I probably should have made myself clearer RIO. When I mentioned cultural, it was the way Indians approach the meaning of the words. To us, respect is always given, until proven otherwise.
I am always civil to others until they treat me with disrespect. So both seem to go hand in hand.
Yet, even if I lose respect for an individual, I will be civil if I encounter then in a public place where it would show bad manners on my part not to do so, such as a wake, funeral, wedding, etc.
We're lucky, Dowser. As daughters of the South, we have our old standbys to see us through the difficult and obnoxious ones...
"That's nice..."
"I do declare!"
"Bless your heart!"
"My goodness!"
... and variations of those themes. They sound civil and sympathetic but in reality they all mean some form of "kiss my ass; go to hell; fuck you;" and things of that nature.
Thank you for posting that just before I head off to bed. If I had read that comment in the morning with my coffee, I'd be needing a sponge to clean up the mess.
When someone would ask my Dad a question he felt was no one's business but his, he would say, " That's just a little too personal, and if I didn't think so much of you, I wouldn't of told you that much."
I am always civil to others until they treat me with disrespect. So both seem to go hand in hand.
I am also, but only depending on how they disrespect me. Personally I take few insults seriously, unless they are directed at my wife, family, even dog ( ) as they are meaningless to me. However I am not a turn the the other cheek type of person. If a man slaps me on one cheek, I'm going to break his nose. If he get's back up I'll hit him with a chair or ball bat or whatever I can get my hands on. There are no rules in a fight. There is no such thing as a "fair" fight and if a man slaps me on my cheek, then he has said he wants a fight.
Try them out some time when you are conversing with a blowhard and are on the verge of a volcanic eruption. It's rather satisfying to double-speak and watch them preen when they think you are sincere.
Only works face to face with spoken words. No satisfaction if you can't see the face.
Civility. Without that, we can never get to the place where we can gain respect for one another. And even when we don't respect, we can still be civil, just not friendship.
It seems to be definitionally distinguished: To some people the concept of respect is such that one must earn respect, to others it is something granted until proven undeserved. This may be because we have differing definitions of the word respect,or, quite possibly, different scenarios lead to different interpretations, based on the nature of the scenario.
As I have said (in response to Kavika) I feel that a person should receive the respect of any normal person until something happens that either increases or decreases that respect. This, by necessity, entails being civil from the beginning. So, really, when one first meets another, civility and respect are, if not indistinguishable, two halves of the same thing, with civility being the active sense of how one interacts with someone, and respect being the amount that one regards that persons standing amongst peers. With time, the two will be differentiated as a function of the two people involved in the social transaction. Civility may remain, respect can go up or down independently.
I went to bed with a smile after Mimi's post, and I'm starting the day right with your's RW!
This Yankee worked down in Arkansas, throughout Missouri, Texas, and Georgia for years. I'm trying to think back if any of those lines were directed my way a time or two. I don't remember any, but odds are......
In writing response to another member, I questioned which comes first... Civility or Respect.
I think Civility.... Treat everyone as nicely as you can.
Respect has to be earned. I had to respect the uniform and rank, I didn't have to respect whom was wearing it.
I think it depends on whether we're taking a poll about people/relationships or an institution. Regarding people I think...
Civility - first Respect (even disrespect) - second
Regarding institutions, I thinkreversing the order is certainly possible.
Thanks for the clarification Lynnn. I changed the body of the seed to reflect your question.
Probably a cultural thing, but respect and civility are pretty much the same. One always gives respect, until it is proven not to be deserved.
Kavika
I think I disagree
I try to always be civil in communication and interaction with everyone, those that I respect and also those for whom I have little or no respect.
In my view civility comes first and within that context respect is demonstrated or not, but productive social discourse between parties is possible.
Just my view
I probably should have made myself clearer RIO. When I mentioned cultural, it was the way Indians approach the meaning of the words. To us, respect is always given, until proven otherwise.
Respect the actual threat of an enemy and no need to be civil.
