Woman fired after disabling work app that tracked her movements 24/7
A woman in California claims to have been fired from her job after uninstalling an app on her smartphone that her employer used to track her movements 24 hours a day.Myrna Arias, a former employee ofmoney transfer firm Intermex, says she was told to keep her phone on at all times and was dismissed weeks after being "scolded" for uninstalling the app. She's now suing Intermex for violating her privacy and wrongful termination, among other allegations.
"[Arias' boss] Stubits admitted that employees would be monitored while off duty, and bragged that he knew how fast she was driving at specific moments ever since she had installed the app on her phone," reads the complaint ,filed in Kern County Superior Court and spotted by ArsTechnica .
"She likened the app to a prisoners ankle bracelet."
"[Arias] expressed that she had no problem with the apps GPS function during work hours, but she objected to the monitoring of her location during non-work hours," says the filing. "She likened the app to a prisoners ankle bracelet and informed Stubits that his actions were illegal. Stubits replied that she should tolerate the illegal intrusion because Intermix was paying [her more than her previous employer]."
When Arias complained to Stubits, he told her that she was required to keep her phone powered on throughout the day. The app Xora StreetSmart is intended to let companies manage employees working away from the office. Its creators, ClickSoftware , says it lets firms "see the location of every mobile worker on a Google Map." However, ClickSoftware doesn't seem to envision the app as a 24-hour tracker, telling potential clients that "field employees" should launch the app "when [they] start their day."
Arias is currently suing Intermex for damages "in excess of $500,000" for lost earnings and wages, with her filing stating that "this intrusion would be highly offensive to a reasonable person." Intermex could not be reached for comment at the time of writing.
Tags
Who is online
115 visitors

Hopefully she gets awarded every penny of what she is suing for.
Really?
I thought they weren't allowed to ask certain questions-- like religious affiliation, etc. If they think their employees are doing something illegal, then fire them. Don't accuse the innocent of being guilty, just because the corporation doesn't know for sure. I would object strenuously to this-- and believe me, I'm not doing anything wrong.
I hope she gets every penny, and then some. If I were on the jury, I'd award her damages in the amount that would make the corporation sit up and take notice, not brush it off.
Corporations don't own your lives, although they would love to think so. Everyone has a reasonable expectation of privacy.
Well, I invite the government to spy on me. They would be so bored after a few days, they would leave me alone forever...
What is interesting about some housewife that goes to the grocery, picks up her son from band practice, heads to physical therapy, etc.?
Articles like this make me want to head for the hills... I'm so glad I'm retired and not at the mercy of some over-reaching corporation.
And I suppose, too, it depends on which corporation you're working for. I can't imagine a water company investing in the technology to track every one of its employees 24 hours a day... I mean, when I left the water company last October, they still had Windows XP on all their computers. Which, by the way, I like a whole lot better than Windows 8. Also, based on what's happened lately there, they had better be watching the watchers-- they're the ones screwing up!
Company phone? the employer has the right to have it on during work hours, NOT off work hours.
The employment contract folks, you are selling your time to the employer to do his business and you no longer have the right to do your stuff. Once your off the clock, that reverses and the employer has no expectation that you will be doing his business.
That is the legal premise that will control here. There are exceptions to this but very few.
She will get paid. The employer had no legal expectation to track his employee 24/7.
The employer will have to prove his requirement of carrying said tracking device 24/7 as a condition of employment was required by the work she was doing. A very difficult thing to prove.
AS long as she was on the clock so to speak, he could require compliance, and she will have to comply. As soon as she is off the clock, he has no requirements the law will recognize.
Easy case. Stupid employer.
I am disappointed with the laissez-faire attitude that allows some citizens to be greatly maligned, discriminated against, and stolen from, just because those who don't have anything to lose just don't care about those who might.
Isn't that called an IP address?
Well yeah, It's called assault and/or sodomy with a foreign object. I suspect it's not so much as a team-building strategy though, more of a take this job and shove it strategy.
Fine with me as long as your willing to pay the cost of such largess..
Now, that would be fun!
Me, a brilliant idea for a patent? Hahahaha!
I don't want anyone to have my private information, but everything intrudes into our private lives. Our medical records, the mailing lists we are on, our "cookies", my son's school, etc. I can't worry about all this, as it would drive me batty...
All of us leave a paper trail. School records, property ownership, car licenses, church records, etc. Thus it has ever been so. I just looked up the name of the ship my 6-greats grandfather came to America on, before the Revolution... It was in the 1750s. I feel sure that when he came over here from Scotland, he had no idea that 6 generations later, his granddaughter would be able to look up the name of the ship he sailed on. Unless one's employer is doing something secret for the government, I don't think they have the right to this information-- especially where you may be physically located 24 hours a day.
And yes, the information is there. But who would go to the trouble of looking it all up, just random, pick-a-name-out-of-a-hat kind of thing?
And, what can I do about it? Not one darn thing. Lord, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change.
This is why I retired, Robert. No corporation is going to "own" me. Look at me! I'm a gray-haired, 60 year old geologist. I'm 5' tall, and have no power to affect change over 99% of my life. I can't even reach the top shelf in the kitchen! Woooooo, that makes me dangerous... Obviously, I've hidden something up there that is baaaaad. (If you look, you'll find the dishes that I don't use often, like serving platters and bowls, etc. It has to be something special for me to stand on a chair to reach all that.)
Years ago, my boss asked me to lie on a report. I would not. He did not fire me. I took an oath to tell the truth as I know it, geologically. I will NOT lie about it. (Which is why I did water, rather than oil & gas.) When he asked me again, I quit. I can go anywhere to work and be underpaid and under appreciated.
And here I thought only my mother was paranoid enough to think that if I want privacy it's because I'm doing something wrong... I answer to a higher power, Robert-- I can't live with myself if I do something wrong. Grandma always said, you can't do wrong and get by. She was right.
The article (not this seed, but the article)is advertising for the app; nothing more, nothing less. That's why it is tagged under 'technology' in the original article. Otherwise, it would be tagged under 'Lady gets job back with a 1,000% pay increase and a little something in savings for her kid's college fund...'
Frankly, it pisses me off. One minute, I'm all caught up in someone's unfortunate and unfair predicament, and the next minute, I'm Ralphie just figuring out that Little Orphan Annie's secret coded message is, "Be sure to drink your Ovaltine!" As cynical as I can be at times, I'm still schmoed once or twice a month.
Ppfffftttttt.
And PS: It's gauchetoguzzleBlue Nunfroma cheap glass.
You're right, dear Sister. One MUST use crystal.
One MUST use crystal.
Meth?
Your choice, my dear friend!
Meth was after my time. Back then it was weed or powdered cocaine (which was for the rich only), though some people did love diet pills. No crack. I was a weed and beer man myself.
I know, Robert. If you work in the oil & gas industry, it is automatic that one will, at least, "exaggerate" the prospects. We call it, "The lure of the closed contour"-- contour lines drawn so that it looks like a dome feature, or an oil & gas trap.
I've been a big proponent on my board for trying to understand why someone would lie. Most of the time, it is because of coercion. Put someone's job at stake, and lots of people will do what they're told. I've always been weird in that I won't.
No job is worth that.
I don't think I'm smart enough to keep up with lies and make the science look like it supports the lie.
I may have said something untrue because I didn't know the full story, or didn't have all the data born out by subsequent scientific research, but never deliberately.
Weed sounds good to me.