It’s time to give Israel the means to take out Iranian nukes
Its time to give Israel the means to take out Iranian nukes
By Grace Meng and Lee Zeldin, New York Post, May 17, 2015
The negotiations over Irans nuclear program have engendered furious debate in Washington and in capitals across the world. But there are steps outside of the nuclear talks that President Obama can take to help ensure that the United States and its allies are stronger and more secure the day after a deal than they were the day before. One such step would be to provide Israel with GBU-57 30,000-pound bunker-buster bombs (known as the Massive Ordnance Penetrators, or MOPs) and the means to carry them, in a quantity sufficient to destroy Irans most deeply buried nuclear sites.
At present, Israel possesses US-supplied 5,000-pound bunker-buster bombs. But experts doubt these bombs could seriously impede Irans nuclear development. On the other hand, there is little doubt that MOPs, which Israel lacks, are capable of destroying Irans nuclear sites.
As Michael Makovsky and Lt. Gen. David Deptula noted in a 2014 Wall Street Journal op-ed, the Defense Department has MOPs to spare, aircraft in storage that could carry the MOP payload and legal authority to transfer such arms to the Israelis.
A longstanding component of Americas Iran policy has been a credible military threat to ensure that Iran does not obtain a nuclear weapon. Many contend that the credibility of this threat has waned, and that Iran is now more assured than ever that it will not be attacked. Providing Israel with a stronger capability to destroy Irans nuclear facilities would help deter Iran from ever trying to break any agreement it may sign.
Transferring MOPs to Israel would also help assuage the concerns of Congress and our Middle East allies, who are wary of the emerging deal. President Obama will need to take measures to strengthen the security of our allies and ensure Congress that he is negotiating from a position of strength. Transferring MOPs to Israel would help the president achieve these objectives.
Because the MOPs are outside the scope of the negotiations, Iran is in no position to object to transferring them to the Israelis. Iran continues to expand Hezbollahs arsenal, placing all of Israels population centers within range of Hezbollah rockets. Iran supports the Assad regime in Syria and Hamas in the Gaza Strip. It supports the Houthi rebels in Yemen, who have violently overthrown a democratically elected government. It propagates violence and terrorism throughout the Middle East.
We are now in a period when more must be done for Israel to retain its Qualitative Military Edge (or QME), a legally binding American commitment to ensure that Israel can overcome any combination of credible conventional military threats against it. Last month, Russia lifted a ban on the sale of missiles to Iran and decided to deliver to Iran a sophisticated air-defense system. The United States needs to ensure that Israels conventional military capabilities become stronger relative to those of Iran, not weaker.
Additionally, the issue of QME relates to the American desire to boost the military capabilities of its Gulf allies; in order to do this while not violating QME law, the president may need to proportionally strengthen Israel. This in part explains why the administration recently announced that it would provide Israel with new F-35 fighter jets, and it further underscores the need for Israel to obtain MOPs.
Some may argue that regional instability and sensitive negotiations make this the wrong time to introduce new weapons into the Middle East. But those of us who trust in Israel and in the US-Israel alliance know that the MOPs would not create further instability. Israel already has significant offensive military capabilities, and it has always used them responsibly.
The transfer of MOPs would not by itself resolve the Iranian nuclear question. Nor would it lessen the need for any deal to ensure that Iran has no technical path to a nuclear weapon. But it would enable the United States to negotiate from a position of strength and remain in a position of strength long after the negotiations.
It is one of several tools with which the president could pave the path to a strong, sustainable nuclear agreement with Iran, a more secure Israel and a more stable Middle East.
Reps. Grace Meng (D-Queens) and Lee Zeldin (R-LI) are members of the House Foreign Affairs Committee.

WTF..... Israel has nukes to fit on their own aircraft...... go for it.
I really don't think that Israel will want to wipe out the Iranian population with a nuclear weapon. If the world already despises Israel because of the collateral casualties caused by Hamas' use of human shields, rather than commending Israel for doing everything it could to prevent civilian casualties, then what do you think will happen if they wipe out a portion of the Iranian population? I believe they need the big bunker bombs to surgically remove the nuclear weapon manufacturing centres.
