Democrats Trot Out Plan C In Their Never-Ending Trump Impeachment Crusade
Politics: It is merely a coincidence that just as the Trump-Russia collusion story started seriously falling apart, Democrats suddenly shifted gears to file a lawsuit against President Trump for allegedly violating an obscure provision of the Constitution involving foreign "emoluments."
On Monday, attorneys general from Maryland and Washington, D.C., filed a lawsuit against Trump claiming that he is "flagrantly violating" the Constitution because he is still the owner of his businesses, even though he's given up the operation of them.
On Wednesday, nearly 200 Democratic lawmakers sued Trump on the same basis, with Michigan Rep. John Conyers claiming that "Trump has conflicts of interest in at least 25 countries, and it appears he's using his presidency to maximize his profits."
For those who don't know, Article I, Section 9, of the Constitution stipulates that "no Person holding any Office of Profit or Trust under them, shall, without the Consent of the Congress, accept of any present, Emolument, Office, or Title, of any kind whatever, from any King, Prince, or foreign State."
The idea that Trump's businesses could be a problem vis-a-vis this clause never came up before the election. In fact, the only article we found in a search was one that questioned whether Hillary Clinton violated it as secretary of state when her foundation was getting fat foreign gifts while she was making decisions that benefited foreign governments.
The topic came up only after the election — but before Democrats decided to charge Trump with colluding with Russia to swing the election, after which the topic disappeared from view.
But after Democrats came up empty-handed with James Comey's testimony last Thursday — in which the former FBI director made it clear that Trump had not been a subject of the investigation and that he didn't believe Trump had pressured him to drop his investigation into Russian collusion — "emoluments" suddenly shot to the front of the Democrats' agenda. Why?
The chance that Democrats will succeed in their cases against Trump are incredibly slim. The Supreme Court has never heard a case involving this clause. As a result, it's not even known whether it applies to the president; there is in fact a debate about that among legal scholars. It's also far from clear whether Democratic lawmakers or state attorneys general have standing to bring such a suit, because they'd have to show that they were somehow harmed by the Trump Organization's business dealings.
There are also plenty of reasons to conclude that Trump hasn't even come close to violating this clause.
For one thing, the first five presidents were businesses owners who sold some of their assets (crops) to companies and governments abroad. University of Montana Law Professor Robert Natelson concluded that if what Trump did violated the Constitution, so did Thomas Jefferson and James Madison.
University of Iowa law professor Andy Grewal argues that if Trump violated this clause, then so might have Obama with foreign sales of his books. These scholars say the clause was designed to target bribes and gifts, but was never meant to cover routine business operations or prevent presidents from owning a business while serving in the White House.
So what's the real motivation for these lawsuits? Some have suggested that the plaintiffs hope they can force Trump to release his tax returns as part of any discovery, should one of these cases ever reach that far.
But more likely, this is simply another despicable attempt by Democrats to hobble a president they don't like and overturn an election they regret, using any means necessary to do so. If Plan A (claiming Trump's campaign colluded with Russians) won't fly, and if Plan B (saying he tried to obstruct justice) doesn't look like it has legs, then it's time to move to Plan C, filing laughable emoluments lawsuits.
It makes one wonder how far down the alphabet we'll have to go before we get to a Democratic plan to engage in a civil debate with Trump over public policies to meet the urgent needs of the country. Do they even have such a plan?
RELATED:
Oops: The New York Times Accidentally Exposed 'The Hillary Clinton-Russia Nexus'!
Did Obama White House And Loretta Lynch Illegally Meddle In 2016 Election?
The Thriving Market For Anti-Trump Hoaxes http://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/democrats-trot-out-plan-c-in-their-neverending-trump-impeachment-crusade/
On Monday, attorneys general from Maryland and Washington, D.C., filed a lawsuit against Trump claiming that he is "flagrantly violating" the Constitution because he is still the owner of his businesses, even though he's given up the operation of them.
On Wednesday, nearly 200 Democratic lawmakers sued Trump on the same basis, with Michigan Rep. John Conyers claiming that "Trump has conflicts of interest in at least 25 countries, and it appears he's using his presidency to maximize his profits."
For those who don't know, Article I, Section 9, of the Constitution stipulates that "no Person holding any Office of Profit or Trust under them, shall, without the Consent of the Congress, accept of any present, Emolument, Office, or Title, of any kind whatever, from any King, Prince, or foreign State."
The idea that Trump's businesses could be a problem vis-a-vis this clause never came up before the election. In fact, the only article we found in a search was one that questioned whether Hillary Clinton violated it as secretary of state when her foundation was getting fat foreign gifts while she was making decisions that benefited foreign governments.
The topic came up only after the election — but before Democrats decided to charge Trump with colluding with Russia to swing the election, after which the topic disappeared from view.
But after Democrats came up empty-handed with James Comey's testimony last Thursday — in which the former FBI director made it clear that Trump had not been a subject of the investigation and that he didn't believe Trump had pressured him to drop his investigation into Russian collusion — "emoluments" suddenly shot to the front of the Democrats' agenda. Why?
