╌>

The Gas Attack in Syria ... ... by Bob Nelson

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  bob-nelson  •  9 years ago  •  132 comments

The Gas Attack in Syria   ...   ...   by Bob Nelson

So now what should we do?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson    9 years ago

Donald? Rex? Jared?

What should we do?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

They haven't the slightest fucking idea...

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

The Syrian mess is inextricable. But... "some people" have been pretending that "the solution" is easy to find. 

So... 

What... should... we... do?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Trump will have to ask Putin what it's OK for him to do since Assad is Putin's friend too.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

That does complicate "American" diplomacy...  close call

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Maybe Putin will flip a coin? Or give it some serious thought..."Hmmmm a single warm water port for the Russian Navy in Syria....or many, many, many warm water ports for the Russian Navy in the USA!!! Up your ass Assad!!! Come to Papa Bear my little Donnie Wonnie!!! Mauh!!!"

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

You think Assad did this?   Really?

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

You mean Vladimir, Shawn, Jared, Rex, Ivanka, Mike and then maybe Donald.   I think one thing we will all agree on is Donald will blame anything that isn't a success on Barack Obama.

This is a terrible situation and IMO, Barack Obama should have handled this a long time ago just like he should have handled Russia.  Now we have a man child in the White House who has more allegiance to Russia than America.

I'm also a believer that we cannot police the world.  We have a responsibility but we need to figure out what our role should be going forward on the international level.  For so long we have framed America as a Country that has taken on the role as advocate and global police but we can't continue to take on this burden.  It's not feasible and our citizens no longer are interested in global unity or humanitarian military acts.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  PJ   9 years ago

Our leaders' capacity to NOT LEARN is amazing. Poppy Bush ran a very successful Gulf War I because he had a specific goal: kick Saddam out of Kuwait, and smash the Iraqi army so it wouldn't ever be tempted to try again. He gave his orders to his generals and let them do the job... and then everyone came home. In a little over six months, the war was won and our troops were home again.

And his son wanted to do better... and we're still quagmired over fifteen years later... 

Obama wanted to get us out, but didn't have the moral courage to just get the fuçk out... and then he got us into Syria all by himself. (Well... kinda sorta pushed by McCain and all the GOP hawks, but he should have stayed out!)

Now we have Trump, who seems to be looking for a fight. Any fight. Syria, China, whatever!

 
 
 
magnoliaave
Sophomore Silent
link   magnoliaave    9 years ago

Just horrible.  We shouldn't go off half cocked with blaming until it has proven who is responsible. 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  magnoliaave   9 years ago

 We shouldn't go off half cocked with blaming until it has proven who is responsible. 

And after its proven who's responsible...then what do you think we should do?

(I haven't read the latest news reports, but I think we know who's responsible. Assad. But regardless-- when we know for sure-- than what, if anything,  do you think we should we do?)

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Krishna if you think Assad is responsible you have not been paying attention lately to the situation there.  He was doing quite well.  It would be insane for him to do this.   It is an obvious false flag.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     9 years ago

No one has any idea what to do, including the current administration.

Trump is finding himself in the same position that Obama was in. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.

It's complicated.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

And during the Obama administration Trump was constantly saying we needed to stay out of Syria, don't go into Syria, Syria is not our problem, no military action in Syria and now he is blaming Obama for not intervening in Syria. Asshole.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

And during the Obama administration Trump was constantly saying we needed to stay out of Syria, don't go into Syria, Syria is not our problem, no military action in Syria and now he is blaming Obama for not intervening in Syria. Asshole

BTW, we already have some troops in Syria, aNd were planning on sending a few more. They are there to help the local Kurdish-Arab-Christian coalition that is fighting ISIS take ISIS' headquarters (town of Raqqa, Syria).

Important to note: We are there to fight ISIS, not Syrian ruler Assad (the guy responsible for the gas attacks). In fact, ISIS & Assad are enemies.

This article (3/15) is from before the recent gas attack-- when we were there only to fight ISIS.

U.S. military likely to send as many as 1,000 more ground troops into Syria ahead of Raqqa offensive, officials say

The U.S. military has drawn up early plans that would deploy up to 1,000 more troops into northern Syria in the coming weeks, expanding the American presence in the country ahead of the offensive on the Islamic State’s de facto  capital of Raqqa , according to U.S. defense officials familiar with the matter. The deployment, if approved by Defense Secretary Jim Mattis and President Trump ,  would potentially double the number of U.S. forces in Syria and increase the potential for direct U.S. combat involvement in a conflict that has been characterized by confusion and competing priorities among disparate forces.

[ Marines have arrived in Syria to fire artillery in the fight for Raqqa ] Trump, who charged former president Barack Obama with being weak on Syria, gave the Pentagon 30 days to prepare a  new plan to counter the Islamic State , and Mattis submitted a broad outline to the White House at the end of February.

  Gen. Joseph Votel , head of U.S. Central Command, has been filling in more details for that outline, including by how much to increase the U.S. ground presence in Syria. Votel is set to forward his recommendations to Mattis by the end of the month, and the Pentagon secretary is likely to sign off on them, according to a defense official familiar with the deliberations.

 (READ IT ALL)

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    9 years ago

What a heartbreaking picture of the life's blood of the Syrians...  

I only wish I knew what to do about it.  No matter what you do, over there, it is wrong.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    9 years ago

What you don't do is arbitrarily declare a red line that you have no intention of enforcing, announce  the leader of Syria days are numbered when they clearly werent, and then falsely claim Assad has given up his chemical weapons to save face. And arming al quada is a bad idea too. 

prety much any other policy would be an improvement.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Sean Treacy   9 years ago

What you don't do is arbitrarily declare a red line...

The question, Sean... is "What should we do?"

You spent eight years attacking the other guy. Now he's gone. GONE!

You own American diplomacy, now.

"What should we do?"

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming     9 years ago

last I knew , there were 193 members of the united nations , since when did it become the USA that has to come up with a solution?

 to me the solution for the US IS simple , get the hell out , they should have never tried to force  out the government to begin with , and as far as I am concerned they can stay there and fight it out , no refugees from a state in a state of civil war , and that's exactly what this is , let the other 192 member nations of the UN figure out what to do , just do so without us . last I knew we had no treaties with Syria .

