Truly Off The Rails, It’s Just A Matter Of Time Before Trump, Fiorina And Carson Fade Away
Outsiders Looking In: Truly Off The Rails, Its Just A Matter Of Time Before Trump, Fiorina And Carson Fade Away
I get the outsider schtick.America has seen it over the years, but rarely have the American people elected someone who is truly off the rails.
In this field of Republican candidates for president, there is absolutely no doubt in my mind that Donald Trump, Ben Carson and Carly Fiorina are off the rails.Their current polling advantage is due to their outsider persona, no question, but none of them have, to use Richard Ben Cramers book title from the 1988 campaign, What it Takes.
Wendell Willkie ran as an outsider/insider business guy in 1940 against Franklin Roosevelt. He was an experienced, viable national figure, knowledgeable on the issues, but lost to FDR in his bid for a third term.
Dwight D. Eisenhower was hardly an outsider, though he had never held elective office before. He was an immensely popular general who had helped mastermind D-Day and was courted at times by both political parties.
Jimmy Carter was surely an outside Washington candidate. That did him enormous good in 1976, but he was still an accomplished governor, two term state senator and experienced politician.
Popular General Ulysses S. Grant and experienced government hands William Howard Taft and Herbert Hoover were other presidents never to hold elective office, but few questioned their experience or qualifications.
In 2015, you have to ask yourself when examining the candidacies of Trump, Carson and Fiorina whether they are truly presidential. Do they have the temperament, experience, knowledge and understanding of what it takes to run for president and be president?
Trump is clearly number one in the off the rails category. Everything is an attack, everything is a show , and everything is about him and his outsized ego. There is no uplifting message of substance, no indication he understands the nations problems or is ready to offer any concrete plans to solve them. This is a soap opera on steroids, Entertainment Tonight that is rapidly ceasing to be entertaining. It is a candidacy that is no longer, if it ever was, meaningful.Trump has no where to go but down and with each passing day of his antics he drops in the publics estimation.
Carson is totally out of his league. There is truly no reason for him to be a candidate. He does not understand the issues. He appears not to have read the Constitution on just who can be president or even how the government works.He may understand brain surgery, but he doesnt have the slightest understanding of basic foreign or domestic policy. His participation in debates and as a candidate subjecting himself to scrutiny will doom any future campaign faster than the Washington Nationals got swept by the New York Mets.
As for Fiorina , she is no wunderkind, as her career at Hewlett-Packard can attest. In fact, most analysts are appalled at her performance. Jeffrey Sonnenfeld pointed out that during her tenure the value of HP fell 55 percent, 30,000 people were laid off, and she invested $25 billion in the dying Compaq computer company. She walked away having made $100 million after her failure and her firing. Not exactly a record to run on.
But, more important, she does not appear to have the leadership skills or the temperament to be a strong leader in the political world. She does study her briefing books, she does prepare for the debates more than some of the others, and she is not shy and not afraid to mix it up. But at the end of the day, she shows her true inexperience by stating that she will refuse to talk to Russias President Vladimir Putin and shows very little understanding of issues, from Planned Parenthood to Iran.
So my guess is that even though these three have taken the lead in some of the polls they will fade quickly and then we will be back to more serious Republican candidates: Bush, Kasich, Christie, Rubio and Cruz.When voters get serious, Trump, Carson and Fiorina will be the outsiders, looking in, and wondering what hit them.
By: Peter Fenn, U. S. Newsa and World Report, September 25, 2015
Tags
Who is online
80 visitors

If they are "off the tracks", does that make hillary the Hindenburg?
It is mystifying why Fiorina is running for President, other than to build a personal brand that can financially benefit her down the road.
Her business record of laying off 30,000 workers completely dooms her, and I think everybody knows it. When this fact was used against her in the California U.S. senate race, it tanked her candidacy.
Even Hillary is a more appealing personality, btw.
Trump has jumped the shark, down to waving Bibles in front of red meat evangelicals, and Carson has been overmatched by his lack of knowledge from the beginning. The seeded article seems predictive, totally.
Sean,
I get you're not a fan of democrat ideology and particularly display loathing for Hillary, do you believe Trump, Carson or Fiorina are ideal candidates for the White House? If any of these were to be the nominee would you cast your vote so a Republican would be President or do you believe they're qualified to preside over our country?
I'm asking because I truly would like to know your take. Being a liberal leaning Independent most would assume I'm a Hillary fan, I'm not. Actually I'm not impressed with what I've heard from the Democrat camp.
Looking forward to additional debates on the GOP side and awaiting the first DEM debate.
Trump is the classic Wizard of Oz figure. Lots of show, but it's not real. He is the man behind the curtain and his exposure as such is growing. Plus he lies through his teeth, which most politicians do, but he is nauseatingly obvious about it. He tells lies to people that the people he is telling them to, knows for a fact that they are lies and he lies anyway. His lies are HUGE and they make one's Head Spin. Not going to be the nominee.
Carson is a brilliant brain surgeon, which qualifies him to be...a brilliant brain surgeon and nothing else. He has already shown either a breathtaking ignorance of the Constitution and the Supreme Court or has decided he'll only obey the parts he likes. The government doesn't work that way. Not going to be the nominee.
Fiorina's business experience has been a disaster. She is just a terrible business person. No one wants to hire her for anything. All she accomplished at HP was to cut the shareholders stock values in half, while destroying jobs (the stockholders were incredibly happy to buy her departure) yet she thinks she can run and win based on her business acumen? She cant. Not going to be the nominee.
Good synopsis of the candidates Randy.
Thanks. Even though none of these three will be the nominee for the GOP, they can still do some real damage to the Republican party between now and past the early primaries, so I hope they stay in for awhile. Oh, just in case I am wrong about one of these three, it would be a Democratic Party wet dream to have the GOP be stupid enough to actually nominate one of them. It'd be like them nominating Sarah Palin. Sadly I don't think that even Republicans are that stupid. Although.......you never know.......
He could probably manage to be just about any job that could bore you to sleep, but he can't be president.
He could get a job watching cement harden or paint drying or grass growing. Just so it's not teaching any level of Social Studies. For that he is truly not qualified.