The chance that Democrats will succeed in their cases against Trump are incredibly slim. The Supreme Court has never heard a case involving this clause. As a result, it's not even known whether it applies to the president; there is in fact a debate about that among legal scholars. It's also far from clear whether Democratic lawmakers or state attorneys general have standing to bring such a suit, because they'd have to show that they were somehow harmed by the Trump Organization's business dealings.
There are also plenty of reasons to conclude that Trump hasn't even come close to violating this clause.
For one thing, the first five presidents were businesses owners who sold some of their assets (crops) to companies and governments abroad. University of Montana Law Professor Robert Natelson concluded that if what Trump did violated the Constitution, so did Thomas Jefferson and James Madison.
University of Iowa law professor Andy Grewal argues that if Trump violated this clause, then so might have Obama with foreign sales of his books. These scholars say the clause was designed to target bribes and gifts, but was never meant to cover routine business operations or prevent presidents from owning a business while serving in the White House.
So what's the real motivation for these lawsuits? Some have suggested that the plaintiffs hope they can force Trump to release his tax returns as part of any discovery, should one of these cases ever reach that far.
But more likely, this is simply another despicable attempt by Democrats to hobble a president they don't like and overturn an election they regret, using any means necessary to do so. If Plan A (claiming Trump's campaign colluded with Russians) won't fly, and if Plan B (saying he tried to obstruct justice) doesn't look like it has legs, then it's time to move to Plan C, filing laughable emoluments lawsuits.
It makes one wonder how far down the alphabet we'll have to go before we get to a Democratic plan to engage in a civil debate with Trump over public policies to meet the urgent needs of the country. Do they even have such a plan?
RELATED:
Oops: The New York Times Accidentally Exposed 'The Hillary Clinton-Russia Nexus'!
Did Obama White House And Loretta Lynch Illegally Meddle In 2016 Election?
The Thriving Market For Anti-Trump Hoaxes http://www.investors.com/politics/editorials/democrats-trot-out-plan-c-in-their-neverending-trump-impeachment-crusade/
Tags
Who is online
106 visitors

They still don't have anything on Trump, but the MSM is preparing the public for the illegal runaway prosecution of Donald Trump. These are the same people who have been there since Bill Clinton and have worked in and out of the White House for decades.
The Deep State has been there since Bill Clinton was President. Just like Obama, Clinton made sure he got as many of his people in the right places a long time ago.
Now we're really suffering from it.
You know this Trump thing started out with voter fraud. Jill Stein, the least likely person to become President, had to have a voter recount, supported by the Hillary crowd to show how Trump didn't win in those few states and it turned out as I remember he actually ended up with more votes than the first time. Of course Jill made a tidy amount of money and went home with her pockets full.
Then it was the collusion. Trump colluded with Russia to win the election. After a year of that and no evidence to support it, it went to obstruction. Trump obstructed the election and people involved in it. Well that didn't work out, so where are we now. Oh yes, Trump obstructed the investigations by ordering little or big and tall Comey the Lion to be fearful of losing his job by telling him he had better be loyal or else.
Well, the only evidence of obstruction of the campaign has been when the DNC screwed Sanders and of course when Hillary got the answers to the test before she took it. And let's not forget about little old Loretta, the sweetheart from NC, appointed US Attorney by Billy and Attorney General by honest Obama. Then little willy waited around the tarmac to talk to Loretta about the grand children and when she became available, they had a nice little chat. Someone whom I can not name told me Willy told Loretta he was proud of her and knew she knew how important this "matter" was to him and Hillary and when Hillary became President he would see to it she would be the next Supreme Court Justice.
Oh she was so happy, she told Comey to not ever call this "matter" an "investigation" again and told a couple of other people the Dems didn't have to worry, she wasn't going to charge old lady Clinton, I mean sweet Hillary. In fact she was going to end that investigation just like she did the foundation one.
Comey said they investigated the Russian interference from late 2015 until today and beyond. He said he waited most of 2016 for the Democrats to decide what they were going to do about it while Crowd Strike, hired by the DNC and was a Democrat Hack outfit prepared them for the hearing. Well, the Democrats had that election wrapped up and weren't going to do anything, until out of the dark and deep dungeon, TRUMP, the dark Knight of Horror became a major problem blocking the road that Hillary was going to take in order to drive to the White House and wouldn't let her by. Kicked her off the road, stole her car and drove it to White House and made claim to it.
Hillary went back to drinking and taking long walks in the woods stumbling over logs and falling in the creeks as she tried desperately to walk across them. After she sobered up she came back out and joined a new group called The Resistance. Their music sucks. I've heard better tunes played by frogs in a pond before, but they had a lot of fans with matches, bottles, sticks, M80s and black hoodies, so they started touring the country, having light show like Michael Jackson and playing in front of hundreds if not thousands of delusional fans who loved every one of their songs.
So here we are today...... The number one band in the country is called "The Resistance" and not a single one of them even know how to tune or play a guitar, but they keep strumming away and their fans don't even know they are listening to Fascist tunes.
"Never ending crusade"?
It hasn't even gotten started yet.