Critics: Trump Defense Budget Increases Not Sufficient
President Donald Trump's budget plan sets defense spending at about $18 billion more than had been planned for this year by former President Barack Obama, but experts say the difference will do little to help him fulfill his campaign trail pledges.
Trump included a 350-ship Navy, dozens of new fighter planes for the Air Force, and a 540,000 active duty Army force, but that kind of spending requires an $80 billion to $90 billion boost a year, The Hill reported on Monday.
The fiscal 2018 budget plan released last week calls for $603 billion in the base budget for defense and national security. The figures are $54 billion over the ceiling set in the 2011 Budget Control Act.
The budget's funds would keep the Army at 476,000 active duty soldiers and plans for eight new ships, which was what Obama forecast. It all does not provide for new equipment, retired Army Lt. Gen. Thomas Spoehr of the Heritage Foundation noted to The Hill.
"It was mildly surprising that the Defense Department didn’t buy any new equipment," Spoehr said. "They chose to put it all in operations and personnel and maintenance."
Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman John McCain, meanwhile, said the budget was "dead on arrival" after it was released, and said $640 billion was needed for fiscal year 2018.
House Armed Services Ranking Member Adam Smith, D-Wash., also complained Trump had not "given us a solid document on which one can plan for the national defense."
Mackenzie Eaglen, a defense analyst with the conservative American Enterprise Institute, said it’s likely Trump does not know a $54 billion increase is not sufficient, and a separate consultant told The Hill Trump probably "doesn't know any better."
“He thinks he’s providing a big defense increase when he’s not. The people in his inner circle don’t understand the mechanics and the numbers, and [Office of Management and Budget Director] Mick Mulvaney is totally pulling the wool over his eyes," the source said.
Meanwhile, Spoehr said there were likely people around Trump who were "persuasive that they thought it was maybe at least as important to balance the budget [as] it was to build up defense," and the president didn't get "much influence" when setting the defense number. http://www.newsmax.com/t/newsmax/article/792923/1
Trump included a 350-ship Navy, dozens of new fighter planes for the Air Force, and a 540,000 active duty Army force, but that kind of spending requires an $80 billion to $90 billion boost a year, The Hill reported on Monday.
The fiscal 2018 budget plan released last week calls for $603 billion in the base budget for defense and national security. The figures are $54 billion over the ceiling set in the 2011 Budget Control Act.
The budget's funds would keep the Army at 476,000 active duty soldiers and plans for eight new ships, which was what Obama forecast. It all does not provide for new equipment, retired Army Lt. Gen. Thomas Spoehr of the Heritage Foundation noted to The Hill.
"It was mildly surprising that the Defense Department didn’t buy any new equipment," Spoehr said. "They chose to put it all in operations and personnel and maintenance."
Senate Armed Services Committee Chairman John McCain, meanwhile, said the budget was "dead on arrival" after it was released, and said $640 billion was needed for fiscal year 2018.
House Armed Services Ranking Member Adam Smith, D-Wash., also complained Trump had not "given us a solid document on which one can plan for the national defense."
Mackenzie Eaglen, a defense analyst with the conservative American Enterprise Institute, said it’s likely Trump does not know a $54 billion increase is not sufficient, and a separate consultant told The Hill Trump probably "doesn't know any better."
“He thinks he’s providing a big defense increase when he’s not. The people in his inner circle don’t understand the mechanics and the numbers, and [Office of Management and Budget Director] Mick Mulvaney is totally pulling the wool over his eyes," the source said.
Meanwhile, Spoehr said there were likely people around Trump who were "persuasive that they thought it was maybe at least as important to balance the budget [as] it was to build up defense," and the president didn't get "much influence" when setting the defense number. http://www.newsmax.com/t/newsmax/article/792923/1
Article is LOCKED by author/seeder

We need a stronger national defense.
Why?