Israel has had the means to defend herself for years. Although she has decided to not take pre-emptive action, it remains their governments choice. Not to be snarky, but when the U.S. determined pre-emptive was in our "best" interest our government didn't wait for worldapproval. Not that I agreed with our action, but wasn't consulted
I've always been pro-Israel,butshe often relies upon the U.S. only when it suits her agenda andgive us the finger when it doesn't. Israel is a sovereign nation and doesn't require approval to act in what she deems her best interest.
A pre-emptive strike against Iran would be of great benefit to the region and the world in the long run.
The world's objective vis a vis nuclear weapons is to reduce them over time. The deal in the works with Iran gives them a weapon in less than 10 years. A number of countries in the region have already got plans on the drawing board to have their own nukes because of the Iran situation. Although it would lead to great instability in the short term, in the long term it would benefit the world, as the other nations would probably take a step back from their own nuclear plans.
So does this mean you're going to go take the oath of enlistment in the next couple of days Jonathan? Take C4P with you. They sound like they're all ready to be the hero type.
Otherwise all I hear is more conservative crap about sending somebody else's kid off to do what they wouldn't.
Waves back....
Remember, recommending sending someone else's kid off to war is considered free speech.
As the rest of the world stopped worrying about Israel thanks to the Obama administration and the onslaught of Muslim migration to Europe and the US and their very prolific and profitable public relations campaign world wide...
.. Israel should just stop worrying about what the rest of the world thinks and protect herself.
If you place the accomplishments of Jews and Israel in so many fields, especially medical and technological, Israel won't be isolated for very long. Even some of the countries who publically supported BDS in the beginning are covertly buying Israeli goods and technology.
California, while allowing the shut down of its ports by BDS supporters rallied by Muslim community leaders, were making deals to buy technology for irrigation and desalination plants... and the world of common sense still sluggishly keeps turning.
I don't see any reference to the US sending our men to engage in this endeavor. If you're referring to Israel, there is an existential threat to them from Iran, both nuclear and non-nuclear.
If you are unwilling to engage me in a discussion about the long-term consequences of either move, I understand. In that case, please don't feel obligated to respond.
Did Israel use American boots on the ground when they rid the world of Iraqi and Syrian nuclear reactors? Does the article say anything about using American soldiers? It seems to me that all it's saying is that Israel can handle it by itself if it had those big bunker-busters.
I think this is an astoundingly stupid idea. First of all, the purpose of the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty (NPT) that we signed is to prevent the spread of nuclear weapons and to reduce existing nuclear arsenals. Using the NPT to create a nuclear club for our friends makes the agreement a sham and could encourage, rather than discourage, the spread of nuclear weapons.
Second, Iran, as a signatory to the NPT, has a right to develop peaceful nuclear power. Israel has not even signed the agreement and has developed nuclear weapons. Unbelievably, Israel has the unmitigated gall to complain that Iran might do what Israel has already done. If we were being evenhanded, we should press for international sanctions against Israel and if an MOP is dropped, it should be dropped on Israel first on the way to Iran.
Third, since Iran has the right to peaceful nuclear power, any attack on Iran by Israel is an act of unprovoked aggression in violation of the UN Charter and should be treated as such. Of course, our duplicity would be apparent when we use our seat on the Security Council to veto any action against Israel for an act of aggression against Iran made possible by weapons we provided for that very purpose.
Fly, I didn't see anything here about our sons and daughters with boots on the ground there.
Second, Iran, as a signatory to the NPT, has a right to develop peaceful nuclear power.
Have a nice day.
Buzz and Jonathan are both advocating a strike on Iran. And since Israel doesn't have the hardware to do the job, just who do you suppose they want to get to undertake this strike?
Buzz seems to think that we should give Israel a number of GBU-57 "Bunker Busters". Unfortunately the GBU-57 has only been fitted to the B-2 bomber. I haven't asked, but I'm sure they aren't expecting that we lend them those aircraft as well.
So.... Boots on the ground..... I never made that claim. US forces to perform a coordinated, a multi-target strike in a high threat environment.... Sure sounds like they want one with the US shouldering the majority of the cost and risk.
Happy days!
Oops . . . those darn treaty rights again.
We've tried to have this discussion before. It pretty much ends the same way with a number of our members.
I appreciate your effort towards enlightenment though. Tends to be like bouncing marbles off the sidewalk at times......
It pretty much ends the same way with a number of our members.
Yourself included, sir.
You say that it's easy for me to sit here and advocate for others to execute war.
