Carrier workers facing layoffs feel betrayed by Trump
Carrier workers facing layoffs feel betrayed by Trump
CBS News
Dean Reynolds
15 hrs ago
INDIANAPOLIS -- A promise made before Christmas is fizzling before the Fourth of July.
In December, then-President-elect Trump told hundreds of workers at the Carrier manufacturing plant that he had worked out a deal to save their jobs.
But it's not working out that way. A steady downpour today did little to wash away the fact that the jobs of 600 union employees are going south.
"They're going to Monterrey, Mexico," said Robert James, president of the local union.
Reynolds said he felt betrayed, since Mr. Trump told workers during his December visit to the plant that 1,100 jobs would be saved.
Watch: Trump touts Carrier jobs deal in fiery victory rally
"And by the way, that number is going to go up very substantially as they expand this area, this plant," Mr. Trump said. "So the 1,100 is going to be a minimum number."
Blasting companies for moving American jobs abroad was a feature of the Trump campaign, and saving the Carrier jobs was touted as a sign of Mr. Trump's bargaining prowess.
"You're going to have a good Christmas," he said at the plant.
President-elect Donald Trump speaks at an event at Carrier HVAC plant in Indianapolis, Indiana, Dec. 1, 2016.
© REUTERS President-elect Donald Trump speaks at an event at Carrier HVAC plant in Indianapolis, Indiana, Dec. 1, 2016.
But the truth is that 400 of the 1,100 jobs Mr. Trump mentioned were white-collar positions that were never going away.
Only 700 union jobs were saved. Six hundred others will be lost, and Carrier is not paying a price. The company actually received a $7 million incentive package from Indiana to keep the plant open with a reduced work force.
"That is what he said was not going to happen," James said. "That's what he told all of us."
"And a lot of these people voted for Mr. Trump" with the understanding that he would save their jobs, James added.
Duane Oreskovic voted for the president, and is among those losing their jobs.
"I liked this job. This was a job that I actually wanted to retire from," Oreskovic said. "It's not going to happen any more."
At the White House Friday, press secretary Sean Spicer said the job cuts here were long-planned and nothing new.
The first round of layoffs will take effect next month, and the second in December -- three days before Christmas.
http://www.msn.com/en-us/news/us/carrier-workers-facing-layoffs-feel-betrayed-by-trump/ar-BBD5YU7?li=BBnb7Kz
Tags
Who is online
102 visitors

"And a lot of these people voted for Mr. Trump" with the understanding that he would save their jobs, James added.
Hahahahahahahaha!
I can't wait to see what Trump's health care bill does to his supporters. Now we know his supporters won't have job's so they won't be able to afford healthcare.
MAGA - but for who?
Once again we see how the union priced themselves out of the competitive marketplace.
And let's not forget to factor in how Obamacare is a job killer. The employer mandate could also be a factor in this situation.
I'm not sure what this statement has to do with Trump lying.
It has to do with the root cause of the jobs leaving not Trumps bandaid tax cut that saved the plant from closing in its entirety.
So you're not disputing that Trump lied and misled these people. You're just saying that it helped the narrative back then so screw the worker today as long as big business is making profits for their stakeholders.
There is no lie he did what he said. He saved hundreds of jobs and kept the plant from closing.
"In December, then-President-elect Trump told hundreds of workers at the Carrier manufacturing plant that he had worked out a deal to save their jobs".
He never said all the jobs that wasn't the deal.
Your response is an example of why I don't trust Trump supporters.
Why can't you just admit the truth. Why do you have to twist things so they don't look so bad? Why tow the line rather than speak the truth. It's okay to say that what Trump said he was going to do didn't happen but hopefully future deals will. Why perpetuate the lie?
Trump lied or was too naive to know that the "deal" wasn't worth the millions that Indiana tax payers will be paying for years to come. Now whether the people he lied to were too stupid to see the lie is another story.
United Technologies CEO Greg Hayes told CNBC Monday that despite already experiencing a difficult situation with the new administration, President Donald Trump stands out from his predecessors because he listens to the company.
"The Indianapolis situation was difficult … I think we came to an agreement with the new Trump administration in terms of saving 800 jobs and keeping the plant open and we have kept that commitment. Unfortunately we have also continued to remove some jobs out as we had expected to do," Hayes said on the sidelines of the International Paris Air Show.
United Technologies is the parent company of furnace and air conditioner maker Carrier, which was under fire by Trump on the campaign trail because of its plans to move some manufacturing operations to Mexico from Indiana. Trump used Carrier as an example to highlight the decline of manufacturing in America.
Ultimately, United Technologies agreed to receive $7 million in tax credits from the State of Indiana, issued at $700,000 per year for 10 years. Carrier also agreed to invest approximately $16 million in its Indiana facilities, and keep around 1,000 people employed in Indianapolis.
"(The White House) will actually listen and take our advice and take our input and that's something we haven't seen in a while," he added.
Meantime, United Technologies is set to increase its aircraft engine production to around 400 engines this year, up from 140 last year. Hayes said that having recently experienced a few "teething problems" with the engines, they now work exactly as had been intended.
Are you saying that Carrier employees' are lying and that they aren't losing their jobs?
He's saying Trump is listening to him and together they saved the plant from closing. He is also indicating the boost in aircraft engine production will be good for the business.
Here is what the $7 million in tax breaks for Carrier is helping do for Carrier.
While economic incentives play a key role in economic development deals, automation is increasingly becoming a factor in our profession. Greg Hayes, the CEO of United Technologies (Carrier’s parent company) said the $16 million investment in the Carrier factory in Indianapolis will automate the plant to drive down costs and will ultimately mean fewer jobs long-term.
The Art of the Deal...LOL the employes taxes will be used to automate and eliminate more jobs...
No it isn't employees taxes, it's a tax break it's Carriers taxes. There is a difference between tax breaks, subsidies and government grants.
We see what liberals claim doesn't happen lower taxes are saving jobs and trickling down. If not for the tax breaks all the jobs would be gone.
Dean, of course it's a tax break for Carrier, but with that tax break, who do you think taxes are going to have to make up the short fall...If their taxes were $10 million for a year and they got a $1 tax break, where does the money come from to make up that $1 million?
The monies saved in the tax break are going to help automate the plant which, as the CEO said will mean less jobs.
Kavika, what is being described is otherwise known as a race to the bottom for the workers and a race to the top for the owners and investors.
It's the same old BS, of trickle down.
There's a difference when you know something and can't control it. Trump saved jobs and couldn't control everything. Obama mislead people and the plant closed even before he took office after being elected. Trump is looked upon as a liar and Obama of course, who knew the plant was closing and told the employees "if the government is here to help you, this plant will be here for another 100 years" is given a pass for twisting his words to get elected. Not that both didn't do the same thing in so many ways though.
This is a huge brouhaha, here, because Carrier is just up the road from us, in Columbus, IN. I know they feel betrayed, and don't blame them. Just another empty promise from Trump, one he couldn't possibly deliver on. So, why say it, other than get the sound bites?
My prayers to those that are losing their jobs.
So how did you feel Dowser when Obama said what he said to the people in Janesville in the comment right above yours already knowing when he said it the plant was closing? I think the final closing was March 2009.
Has the plant up the road closed entirely? Were any jobs saved? Solyndra didn't have any problems getting the money to support them. Of course, they closed, took bonuses as they were closing, destroyed merchandise as they were closing and all the top dogs came out getting a big bang out of their political donations. They only people who took a loss were the American Citizens.
Where is Janesville? I only commented because this was located near us!
I don't blame the people for feeling betrayed. And where was I, during all this businesses moving out of the country? Mad about corporate greed.