╌>

Trump Aide Stephen Miller accused Reporter of "cosmopolitan bias," here is the term's ugly history

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  johnrussell  •  9 years ago  •  9 comments

Trump Aide Stephen Miller accused Reporter of "cosmopolitan bias," here is the term's ugly history

So what is a “cosmopolitan”? It’s a cousin to “elitist,” but with a more sinister undertone. It’s a way of branding people or movements that are unmoored to the traditions and beliefs of a nation, and identify more with like-minded people regardless of their nationality. (In this sense, the revolutionary pamphleteer Thomas Paine might have been an early American cosmopolitan, when he declared: “The world is my country; all mankind are my brethren, and to do good is my religion.”). In the eyes of their foes, “cosmopolitans” tend to cluster in the universities, the arts and in urban centers, where familiarity with diversity makes for a high comfort level with “untraditional” ideas and lives.

https://www.mediamatters.org/blog/2017/08/03/stephen-miller-accused-jim-acosta-cosmopolitan-bias-here-terms-ugly-history/217513

In  Politico Magazine  political analyst Jeff Greenfield explained how President Donald Trump’s senior policy advisor Stephen Miller’s invocation of the word “cosmopolitan” in a White House press briefing to attack a reporter connected him to a long history of the term being weaponized by “anti-Democratic political movements,” often with clear anti-Semitic undertones.


During an August 2 White House press briefing, Miller defended the president’s support of the  RAISE Act , a Republican-sponsored immigration proposal that would prioritize immigration based on the "skills" immigrants bring to the country and favor English speakers over non-English speaking immigrants. Miller, who once reportedly  told a classmate they could no longer be friends because his classmate was Latino, has a  long history  of promoting anti-immigrant policies. Miller also has a  close  relationship with former Breitbart executive chair and current White House chief strategist Stephen Bannon and  shares  the same extreme  nationalist ideology with him. During a  contentious back-and-forth  with CNN’s Jim Acosta over the RAISE Act in the press briefing, Miller accused Acosta of harboring “cosmopolitan bias.”  

As Greenfield  explained , the word “cosmopolitan” is something of a “cousin to ‘elitist,’ but with a more sinister undertone.” The word has come to represent “people or movements that are unmoored to the traditions and beliefs of a nation,” and has long been a favorite of “nationalist political figures” as a means of delegitimizing and attacking opposition forces. As Greenfield noted, the term was invoked by Josef Stalin to “purge” the Soviet Union of “dissident voices,” and has often carried strong anti-Semitic connotations. From the August 3 article:



When TV news viewers saw Trump adviser Stephen Miller accuse Jim Acosta of harboring a “cosmopolitan bias” during Wednesday’s news conference, they might have wondered whether he was accusing the CNN White House reporter of an excessive fondness for the cocktail made famous on “Sex and the City.” It’s a term that’s seldom been heard in American political discourse. But to supporters of the Miller-Bannon worldview, it was a cause for celebration. Breitbart, where Steve Bannon reigned before becoming Trump’s chief political strategist, trumpeted Miller’s “evisceration” of Acosta and put the term in its headline. So did white nationalist Richard Spencer, who hailed Miller’s dust-up with Acosta as “a triumph.”

[...]

So what is a “cosmopolitan”? It’s a cousin to “elitist,” but with a more sinister undertone. It’s a way of branding people or movements that are unmoored to the traditions and beliefs of a nation, and identify more with like-minded people regardless of their nationality. (In this sense, the revolutionary pamphleteer Thomas Paine might have been an early American cosmopolitan, when he declared: “The world is my country; all mankind are my brethren, and to do good is my religion.”). In the eyes of their foes, “cosmopolitans” tend to cluster in the universities, the arts and in urban centers, where familiarity with diversity makes for a high comfort level with “untraditional” ideas and lives.

[...]