(That's a serious question, having nothing to do with Trump or anyone else. It is one of my pet peeves that people of all political colors state that we need X airplanes and Y tanks and Z aircraft carriers and this many soldiers and that many sailors... and those people never tell us "what this military is supposed to do"!
"Defense" -- a strange word for military action that is mostly on the other side of the world -- is the largest post in the federal budget. America's military spending is over one third of the entire world's! More than twice as much as Russia and China combined.
I am not opposed to military spending. I am a US Army combat veteran. Intelligent use of force is a necessary component of foreign policy.
But I am opposed to any spending that is unnecessary. And I hear no one explaining why we need to spend more on military items.)
But I am opposed to any spending that is unnecessary. And I hear no one explaining why we need to spend more on military items.)
I'm an Air Force veteran and I'll be damned if anyone has ever told me any good reason why either. It just seems to be a knee-jerk reaction, go-to thing for the GOP when they have the power to up the defense budget as much as they can and usually at the sacrifice of other more needed social programs. It give their base a hard on of some type. I mean a 350 ship Navy? What the hell for? And how many of those dozens of new fighter planes for the Air Force actually work or are not wildly overpriced?
And I hear no one explaining why we need to spend more on military items.)
Why? Its actually quite simple. THE POWERFUL DEFENSE COMPANY LOBBIES!
(Well there are also other reasons-- for example some well-meaning but poorly informed "big government" people who actually believe that spending more by the government always results in better outcomes).
C'mon, XX!
For once you've seeded a policy article.
So GET INVOLVED! Express your ideas on defense spending...
For example: What is the role you see for super-carrier task forces in the year 2040? In a nuclear cruise-missile environment? Against pilot-less aircraft pulling 30 Gs?
Please, XX... I know you well enough, now, to be pretty sure you have no idea what I am talking about. You seed stuff without understanding it... sometimes without reading it... just to occupy the stage. But in this case, you have seeded something that could be the basis for a worthwhile discussion. So please! Please, please, please... participate in your own seed!
You don't have to be "right" on every detail. In fact, you don't have to be right on anything...
"More money for defense" is such an automatic plank in any conservative platform that I am not at all surprised that you go for it without knowing why.
Isn't that -- supporting a HUGE government program without even thinking about it -- a bit unsettling for you? Wouldn't you like to understand why a "small government person" like you wants to increase an already gargantuan expense?
When the country was founded "the national defense" meant a lot more than it does today. Countries actually invaded one another with the intention of either imposing a new government on the loser, annexing it, or extracting their material goods and monies. That is a threat that the United States has not faced since 1812, over 200 years ago. No one on earth seriously believe that America could be subject to an armed invasion requiring a large army to repel. Even during WW2 no one seriously believed that the US could be conquered by an occupying force of Japanese, Germans, a combination of both, or armies from any other nation. There is no need for large armies or navies to protect the "homeland" from mass attack.
Why do we have the most powerful military in world history? So we can impose our will on others through threat of force or force, and to protect global business interests.
US and international corporations should be paying for this protection out of their profits, not the American taxpayer.
Well, Germany assumed they were indestructible also (the master race and all). And the Japanese thought they were the premiere fighting force in the world-designed to rule over the lesser peoples of the world, but it took nations all over the world to fight against these two (along with their junior partner, Italy) and defeat them. Should this type of world conflict ever be allowed to happen again? If not, how would you propose to ensure it never happens again?
Should this type of world conflict ever be allowed to happen again? If not, how would you propose to ensure it never happens again?
Well one way to increase the odds of it happening again would be to weaken crucial alliances like NATO (like "you know who" is trying to do).
Why do we have the most powerful military in world history? So we can impose our will on others through threat of force or force, and to protect global business interests.
And there's another reason as well. (I won't tell anyone what it is-- but I will mention that owners of stocks in defense companies are currently very "happy campers").
For example, here's a chart of the stock price of the defense company Raytheon (stock symbol RTN):