Kavika
My apologies - I misunderstood
Thanks for he clarification
I also think they go hand in hand. I've tried to live by, "Everyone deserves my respect, until they prove me wrong". Which lends itself to civility...
No apology needed RIO.
I am always civil to others until they treat me with disrespect. So both seem to go hand in hand.
Yet, even if I lose respect for an individual, I will be civil if I encounter then in a public place where it would show bad manners on my part not to do so, such as a wake, funeral, wedding, etc.
I don't know about you, but I see that narcissism is more prevalent with the youth of today.
Kind of hard to do that around these parts from time to time don't you think Mimi?
I'm sorry, I think they go hand in hand... Civility is the first step to developing respect, to me...
When it get personal, it stops being a discussion.
More often than not by the time that happens, civility and respect are already fading in the rear view mirror.
I think by reviewing the responses here, the majority is in agreement with you Dowser.
We're lucky, Dowser. As daughters of the South, we have our old standbys to see us through the difficult and obnoxious ones...
"That's nice..."
"I do declare!"
"Bless your heart!"
"My goodness!"
... and variations of those themes. They sound civil and sympathetic but in reality they all mean some form of "kiss my ass; go to hell; fuck you;" and things of that nature.
There are more ways than one to skin a cat.
Oh that is priceless Mimi!
Thank you for posting that just before I head off to bed. If I had read that comment in the morning with my coffee, I'd be needing a sponge to clean up the mess.
BEST COMMENT OF THE DAY AWARD!!!!
Okay.... so from the old Saturday Night Live, can I get the interpretation of:
(POLL) Which comes first... Civility, or Respect?
That's nobody's fucking business!
And now, a word from our sponsors.......
That is quite a revelation about Indian culture , Kavika . Perhaps it explains some of the intercultural disagreements that occur .
ROFLMAO....
you got that one right!
When someone would ask my Dad a question he felt was no one's business but his, he would say, " That's just a little too personal, and if I didn't think so much of you, I wouldn't of told you that much."
I am always civil to others until they treat me with disrespect. So both seem to go hand in hand.
I am also, but only depending on how they disrespect me. Personally I take few insults seriously, unless they are directed at my wife, family, even dog (
) as they are meaningless to me. However I am not a turn the the other cheek type of person. If a man slaps me on one cheek, I'm going to break his nose. If he get's back up I'll hit him with a chair or ball bat or whatever I can get my hands on. There are no rules in a fight. There is no such thing as a "fair" fight and if a man slaps me on my cheek, then he has said he wants a fight.
Thank you, FLY.
Try them out some time when you are conversing with a blowhard and are on the verge of a volcanic eruption. It's rather satisfying to double-speak and watch them preen when they think you are sincere.
Only works face to face with spoken words. No satisfaction if you can't see the face.
Kavika,
That is pretty much how I view it.
Civility. Without that, we can never get to the place where we can gain respect for one another. And even when we don't respect, we can still be civil, just not friendship.
It seems to be definitionally distinguished: To some people the concept of respect is such that one must earn respect, to others it is something granted until proven undeserved. This may be because we have differing definitions of the word respect,or, quite possibly, different scenarios lead to different interpretations, based on the nature of the scenario.
As I have said (in response to Kavika) I feel that a person should receive the respect of any normal person until something happens that either increases or decreases that respect. This, by necessity, entails being civil from the beginning. So, really, when one first meets another, civility and respect are, if not indistinguishable, two halves of the same thing, with civility being the active sense of how one interacts with someone, and respect being the amount that one regards that persons standing amongst peers. With time, the two will be differentiated as a function of the two people involved in the social transaction. Civility may remain, respect can go up or down independently.
Sorry if this was too long.
Not too long Brolly, and well put.
I went to bed with a smile after Mimi's post, and I'm starting the day right with your's RW!
This Yankee worked down in Arkansas, throughout Missouri, Texas, and Georgia for years. I'm trying to think back if any of those lines were directed my way a time or two. I don't remember any, but odds are......
Nicely done Brolly....