One reason why “cosmopolitan” is an unnerving term is that it was the key to an attempt by Soviet dictator Josef Stalin to purge the culture of dissident voices. In a 1946 speech, he deplored works in which “the positive Soviet hero is derided and inferior before all things foreign and cosmopolitanism that we all fought against from the time of Lenin, characteristic of the political leftovers, is many times applauded.” It was part of a yearslong campaigned aimed at writers, theater critics, scientists and others who were connected with “bourgeois Western influences.” Not so incidentally, many of these “cosmopolitans” were Jewish, and official Soviet propaganda for a time devoted significant energy into “unmasking” the Jewish identities of writers who published under pseudonyms.

What makes this history relevant is that, all across Europe, nationalist political figures are still making the same kinds of arguments—usually but not always stripped of blatant anti-Semitism—to constrict the flow of ideas and the boundaries of free political expression. Russian President Vladimir Putin, for example, has more and more embraced this idea that unpatriotic forces threaten the nation.





Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    9 years ago

Stephen Miller (you know the guy who creeps everyone out because he looks like a young Hitlerian functionary) 

 

wants immigration into the US to be restricted to those from white nations or those who are the most likely to come here and immediately conform to the traditions of our Euro-dominated culture. 

He is a darling of trump's white nationalist supporters. 

 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell    9 years ago

The use of the word "cosmopolitan" was a dog whistle to white nationalists

The word is frequently used across white nationalist websites and forums like Stormfront,  which has its own section on the philosophy page devoted to the idea of “cosmopolitanism.” There, white nationalists espouse dangerous thoughts, including this one: “Confronted with the ruins of their culture, and having been abandoned by the state which purports to represent them, white Americans will have to fall back on their inherited racial and ethnic identities. Only then will the historic American people find the strength to turn the tables on cosmopolitan elites.” This, they claim, is the antithesis to the nationalist, who, above all, puts love of country first.

What we can learn about this is two things. First of all, it is obvious that Stephen Miller, a senior policy advisor in the White House, is seriously steeped in the culture of white nationalism. He parrots their viewpoints and has adopted their language. That isn’t breaking news to most of us, but this level of immersion is deeply disturbing.

Secondly, when it came time to defend the president’s proposed immigration reforms, the White House decided to give that job to Stephen Miller, who not only did so by fanning the culture war flames, he also sent out clear dog whistles to his white nationalist friends that this administration stands with them.

 
 
 
Squirrel!
Freshman Silent
link   Squirrel!  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

I suspected that term had some hidden meaning.  It reminded me of an old episode of West Wing when a Christian conservative woman accused Toby and Josh of having a "New York sense of humor" or some such coded insult.  They knew that she just called them "a couple of Damn Jews".  I have never forgotten that episode, and now I guess I will never forget "cosmopolitan bias" either.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Squirrel!   9 years ago

Stephen Miller is a piece of work. But since people are on to him, I think he is little less of a danger.

 
 
 
Squirrel!
Freshman Silent
link   Squirrel!  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

Except that it is the Stephen Millers of this country that have helped to create the situation in which the NAACP has published a warning (travel advisory) to Black People NOT to travel in Missouri if they can possibly avoid it.  Why?  Because they might get killed just for being black in Missouri.

All the Stephen Millers are dangerous.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   seeder  JohnRussell  replied to  Squirrel!   9 years ago

There is/was a rumor going around today that Miller could get Scaramucci's old job as communications director. That would be a trip.

 
 
 
Squirrel!
Freshman Silent
link   Squirrel!  replied to  JohnRussell   9 years ago

There's also a rumor going around that "The President does not lie."  (Sarah H-S started that rumor at a press briefing).

What I have learned from the Trump administration is not to believe ANYTHING they say or is said about them, except that Trump LIES.

I do think that if Miller gets the job, his new nickname should be "Cosmo".

 
 
 
PJ
Masters Silent
link   PJ    9 years ago

I find this young man disturbing overall.  From his early years in HS through College and now in the White House.  He seems very angry all the time.  I hope he get's help soon.

 
 
 
Squirrel!
Freshman Silent
link   Squirrel!  replied to  PJ   9 years ago

Not only is Stephen Miller disturbing, I believe he is also seriously disturbed.  (Mental!)

 
 

Who is online







113 visitors