╌>

Hillary Gave Away Our Uranium

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  9 years ago  •  10 comments

Hillary Gave Away Our Uranium

The right wing media bs megaphone has a piece of crap caught in their mouth that they can't stop spitting out. (Actually they have a lot of them, but for the of purposes of this article we will stick to just one. )

 

I have lost track or count of how many times I have seen right wing media burble out the mantra "Hillary gave away our uranium to the Russians".  ( A charge that more than a little implies treason by the way) In the la la land of right wing "news" this claim has taken on the appearance of a "given", or something that everyone knows is true. 

This is probably why the US political right is justly known as the home of fake news time after time. 

I went to Google and I typed in "did Hillary give away our uranium"  which is a direct variant of Trump's exact words "  Hillary Clinton gave away 20 percent of the uranium  ". 

 

On the first page of the Google results, every single entry of the ten debunks the charge. 




Trump claims — falsely — that Clinton gave Russia 20% of US uranium




Feb 16, 2017 -  "We had  Hillary Clinton give  Russia 20 percent of the  uranium  in  our  country. ... However, Clinton  did  not represent the State Department on the ...







No, Hillary Clinton did not "give Russia 20 percent of the uranium” in ...




Feb 17, 2017 -  I  did  not do anything for Russia. I've done nothing for Russia.  Hillary Clinton gave  them 20 percent of  our uranium .  Hillary Clinton did  a reset, ...







Donald Trump repeats his Mostly False claim about Hillary Clinton ...




www.politifact.com/wisconsin/.../donald-trump-repeats-his-mostly-false-claim-about-/
 


Feb 16, 2017 -  We had  Hillary Clinton  try and do a reset. We had  Hillary Clinton give  Russia 20 percent of the  uranium  in  our  country. You know what  uranium  ...







In a nuclear claim, Donald Trump says Hillary Clinton 'gave up' one ...



www.politifact.com/wisconsin/.../nuclear-claim-donald-trump-says-hillary-clinton-ga/
 



Claim:  Says Hillary Clinton "gave up 20 percent of America's uranium supply to Russia."

Claimed by:  Donald Trump


Fact check by PolitiFact :  Mostly False









Cash Flowed to Clinton Foundation Amid Russian Uranium Deal - The ...




Apr 23, 2015 -  Uranium  investors  gave  millions to the Clinton Foundation while Secretary of State  Hillary Rodham  Clinton's office was involved in ... If the Kazakh deal was a major victory, UrAsia  did  not wait long before resuming the hunt. ..... A commission spokesman said that “to the best of  our  knowledge” most of the ...







FactChecking Trump's News Conference - FactCheck.org




www.factcheck.org/2017/02/factchecking-trumps-news-conference/
 


Feb 16, 2017 -  For example, the order  did  not say — and the administration failed to ...  Hillary Clinton gave away  20 percent of the  uranium  in the United States. ... Since  my  election, Ford announced it will abandon its plans to build a new ...







A False 'Corruption' Claim - FactCheck.org



www.factcheck.org/2016/10/a-false-corruption-claim/
 



Claim:  Claims Hillary Clinton "even handed over American uranium rights to the Russians."

Claimed by:  Donald Trump










Hillary Clinton Gave 20 Percent of United States' Uranium to Russia in ...



www.snopes.com/hillary-clinton-uranium-russia-deal/
 



Claim:  Sec. of State Hillary Clinton's approval of a deal to transfer control of 20% of U.S. uranium deposits to a Russian company was a quid pro quo exchange for...

Claimed by:  Internet










Why We Really Don't Need to Investigate Bill and Hillary Clinton's ...




www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-russia-hillary-uranium-575071
 


Mar 28, 2017 -  Trump tweeted late Monday night: “Why isn't the House Intelligence Committee looking into the Bill & Hillaryth deal that allowed big  Uranium  to ...







No, Hillary Clinton Did Not 'Give' Russia Uranium - Foxtrot Alpha




foxtrotalpha.jalopnik.com/no-hillary-clinton-did-not-give-russia-uranium-1792446097
 


Feb 16, 2017 -  No,  Hillary Clinton Did  Not ' Give ' Russia  Uranium  ... One's assets in Kazakhstan, the world's largest  uranium  producer,  our  colleagues said.

 

 

 

 

   This is the conclusion of fact checking organizations, the New York Times, Newsweek, etc. 

 

I am not surprised to see that be the case, in fact I expected it to be the case, because being an intelligent and careful consumer of news, I knew it already. 

 

One of the far right members of this forum repeated this false charge in a casual way in one of his latest seeds. This person "demands" respect  on a daily basis, generally fruitlessly I might add. 

 

You don't get respect by constantly posting falsehoods. 