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

get the hell out

That's pretty much my opinion... but then... I've been preaching "get the hell out" for fifteen years...

I'd like to hear from the hawks...

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     9 years ago

We can go back to WWI when poison gas was first used. It created a terror among that troops. 

Mussolini used it. The British used it in the ME in the 1920/30. It was used during the Iran, Iraq war. It was used by Saddam against the Kurds.

This is not the first time that it's been used in Syria. Assad knows that he can get away with it, and it's meant to terrorist the people by saying, ''look what we can do'' and nobody will do anything about..

The bottom line is that he can and will use it, to send a message to his people. It's that damn simple and there isn't the US or any other country or the UN can or will do anything about it.

With the Russians there, they will provide cover, as they have already issued a statement saying it was the rebels who used it.

And there we have it.

 

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

You're not in power, K. Your party is not in power. Your candidate didn't win.

Your opinion on the topic is interesting... but not very...

On the other hand!

It would be great to hear from our NT conservatives. What do they think Mr Trump (or Mr Tillerson) should do? The errors of the preceding administration have received considerable attention in NT. But that is the past!

Now we have a new administration! People who know what must be done!

All I am asking is... what is that? What should be done?

What do you think, K? Will our NT conservatives propose something? Until now, "propositions" have been few and far between.   confused

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Bob I already stated my position , some claim I am a conservative , and I am somewhat of a hawk, I believe as I stated we should remove whatever troops we have there , stand down on air strikes within Syria ,Iraq is a different situation because of agreements and treaties , as far as ISIS is concerned , I think the EO banning Syrians,  refugee or immigrants is right on  the target as long as there is a civil war in progress and there is no real way to vet the individuals , like I said , there are 192 other UN nations  that can and should be doing something , the US is not the only lonely .

 I would say just let them ( UN ) and the Syrians and their respective allies do what they will and just wait and see who we as a nation will eventually be dealing with , diplomatically  and if need be confrontationally , just depends on how that particular war plays out . assad may stay in power , or the rebels might turn the tide , but that is doubtful , and the US shouldn't be arming overtly or covertly either side , just as kav said right now each side is blaming the other for the use of gas , and no one can say neither side wouldn't use it . personally with my time spent in the ME, I wouldn't put it past either side, which leads me to say , might be time for the neighbor nations there to get involved, it sure isn't our place here in the US until we are attacked .

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

In short: we should do nothing. Right?

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

yup. unless this nation , our assets , or citizens are attacked , frankly , its none of our business ,  and even if one wishes to pursue a moral objective , there are other avenues to try to convince the combatants to change their behavior than direct involvement .

 During the so called "arab spring" , the last admin  did pretty much the same thing, sat on their haunches and waited , how is Syria so different ? simply because the rebels didn't get the majority behind them to take down their own government? and that's not even talking about the covert actions that admin went about .

 time to say time to shit or get off the pot , but don't expect help overtly or covertly till you get it sorted out for yourselves. Reverse Monroe doctrine . we stay the fuck out of their affairs until it directly affects us as a nation and citizens . its been a while since this country did that.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

yup. unless this nation , our assets , or citizens are attacked , frankly , its none of our business 

Are you aware of the factthat while we have some troops in Iraq, we had none in Syria?

Until recently-- when Trump actually did some troops into Syria, and planned to send a few (maybe 1000) more-- to fight ISIS? It was a campaign promise-- and he began keeping it by sending in troops to Syria.

So Trump has sent in troops-- that was before this poisin gas incident. 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

 I would say just let them ( UN ) and the Syrians and their respective allies do what they will and just wait and see who we as a nation will eventually be dealing with , diplomatically 

First of all, anyone familiar with the situations what they will do-- basically, nothing different thn what they have been doing all along. 

And secondly, we already know what we're dealing with--in fact we've known for a long time. 

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

well Krish , why be a part of a group or organization that's about as useful as tits on a boar hog?

 yes we know who Assad is and we know the ilk of ISIS( the rebels), eventually we just may have to make them wish their mommas had swallowed instead of farted , when dealing with people , and I use that term loosely , that show no mercy towards non combatants , they should not expect any mercy shown to them or their adherents. do I need to put it any plainer?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

well Krish , why be a part of a group or organization that's about as useful as tits on a boar hog?

Well, that's a bit of a different subject..for discussion later. But now the question is what, if anything, to do about Syria.

 yes we know who Assad is and we know the ilk of ISIS( the rebels), eventually we just may have to make them wish their mommas had swallowed instead of farted , when dealing with people , and I use that term loosely , that show no mercy towards non combatants , they should not expect any mercy shown to them or their adherents. do I need to put it any plainer?

No, that's clear -- your solution would be to send even more troops into Syria and greatly escalate our actions? ...(or am I wrong?)

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

no troops needed Krish, my little play date in the sand back in the 90s showed me that true peace comes through superior air power , like I said , make them wish their mamas swallowed and not farted ,  and no warnings nothing , but until we are attacked , our citizens harmed or assets  threatened , let them kill themselves , they have been doing that for the better part of 2 millinia ,  escalation and ending all at once

thankfully the current POTUS is no more my choice than the last one was , didn't vote for either of them so I can and will let my disagreement be known, and my disagreement is when faced with rabid animals on both sides , let them take care of each other , then dispatch the one left after the dust settles .

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

that true peace comes through superior air power 

is that why the Israelis now have "true peace"?

/sarc

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

I actually think they have shown remarkable restraint for whats been thrown at them over the years , and they are still in a position of power over themselves even without US backing.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     9 years ago

Too bad that my opinion and the background on the use of poison gas wasn't interesting.

But it is what it is.

If I'm allowed another opinion it will be that the conservatives are finding out that they now have to make a decision, and they can't or won't do it.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Kavika   9 years ago

The thing is, K... that we progressives probably pretty much agree.

