╌>

Social Security's Demise Is Much Closer Than You Think

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  xxjefferson51  •  11 years ago  •  16 comments

Social Security's Demise Is Much Closer Than You Think

E ntitlements: Officially, Social Security has enough money to pay all its promised benefits until 2033. But a new study suggests this forecast could be wildly optimistic. And that spells big trouble for future retirees.

Every year, the Social Security Administration releases its Trustees Report, which projects the program's solvency how much it will take in, how much it will pay out and how long the "trust fund" can cover revenue gaps over the next 75 years.

The latest report says that Social Security can meet its financial obligations for about 18 more years. After that, the trust fund will be exhausted, and payroll taxes won't cover nearly all the benefit costs.

That's bad enough. But a new study by researchers at Harvard and Dartmouth shows that this day of reckoning will almost certainly come far sooner than that.

The authors compare previous Trustees Report forecasts about life expectancy, fertility rates and other variables to actual results. They found that these forecasts have grown increasingly unreliable.

Worse, since 2000 "the direction of the biases are all in the same direction, making the Social Security trust funds look healthier than they turned out to be."

For example, Social Security has been consistency underestimating life expectancy, which means that people are living and collecting benefits for longer than predicted. Underestimating life expectancy by just 1.3 years leads to 150,000 more people collecting benefits than predicted, the researchers note.

The Trustees Report has also overestimated the nation's fertility rate. In 2010, for example, 315,000 fewer children were born than predicted. This error makes the population look younger, which in turn makes Social Security's financial outlook seem healthier.



Read More At Investor's Business Daily: http://news.investors.com/ibd-editorials/050815-751813-study-finds-that-social-security-forecasts-too-optimistic.htm#ixzz3ZeozlQF5


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Very good post Badfish. I was just looking over government information today about Social Security. Take a look at these numbers. I went back and looked at projections from earlier projections and the end is moving faster toward us than we are toward it.

Here is the main page link...

Choose "Historical Tables" on the left going down under "Budget" and then click on table 13.1 and look at the surplus/deficit of "Old Age and Survivors Insurance Fund". Don't forget to slide over at the bottom of the screen to get to the current dates as it comes up when you first click 13.1 on your screen starting at year 1936. It looks like a deficit rock falling starting in 2016. This file opens with Microsoft Excel.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Yeah it does..

The projections are it will go negative in 2016.

In fact it took a huge dip in 2009, loosing half it's value by 2012,
and accelerating. Projected to lose half it's value again this year and going red next year at an accelerating pace.

You need the actual numbers?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

All anyone needed to do was watch The West Wing series to find out what's happening in the USA. Josh Lyman (played by Bradley Whitford) predicted that Social Security would go bankrupt in 17 years (from THEN) and the presidential candidate he was working for (Hoynes) didn't pay attention to him, so Josh went to work for Josiah Bartlet (Martin Sheen) instead. I guess people knew back then what was bound to happen.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

You need the actual numbers?

Yes, that would be very nice if it isn't too much trouble. The thing I notice, not in the file I've provided but the previous files I've observed and probably have saved is the years are going by but the deficit time has moved toward us much quicker. In other words a few years ago the deficit started later than 2016. The updated calculations appear to show the time when the deficits start is accelerating.

 
 
 
One Miscreant
Professor Silent
link   One Miscreant    11 years ago

Decent post, I must say.

I would only add that allowing monies collected, in the name of social security, to be misappropriated by congress needs to end now as well.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

So the successive American governments are capable of fooling most of the people most of the time. It makes you wonder about other things as well, such as Roswell for example.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Here are the numbers from 2008 on thru the 2020 projection;

Old age and survivors insurance fund: Fund balance, end of year

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014

183,003 145,784 102,542 93,278 94,282 69,114 57,380

estimates---->

2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020

43,490 -12,938 -42,727 -65,846 -89,936 -122,626

That pretty much sums it up.

(extracted from the XLS file provided at the link above)

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Reagan didn't steal a damned thing from the SS trust fund.

CONGRESS did.

A democrat congress at that.

And your right, that site you got the piece from The Big Lie. is known as a big lie...

And if not that, one of the myriad liberal Reagan bashing sites there are.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Barbara, I really appreciate you bringing this up. This is something we can look at and see how this all developed. I have some information and some questions. I can't completely agree with everything Allen W. Smith has written, but I can agree with quite a bit of it. It's the question of putting the money in the General Funds in the 1983 version I question. If they didn't the president didn't have the power to make it so and still doesn't even though he has a phone and pen. Just kidding.