 

 

---------------------------------

 


 


The deal Clinton had a role in approving gave Russia ownership of 20 percent of U.S. production capacity — not existing stocks of uranium. Furthermore, Clinton alone could not have stopped the deal; only the president could have done that with a finding that national security would be endangered. Lastly, none of the uranium goes to Russia. That would require export licenses.

Trump was referring to Clinton’s role in the 2010 purchase by Russia’s nuclear agency of Uranium One , a Toronto-based company with mining operations in Kazakhstan, Tanzania and the United States, where the company’s operations amount to about  20 percent of annual U.S. production capacity .

The fact is — as  we reported nearly two years ago  — Clinton had no veto power to stop that deal. She was  one of nine voting members  on the foreign investments committee that unanimously approved it, a panel that also includes the secretaries of the treasury, defense, homeland security, commerce and energy, the attorney general, and representatives from two White House offices — the United States Trade Representative and the Office of Science and Technology Policy. (Separately, the Nuclear Regulatory Commission needed to approve (and did approve) the transfer of two uranium recovery licenses as part of the sale.)

Only the president could have stopped the sale, and only if at least one member of the foreign investment committee had objected. And even then, the president cannot prohibit a transaction without finding “credible evidence” that the “foreign interest exercising control might take action that threatens to impair the national security,” according to the  federal regulation  that governs such matters.

Finally, Russia may own the mines, but the uranium coming out of them stays in the U.S. As the  Nuclear Regulatory Commission noted  when it approved the sale, “no uranium produced at either facility may be exported.”

Trump made the same claim in slightly different words three times during his news conference. It’s a replay of a bogus accusation he made during last year’s campaign, when it was  debunked by us  and other independent fact-checking sites. But constant repetition doesn’t make a false statement true.






Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    9 years ago

Why do people excoriate right wing media such as Fox and Breitbart and Infowars?  This is why. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    9 years ago

She took millions in donations from Putins uranium pals (and failed to properly report it) who had business pending upon which her agency sat in judgment.

 

everything else is semantics. 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   9 years ago

rofl.

 

You are not a serious person if you say something that silly. 

 

It was not Clinton's decision to make. It's that simple. 

 

Sean , would not this deal have gone through if Hillary Clinton DID NOT EXIST ?

 

There is no point to the charge that Hillary gave away our uranium, in fact it is a scurrilous lie. 

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Some defense. Is it legal to give a judge on a panel hearing a case that you are a party to

millions of  dollars? Argue that with a straight face. Because that's what your defense of Hillary consists of.

Putting aside the undisputed facts that she took millions from foreigners whose application she sat in judgment on,  your whole "defense" is predicated on her not having a de jure veto, even though Scweitzer's  claim was that she had a de facto veto. You are arguing against a straw man.

Let's say Hillary received even more millions from a rival company that wanted to stop Putin's friends. Given how the democrats basically rigged their primaries to ensure Hillary's nomination and their history of falling in lockstep behind their leader, can you imagine any scenario where the other minor cabinet officials overrode Hillary's position? That would be impossible.

you can't get around the fact that she took millions from Putin's friends, failed to disclose it  as required, and then voted in support of their uranium application. Thats the substance of the charge and that's  not appropriate in any sane universe.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Sean Treacy   9 years ago

The charge is that Hillary gave away US uranium. Those very words have been repeated thousands of times on conservative shows and blogs, and by the right wing candidate, the now president. He continues to utter them long after the charge has been thoroughly debunked (that fact is a disgrace in itself).

I think Trump may have shady dealings with Russian mobsters, but I don't state it as fact.

There are no facts that indicate Hillary Clinton approved the giveaway of US uranium  to Russia in return for money to their foundation. None. 

There are serious counterfacts. 

Clinton did not have the power to approve the deal. She may have had the power to be one vote out of nine. Her state dept. said she was not involved in the decision which was handled by others in her office. Be that as it may, she did not have control of the decision. Given that , any claim "she" did this or that in a conclusive way is simply a lie.

Please stop.  

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

OK how about we only discuss this:

"the fact that she took millions from Putin's friends, failed to disclose it  as required, and then voted in support of their uranium application."

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  96WS6   9 years ago

The assumption is that donations were made to the Clinton foundation in exchange for the approval of the uranium deal. Clinton did not have the power to approve the deal, so there can not possibly have been a quid pro quo. 

I think the CF made a mistake by accepting money from such foreign sources, but I guess if you want to run a world class charity you need a lot of money to do it. 

I am not going to defend whether it is right or wrong to accept charity donations from Russians, all I'm saying is that Trump and the right wing media are liars. She did not give away our uranium. 

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Sean Treacy   9 years ago

And yet the right keeps peddling an untrue narrative.  Why not just peddle the truth?  Is there not enough evidence to establish your version of the truth?

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   9 years ago

Feel free to rebut anything I wrote. 

The left creates their strawmen  to argue against, quibbling over descriptors and characterizations while ignoring the substance. 

 
 

Who is online






127 visitors