For example, I agree with everything you said. BUT! What you and I think is of no great importance in Trump-America. So I'd really, really like to hear from our conservative members. Perhaps their chosen leader will listen to them... 

                     don't laugh, K.............

 
 
 
magnoliaave
Sophomore Silent
link   magnoliaave  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

It didn't matter what Obama's constituents thought and it doesn't matter what Trump's constituents think.  It never has to either Party.  They do what they think best and, then, we have a poll afterwards. 

The President has advisors and he will depend on them.

For me, I say leave it alone and let that area handle their own damn problems for a change.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  magnoliaave   9 years ago

For me, I say leave it alone and let that area handle their own damn problems for a change.

Well, in that event you are in disagreement with the current administration Trup made a campaign promise to escalate the fight vs ISIS and he's starting to keep the promise. he'sfinally send troops into Syria,ad saidnhe planned to send more (this was before the recent gas attack): The U.S. military has drawn up early plans that would deploy up to 1,000 more troops into northern Syria in the coming weeks, expanding the American presence in the country ahead of the offensive on the Islamic State’s de facto  capital of Raqqa , according to U.S. defense officials familiar with the matter. The deployment, if approved by Defense Secretary Jim Mattis and President Trump ,  would potentially double the number of U.S. forces in Syria and increase the potential for direct U.S. combat involvement in a conflict that has been characterized by confusion and competing priorities among disparate forces.  

So what you could do is contact the administration and tell them your thoughts (but I don't think you'll get trump to change his mind-- after all, it was a campaign promise).

 
 
 
magnoliaave
Sophomore Silent
link   magnoliaave  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

It didn't matter what Obama's constituents thought and it doesn't matter what Trump's constituents think.  It never has to either Party.  They do what they think best and, then, we have a poll afterwards. 

The President has advisors and he will depend on them.

For me, I say leave it alone and let that area handle their own damn problems for a change.

 
 
 
magnoliaave
Sophomore Silent
link   magnoliaave    9 years ago

Sorry about the double post.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  magnoliaave   9 years ago

The system appears ot require a double post to get something posted.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

The system appears ot require a double post to get something posted.

You can say that again!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

The system appears ot require a double post to get something posted.

You can say that again!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

The system appears ot require a double post to get something posted.

You can say that again!

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

I did.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

I did.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  magnoliaave   9 years ago

The system appears ot require a double post to get something posted.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    9 years ago

IMO the USA should defend itself and those they are by treaty obliged to defend, and if there is an attack from Syria across its border to one of the USA's allies, only then should the USA come in with enough force to end the problem once and for all. It is the job of the biased ineffectual UN to do something about what is happening there now other than continue to prove its uselessness.  Why is it the Muslim countries are so overly concerned about the Palestinians, but silent when it comes to what is happening to their brethren who are being slaughtered?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    9 years ago

What should we do?

That's really not a difficult decision. In fact, most people know exactly what we should do:

-Liberals will issue numerous statements blaming Trump. (And some of the more creative Liberals will blame Bush).

-Conservatives will issue numerous statements blaming Obama. (And maybe also condemning Black Lives Matter).

-Libertarians will issue numerous statements saying we should never get involved in anything overseas, and that the u.S. military should not be used to fight wars.... U. S. troops that  are in the Middle-East (well, actually anywhere outside the U.S.) should be brought home immediately. And also condemn the Federal Reserve.  (Any anyway, none of this would've happened if pot was legal-- and more people owned guns).

-And of course the U.N. knows exactly what to do. They will debate it thoroughly-- then they will leap into action by attempting to pass a resolution condemning the excessive use of force by all parties involved. Initially it won't pass, but eventually they will pass several amendments watering it down, so it will be OK. (And also add an amendment condemning Israel just for good measure. Then it will certainly pass!).

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

What should we do?

That's really not a difficult decision. In fact, most people know exactly what we should do:

Oh,  and how could I forget?

As most of us know, there's a significant number of "mentally challenged" folks here on NT.

These morons won't really have concern for anyone else but themselves-- and certainly not for victims of poison gas attacks. All they really care about is expressing their own childish impulses-- so regardless of their political views, they will launch into attacking the more intelligent (& infinitely more mature acting) adults on the site.

Because all they really care about is the short term gratification of getting their "bon-bons":

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Exactly.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

So... All those people are wrong. Perhaps even foolishly wrong. 

What would Krishna do? 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

So... All those people are wrong. Perhaps even foolishly wrong. 

What would Krishna do?

Actually, I'm thinking of going into the kitchen and having a snack. 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

No problem. You can post your Reply after the snack. waving

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

No problem. You can post your Reply after the snack.  waving

Ah that was great. A bucket full of the world's most expensive Caviar, with gold leaf bits sprinkled on top by one of my favourite concubines. Then half a bottle of Chateau Mouton le mouton le sheep 1492-- followed by some nice ripe elderberry-infused  Fetchez la Vache!  (Appellation Contrôlée) over lightly braised & sauteed Hamster sweetbreads.

But, back to the topic: it is important to realize that this situation is compex.

At first it seems simple-- a brutal dictator committing horrendous atrocities against his own people. So our choice is-- intervene, or not? The plus re: intervening-- we stop these atrocities. The downside: more Americans killed & injured..ditto Syrians.

But its more complex than that... (see following comments)

____________________________________________________

P.S: there are basically 2 types of interventions we might consider-- we tried each in each of the 2 Gulf Wars against Saddam:

1- Just stay long enough to stop Assad's atrocities & to convince him that if he tries it again he will pay a heavy price-- but not try to remove him from power. Similar to what we did with Saddam in first Gulf War (Bush Sr.)

2-Stay longer, remove Assad from power. Similar to what we did in 2nd Gulf War (GW Bush)

So-- we could do nothing, do a shorter intervention, do a much bigger intervention. 

But....!

Comments ...anyone?

 

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Do you personally recommend n° 1 or 2?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Do you personally recommend n° 1 or 2?

Wait, not so fast.

I wanted to mention the important things to consider before deciding what I'd do.. It was a three art explanation, but too long to fit in one comment. That was only the first part. There are two more very important reasons why this situation is different than a simple case of a bad guy doing terrible things-- and deciding whether or not to intervene. 