I say it's easy for you accept another nuclear state.
I sometimes aim at heads rather than the sidewalk, if for no other reason than entertainment.
However, it's always a pleasure debating an issue with thoughtful people like you even if we end up on opposite sides of an issue.
There is a difference between being wishful and realistic. We've been through this before.....
If you have a number 4 Jonathan, let er rip...!
I'm sending you a FR if for no other reason to find out your background...... I'm intrigued to say the least.
Let's read the article again. It contains these statements (bolding by me):
But for what purpose? Not to go and bomb, but as a deterrant, as a means to provide superiority to force Iran to be honest (which, by the way, they have not been when it comes to nuclear development):
So the USA wants to send Israel some F-35 fighter jets that the world already knows they can't get to work well.
But I guess it's okay with some of the members of NT that Iran has threatened Israel's destruction, has established its support of terrorism, and as the article states:
All of this is an opinion FLY, so your opinion that is contrary is of course welcome as well.
Which "they" would be steeled ?
If Iran is attacked, the Iranian people would most likely support the program in greater numbers.
I guess we could give them the GBU-57, but they can't do anything with them except polish them as they don't have an aircraft that can carry it.
The Iranian people are not consulted on such issues . The ayatollahs would declare a fatwah or sumpthin' but that's about all that would come of it . They are as anti-science as any bunch there is .
What instability ? Israel has regularly kicked Arab butt in that region . That is as stable as it gets in such a location .
Learn how to live with people who have been brainwashed since birth to slaughter Jews and receive rewards from doing so? Learn how to live with a faction that has sworn and in their constitution declared the need to destroy Israel?
Sure, flame, YOU can live with that, right?
It has been our dollars and weapons that have enabled Israel to attack/defend in the region since 48. Without either Israel as she is today wouldn't exist.
AGAIN!!!
Quotes from the article (the bolding is mine to make the point, AGAIN):
Which weapons are you referring to ? The US aircraft were never a gift . They were bought by loan guarantees and from the US defense industry .
And you know that how ?
Read the article. It speaks of using the transfer of the weapons to be used as a deterrant, an incentive for Iran to toe the line, not to supply or encourage a bombing.
The removal of the sanctions means something is necessary to keep Iran in line. They have already proven that they cannot be trusted. They have already established that they provide weapons to their proxies Hezbollah and Hamas and probably the Hoothies for terrorism (if they don't take part in it themselves as they did in Argentina).
This is a delusional way of looking at Islam . It is a religion designed to split into groups which violently attack each other . Anyone who reads the news can verify that for themselves .
Which means Israel buys, or we give them B-2 bombers as these are the only aircraft configured to carry the weapon.
The weapon was tested using a specially configured B-52.
If memory serves me right there are seven targets that everyone is worried about. You need to plan a minimum two aircraft with two weapons each to reach upwards of 85% strike effectiveness on all seven targetstargets. That's 14 aircraft in the flight at a minimum.
Good luck getting the BUFFs through Iranian airspace BTW......
But that's not all. Then you have, tankers,escort fighters, SEAD aircraft for SAMs, jamming aircraft, and AEW radar aircraft and specialOPs aircraft. Back in the early 1990s, one of our regularreserve exercises was strikeplanning against Iranof a similar type. Even with the BUFFS, Israel cannot get the job done on all these targets.
All for what..... a 12-18 month setback in their program that their entire population becomes in favor of? Brilliant political move.
ENGAGMENT BUZZ..... ENGAGEMENT with Iranis the only long term answer.
1ofmany is right. The Arabs have nowhere to go but tiny Israel, so they can change it from being the Homeland for the Jews (as intended by Partition) to the slaughterhouse of the Jews.
Okay, FLY, ENGAGEMENT. Then go ahead and have Iran sign a peace treaty with Israel. See if you can talk them into it. They will have to stop vocalizing the destruction of the "Zionist regime" first.
I think Israel needs a new Esther to tempt the Ayatollahs, and Haman will have to be hung before there will be peace.
Not to derail your seed, but I posted a seed on N. Korea today, and I can't remember ever seeing your thoughts or comments on the country.
If I could impose, could you add your two-cents worth on how China feels about N. Korea, and where that country could be heading in the long run? You have a unique exposure that the rest of us just might be able to learn something from.
Thanks.
...
I left a comment on your seed, FLY.