╌>

New mystery in train crash: Was it hit by a flying object?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  randy2  •  11 years ago  •  11 comments

New mystery in train crash: Was it hit by a flying object?

PHILADELPHIA (AP) The Amtrak train that derailed along the nation's busiest tracks may have been struck by an object in the moments before it crashed, investigators said Friday, raising new questions about the deadly accident.

National Transportation Safety Board member Robert Sumwalt said an assistant conductor aboard the train told investigators that she heard Amtrak engineer Brandon Bostian talking over the radio with an engineer for a regional railroad just before the crash.

The regional engineer, who was in the same area as the Amtrak train, said his train had been hit by a rock or some other projectile. The conductor heard Bostian say the same had happened to his Amtrak train, according to Sumwalt.

The windshield of the Amtrak train was shattered in the accident but one area of glass had a breakage pattern that could be consistent with being hit by an object, he said, and the FBI is investigating.

Sumwalt declined to speculate about the exact significance of a projectile striking the train, but the idea raised the possibility that the engineer might have been distracted, panicked or even wounded in the moments before the train left the rails.

The Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority does not yet know what caused the damage to its train that night, said Jerri Williams, a spokeswoman for the agency.

SEPTA trains traveling through the area including one of the poorest and most violent parts of Philadelphia have had projectiles thrown at them in the past, whether by vandals or teenagers, she said. It was unusual that the SEPTA train was forced to stop on Tuesday night.

Not long before the derailment, two passengers on a southbound Amtrak told The Philadelphia Inquirer that something shattered a window on their train as it passed through the same area. They said Amtrak police boarded the train at 30th Street station in Philadelphia to document the damage. Amtrak has not commented on the report.

NTSB spokesman Peter Knudson said the board was seeking more information about the other Amtrak train's window damage.

The Amtrak wreck has made it clear that despite the train industry's widespread use of electronic signals, sensors and warning systems, safety still sometimes comes down to the knowledge and experience of the engineer at the controls.

Those skills would have been critical on the curve where the New York-bound train derailed, killing eight and injuring more than 200 in the deadliest U.S. train accident in nearly six years.

Instead of high-tech signals or automatic controls, engineers on that stretch of track have to rely on their familiarity with the route and a printed timetable they carry with them, not unlike engineers a century ago.

"We're depending heavily on the human engineer to correctly obey and interpret the signals that he sees and also speed limits and other operating requirements," said David B. Clarke, a railroad expert at the University of Tennessee.

The engineer, who had been working that route for several weeks, told investigators that he does not recall anything after ringing the train's bell as he passed by the North Philadelphia station a couple of minutes before Tuesday night's crash.

The engineer told the NTSB in an interview Friday that he felt comfortable with the train and was not fatigued, Sumwalt said.

In the minute before the derailment, the Amtrak train accelerated from 70 mph to more than 100 mph, even though the curve where it came off the tracks has a maximum speed of 50 mph.

It's not clear whether Bostian manually accelerated, Sumwalt said, though a data recorder shows that he did engage a braking system seconds before the derailment.

Experts say the railroad's signaling system would have slowed the train automatically if it had hit the maximum speed allowed on the line, but older cab-signal and train-control systems do not respond to localized speed restrictions.

Investigators are also conducting drug tests. Bostian's lawyer has said he was not using drugs or alcohol.

James Weir, a friend of Bostian's since they were teenagers in the Memphis area, said he called the engineer after hearing about the wreck, but that his friend was hospitalized and could not say much.

As a teenager, Bostian was a safe driver who would not go even 5 mph over the speed limit, he said.

"Whenever I would drive, I'd tend to go a little over and he'd fuss at me. He'd tell me to slow down. He's just not the kind of guy that breaks the rules," Weir said. "He puts safety ahead of everything."

Preliminary checks have not found any pre-existing problems with the train, the rail line or the signals.

Because of his experience, Bostian should have known the route, even if there's not so much as a speed limit sign on the side of the tracks, said Howard Spier, a Miami-based lawyer who is a former president of the Academy of Rail Labor Attorneys.

"It's engrained in them. He knew it," Spier said. "I'm convinced he knew he was entering a speed-restrictive curve."

The wreck has raised questions about positive train control, a system that automatically brakes trains going too fast. It is installed on the tracks where the train derailed, but it had not been turned on because further testing was needed, Amtrak President Joseph Boardman said.

Boardman said this week that he intends to have the system running across Amtrak by the end of this year, as Congress mandated back in 2008.

The system is already operating in other parts of the Northeast Corridor, the busy stretch of tracks between Boston and Washington. An older, less robust automatic-control system is in place for southbound trains in the same area as the derailment.

Also Friday, the first funeral was held for one of those killed in the wreck. U.S. Naval Academy midshipman Justin Zemser, 20, was laid to rest on Long Island.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

The Southeastern Pennsylvania Transportation Authority does not yet know what caused the damage to its train that night, said Jerri Williams, a spokeswoman for the agency.

SEPTA trains traveling through the area including one of the poorest and most violent parts of Philadelphia have had projectiles thrown at them in the past, whether by vandals or teenagers, she said. It was unusual that the SEPTA train was forced to stop on Tuesday night.

Not long before the derailment, two passengers on a southbound Amtrak told The Philadelphia Inquirer that something shattered a window on their train as it passed through the same area. They said Amtrak police boarded the train at 30th Street station in Philadelphia to document the damage. Amtrak has not commented on the report.

It would be terrible if it turns out that this was caused by teenagers getting off by throw rocks or taking pot shots. If a rock came through that windshield and distracted or hit the engineer, that might explain why he doesn't remember anything just before the crash.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

It's not the first time teenagers have caused a train wreck. My daughter was on a train from Toronto to Montreal and a kid had placed a heavy metal rod that prejected upwards on the track and caused the train to catch on fire. My daughter was able to get out and help others.

The only thing I ever did as a kid was to put pennies on the track to flatten them.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    11 years ago

They're coming out of the woodwork ...

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

The rock must have hit his foot and made him press the gas pedal down really hard. Grin.gif

It must have been the rock of Gibraltar!!!!!!

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Actually the throttle is a handle coming from the control portion of the engineers station right in front of the windshield. It is quite possible to be hit and slumping over the handle that would speed up the train. He come to seconds before the crash and desperately grabs the emergency brake, but it was too late. He was taken to the hospital with a head injury after the crash, which would account for him not remembering what happened up to the crash. Most people who are knocked out do not remember what had happened for a minute or two before they were knocked out.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    11 years ago

Siemens ACS-64Amtrak Cities Sprinter weighs215,537lb (97.766t) and is20.32m (66ft 8in) long. What could "a rock or some other projectile"do to it?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Smash through the windshield, which is what the NTSB says may have happened and are having the FBI investigating. With the speed of train at the time going 70mph a rock could hit the windshield with considerable force. They are also investigating to see is it was type of gun shot. stranger things have happened, still I think calling in the FBI to clear it up one way or another was a good idea.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Randy, I hope you are aware I know it isn't a gas pedal. Your explanation can probably work though as a defense.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Sorry for the bad assumption. It could work as a defense, but if the FBI can show that a rock, brick or maybe a pellet gun pellet came in through the windshield just before the crash he might not even have to defend himself any longer. I doubt charges would be filed.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Yup, just another example of workplace violence by some folk getting even for the crusades.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
Another train in the same area had something shatter its window, so a rock or other projectile could have shattered this windshield. May have even hit the driver. Just like when kids throw rocks from overpasses, not understanding just how bad the consequences can be.
 
 

Who is online



91 visitors