Those two other factors make the decision extremely difficult. 

So here's the second part. And that is that's its not a question of confronting Assad alone. He has two important allies-- Russia and Iran. And the key consideration is-- how important to them is their alliance with Assad-- to keeping Assad in power?

1. Russia. Russia has lost some influence in the Arab world. Particularly Egypt (Now a U.S. "ally"). So, if I'm not mistaken, Putin now has only one allied country which he can use as a naval base in the Meditteranean-- Syria. If Assad is ousted-- or even significantly weakened -- Putin would be very upset..  a strong reason for him to prevent that! So if we start fighting his friend Assad we could up fighting Russia! (Neither Putin or the U.S. wants that , but..).

2. Iran. Iran also has a strong reason to ensure Assad remains in power-- and that he's not weakened. Their leaders are obsessed with destroying (or at least severely weakening) Israel. And it doesn't have to be missiles fired from Iran-- they have a friend military force right on Israel's border in Lebanon-- Hizb'Allah. And they need a friendly Syria as a corridor to ship weapons to H. in Lebanon. They would defend Assad in Syria-- by attacking Israel and American troops in Syria! (the wouldn't even have to risk Iranian troops-- H. coud do it for them.

So if we start attacking Assad, we might find ourselves in a shooting war with both Russia and Hizb'Allah). Heavy American casualties on because we wouldn't be fighting just some tin horn dictator like Assad. Pus a weakening of a crucial U.S. ally (Israel).

So that's the second part of my comments. Stay tuned to more thrill and chills in the third and final part.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

well I can think of one variable  that you didn't mention.

though isreal over the years has neither confirmed nor denied  being a member of the "nukular" weapons club, the widely held belief is , that they indeed are even without the US as back up, remember the big stink during desert storm about keeping them OUT of the action?  it wasn't worth risking them turning bagdad into a sheet of shiney glass, and they showed restraint even after SCUDS started coming down on them, though it did get them an anti missle defense system ( that they most likely improved , funny how they tend to do that). and if  they do have the French designed nukes I have heard scuttlebutt about , they most likely have tweeked them  to improve them much like they do any other piece of hardware they aquire. and then turn around and show exactly what it can do. I remember the F-16s sold to them stopping over and spending the night states side on the way for delivery in the early 80s , suckers were stripped of everything but essential flight instruments to just get them there , they added their own when it got there and they turned around and used them on not 1 but 2 different and separate raids on their enemies nuke plants before completion.

to make it shorter , the variable you missed was a nuclear capable and just ballsy enough isreal to take on the arab world with decisive action where it would do the most damage , be it in Lebanon , Syria , iran or elsewhere.

and its a very good bet they do have nukes , the easiest way to get rid of Isreal would have been to have every arab .palistinian , turn west and march towards the sea in one big riot line formation , so why didn't or don't they?

my guess is it wouldn't be worth the hell on earth to certain sites the isrealis would unleash.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

Of course they do have nukes. However if they ever use them they would unleash a full on war throughout the region that would be very different then the 1967 war. A lot longer, a lot more out of control, a lot more unpredictable and a lot more bloody. Remember we are allies with Saudi Arabia and Jordan and Iraq and Qatar and the UAE, etc. and even (as much as it sickens me) that bastard in Egypt. Israel can not get involved in the Syria problem in any manner as it would put the US in a position where neither Israel nor America wants to be.

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Randy   9 years ago

randy I think both you and I can agree that if the time ever comes that israel uncorks that genie , they have already decided that its all gone to shit in a 5 and dime handbasket , what is interesting to remember , we sold f-16s to them in the late 70s and early 80s , it took us until after the second gulf war to sell them to saud and other arab allies , we DID sell AWAC s platform ( Plans only) and kept control and security of the electronics to the sauds in the late 80s ,I was deployed for security to KKMC twice before the 1st gulf for AWACs security , and the  3rd and final time for the storm , I saw the worst case of hell on earth delivered through Arc light on the highway leading out of Kuwait city north .

yes I was USAF , I was a muddy security penguin , that was EST trained in ABGD , AIT and a couple other things , I was a ground grinder. with training from all branches except the navy , though the marines training me insisted they were a dept of the Navy , the mens dept.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

yes I was USAF , I was a muddy security penguin , that was EST trained in ABGD , AIT and a couple other things , I was a ground grinder. with training from all branches except the navy , though the marines training me insisted they were a dept of the Navy , the mens dept.

Bless you my son, for ye have suffered. Sincerely. I mean...Marines?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

yes I was USAF , I was a muddy security penguin , that was EST trained in ABGD , AIT and a couple other things , I was a ground grinder. with training from all branches except the navy , though the marines training me insisted they were a dept of the Navy , the mens dept.

Bless you my son, for ye have suffered. Sincerely. I mean...Marines?

BTW, I loved the F15 instead. I was stationed at Grand Forks in 1975 when it broke the world time to climb records. It went from a standing start to 30,000 meters (98,425ft) less then 3 minutes and 28 seconds. Damn it was a sight to see it take off!

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

The Original Screech Eagle is on a stick at Langley AFB..........

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Randy   9 years ago

saw video of that on base one time , the plane took off  so hard , it literally bent the front landing gear,  a tach sgt I knew was there and said it was like blink of the eye and tilt of the head up and it was gone., he said the only thing he had seen 9 or experienced) faster , was watching an SR- 71. and that was on radar when he watched that.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

a tach sgt I knew was there and said it was like blink of the eye and tilt of the head up and it was gone

I was standing behind the fence at the flight line watching for a few of the attempts and the pilot (in a NASA Spacesuit) had less then 4 seconds from a standing start to pull up into his initial climb and then gone. In the computer room we ran the flight data for the runs and it was nerve racking having all of those gold and silver bars, oak leafs and stars standing around waiting for the results. It was also very exciting when the computer made it official and everyone was cheering. A highlight of my time in.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Mark in Wyoming   9 years ago

well I can think of one variable  that you didn't mention.

though isreal over the years has neither confirmed nor denied  being a member of the "nukular" weapons club, the widely held belief is , that they indeed are even without the US as back up,

Actually I don't think anyone doubts that Israel has nukes.

