
But coal? Fergeddaboudit.
Just to the West of us in the pass between the desert here and the ocean area we have a huge wind farm. Hundreds of giant windmills constantly turning in the constant winds coming through the mountain pass. It's a sight to see. 40 years ago when people were talking about windmills and wind power they were written off as some kind of environmentalist hippie nuts. Now major energy company own them and they are providing electricity for hundreds of thousands of homes. Are they the only solution? No, but they are a big part of it!
We need robots-- working on a factory assembly line can be quite exhausting!
[Factory Scene - Chaplin in Modern Times]
Still modern a century later!
Still modern a century later!
(You know what they say: "Plus ça change . . . ")
A lot of Charlie Chaplin's stuff was amazing.
Unfortunately Chaplin is not widely known by most people today.
Here's another gem. The final speech from The Great Dictator (Chaplin actually speaks!):
A true classic...
The Other Great Chaplin Speech / The Tyranny of Authority
Charlie Chaplin's speech at the end of The Great Dictator has become famous as one of the most inspirational ever recorded. 17 years later, having been forced from the United States because of his political views, Chaplin made A King In New York, satarising McCarthyism and once again using an epic speech to share his views. This time it is his 10 year old son, Michael Chaplin, who delivers it...
OK-- enough of my derails!
Now back to the topic at hand...
OK-- enough of my derails!
Now back to the topic at hand...
Ok-- so I lied...(at least I'm honest about it).
Charlie Chaplin: The Greatest Speech Ever Made
My favorite film of his ever. The brilliance of the speech is that you could tell he was not acting. That he was completely sincere. That it was a real message for the people watching. That it was made just before WWII started was amazing and prophetic, just as Casablanca being made just before America entered the war. I also love the scene where he is playing with inflated earth balloon.
And have to noticed that the symbol that they use instead of the Swastika looks just like the flag for the proposed state of Jefferson?
the symbol that they use instead of the Swastika looks just like the flag for the proposed state of Jefferson?
OMG-- I hadn't realized that! I wonder if its more than just a coincidence?
LOL! They might well "be on the same wave-length"!
the symbol that they use instead of the Swastika looks just like the flag for the proposed state of Jefferson?
OMG-- I hadn't realized that! I wonder if its more than just a coincidence?
LOL! They might well "be on the same wave-length"!
P.S: I had not seen that other video before ("The Other Great Chaplin Speech", above). I was wondering who the kid was-- its Chaplin's son! Fascinating video).
And if anyone hasn't seen the other video-- The Factory Scene from Modern Times-- Its exceptional. (I realize its not politically correct on NT to actually watch videos before commenting on them, but that one is wonderful-- and very, very funny).
Well, they had to get the symbol from somewhere. I have been thinking every time I see XX's flag symbol that "Where have I seen that before? I know I have seen it somewhere?" and there it is! LOL! It has to be some sort of mental connection!
Well, they had to get the symbol from somewhere. I have been thinking every time I see XX's flag symbol that "Where have I seen that before? I know I have seen it somewhere?" and there it is! LOL! It has to be some sort of mental connection!
I just realized-- maybe we've got XXjefferson figured entirely wrong. Maybe he/she (she?) is actually a brilliant satirist-- in the mold of a Chaplin. And all the stuff she posts is not what it seems, but rather very subtle and very brilliant satire! Perhaps its all "gone over our heads"--XXJefferson has been fooling us us along!
(Ya have to admit-- some of it is really quite bizarre-- when you think about it. It can't be serious. Damn-- she had us fooled all long-- its all actually satire.
Brilliant!!!
It's either extremely brilliant...or extremely...(censored)
Trump needs to hear that speech, but I doubt he'd see that Chaplin was also talking about men like him. He's too thick headed. Too egotistical. Too arrogant.
And have to noticed that the symbol that they use instead of the Swastika looks just like the flag for the proposed state of Jefferson?
I just went to his home page and the resemblance is undeniable!
Still modern a century later!
(You know what they say: "Plus ça change . . . ")
A lot of Charlie Chaplin's stuff was amazing.
Unfortunately Chaplin is not widely known by most people today.
Where is Buzz (He of the Orient) when you most need him?
This is an excellent article/study by the Brookings Institution on coal mining and it's future in the U.S.
From the article.
A recent study , for instance, has shown that growth in the solar industry can absorb all U.S. coal workers who will be laid off during the next 15 years.
A recent study , for instance, has shown that growth in the solar industry can absorb all U.S. coal workers who will be laid off during the next 15 years.
Let's hope so.
I don't know how much manpower it takes to manufacture solar panels. but maybe its the installation where many people are needed (Of course, in the time-honoured tradition of the Internet, I haven't actually read the linked article before commenting on it
).
It's like a murder mystery: Who killed King Coal?
Globalization didn't kill King Coal. The EPA didn't kill King Coal.
Big Oil killed King Coal. Natural gas obtained through fracking.
And Big OIl managed to frame the EPA for the murder!
It's ironic that Trump is pushing coal and at the same time fracking...Natural gas is one of the main reason that coal is going the way of, coal.
If interested in the possibilities of where we are headed on this issue, I suggest a book called The Master Algorithm, by Pedro Domingos. It covers the history and future of machine learning, which is a very complicated and sophisticated subject. The first 3/4 of the book is very technical, and above my head anyways, but the last 1/4 goes into futuristic scenarios where humans basically evolve towards having an individual avatar that thinks for you. Automation is so advanced that there's no other option than a basic wage for everyone in return for nothing. Those who want more can enter what's left of the ultra competitive industries that still use humans. The book is surprisingly upbeat about it, but it certainly didn't leave me with a good feeling.