We all know the president at that time didn't run the country like it has been run lately. He didn't just pull an executive order out of his pocket. Don't get angry yet. Let me go on. In 1983 the House was controlled by the Democrats (269 to 166) and the Senate was controlled by the Republicans (54 to 46), so the House could have easily rejected the change. But let's go on.

Back in 1979 during Carter's presidency Alan Greenspan and advisers had been planning on taxing Social Security Benefits which had not been taxed since its inception in 1941. Keep in mind they started taxing Unemployment Compensation Benefits during Carter's presidency in 1978.

I guess my unanswered question is the 1983 amendment was set up for the taxation of Social Security to have the funds put into The Social Security Fund and it was to raised $26.6 million during the first 7 years. I don't see anywhere to indicate that didn't happen.

I can tell you right now that they only taxed 50% of the benefit amount and it was capped of so lower income people didn't even pay anything. Only 10% of the contributors were affected by this.

So in saying that Reagan reduced the the top Federal rate from 70% to 50% and then to 28%. Now I assure you the paragraph above is insignificant to this reduction of tax rate even if the tax revenue was put into the General Fund.

...

Here is some info...

Ultimately, the 1983 Amendments were passed in the House on the evening of March 9, 1983 by a vote of 282 to 148. On the evening of March 23rd, the Senate passed its version of the bill by a vote of 88 to 9. Both bills contained virtually identical provisions for the taxation of benefits, with only one change in the Senate bill: requiring that tax-free interest income be used in the computation to determine if the thresholds were exceeded. In the Conference, which took place on March 24th, the House accepted the Senate provision. Immediately following the conclusion of the Conference, at 10:25 p.m. that night, the Congress reconvened to consider the Conference Report. The House quickly adopted the Conference Report by a vote of 243 to 102. In the Senate, the debate went on through the night and finally, in the early morning hours of March 25th, the Senate voted 58-14 for final passage. ( See detailed Summary of the 1983 Amendments .)

And....

The Senate Report thus acknowledged that one motivating factor in introducing this change was to raise revenue for the Trust Funds. This was part of a much larger package of program changes designed to address the financial solvency of the program. One might fairly say that cutting benefits and raising revenues was the purpose of the 1983 Amendments, and the adoption of Social Security benefit taxation was simply one provision among many to facilitate these aims. It is also important to note that funds raised under this provision do not go into the General Fund of the Treasury but into the Social Security Trust Funds. This emphasizes again that the purpose of introducting this provision was to raise revenue to help restore Social Security's financial solvency. (The Committees estimated the six-year savings from this provision at $26.6 billion, and estimated that this provision would supply almost 30% of the total additional long-range funding provided by the Amendments.)

Now every year Reagan was in office the House was controlled by the Democrats. The Democrats controlled both Houses the last two years he was in office. Remember the amnesty and the Democrat promise. Well, they never did come through with their promise and no one else has since then, but isn't it feasible Regan signed an amendment to the 1941 Social Security Act in 1983 to tax it and put the money in the Social Security Fund and Congress never did that either, because that was the way it was presented to him?

Bush one, Clinton, Bush two and Obama have basically been the same presidents only digressing as each one left office or came into office. The Republicans controlled Congress during Clinton's surplus years.

I'm not taking responsibility away from Reagan, but Reagan had to fight the Republicans as much as he did the Democrats while he was president.

Now Barabara, I'm not saying Allen W. Smith is wrong in everything he has written, nor am I saying I am right in everything I've written, but the question is what happened and why after the amendment was passed and why.

Now here is the very important information links to read considerably more and help us to find out what happened, why and most of all we need to figure what we are going to do about it today. Thanks for your time. I really hope you check these links out and the links contained within them.

Research Note #12:
Taxation of Social Security Benefits

SOCIAL SECURITY AMENDMENTS OF 1983

H.R. 1900/P.L. 98-21
(Enacted April 20, 1983)

In this amendment was...

Allocations to the OASI and DI Trust Funds as you will see.

More information...

REPORT OF THE
NATIONAL COMMISSION
ON
SOCIAL SECURITY REFORM

JANUARY 1983

Under the 1993 change it specified revenue to go into the general fund. Keep in mind both Houses were controlled by Democrats in 1993 (57 to 43) in the Senate and (258 to 176) in the House.

So the author Allen W. Smith has to deal with an amendment signed by Reagan specifying the revenues as small as they were affecting on 10% of the beneficiaries were to be put in the Old Age Retirement or SS. Did it happen. Well in 1993 it was changed by total control by the Democrats to go into the General funds, we know that for sure.

Please help me out with this. Don't forget to go to the links provided. I think you will enjoy the information there. Are you reading or read the book by Allen W. Smith? Thanks - six

 
 

Who is online




136 visitors