They've shown great restraint, however. There have been a few wars with the Arabs (always a few Arab countries attacking Israel at once). In the last few wars Israel already had nukes, but of course never used them. 

BTW, I believe they have 2, maybe as many as 4, submarines that can fire missiles with nuclear warheads. I think they said they have 1 or 2 permanently stationed off the Iranian coast, going back and forth...(Its not a secret-- in fact they want the Iranians to know about them :-)

remember the big stink during desert storm about keeping them OUT of the action?  it wasn't worth risking them turning bagdad into a sheet of shiney glass,

Actually I think it was another reason. During that war there was a coalition of many nations allied with us-- including Arab nations. It was a war against a country (Iraq) that had invaded a neighbouring Arab country (Kuwait) and occupied it by force, with the intent of totally conquering it and annexing it. Many Arab states were obviously appalled by that, and joined the coalition against Saddam. Imagine if Israel had joined?It would then be seen as a war in which Israel and nother nations were fighting an Arab country! if Israel had joined the coalition, Arab countries would have quit! So that'd why they were kept out.

(cont'd in next comment)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

  Imagine if Israel had joined?It would then be seen as a war in which Israel and nother nations were fighting an Arab country! if Israel had joined the coalition, Arab countries would have quit! So that'd why they were kept out.

(cont'd in next comment)

and they showed restraint even after SCUDS started coming down on them, though it did get them an anti missle defense system ( that they most likely improved , funny how they tend to do that). and if  they do have the French designed nukes I have heard scuttlebutt about , they most likely have tweeked them  to improve them much like they do any other piece of hardware they aquire. and then turn around and show exactly what it can do. I remember the F-16s sold to them stopping over and spending the night states side on the way for delivery in the early 80s , suckers were stripped of everything but essential flight instruments to just get them there , they added their own when it got there and they turned around and used them on not 1 but 2 different and separate raids on their enemies nuke plants before completion.

Yes, they have a lot of incredible techies for such a tiny nation. And in fact not only do they modify and improve equipment they get from us, but there have been several Israeli miitary innovations we've gotten from them. 

They also have the best airport security in the world, as well as the best tactics for certain specialized types of warfare (for example, house to house urban fighting). American Marines and some special forces train in Israel for certain situations-- because they are the wforld's leading experts in some types of warfare.

to make it shorter , the variable you missed was a nuclear capable and just ballsy enough isreal to take on the arab world with decisive action where it would do the most damage , be it in Lebanon , Syria , iran or elsewhere.

Well, if we're talking about U/S. taking action against Assad, I don't think Israel would be a factor. They have enough trouble with Palestinian terror attacks inside their own country-- and if the U.S. went into Syria in force, we woudn't need the Israelis to help.

and its a very good bet they do have nukes , the easiest way to get rid of Isreal would have been to have every arab .palistinian , turn west and march towards the sea in one big riot line formation , so why didn't or don't they?

Actually at one point they tried something like that, but the Israelis fnigured out how to stop it. 

my guess is it wouldn't be worth the hell on earth to certain sites the Isrealis would unleash.

 

Actually its not their style-- they usually do very accurate precision bombing to avoid collateral damage. They probably do this more than any other military in the world. (They did it in Gaza-- considering the conditions, Palestinian casualties were pretty low (although the media reports were were inaccurate ).

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Well, if we're talking about U/S. taking action against Assad, I don't think Israel would be a factor.

I agree. Right now, Israel has reached an understanding with its Arab neighbors: live and let live. The Arab states are nearly as tired out by the antics of Hamas as is Israel. The boat is sailing smoothly, and Israel will not rock it!

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Krishna,

I pretty much agree about Russia. But unless Putin is ready to go nuclear, Russia just isn't much of a military threat. I have to wonder if he would dare ramp up a conventional war against the US... and a chemical war would be about as big a mistake as he could make.

I don't agree much about Iran, but I'll wait for your Part II to see if the difference of opinion about Iran changes anything overall. I think Iran's "obsession" with Israel is in fact primarily for domestic purposes: keeping the Iranian people fixated elsewhere than on their own country's problems. In the same vein, Iran's support for Hizbollah is largely a mean of harassing the US on the cheap... although there is surely some degree of genuine affinity for fellow Shia.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Krishna,

I pretty much agree about Russia. But unless Putin is ready to go nuclear, Russia just isn't much of a military threat. I have to wonder if he would dare ramp up a conventional war against the US... and a chemical war would be about as big a mistake as he could make.

I'm sure that Putin does not want to go to war with the U.S. He has a strong interest in seeing that Assad remains in power. But the U.S.won't attack Assad-- and risk even an accidental confrontation with Russia.no longer have the stomach for war after all the recent wars we've been though. They didn't accomplish anything, they got a lt of Arabs really angry at us-- and got a lot of American kids killed or maimed-- for no good reason.

But Putin does not have to engage us militarily-- the U.S. is now a "paper tiger"-- and Putin (and the rest of the world knows it...look what we did when he marched into Cimea and annexed it.).

The only thing that's worrysome is that American troops in Syria might accidentally get into a shooting match with some Russians-- and tempers could escalate. There are a lot of armed people wandering around: Syrian gov't troops, Russian troops, Iranian troops, Hizb'Allah fighters-- and also a-lQaeda, ISIS, the Democratc resistance (allies Kurds, Arabs, and local Christians), Turkish soldiers, Iraqi Shiites, plus a few other small groups. (And at this point probably more than one Kurdish group). Oh I almost forget-- now there are American militay on the ground ther as well.

Most Americans 

I don't agree much about Iran, but I'll wait for your Part II to see if the difference of opinion about Iran changes anything overall. I think Iran's "obsession" with Israel is in fact primarily for domestic purposes: keeping the Iranian people fixated elsewhere than on their own country's problems. In the same vein, Iran's support for Hizbollah is largely a mean of harassing the US on the cheap... although there is surely some degree of genuine affinity for fellow Shia.

Well,I actually agree about Iran.

Iran (and in fact also most of the Arab word) hates israel for the same reason-- their rulers keep their people miserable, so they're afraid of a popular uprising. So they try to re-direct their people's anger away from them (their rulers) and towards a scapegoat.

In fact, the Israelis have a saying:

If we didn't exist...the Arabs would've invented us.

Every once in a while someone in an online discussion attempts to spread panic because they're sure that Israel will launch a pre-emptive nuclear strike at iran-- at any moment! Which is nonsense-- Isrel has no reason to do that. And iran wont attack israel. (Anyway they don't have to-- they can use Hizb'Allah to fire rockets from right across the lebanese border (although lately H. has been to busy fight the rebels in Syria). 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Krishna,

I pretty much agree about Russia. But unless Putin is ready to go nuclear, Russia just isn't much of a military threat. I have to wonder if he would dare ramp up a conventional war against the US... and a chemical war would be about as big a mistake as he could make.

I'm sure that Putin does not want to go to war with the U.S. He has a strong interest in seeing that Assad remains in power. But the U.S.won't attack Assad-- and risk even an accidental confrontation with Russia.no longer have the stomach for war after all the recent wars we've been though. They didn't accomplish anything, they got a lt of Arabs really angry at us-- and got a lot of American kids killed or maimed-- for no good reason.

But Putin does not have to engage us militarily-- the U.S. is now a "paper tiger"-- and Putin (and the rest of the world knows it...look what we did when he marched into Cimea and annexed it.).

The only thing that's worrysome is that American troops in Syria might accidentally get into a shooting match with some Russians-- and tempers could escalate. There are a lot of armed people wandering around: Syrian gov't troops, Russian troops, Iranian troops, Hizb'Allah fighters-- and also a-lQaeda, ISIS, the Democratc resistance (allies Kurds, Arabs, and local Christians), Turkish soldiers, Iraqi Shiites, plus a few other small groups. (And at this point probably more than one Kurdish group). Oh I almost forget-- now there are American militay on the ground ther as well.

Most Americans 

I don't agree much about Iran, but I'll wait for your Part II to see if the difference of opinion about Iran changes anything overall. I think Iran's "obsession" with Israel is in fact primarily for domestic purposes: keeping the Iranian people fixated elsewhere than on their own country's problems. In the same vein, Iran's support for Hizbollah is largely a mean of harassing the US on the cheap... although there is surely some degree of genuine affinity for fellow Shia.

Well,I actually agree about Iran.

Iran (and in fact also most of the Arab word) hates israel for the same reason-- their rulers keep their people miserable, so they're afraid of a popular uprising. So they try to re-direct their people's anger away from them (their rulers) and towards a scapegoat.

In fact, the Israelis have a saying:

If we didn't exist...the Arabs would've invented us.

Every once in a while someone in an online discussion attempts to spread panic because they're sure that Israel will launch a pre-emptive nuclear strike at iran-- at any moment! Which is nonsense-- Isrel has no reason to do that. And iran wont attack israel. (Anyway they don't have to-- they can use Hizb'Allah to fire rockets from right across the lebanese border (although lately H. has been to busy fight the rebels in Syria). 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

its really difficult to follow the threads of conversation the way this site is laid out-- so I'll just post part III here (why this situation is unusually tricky):

Usually one side in a conflict can be identified as "the good guys'. But that's not the case here.

Like much of the conflicts in the Middle-East, this is a sectarian religious conflict-- a conflict that goes way back..Sunni vs Shia. Here are the two sides:

1. Shia: The barbaric Syrian dictator al Assad. Backed by Shia Iran & the Shia Lebanese terror group Hezb'Allah.. Supported by Russia.

2. Sunni. Democratic resistance forces trying to overthrow Assad comprised of various Sunni Arab groups. But they are allied with other Sunni forces as well-- who are also trying to overthrow Assad. Namely-- al Qaeda and ISIS! Supported by Sunni Turkey, Sunni Saudi Arabia & the Gulf states.

Then there are various Kurdish groups who are fighting both Assad and al Qaeda & Isis. (And Turkey is in Syria supposedly to fight ISIS-- but they are trying to massacre the Kurdish forces. 

So here's the problem. If we go in and fight ISIS, we are therefore strengthening ISIS's opponent Assad ((the guy behind the poison gas attack). If we fight Assad, we are strengthening his opponent: ISIS. 

Ideally both should be eliminated-- bu if we destroy the Syrian gov't (Assad's forces) and most of the opposition forces (ISIS, al Qaeda,  etc)-- mot of Syria will be destroyed (well, what han't been already).

And then there's this to consider: in addition to that, American lives would be lost. More Americans woud return home with limbs lost, PTSD, etc. And-- all for what? remember--this is the Arab world. No matter which group you beat in battle-- whoever replaces won't be any more capable of peace then the group that came before them.  

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

its really difficult to follow the threads of conversation the way this site is laid out-- so I'll just post part III here (why this situation is unusually tricky):

Usually one side in a conflict can be identified as "the good guys'. But that's not the case here.

Like much of the conflicts in the Middle-East, this is a sectarian religious conflict-- a conflict that goes way back..Sunni vs Shia. Here are the two sides:

1. Shia: The barbaric Syrian dictator al Assad. Backed by Shia Iran & the Shia Lebanese terror group Hezb'Allah.. Supported by Russia.

2. Sunni. Democratic resistance forces trying to overthrow Assad comprised of various Sunni Arab groups. But they are allied with other Sunni forces as well-- who are also trying to overthrow Assad. Namely-- al Qaeda and ISIS! Supported by Sunni Turkey, Sunni Saudi Arabia & the Gulf states.

Then there are various Kurdish groups who are fighting both Assad and al Qaeda & Isis. (And Turkey is in Syria supposedly to fight ISIS-- but they are trying to massacre the Kurdish forces. 

So here's the problem. If we go in and fight ISIS, we are therefore strengthening ISIS's opponent Assad ((the guy behind the poison gas attack). If we fight Assad, we are strengthening his opponent: ISIS. 

Ideally both should be eliminated-- bu if we destroy the Syrian gov't (Assad's forces) and most of the opposition forces (ISIS, al Qaeda,  etc)-- mot of Syria will be destroyed (well, what han't been already).

And then there's this to consider: in addition to that, American lives would be lost. More Americans woud return home with limbs lost, PTSD, etc. And-- all for what? remember--this is the Arab world. No matter which group you beat in battle-- whoever replaces won't be any more capable of peace then the group that came before them.  

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Do you personally recommend n° 1 or 2?

Wait, not so fast.

I wanted to mention the important things to consider before deciding what I'd do.. It was a three art explanation, but too long to fit in one comment. That was only the first part. There are two more very important reasons why this situation is different than a simple case of a bad guy doing terrible things-- and deciding whether or not to intervene. 

Those two other factors make the decision extremely difficult. 

So here's the second part. And that is that's its not a question of confronting Assad alone. He has two important allies-- Russia and Iran. And the key consideration is-- how important to them is their alliance with Assad-- to keeping Assad in power?

1. Russia. Russia has lost some influence in the Arab world. Particularly Egypt (Now a U.S. "ally"). So, if I'm not mistaken, Putin now has only one allied country which he can use as a naval base in the Meditteranean-- Syria. If Assad is ousted-- or even significantly weakened -- Putin would be very upset..  a strong reason for him to prevent that! So if we start fighting his friend Assad we could up fighting Russia! (Neither Putin or the U.S. wants that , but..).

2. Iran. Iran also has a strong reason to ensure Assad remains in power-- and that he's not weakened. Their leaders are obsessed with destroying (or at least severely weakening) Israel. And it doesn't have to be missiles fired from Iran-- they have a friend military force right on Israel's border with Lebanon *-- Hizb'Allah. And they need a friendly Syria as a corridor to ship weapons to H. in Lebanon. They would defend Assad in Syria-- by attacking Israel and American troops in Syria! (the wouldn't even have to risk Iranian troops-- H. coud do it for them.

So if we start attacking Assad, we might find ourselves in a shooting war with both Russia and Hizb'Allah). Heavy American casualties on because we wouldn't be fighting just some tin horn dictator like Assad. Pus a weakening of a crucial U.S. ally (Israel).

So that's the second part of my comments. Stay tuned to more thrill and chills in the third and final part.

___________________________________________________

*As always, a excellent linked article with great pictures

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

A bucket full of the world's most expensive Caviar, with gold leaf bits sprinkled on top by one of my favourite concubines.

Has that concubine been tested for STD'S? One can't be too careful with ones best caviar.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

Has that concubine been tested for STD'S? One can't be too careful with ones best caviar.

Yes. By one of my two OCI*'s (who live in another part of the castle).

______________________________________________________

*OCI = "Official Concubine Inspector

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Can I send you my resume for a job as a position as an OCI. I can promise you I can provide excellent references and will work for room, board, scotch and the occasional doobie or line of good blow.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

So... All those people are wrong. Perhaps even foolishly wrong. 

What would Krishna do?

Actually, I'm thinking of going into the kitchen and having a snack. 

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    9 years ago

So now what should we do?

Gotta tell ya I was sickened watching the news of this. The images of the White-hats desperately flinging these little babes onto a flatbed, trying to hose off chemical, and then trying to give care ,,,, thinking how I would respond as a true first responder risking life and limb to be a savior...

...Jesus fuckin' Christ...

So now what should we do?

We should prepare for what's next. Humans have become callous in their prevue of suffering, particularly so if also caused by humans. The reaction to the abject horror taking place in Syria is in essence no different than past reactions to the loss of life due to other atrocities witnessed in recent history, yet is much more dynamic in it's volatile consequences. This powder-keg will blow; it's a matter of when. Whether we do nothing, play it as smart as possible (*right*), or go in guns blazing, this will blow. The world has stood idle too long, and this is a catastrophe that has equally valued repercussions. Humans are only enslaved to this type of barbarity for so long before all involved parties reduce their own existences to barbarity. That is what we are witnessing; yet, we do nothing. The only ones doing anything of true value are the aforementioned White-hats who are literally, physically saving people everyday ( MY hat's off to those courageous souls (...and anybody who has ever worked in an ER setting will know the type of toll this sorta work extracts)).

We should prepare for the fact that this will eventually lead to an all out battle in the ME. There are too many players now involved in the region, too many extended interests, too little valuable relationships diplomatically, and way too little leadership globally, to prevent a spark from igniting a forest fire...and our current administration is charcoal fluid...

We should prepare for what we are seeing in Syria occurring on a on an even larger scale globally. We are doing little, next to nothing, to prevent ourselves from committing Special (as in Species) suicide. The sheer destruction of or planet's fruits, it's inhabitants, and of peace alone, are enough to warrant our extinction; let alone, our destruction of each other.

Eh,  planet Earth has seen many bi-jillions of species come and go, because they didn't adapt and coevolve. Humans may end up being a blip on the cosmic radar.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

What to do, Larry?

We can do what the UN and many others do when Hamas shoots Iranian-provided missiles into Israeli civilian areas, and when Palestinians stab and drive their vehicles into innocent women and children - we can blame Israel.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

Got that right Buzz.

Go figure,,,

Under cover of night, Syrian wounded seek help from enemy Israel

 

It happens nearly every night. After dark, the Syrian wounded come to known locations on the Israel-Syria front in the Golan Heights, driven by desperation to seek help from an enemy army.

Israeli soldiers on lookout or patrol spot them waiting by the fence and whisk them away to a rear position where army medics soon arrive, according to army officials operating in the area that was seized by Israel in the 1967 Middle East war.

Israel refuses to accept refugees fleeing the nearly six-year conflict in Syria, a country with which it remains technically at war. But it has allowed in more than 2,600 Syrians for medical care.

On one bitterly cold January night, gunfire and explosions could be heard in the near distance as Israeli medics dressed the injuries of two Syrian men, one suffering a head wound.

"We're doing everything we can to save their lives, to stabilize them and evacuate them to hospital," said Captain Aviad Camisa, deputy chief medical officer of the Golan brigade.

The medics lift the wounded men onto an army ambulance which slowly drives off down a dirt road.

A Syrian family -- two grandparents, a mother, father and a child aided by a walker -- pass by as they prepare to cross back into Syria in the dead of night.

 

"Some of the stories stir your emotions. When children come, as a father, it touches me personally," Camisa said.

 

israelisavesyrians.jpeg

 

 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

When the quake happened in Haiti-- look what the Israelis did:

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

That's all very reasonable... How do we "prepare"? 

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

That's all very reasonable... How do we "prepare"? 

We need to prepare for a world, a life, that HAS to be vastly different from the one we have been leading.

What I propose is not unique and yet also not widely appreciated...

....yet.

Firstly I would offer that we need to humble ourselves to an immense level.

We are mere animals on a planet of life that has seen many other species die off because they didn't adapt to the reality of existence here. We believe that our superior use of tools gives an advantage to manipulate nature to our desires. While that may or may not be true, what is most assuredly true is that we have ignored the consequences of those manipulations at our own peril. We CANNOT continue on our present course without paying a globally catastrophic price. Our very own machinations are destroying our resources. We need to humble ourselves so we truly understand how truly valuable life is. And I believe we may be doing that without even realizing it. There is little that is more humbling than bombing ourselves back to the Stone age.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Bob Nelson  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

I agree completely... including " not widely appreciated..." 

Other species have gone extinct. 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

Maybe it's our turn. We sure deserve it and have been doing just about everything we can to make it happen. We'll take a lot of other species with us too.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

There is little that is more humbling than bombing ourselves back to the Stone age.

That doesn't happen. In a nuclear exchange, not even a full one but a small one of say only 500 or 600 warheads (though there are somewhere between 12,000 and 16,000 in the world today (much fewer then we used to have) and a few fired will trigger most others so a full exchange is much more likely)), nothing on Earth will survive. No animal life forms. All of the post apocalypse, post nuclear war "Mad Max" type survival world movies are all lies and fantasies (except for maybe "On the Beach" where survivors are waiting in the last place on Earth that the radiation hasn't hit yet, Australia, waiting for it to finally get to them and then they will die too). It doesn't work like that. Those unlucky enough to survive the explosions will die of radiation poisoning and the very, very, very few (if any and it's not likely) who don't die of that will be horribly sick and die of starvation and cold in the nuclear winter of 2 to 4 years to follow, when no food will grow. However, all will die. Everything that needs air to live, will die.

On the wall of our computer room at the SAC base I was assigned to we had a poster of what to do in case of a nuclear exchange. The first few items seemed pretty normal like gather water and food and first aid supplies and such, but the last one on the list was to sit down in a chair, put your head between your legs and kiss your ass goodbye.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

"...nothing on Earth will survive. No animal life forms."

...except maybe the cockroaches. Where is Klaatu when we need that robot?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

There's an old joke that after a full nuclear war the only two things that would survive would be cockroaches and Cher. LOL

 
 
 
Mark in Wyoming
Professor Silent
link   Mark in Wyoming   replied to  Randy   9 years ago

you forgot twinkies........

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

"...nothing on Earth will survive. No animal life forms."

...except maybe the cockroaches. Where is Klaatu when we need that robot?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Bob Nelson   9 years ago

That's all very reasonable... How do we "prepare"?

Easy. A pistol with one bullet for each member of your family to use, leaving one for yourself.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

I disagree Randy. We are the generation that sees Humanity off on a new path; and, that sending off is of ultimate import my friend. 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

We are the generation that sees Humanity off on a new path;

I don't mean to be overly difficult, but...

How's that been working out so far?

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

IMHO it's going downhill fast.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Randy   9 years ago

I will say this to you guys: the only thing more painful than child birth is the loving and raising of a child.

Every parent I know, knows the same thing, that they without question never allow harm to come to their children. sometimes though we know that allowing them the risk, is the only way to ensure our own passing of that responsibility to them. THAT process is superlatively painful and rewarding. 

That's where we are as a species,,,we see it every couple thousand years or so,,,a jump in our evolutionary growth.

We, Humans, are another child of this planet.

Possibly even a child that can appreciate and learn to be co-creators rather than destroyers. Perhaps that is what the gift of excellent tool usage is meant to be used for, to increase life rather than taking it away.

?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Larry Hampton   9 years ago

I will say this to you guys: the only thing more painful than child birth is the loving and raising of a child.

Every parent I know, knows the same thing, that they without question never allow harm to come to their children.

You must not know many Palestinian parents--- because many of them wish for the opposite:

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

Every parent I know, knows the same thing, that they without question never allow harm to come to their children.

If we go down the wrong path and we are closer to it then in many, many years, parents will have no say in it.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton  replied to  Krishna   9 years ago

You must not know many Palestinian parents--- because many of them wish for the opposite:

That is correct; and, no, I don't know any Palestinian parents personally.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    9 years ago
The question asked here was: "So now what should we do?" Where can we look for the answer to that? We are supposed to learn from history, so is there an answer in history? Sometimes Life imitates Art, so should we look to the movies? Perhaps the answer is in LIterature. Voltaires Candide survived through what was called the "Best of all possible worlds" but then had to strive through many challenges and tests of what could be called the worst of all possible worlds, and his final answer (take note of this, as it may be the answer to the question) "We must cultivate our garden."
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   9 years ago

What we should do now is use common sense.   Why would Assad do this while ISIS and AL Quada are on the run, peace talks are going well and he is on top?  What on earth would he think to gain by it.  Isn't it obvious this is a false flag?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    9 years ago

So a bunch of Syrians get gassed while things are going quite well for Assad and right after Trump says "let the Syrians decide who should run their country", peace talks were making out and ISIS and Al Quada are on the run and some of you actually think Assad did this.   Why on earth would he?   Isn't it much more likely his opposition did it?   Have you lost your common sense?   This is one of the most obvious false flags I have seen next to the guy that torched the church and spray painted vote for Trump on it for crying out loud....and the unwitting  steeple react just as the are supposed to ....."Oh the humanity! We must do something about it"  **FACEPALM**

 
 

Who is online



77 visitors